High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3481/2021allowed

Vidya Devi And Others v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam And Others

2023-11-17Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

!"#$# %& !'##

() *+,(# - ,- ,, (+ ****

! "

"## $% & ! " ' #

! ( )

* ) #&(! " '

+ (! " ' ,- -.!/( 01&23 # .,/ %# # '( # & 0

"( 11-'# 2 '3&# ' " '& #

' ' 4 # ' # $ $ 15,61616 .

8-/ 9 5:2# '; <=# ,1,61616 .

88/ 9 > "

<?3= 68611616.

81/ 9 5 8= 4

,16@16,A .

58/ 9$ 9 B : ;<2 "# ?# ,-6C16,C .

1/ 9

8? ; .

$/ &#"## # 9 '# # 9 $ D

" #' #

( '

'( '

$# ' ' " * # * 6-6C16,C((# ' $ 1,611616!(&# " 4 ( 9 '

- 2 - .1/ %# " ! $ ( * # * & 9

- : ; .

/ ,66A,AA5

%# ' ! # & $ > 2( 0 '

$ 2$$ "( '

.D/ "## # ($1@ ' 9( $# " ((1616%# &(" 6-6-16,C .

,/ # 9 ' "( 686B16,C # # # ! ( &# # ''"

<''"(!&' 7 9 '" $ D3 558 6@6-16,C & " ,-@<,16?

<86A<816<8-@<8@,32 ",5.,/././'

"((# (4 "( # 8: ; .

$/ "# ?# # ,-6C16,C .

1/ &#"# # 9$ ( ( ,B6,16,A .

5/ %# 4 ''"

9$ # ,16@16,A .

58/ " ' &#"# & # * # * . " /! &# ( 9$ # 9+ " .

5-/ #& " " & 1A,,16,A .

5@/ * # * " ( # 7 $ ' " ' ( # # & $ (! )

$ ' $ ' 9( ""

* # * ! .D/ "# 1,611616%# !9 # ( (# ! # " < 9 ' "$ $ '#&

!# $! # E; ' > ( ,@651616 .

8,< / ' $ # # * # * # ( 9

- 3 - $ '

$ " 68611616.

81/ %# '( ( &#"# & $ ,1,61616 .

88/%# '

!&#"#$ &# # $ ' # $ &$ 15,61616.

8-/9

5&# $# " # & #9 '( .5/ " (' # " ## $( ' # * # * &# +

" $ "# # # # ' # ' .D/ ;< @&# # "# ?# .

5/#9 9 8 #$ ' $( # 9 '(" 9 8 9 # %# "# ?# ( @ ' $$+ (" (9 (9 -9 # # '# * #* " $ ( 8 # # ' * # * ! # " "

($ $( ' * # *

&# +

" .8/

! " ' # # $ (

## #$ '$(' $( ' ?$ " 9 $ ( $" " ( 5.0/ ' # ;$( . #$ (/ (!16,A&# # " !# # " '# '' " ## & $" "# '# " * '

" ## (( ('1C("#(9 9 & '

- 4 - (( '$ 9# " * $ "#!# (( (!'!&

" $9(("" '& 9+ "&#"# '

$ 9 4 .

1C/ # & 9 4 (

9 # $ '

$9((.

8C/ "## (' !

.B/ " ('

#" * & $ #( ' $ ' 9( ""

" 16,, "#! & #$ ' #" ( ( # " " ' # 7$ ' & 4 ?F?

# $ # "# ?# &#"# ( ' # "( '

( + " ( 7$??"# ' &

! # 4 "## "# #9 9# ?$# 9 " ' '# & ! 9&'"

? 7$! (("(

(' (@.,1/'# 16,A ( .-/ " ' $ & ,B61161,

!# ?$#'( (6@6,1611 .@/ " (' # ?$

## "&"

# "'$ $ # $ .9((

/ ?

$ "# ?# & # -# # 9'"

" '

" ( 9$ # 4 ''"

;<2$$ "( "0 ''" " " # " "" " &# #

( (' $ #

* ! &"

? 7$ 9 $

- 5 - #< ! ( * ! ;! * # 2 + 2 # # $ ,,6116,A## &" ?

7$ # & !$ (!+ #!E; ( 9$ # # # ( ' 9 ' "$ $ '' " ,@651616 &'# " "

( ,B,,16,A3' $ ## $( '* & ##$ 9 ,@651616.

,6/ .C/ 3 '

# # (" ' #

" ,B6-1616 .

,/ # $( ' * &$ 0 <>!"#0 (&# # # ( ' 9 ' (' $ # '$ "(" # # 9'# ',-B6 (0#! ,6 (0# # 9 9 # ' # " # $G"" ,-651616 .A/

# ( ( ! ( " ( ' # ?$

# # 16,A

(! ; # # # & $ <$+ #$ " '2# 9 # 2!((# " #9 #( 9;D

?$ '(' " ! # # ( .

