← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/56/2015dismissed

Mohinder Singh Chauhan v. Rakesh Gupta

2015-01-09Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan7 pages

  

   

    

  



    !""

# $ $

%$ &"'  ('  )*+ ,- !

$&"$  

 !"#$$"$%"$!

 $".

 / "0#  ('1)" + "&"" / 22222 $"$%"$!&  $  )"(&"  &""  $  -  +*  & 0  +

"" )"(&"& ) $ $"" $&"$+ 3**+ **0'

$-0 " "4/45/647&$$8/769+ 647/   &"" '  3  $  "  ((-  +  $"

)"  

$$)"'

3$*)"""&$"+ $"'$"

)"

$$)"'

+ " " ($//55:55'64444 64464;/  *6<:=+"$"

$$)" *$$""$ ""0*)"((- + 0&$")*"++)+" $"

$$)"*0+ " "($$*+"(/$ ATUL KUMAR TRIPATHI 2015.01.27 11:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

6 " ($  +  "  + $  *'  "  &""  3$  -

  + ( )"$"  "  *)"  +  "  ++)  +   $"'  $"

)"  

$$)"'

+ "+ ""('+* >/?5?+ 647)** *6<:=1  $

 $/#" (

"  45/47/647'    3$  & (""  "  )"$"'  3)   $ ))$$+ **0'3$)*  *)"$ $"+" $"

)"    $$)"' 

    4?/4?/647  $ -,)"  "  "  ")(+"3 "&""/ *"("*0'7/4:/647'"3 "

&""3$$($$/ &"" & +

8/769+ 647'3)3$$&$+"$$ ) 1-*++ "  )*+ ,- 0"""$$  $" &&*3 *- $$-0"()$$ 0$"&$$**- "%  "  "

 )    + (  &""   +  * -*"0  )"  +

)"$" ' 1"   " "   +  @) "1 (- $A ++) - $+ $$)""$"

)" -1$*1*$/$"  )*$$ + $* """$$ $ $-0" '"3$ )""""+ $*)"& )$$'"" "*)"" $"+$"

$$)")$B "" $($$*  + "3 "  &""' - %&"    -0)"**  " 

 )*  "%$  "$  )$    "  &""  -  & (""  " )" $" ( $""**"/   + " )  +  "  + $   )"$'  "  

 )*)**(" +** $"$' ) "

$"

; ++)- $4/45/647/03  B $""- *$A )$"" "A-0*3$+" $&)"1 $$)"$*$

B $""$ -("& &$*$-*++" $$)"$$ ""    )$ "  " +'  *$    *"$  ) *  - + ("-  + ("0"

$& )0") )"+ "*)"+1  $ $$)"$+ ,-' 0



/ +"5 $$)"$' & $""1$+?C

$$)"$"""(" +" "**- "$'

 +" *$ *"$"-+**0&& 1'3 + ( *"/ $( 0""-&& 1-0"  * $/

"4/4/647<@ 9=3$&$$-0"  (

 )*+ ,-D 0'" $*1"$& "3"

" "* -*"0+"&"" ")"$"*)"+ "+ ""(/ "3$-$ 1"" *6<:=+"$"

$$)"

 *$)* *0- & $+ ()"$" *)"( "" "($"$ *$3  *0&& 1-0"

$"

  " )"$ $"

")"':C4$*$-0"  )*/*)"+"&"" - )"

1"+ "@$" *$3$)* 1*$"$/ 

$$)"

3$ 1*- "0"*)"0& $+ " &$"+ $"$& " @$" -0*3$/"3$ )"""

+ "

'*)"$+ $$)"$$**-) )")) 

"" *$$"-&& 1+**0/

7 &"" $$*"+ $ "   > /6649C+647)" """ ($+" )"$+"$

 "    8  /  769  +  647'    )$ 

  " E$)" )$ $") *1-"%-+ + (  "  *$/     $  3 "  &""  3$  $($$   ;4/4/647/&"" & +

8/:9;+647'3) 3$$&$+1 "1(- 7'647/ "3$ -$ 1 ""  "  "  3 * - * )""  " " +   " " * ++ $A*)"+" $$)"$" " $ $& "$ @&)""- $*1"   $()$(/ "3$+ " -$ 1"""*$""3 ($'+"( '

3   1*-*  "  "  &""  (*0'    "  && )  "  * $+"  )*"+ ( *"&*)0" " "$%(+)"+" *$+ ( *"-0"$"

)"

$$)"'

/ "**" (03$1*-* 

)"7:+"1)"$)"/83$$&$+3" *- "0""&"" "1*+0+"+ $ ($/ &"" & +

&&*)"  )" 7:  +  "  1)"$  )"'  5C  )**  "    " 4/4/647/ $ "" ""  )*+&$$  "9//647'3 -0'"("" 3$ (-)% "" ""  )*/"3$-$ 1"""("+" )$+"$  "8/769+6473$"""+ $

? *)"3$"-%&"-0)"**""  )"+ + (

*$""" ""  )*) *"1$"$" E$*)"3" ""+ ( + + ( *$/ ""  )*3$ )"")$ "("" + $&$$ )$$ 0 $"* "+" 8/769+647 3"C3%$+ (" )&"+" / **"("" $ )-0" ""  )*'"& "+" &$$ -0"3$ )"" ($"0/ $"-$ 1"$)"" +

 )*+""" "4/4/647&$$-0"

""  )*$3$

$$$ $&)""" &$$-0" 1$  )    8  /769  +  647'  "  & $"  )"(&"

&""$-+*/ 1  / "0#  ('* ) $* + "&"" '3$)"""" ($+"

&$$ 8 /769 + 647'"+ $ *)"& )$$+

*)"+" $"+$"

$$)"'

3$" -  %&"    -0)  "**  "    )*  "%    )$   "

 )"  +  + (  &""   +  * -*"0  )"$  ")/  +

*)"  +  ++)  - $  +    $$)"$    "**  "  "  3$  "  -  **3  "  )"   $   $"/   "  $ )"""" +"  )*+ ,- 0 )* "&"" E$*)"$ $"$1 -"

C -+ +*F "3 *$ *"$1*"$"

&$$8/769+647/ (013'"&"" $& )* + ( $ " + $)""""$$"

/)** " " 4/4/647&$$-0"  )*-0+* >/6649C+ 647'   3)  3$  $($$  1    "  ;4/4/647/   $$* ""    -0  +*  8   /:9;  +  647'  3)  3$ $&$+-0 1 *- "0"("1*+0+" "

($1*-*"(/  +" '+*&&*)" 

)"7:+"1)"$)"-+ "  )*+'

3)$ ("""("" + )$ "" ""

 )*/   &""  1  *)"    1*  +  " + $  ($  $"  "   $  "  4/4/647  +  "

""  )* )" -& ("""  """(""

"    "  & $"  )"(&"  &""/    1 '  "  8"" $ "")"$ "7//6473*"% "+" $"&$"%-0" ""  )*"+ ( *""3 + ( "

$& " *$ *"$'3)3 & && 1* +"  * $'*$")"+)""""*)"+" 3$$"$ *0 " *$+"$"

$$)"'

' "+ )/ "3$-$ 1"""

 "  3 *  * )""  "  " +     "  " $  *)"

9 ++ $A$& "$+" $$)" "  )*" 3$ * """ ($1*-*"(/ + 3)'"&"" $$)1*/ "* "+"+ $'" $( "" &"""$($'))  *0'$($$/