High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1116/2019disposed of

Rajsthan Rajya Vidyut Kamarchari Superannuation Fund Trust v. The Govt Of Punjab Through Its Principal Secretary And ORS

2022-10-11Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj13 pages

!"#!$%&%"'(

!" # )!*&+& $ % $ &

' (!") "

( ,-

.) .

*****

" + #,-- ".)!/ . 0!# , ( !" #" 23245 2565245 # 7 , .)!/ . 0!# , ( !" #" 24824 # "$#! #.)!/ . 0!# , ( !" #" 29:24 #;

") ("<, -= #.)!/ . 0!# , ( !" #" 2845524 #7

!, "$>( .))-$ @ #$ ># !,>"

.)!/ .= , #

$!A -.)!/ . 0!## (!") " ! # #>" -.)!/ . 0!## (!") " !" 2845524 ")

29:24

-2- # ( 7 @, #= -.)!/ . 0!## (!") " !B " 23245 #),>.)!/ . 0!## (!") " !9" 2565245 ")

23245 #

= ">;

#.#)!/ .= , #>#A >;

#.)!/ . 0!## (!") " !9" 24824 ***** ) .

, (# " !#) # --) /) @ /,!00 ( !"

, /!>"

-0!# , # ( / ( # # ,

> "!- )" , (# " @ /,!0( !"

) " / ") , , A/ "@ ) /) )@A ;

!0 /!;;!" !#) # , ) - !0 ,

; # @>- )

>") #+2 # ! 1#

!" >;@ # - (!") " >;@ #

232 45

% $

@ "

!#(!# !" (!") " !

2482 4 C $&&

C %

@ ")> #

!#(!# !" &; ) (!") " !9 9

2565245

C $

% $

@ ")> #

!#(!# !" &; ) (!") " !

-38

29:2 4 $ &

@ ")> #

!#(!# !" &; ) (!") " ! 6

284552 4 %&

C %

@ ")> #

!#(!# !" &; ) (!") " ! !# , 0 /- A !0 # 0 # "/ . 0 / , @ " 7 " 0#!;

!3245 - ) D ?

" ?A )A> ;

#/, # >( # ""> !" >") #> , $! !0 @ ,#!><,

#"/( - /# #A , # E %# 0-A >;;

#F ). , "

" @ /,!0( !"

@ " 0- ) 0!# 7"<

> "/ !0 )# / !"

! # (!") " ! F , $! #"; " !0 @ ") , # (!") " !F , @"

!#(!# !"C

, /

;

A @ . ! 0>-0-- , # !@-< !"

" ( / !0 , @!")

> )@A# (!") " ! "))>-A<> " )@A (!") " ! B !0 @ ) - # !0 <> " @ #"< !CC46C82%C9 ") 3CC46229C453 ) ) 9446 94443# ( / -A , ( !" #.=,/, !;;!"#> .=

"/!#(!# ) ) # < !") )949440!# -- , 6 " !0 , # =,- ?

" - / #/ A %!

#) , , ) @ " >"@>")- ) - )"< ! 0!#;

!" !0 6 >//

!# !;( " 0 # "! 0/ !" !0 , " =

- / #/ A/ .449 , # (!") " ! @ "

"/ !#(!# !"

@ ")> # - -!(; " !#(!# !"

-4- /"<0"

"/ -/#>"/, ")" ") ) !;(#! 0"

"/ -, - ,@A #>/ >#"< ,<,/!

@!##!="< , A ,>

> )@!") "

; -A G&&+! / .!*%!& H!00 #"< "" # I:6J( # "">; G&&+!.!*%!&H!00 #"<" # I59J, @!")

> ) =

:4443 ") 4443 # ( / -A , ( !" # #>

((- ) 0!# --! ; " !0 , @!") ") =

--! ) ,

; " =! )00 # "

> , ) - !0 ,

) ((-/ !"

--! ; "

@>- )

>") #+2 ! !0 %!") / -> !0 & 7,

/, %!") !0 --! ; " ; !0 -! / -> !0 !

@!") 64 :6J @!")

> 2443 # 2 443443 >( # ""> !" >")#> 64.44.444C2 44 59J @!")

> 2443 # 2 4443 >( # ""> !" >")#> .44.44.444C2 !

