← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/71/2019disposed of

Charan Singh v. Xen/P.W.D. (B And R), Malerkotla, And Others

2019-03-14Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mr. Justice Arun Palli7 pages

 !"#$ %#&'($) "( !$

 ( **+ , -

".*/ 01122 34

567('$82928./4 0$1   

  .9.*/ 01122 34 7('$8292 0$1   ,:

 9.*/*4/*2/21*; 01122 34 7('$82928./4 0$1   < 

 "=*.*/ 01122 34 >4*; /*87('$82928 0$1 "$+ ?' $&#.

" @$ .#$$ 8  "

%&#.

"

 ?' $&#.

" $# 8&#(!



    





$# 8&$    ! "   # 

 $% &

   

!!  !  '   ( $)* +,-.

/01."' " ' &$ "!            !

    "  "      

 # "! 2   !&* 31 /014"   $)* +,-. /01.   5     '

 #"!   &$ " "!

'"     #  "#!

' "" -1,6# ! "  "    /4 0/ 147-   

   '  !  "  "    ' 8'  '!  !

     ""'  "    " 

" 9  '    #    "

 #"! " !

'!

' "#  !       !

 ""    9   ' 8'"8   "! "   '!

   :

   !

    

&$  " 13 /01/  

 #"!   !  /-0'     '  !! '             

" "  !

    /+#2 5   ;  14-3<  =  >   ' "! "    "    '  " !   " "    ?     #  "  13 /01/  $ "     

        (    !

        !    1+ /017        !$  ' .*/A*A*3'44A28

,."" B   2?  $  4**12"4*28(*/

*2    (**  !414  3  **/  

*8  C4  "48 !4148 

<  $,:<8      ; ?  .4*2@4A3**/

*8 4*2 *C42

4A C4"48!4148  &* /037

/01- 14 /01+     "

  !   !

         "@  "!

     "! A .00006#   ! !

 '  

 ' "  " '"  "!' &$ " !  9 

 )   

     ? "     "@   

   '   ("  # B 

 

  

  

 

   

    





             

      

   

        

 

    

      



   !

 

   

 "    

   

  

  



 

  # $   



    

   % %

 !  

  &  

  '

  

     

  

 

   ( )   * & +,

 * -%.

!/ 0& 1

 ( )   





2  1         

      



$      

           

           

     



                    

       

 5            



    

 6

     

 



        

         

   

        

     

  

    

 





      

  

 

     &  %78 

1   9 

           

      

              

               

 

 $ 

:  



    

;

.

*   

 

   

 

   

 "         



   

  

              &  %78 1   9 

 !0- 3 ;/ <

    

 

 

     

 "   

 !



            

                 







 1 "     9  +  <   =  9 

>

 ?

#

@

,    >

   

%.

7- /#,:!A7 ( 8*  

           

      

  

  

 

   



 ,     



     

  

 ( 8*  

 

2 3-/<  

    

             



    ,         

           

           

    



                  

  

       

 



 

        

 

  

  



  

    

    

         

       

%!.     

 



             



   

;

% 1



  

9  *  

     &  B  ?

 #

  @

  1    < ,       >

    

  ,#

+  %.0    %.

! 



  

%.

7  

 

    

 

              :

4....6   

  



:

 

    

  

           

        C  :

4....6  

       

  

  

 ;

   "! " 



' &$   #!

       /+#2   "         

'    "! "!

' "#  !  "      " ""  *  &$           '      !  "!       '!        9"     '  " "" "  @    ""!

'" !"      5    @   '    &$  "!   

!  !   !   /<     !

"' @

    <   !    ?   !'       !$  '44A2418 2?  4**12 "4*28(*/ *2(**!414418       '        "  " "         

! '    8    !   =   

  '    ' "" 

 "      '      >7*1***AC D@  "!   ' '   !  "  /4 / 147- *        

 '   ! 

 /4 + 1474" "6       "  !  

5      

     " !    "  "  " "    11/ 1473  "  '           '    "!    /4 0/ 147-.+' '

9  !                             ! '

2   !$  '44A2418 '

 "  !   '" 

    "      !'    /+#2    "  !$

     " "   !      "! "!  '!

   " "!      9  "  "    "   !

        !      1+ /017     '    ( 9

  !  '

! @$ .#$$  $#  "

%&#.

"

&#(!

 ,8

! )   6 

ED ) F