← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/627/2023dismissed

Veena Dattta Sunanda Datta v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2023-01-12Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj8 pages



       

!"

VEENA DATTA SUNANDA DATTA  

  

 #  $%#  &' &  ( )))))



 !"#!

$ % &! '

 ))))) ' &  (* + ,-.

(    

 (! *  ' +  ,

   &+--./--0 (1

 ,

'2

!3 4 ,!

'!5 !, '1

&(!++

4((

 & 67 -889-8--:

 -<

 !++  

4 !

 4 ( '

= * 4 !

*  "$ ++4!+ !

&

" (

% 

'(&!

,+'

!= ( ,

- > '+",==!

? ('!& '( &!!

(!@,=!

1(!

! !! !,4( ' !

 @ (!

 !!  !  (!% '

=  !

4   & "3

!!

A !

 ,&!

 & "% 4 

  -880 970 77  ( "!

 970 !

 (!

 

 "   ( (, (!+! &(

+$ 7$

+   5!

 ,

4 (  + '  = @,=!

1(!

!!!(!

;&, ! 4  B ++ -08-88 (  

 (!

 ( = $ (  

 ,&&

   * 4 * ' & !

" ,

 ( B ++ ! !'

!

 (  

-2- ,*C, +" ;&,  !  '   *!

! 3!   .8 8-80 '@!

!!

',*(!(1(!

!!! 

'+! 60$>+ &3 8$ (!+ =+ " & "$&

.7$ (!+  & =+!

 5! ' +  *"

  0 !%

 @,=!

 #!

,"1 == 

5!

!++4 4(!!' !( '= 1(!

!!!$ ===* '( & "(!

= !

(!

 = =!

!4  ( !''!

' (  & "  % +!

'  ! = !

* & % !

 !&&

4+"  5!  !"  '

,& ' ! ! + " ,

 &

 6 ' ( !

"!

! 4 

 D 4,+!

 &  &$-8-& " '(!'

!

=+!

5!'

5!

*"

  - ," 1 == 

 5!

 ( 4   A !+  =D &  '

 ! 4!

!

4

-.8--8-( 

!+ ," 1 == 

$ 5!

  . 5! !+ !

! +

3 =!

4!++4!

( 5 1!,  & 67 -889-8--:

 -<(!*  , *" (  " '' &  (  

 ( 5 &!, !   5(" &!

!&

 *

 !3  !4!

 (  *" &!

&++ ! 3!   .8 8-80  5( *"  ' ' 

 " (! *  ''&  '!% @!

!!

',*(!(1(!

!!!2(!!+ * !%

  

 (! , ,!

  &  ' ( !

 ( 5 &!,

 &$ !

! + +"(!!+ "* ,*=  *"( 



,(! ( '   *!

(B ++ ,+";&, *"1(!

!!! '!% '( 

(!=(!!+ "* (+ +4!+!

%!+ % ( , !

 '(1 % +1  -98-80 1 % + ,  99 '-8025!!+ ,*=  (!( & "(!!+ ' + ! & % + ,   +  ! E!

 A !

  ,!

  & " % ,  ! !! !

-3-

F&(!++ 4( '  ! 3! .8 8-80!

!+ (B ++ '1(!

!!!;&, '( 

(!

1 % +,  

4*'

(1 % +1 !5!

25!$(,$, 4 (!

(! % 5 '(

4& % ++  4!

$(+4!+ " ( '  8-80&!

*  G!

+ !!

 *(!+' ' (  

 (!

((

 &:

 -<!

(!(+ (!(( 5 &!,

 & + !*+  * !  !( '' & (! , !* %!

 & 5 ( ! * ! =

 '

' '!& (! !+ " *

,

*"( 2 (,, 4 (!( "

4 '!+!

!''

!'!



, "

,'

(( &!  +!& + !

 ( ,  --8- ! =! '   

   F

!    

 (! 5

 !4!

 ( 51!,  *=!

!

!*++ !

&(!* +!&

!

!9 '(!'

!

5( &( (,



        

                                

   

                     ! "                    

    #$#$$#$%

    

 &       

         ' " !(  )  *



 

     +      ,

-4-  (!', =!

! & ( , '(

H*+ , = 1  ( =!    !

 "

#    

   $

 ! % % & ' 

 (! (

4  ! *"!(

 &4%  ! *", '!

!

* !!

(!(,*C, 

4*& =!

!+& =

" 6 2 (!% (!

 ( +!

+ !!

 *(!+' ' (  

 (!% 4

 (

,4( (

&,=  !

 !+

45 ( (

!

!!+ ( , &  *"(1 +

'(!

4,=  .  ! & !( &

"$ 5 *!

! +%!

; !& '((  &!

('!&(! (!%*

 & ( ,

      -  .  /0%#1  %2#1$#%3        2###

 4-5 . -        6 -              

7 8 4 9 )4  44 ":"9*; <  / <   /13=  #=#1$#%0      .  /0%#1  %2#1$#%3    "

    " .   $*  . /13#$$3#1$##%  

. /0%#1%2#1$#%3!    .  /13#$$3#1$##%"  . /13#$$3#1$#$%  >     ?   