- .64.44.444C2 , ;

># A( #!)!0 , @!") !0@! , , # =

" = ,# ) ;( !" , ")!0 /,A #/!;; "/"<0#!; , 3 , # " , # ! !0 4J /, >/,. , -

;

># A ) =

44343 ")443# ( / -A & #" )/!>"

(( #"<!"@ , -0!0 , ( !" #,

>@; ) , !

;!>" )> --94:4:=

.6.98.645C2 , ) -!0 ,

) ;!>" ") / -/>- !",

!@ " @>- ) " , ( !" >@; ) , =, " , # (!") " !

-5-

!#(!# !" 0 - ) ! # ( A , @!") !" ;

># A. # # (# "

") # ;") # = # >@; ) = , , # (!") "

. ,!= #. ,

; =

!"! - !;;>"/ !" ")/!## (!") "/ " # , - -!0 , $! #"; "

, ) !@ "" )- # =

" @A , , 0" #. ?

".!":44: ") ,

; =

)>-A# (!") )!"444:

= --

48464: /7"!=- )<"< , - @- A != #) # ( A; " !0 , @!") ;!>" -!"<= ," # /!" ") ) @A , ( !" # , !"/ , - @- A " K> !" >") (> ) /7"!=- )< ) ") ,

@ /!; ;

># 0!# ( A; " . , # "!#

!"=,A , # (!") " !><, "! !# ( A , ;

># A ;!>" " #;

!0 , @!") )>-A <> " ) @A # (!") " ! 0># , # >@; , , @!") = # <> " )@A , ! # <" ") , !@-< !" !0 , =,!--A !=" ) $! #"; "

!#(!# !"

" ) !@ ) /, #< )@A , $! #"; " !0 @, #<, !0 , " !# / ""! @ - 0 , ; #/A!0 , @!##!= #, #"

!" , ( # !0 , $! #"; " !# ( A , ;!>" !";

># A ) 0

, #A!@? / @ ,") ! # <"<> " 0># , # /!" ") ) , @ /, !0 =# ( !"

#- #/!; >(0!#, #"<@ 0!# , !># " !8::!04:

") ! , # . ) /) ) !" :45 # < #)"< , @!")

> ) @A , (!") " B .=, # " , !0 @=

)# / ) !( A , ;

># A ;!>" ! , ( !" # , # "= ," ( #!)!048= 7 0#!; , # / ( !0/ # 0 )/!(A!0 , ?>)<; " 0># , # /!" ") , , !"E@- >(# ; !># ,

, -)" , ;

#!0

-6-

! "

. , , #A (>#(!

!0 $! #"; " <> " ! "

># ( A; " " /

, 0 ) # !"=

"! @- !;

7 ( A; " "

"/ -)00/>- !0 , 0 ) # !"/ ""! @ <#!>")0!# , !

A , , A=--"! ;

7 ( A; " !0 " # " ,!><, , A , ) <> " ) , # ( A; " = ," # // ( "/ !0 "A >/, /!" " !" =!>-) ) 0 , #A (>#(!

!0 , <> " "<> ,=

! L(#

)@A , !"E@- >(# ; !># !" >/, (- @ "< 7 "@A , !0 # ) , , # - " L # / !0 ,

)?>)<; " # ) ,> +2

! " ## ###$%&!

(

)

" -

' )

-7- '

)

/ 0 )

"2 3-

3 - & *

(

5 ># , #;!# . , 0!#

) ?>)<; " !0 , !"E@- >(# ; !># =

!# - )>(!"" , /

!0 #$ %&

'!()% *+ ,-

, # - " L # / , # !0# ) ,> +2 + 1

6 1 /&

( 7

' 8 "29

) :

-8- (

(

""- (

( )

"<-

1# "

; " !" @ , -0 !0 , # (!") " ! B

"/ !#(!# !".,

@ "0- ) ")( <# (,!!0 , (# -;"

#A >@;

# ) ,> ;% 0

7 #+ "" 9#" '

&0 <-

)= 3 ?9-

))) = (

, 7 8, "9& ( 5

-9- , # - " L # / !0 , =# "

; " 0- )@A # (#!)>/ ), # 2"2 0 #@ -!=+2 2

)>7

9## 9#"?

?" #0 9#99

?" #0 9#99! 2+ < & ! ?9< 9 ! "9< +# (

! ?+< #" ?" #0 9#99

! 23+ +" & ! ?+< #" 7 @ ) ! "9< +# ( ?" #0 9#99 ) 7

! +##

, 8, !%9$9

: >

) 7 )

8, !%9$? 8

8, !%9$?