1/! # ?$ # # "

$ < " $ '# $ ( 4 .,6/ %# # ('( + # ('( 9#

?$" #

$ $ 9# $ .,,/ ( " ( ' # # # #

- 6 - .,1/ 3 $ ' '" # # $ ( 4 # "# ?# !(# $ '&* ! $* (& $ # ('& H# !# ''"

# ( 7$ + $9!E;!

#! !& * !

#* !E;& # 4 ' # '

& ! 7" + $9!# & "# ' 7$ # "# ?# .

?1/ $ (! # * ! E; 9 # ( # 9 " # $ .

1C/ & + #! E .

/ ,! ! # (( &#"#& 9 # " '"# # .,5/

!# ( #&9# $&

" $ 9(( &#"# & 9 4 (

9 # $ ! '

$9((.

?8C/ $ ' # "# I 9?"# ,./!.9/!./ .'/& ((2# 33!333! 3 # 4 #&# " &( 9# $ .,8/ $ "#! (5.0/!# #$ $( " ( 9 $ "" ' $" " %# ''$" " 9# ?$ # # # & " ' # (( '

$" "!# 9 (( '$? # '# * .,B/ %# 9" # " '# ## 4 !'

& & 7$ !'&#$!( & !$ ( & * !

<3 "! & $ "# ?

- 7 - # !&# # $ '# 5& &$ "# # %# " ' # ?$ $ ( ' "( '

(+ " $ "#!# ?$" (# # $ .

51/9&

* + #!' "('#

$ ! # 9"0 ' "# ''"( &# ' "

7$D

! $.

,6/!"( #"# ' 7$'

! & # 4 "

$ & 9 # & H# # "# ' 7$'# & &$ (9( # "# ''"(! #&" (# # "

? 7$ # & J%# "# # 9 9# ?$# 9 " ' 9& '"# ' 7$! 9&'" ? 7$ (( '

" "9 $

&# # $ 2

# ( # # 4 ''"

" &'

" ' ('# $( # 9' "# " &#"# ( (($9( " 3'

# (#?

" # #

- 8 - % #

&% #

(

)

! ( #

# *

.,-/

( ' # "# '

$ # * # * & (#&# $ 9" !# (( ( ( 9 ?

$ * # * ' 7" $ ! 9 ! 7" 9( '

! &

'" ' ( ( %# 2

' # " &##

'(( ( ( * "(( ' $ ' $+ ( ' $( '

$ " (0 # ( ( # ' " 9( $# "

' * # * " # $ # ,AA5 %# #$ 9 "$ + ' # # " # #

( '" " #9 $ 9# ?$ 9

9(( (! &# * # * # ' ( 7 ' ( (( '9(""

%# # # (# 0 ( "$ & 0 " #

- 9 - "

( ( # " 3 "# !# ('$( '

$ " '* #9 # (9 # # & '#

'(( # 4 $ (! ' # "( # # $ # " # $' #$ " '$" "# ( '# 2

( " &'# '# $" "!# '

" &## $' #$ " .,@/ 3

"#$ %&' ()*+! # $ 2

" # 4 &# # + "(

& & $ (& $ # # 2

# $ 9 ( ( # "( ' K (K 3 # + $ !

" & $ ( " ;((# " "## 4 'K (K3 ,B# '! '

" $ # " ' ,$- .#

/ &'0( )'' &# ! ' ' # (( ( "

$ (! # & $ '

$ " " '$ $ &($ $ 9

$ "H#( 4 ## #$ # # & K! K! # $ 2

! 9

? +,-

. /

# #

- 10 -

# #

$ .

.,C/ 3# 9"0 '&##9 9 ! # "( # # & ' '

" &# # 4 $ ' #$ 7 $ ( ($ &# ( '" 0 '! &#"# # $ 9 # 4 $' #$ !"

(#2

" " ?

" " # (! " # #$ 9 & 3 ## &"" # ( " " #

( $" " ' * " 7" # "# &#"#& # 9+ "$ ' "# ?# ' $('

$ " %# #" ## " #$ $ #"$$ "''

3'(#9 " # ?$#

# '# "( '"# #&!# $# $ "

(

( &#"#"9 $ 9 ( " &

# 7 $ #$ '$('

$ " .,A/ D # $ 9 !#& ((& # $ $ 15,61616.

8-/ 9 5 :2# '; <=# ,1,61616.

88/ 9 > "

<?3= 68611616 .

81/ 9

5 8= 4 ,16@16,A .

58/ 9$ 9 B:;<2 "# ?# ,-6C16,C

- 11 - .

1/ 9 8 ? ; .

$/ # 9 4 # " #

9 # 4

<"# ?# ('#9 !# $ $ ' #

?$ ( # ( # " < ( 9 ''# " %# $ 9 ( ' #&#9 ( #, '

$# ' " '"

' "'# .16/ " # "# ?# #$ # 9 4 # # (#'# $ '"#* ' (

# "

" ' # " ! # "($ ' # ' "$ $ ' ' * # * #(( 9 " ! $# "((! "" " &# (&

(

( (" '

$ 9 # ' ! ("9( # ?

$!&## '&$#'

$# ' " '"

' "'# .1,/

"" ( ,@,,1615 11

4-.!/( 01&25

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No