Ved Parkash And Another v. State Of Haryana And Another
!"# $%&%!'((
)*
(+ + ,
! "#! $
% &!'! %
'( & ) ! "#! $ * ----
+ ,.(/0 +$, #-.*//!
$& ***012314 +%
, 5 &! '&(! 6 +% " $, +% #(, +,,6 ! +%!
700*0123.4 +% 5 #, &8/,!
'&(9 (& ,# $, +% * #(, #71//$((&
, ## 8 :0 *01*0;! &
#-0:!-*0!<0: *0)8/!,# ) !
'&(! + ! ,/ + #
# ,#$ 6 ,=&"6 +"$ ",/
*
* $#!",+,! $, * #(, , & #(,6 ,#,,&&
= > = (! , 2 = (,4! ##%! ( (6 ( $ -0,= (6#" +%### !(,%!
= > = ( ,+%& %6,,3# &(,,?*#$, $" (!6 # ## ! ( (! "
##( ( $ #(, ( , % (% , 6,,+$ $"
6"!+?,%!$&&(%$( #(,!# ## !(,%! = > = ( "$ %&(,,6 #(, !### !(,%!
= > = ($ (, 6 # 6(
+, #(,!$"$ @ ,,&! #(, , & +" 8 7 $"&! ,# $, # ,,&# ## !(,%! = > = ( , - $3($ #(,! #(,
$, ,# #71 // $((&$
,#6 +% ,/!" 700*01 $! * #(,$, "& 700*01
" +,,6 " (& ***01! +% ,/ + 96 $ #
7
,/ # ,# #71//$ $,%&( $# ##(#(
/ ,,&& ***01! " +$, +% < @ , && #! #, $ +( +%
, 5 &!6&!
!+# ##, " # ,/ # ( =& "6 +" ( +% ",/)&",/!#, " # ,% $ ?% ( $ +% ",/+ #A# ( #$# " # + $ +% ", / (& " ##,8" ,,& & % +$#$%(% +% #(, (6,%+6 #(, ### 6 ( (%6$ ,% !# ## !(,%! = ("$#& # &
#7.$ 8#!##$# ?&"+% ( "&+
$, "%$# # ?6 +% ### !
6 6 +,% ,+,%9 6 # 6
# &9##$ "&#" (%$( #(,
#! "," (!+%%(8 $ +( !6 (%6#" +% # ## ! 6, & ($### !(,%!
= ( , 6 +% ### ,%
-
+?,%9 6 $ $ ### =
( 3 : B #,$ $ +( ($ (( +% #(,+$ /!
#+( & $& $((&
$# ,8$ #!,
#, , A &( +% C+, ( /
/,$ $ +(
+ ( ( " # #+ $ ,,&$( $ #(, $((&
+#!6 # & $(&$# && ### B #, ,
A &( +% C+, (// ! "
#$ %
& '( ) *
! + ,-
& #+ *
. + ,
--&
/# 01 $"
$
# #, 6+%
C+, (/$((&
! $ #! $! ,/ & ,%
,# $, +% #(, # 71 // ",/ &,,%6&,6"& 6,, +% ,/ ; !#,$ #,$
<
#(, "+( !& $( +&&! ,,&$ #(, ,&6 # ## !6 ,+ 6! "
$ #(, ( , 6,,+$
$"!$ % ?(% #,%! #(, 6 ( $ -0 ,= & += # %($(%" +% ###
+% 6"!#,, ## 6#& ##%! $!$&& (%! ### =
$ $"$ 9A
" #(,$ , ,$ (%6 # 6 , %=+%,, ## #6# +% 8"&&&#%+% ,/@ ,& 6+$ ,/! #(, ,% 6,##%6 ###
##%,%! ##( + #(,? $$ , 6 # ,,$ (6 +$#$ $$ , $"!, & (6( +, #(, ($=&(%$( #(, $" &(,,!#, + +6 8$#!(%,,& "+ +% + $&&$ $"!6 # 6 $$, $"$ &!+ $ ##%6 # ,, ## "# ,,
:
$# "+ ,%+& # +% #(, #! ",/ & ,%# (,# ", /! $ & $ ((& $
! ",# ,% ( &"%& +%(& (+#= ,/,% ( ? ,#(" +% #(, $,#+$ 6 # +% ",/
#! "+ B #,$ #(, * , A &( +% C+, (/
! + 2
-!+ &( ((( +% #(, 6 ,& 6+$ ,/!#+$$#((
.
"& #,$ ! /$ "6 6, +$ /! &!(= (# #(( ($ #!, #$ , + ",%$$# 6"!$$#% ,$ +% ,/ 6 ( ## ",+, $,!6 , (& ,# #71 //(" +% #(, # ,%++& +% ,6",/ ! +% , / & ,%+ ( +( , /$# / $ %& $ 6 +% #+,6
;
1 , & #,$ " (,%&
& & #+, #( ##,6 " + ((
, ## 6 , 3#& 6 #71//! 6"! &(!! #8#6 ",/ " +% ,/ ((&
",/ ,% +% ,/!" !+%&#$# ##(#6 # , " +# +% ,/6 ,A#& ,#(" +% #(,86, +$ ,/6,% # , 6+% C+, ( #$! "
2 $" #9$#(& ##,6 "+((
/? 3% & ! & 0 , & #,$ ,& ",/ &6&,6 #& ,/ # # # ($ "6$ +" ( +% ",/! 6"!" &(&( $ ,$ ,% ", / ,% #(,!$# ##(#6 # ,/6, 6+? # 96 , # &$ ,#(" +% #(, ",/ ( ,/
6"!#,$% +"#! &
.
,/6, +? =# $#
##(# +% ",/! 6"!6, + $= #!## #6 ,6!6 &&$,# +%%(# +% +% ",# 8"6$ +"! (( / + ,2 "=( @ D=&E D @ +,E D