-5-

4  44 "@1%A":" 9                   13B

   ( " .  /13#$  $3#1$##% )

( 13B

*     1*  &  9  6 " - '

"9

       .  /13#$  %B%#$#$%      . C " -   9". /13#$$3#1$##%

    <  4  4 4  @ 1%A" : " 9   2*7 8 4  B*  &    7 8  4 9   7 8 4 "9   "( ?    -      7  8  4   9  ! "  

 

   

 . /0%#1%2#1$#%3 ?

           "       , 0  ,!+ '(!=5 ( 5(!( (!

+"! 

!* ,('!&(!(!%& =

(

'(

4 "!

'

=( *!  '((  &!

(!& ==, &!

',&('!&5

 !=  

4 ! '

4 ! 4!

 ( &

&+,

' 4, + !*+ ( !4!

( 

2 '!&$   !( ', '(

-6-

& + ''!

$ !

&"!

!''

'!

''& % 

, " (!('!&(!%& ='

(

4 "

'  " '' &  * ,   (  

   !    !*+ ( ''& %+"

(!=(% * & '!(  &  '

=( 

'(=! !+!4!

( = (!!

''& %

&!

* & %

 

&

=

( 4( '=! !+(! 5! % , ( =

7 ( 

(!

+%++ "!++4!

'=!+ &

* ! !4!

 (  " '' &

 ! = & !

' (

&,= !

% (1&!

* ,= !!

* ! 9 (& +'

(!!

4, (!(

 " ( & "5!4 % ( *"(B ++ -08-88!

(!

B ++ 5!,(+ *"(1 % +1   , !

 -98-80  5%  ,!+ '( , D !* %( 5(!(!

B ++ 5! %  !,* &  , ( !* % & % +,  (+!

 '' (  ,4( &+!

(

(*!  '( ,  (!&

*!*+ (   , (  4!

5!!+ '

!= !=! '!&$  ( &! '( 

(5  != ' + 1 % +, !* % !

!75!(!

+"(   !+*, +

45!4 % ( % (B ++'



41

& ,+"$( 

&(  =!3!

&

& !

 = +!

4 !% =  (  

 (! (  

 4 ,&&  (   

 " D =!

!4= ' (  & "  2  ( !

'( 

(! ! 3! .8 8-80 *!

B ++B(!(!*

%" *"( (1 (!

! 3!   .8  8-80  !* , %! 3!   08- -08-88D(!  +!

+"   !+!

!=!,

406C"!

-7-

  &(

+

+" (, (  5 ++ =!

" !& (! C,  *

&!& =+!

(!

* & % 8 2 !+  4 ' &!



 &(!% ( ,4(( "(!

!+ " *

&+,

&!

&

 -8--8-- :

  .< (!

 !+ " *  ,*=  $ ( 5% $ (  

 (! &( 

 ! !&(!++ 4 ( "

!

!= ,*"3 4 4! '!++&

C,  !+

4( 

+" !

 & !  (  " 

4$ *, !+  5!   '

,& = '( "

4*'

' + '(

!! &+!

!' ( ,4(!

!= 5 44+ , '( ==

=!

*"( (' + '(

= 4+"  = &( % ,   '!

 ! ( &   ( ,  ( =!   

   F:, !< &

&

$(

'(&!5

*!+ &!*+ ('!& '( &! !=,&( !( & !

((  & 

,'' &   !*+ (

% 

 * !

,& = ' ! * !  =

   =,&(  $ (  

!+ (!

!++4 "* !!4!

!

'( '' & !+! & !

 (  " 

4 ,+!

+"$ ( !

 ,  5

 * !+ &!*+ ('!& '( &! = +!

+"$  '!

! + !

( , '

H*+, =1 (=!    "

#   

  $:, !< &

&

$% (!=

 !+ &!*+   ( &! ' (  

   ( !

 &! ( !,(

"(!

 &

&+, (!( 

5!4, +" '(!% 4&!,

 ,&

'(&

 4 = !

((

 &(!

*  , ! 5("(+ & 4

*

&!

&++ (!= 

-8- (&!( !=! '!'!&$

&+,

(!

*

!5 !(  = ' ,!

'((  &!



, "

(=! !+(!(!

='

(

'!

4 (!

 *  ;

 (  

 ( != &!

 *  & %  ! ! '!++"

!5

&+,

*"( - > $  !+ !!

(!('

!+ "

(!% !+ " *

&+,

==

 (!% 4 *  =!

$ (  

(!%

 =,4 (!=

"4

(!% 

!  ! &(!++ 4

+"   ( !

 ( 5 1!,  '+& (! (  

 (!

 4 %!

& !4!

 ( &

,!

' ( 

4 !% 4,* & ( =+' ( "

4$( 

&!

*4 + * " ! !&(!++ 4  !

 "

5 ( ,&(!++ 4 ('

!+

  > $ ! 1 % + ,  (! !+ " *  ' +  *" (  & " !4!

 (  

 D ( !=  

4 (  

 (! ' +

!

  

 %  ( ,4( ,  C,

' '!& !

 (  5( &( &!

*!

&! !5

(

 !&&

4+" =    +' &  (.    *!"   . 4 B(( !3 4/ !

/ B(( 

!*+

/