-10-

)>7

) 7

! 97 9#"<%"3 ! 99

9#"3%9# ! "0 ?<

9#9#%9#9"! 23

9#9"%9#99

: =

)

! "0 ?< 1 4 7

7. B 92"<<

9#"<

"< "" 9#"3

9#99%9?

! 9# ##

! 9#

! "<# ,

)

! "# 9+

-11- 4 7

7. B 90+"

9#"0 :

9+ #? 9#9" 0

9+ 3 "9 9 9 "2 92 + " 9 0 "0 93 "9 9#"< 90 #? 9#"3 "+ #< 9#99

0 0#- 0 <#- 3 ?9- &"A9( 3 ?9- 9##3"D3 2?-

9##39 3 #-9##3? < 0#-9#"# " 3 #- 9#"# 9 3 0#- 9#"9 " 3 3#9#"993 3#9#"?")>7

$ &(

5 ( #>

- !0 , 0!#

) =# "

; "

0- ) @A , (!") " ! ,!= /7"!=- )< ; " !0 , ) @ ") , - @- A@A ,

)# (!") " , ;

7 ">(!" #!> )

0!#/!;(- !"!0 (- )"< ") "

#>/ !"

" # >; ) , #"< !0 , /

. - #" ) /!>"

(( #"< !" @ , -0 !0 # (!") " ! B . , ( 7 @, #= -. )!/ .

= --

, $ ># !,>"

. )!/ .

(( #"< !" @ , -0 !0 . !" "

#>/ !"

0#!; & = 00/ # , "? "<, ") "!#

" , ,>?

. , ;

)

; " , ;

># A -> !0 , @!") -- @ )>-A ( ) = ," ( #!)!049;!" , 0#!; , (

"<!0 , !#) # -!"<= ," #

") , @ " 0 //#> )

( # , # ( / @!") /!" ") , " / # " ;

, ;

># A ,

"! A @ "

" ) ") ,

-12- =, " ,

) @!") --

" ;

># A. , )> ;!>" -!"< = ,

((-/ @- @ " 0

( # , @!") -- @ ) @># ) " , @! ( #!) " = !0 , 0!#

)

; " ;

) % # @A , /!>"

(( #"<!"@ , -0!0# (!") " !=,/,,

@ " 00#; )

")# # )@A , /!>"

-.- #" )/!>"

(( #"<!"@ , -0 !0 , ( !" # )!

"! (#

, "

" ( !"

. ,

< # 0 # "/ .,!= #. !;

) ! , ?>)<; " ) ) 494. (

) " !36 !0 4 - )

G ! . +! /

01 .H ! /!" ") , " ;- # /#/>;

"/ . , !># , ) , -) , " , " , )!

"! # ( A , ;!>" " , ; @!>");

"" #. , ( !" # B@!"),!-) # --@ " - ) !" # I:J( # "">; ,

)K> !" .,!= #.7 ( !( " ,

< , ( !" # =!>-)@ -@ # A ! 7# -!0 , (# " ( !"

" , " ,

; " C>") # 7"< < " @A , # (!") "

"! ,!"!># ), K> !"!0) 0 >- C( "

-" # -- , "@ L ;" )

((#!(# !#) # =--@ (

) , # >(!" )-

! ; " !" , "A ! , # (#!/ )"< , ;

A @ " "

> ) @A , # ( / ( # " # - !" ! , /- ;

# "<!> !0 , 0!#

)@!"). ,

; --@ = ,)# ="@A , ( / ( # ") , ;!>"

-# )A( ) --@ )>-A )?> ) ! ;

) /- # , " /

, >") # 7"< "! ,!"!># ) @A , # (!") "

, !0 @

= --

(!") " !!"!#@ 0!# , ; -"

>") # 7 " !) A. , , 0

-13- /# #AM , #"/( - /# #AC "

"/ . @.

= --

, "

<"<# / !#!0 --# ;

"(# " " , !># ! L(- " , #

0!# ) - A ") 0 -"< ,

;

! =,A , /!" ;( (#!/ )"< @ "! " ) < "

, ;

# ) (!

)!0 //!#)"<-A (,! !/!(A !0 , !#) # @ (- / ) !" , 0- !0 /, /!"" / )/

$ "0!*1 (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ) 0 2! 2!*&3!4%'56*!&"'!7 (!&6" 2! 2!**!3"* 08! (!&6"