High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2244/2020allowed

Union Territory Chandigarh Administration And Others v. Siri Narayan And Another

2025-09-10Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri6 pages

!"#$#%

&" '(& # ) )& )) '(& # )*+))

! "#$ % &

' " '&%# ( '# &

)* &+# , -# '&

)* & + ./#"# 0 11111 )& )) ,#- (.

. # & #*# ''" #

.22342.5/ 6.0 78# '

! )7 '&

# " #,*#& # " #&78%#*#& *# 7")#

" .#7++ ' 8+#+8 +

! 6 +#%8 &78 !"# .# %( 8#!+'' ' 8+#+8 +6 329+# 8 ''% *+#* 8 +6 4 : *' + # " # 6 )** 7*' ! ! +"# # * & %# )"# +' %&#7 '# #'

# " +7++6 . 7 8 ''" '

# " &#7++ ' 8+ ! +6

/40 )*&# 7" &%#*#!

- "!+7 '! 8 ( '87 = : *'

" 7# '+ + .

7!# *&#% -+* 8#7++6 .&#7++6 *>'8&#7++ ' 8" .+# +*'8) '

'" ' < : *'+# 7!# ** # #* + .% ' #&# * * 7 # %#*#%+ +)" 7+#

'* ( ")%# + *'+& # +! *

"8+ .% )" &#% 7++6)* 3 ;# )# #' *'+# # ) "#"##* +#* %## 7' * ? ' * '+' %# #7++6 * 7*' ! ! +"## * &#7 '# " .#7++ ! 6)* '"

%# # ' 8 + # ! 6 & ) #"# .# * ''8%( + "' 8 "#

@ ! 87* # * *# )7 7 . %#' # % )* 7+ " # " + &%#*# *%+ # '*+# + )" # '+ ! # * % *

/=0 . "#)* A ! 87* # #7++6)*7 " !

'8&%## 76* '%#' +!"#

" #!B# %''7 #) + "# "+ &%# #7 '# " 7++6 .78 "#6 )*%#*#76 !

'8 ! +"# 5 #' %' 78# C7' ! + $/$, )0%&*' '8 # # 7++6)** '87 " # *!

++* !# + # %#*#!

'8# 7%(" *+ 8 7+ + ) "# " ++* D#& # - "!+# C7' ! + )'

'535 5?2+4222& * 4@2<422?&'

!" #

&# 7#'

# )#"##

") * * *' !+ !

'8+ " +7++6)* &*#7

" *#7+ !

'8&( ")%#- *7#

*#&# 7++6 ! +"##')

" #43 4@+# - "!

E43 # "! + # ' *' + #

'' * !

#+#! %#*#6+)*7" , (+,( F #)F "# : '

/# +GF "# : 'G0# # **

# ' %#*#6+)**

/<0 7" 78 #! ' "+!& ) '" '"##!

'87" *# 6#)8 !"' #* % F "# : '/ 0 %

## #' +")"6+ )* !#+#7 ( *+ 87++ )"++*%

# % *+!+ 7+

)'"++*'87* #++*# #>!7+8 +)*&# #!B## 7+ )'"# 7)

G#, (&#%)&> * # * + ) '++*%# " /0 * '8H/0" # '#H /0"8 78 *#+#++*+#++*' *( ##&#, (7 ")#!

6+)*#* &#, (# #% # "# # # * + # % * # +# " '# "#

' " # *# "#

*'44?* )%# *G+# 7 (* # #* *+)*+ ++* 7'#+#7 (& ! 8 ''% #! * 78 # " + + # 7 ( * # # )*+#++*> 78 # " + &# # +#! D#&6+)*+'* #* '7+#++* * "! 4? IIII 4@ # # # *' 8 '+ 7"" #

'' ! ++ *&#

'' +!)*55.55= 4223#' *'+#

'' * # )#"##

'' # &#'" '#*'

/30 7" #! 87+#+"# #

'' % ' "6+)*78% 8 % '' ! )%&7##* 7') +#

'' %** #

'&#! + ) 7' +#!*'

# )7 * # 7 (* #* + ! '* 6+#)* 78 # "+++8"#8 #&)%#*#

*&%'

# )7 7'+ 8 # # 7 (% 7 " #+#

'' J*' !#&#>+! 8 '+7"" #'" '#+#

'' D# *# *7*!* 8 *% + # #

'' % ' 8'+K .2 )#%&** + *# .# +! # * ' "# +6)*

*&" "+#7++ ' 8 .78#7 '

%##! * ''8%("# & * ''8%## 6 8 "# * * )* + " # " + &%''7#+# ")#

7'*!8 !

'8 # &%##7" 8"# ) *#!

'8 .. $ ")%#' * '+' %' 78#

C7' ! + * #7+ # * !

&#!

78#7 ''8 )# + *7 '#' * '+' %* #+&* 7 .4 )%+# 7)&#

' ''%

/?0 !

.22342.5/ 6.0 78#7 ' - )& )).

-*+))

)1234,% ;## ("B

;## 7'