High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/76/2021disposed of

Haryana Space Application Centre (Harsac) And Another v. M/S Rolta India Ltd And Another

2021-02-15Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill4 pages

-a

!" # $%&%!' ( )*+ *, - . / . 00000 %%!' *& 1 *&+&

2. / / 0000 &3!'# '& ( 4/ .0 . /. // * & '(

*0 5+6# 3 %7 *%- ##60 - "!* 8 3 %%!' *&0

*0 &8%&8 99 *7 6- . '%!* #:!$ 7%8

*0 5 *%; +3 - #:!$ "!* * &3!'# ' !0 0 <<< /. //- 0 8%& = * %& ) %'9 ; ' +3 "!* 8 *%'9 8*!+98 :%# ! $!'" * '$%'9 #+ ! !+)* ; !" 8 3 '# =%$- 1 >0 * , * %' 8 3* & ' 3 %%!' %& "!* & %'9 &%# !*# * # 00 3 && # ), 8 6 *' # ##%%!'

%&*%$ +#9 - 8 '#%9 *8 78 * ),

336%$ %!' +'# * . $%!' > !" 8 *)%* '# !'$%6% %!' $- >> "%6 # ), * &3!'# ' !0 "!* ? '&%!' !" %= "!* 3 &&%'9 8 *# ), 8 *)%* *%)+'

6 8 66!7 #0 !66!7%'9 "

$& * '! #%&3+ # ), 8 3 *% &0 %%!' * !0 .3 $ 336%$ %!' '* .

*= ' !" 8 .$% '$ '# $8'!6!9,- !: *'= ' !" %& '!#

9 '$, "!* !9* 38%$ '"!*= %!' .,& = . 336%$ '# =!

. '&%'9 "!* 8 !: *'= ' !" 0 @+ & "!* 3*!3!& 6 7 & %':% # ), . %' . 3 =) *- "*!= @+ 6%"% # : '#!*& "!* =!# *'%& %!' !" / $!*#& %'$6+#%'9 #%9%%& %!' !" $ &*

3&- ' 9* %!' 7%8 * $!*#& 9 = ' !" !6# * : '+ #!$+= '&0 +*&+ ' 8 * !- $!'* $ 7 ""!*# # !

8* : '#!*& %'$6+#%'9 * &3!'# ' !00 . *:%$ 6 : 6 9* = '& # >0A0 7 * ? $+ # ) 7 ' 3 %%!' * !0 '# 8* : '#!*& %0 0 * &3!'# ' !0 B &0 !6 '#% /%=% #- 2& ,% ' /%=% # 2& '#% !'&+6 '& *%:

/%=% #0 *)%* %!' $6 +& 0 !" 8 . *:%$ / : 6 9* = ' # # >0A0 3*!:%# & "!* * &!6+%!' !" #%&3+ & +'# *( C0 &!6+%!' !"

%&3+ .-

'# 8 1 '#!* &8 66 = ; : *, ""!* !

* &!6:

=%$ )6,- ), #%* $ %'"!*= 6 ' 9!% %!'- ', #%& 9* = ' !* #%&3+ *%&%'9 ) 7 ' 8 = +'# * !* %'

$!'' $%!' 7%8 8 $!'* $0 "

" *- 8%*, # ,& "*!= 8 $!== '$ = ' !" &+$8 %'"!*= 6 ' 9!% %!'&- .-

'# 8 1 '#!* * +'

)6 ! * &!6:

=%$ )6,

$!'* $ #%&3+ D %8 * 3 *, = , * @+%* 8 8 #%&3+ ) * " ** # "!* * &!6+%!' ), "!*= *)%* %!'0 66 @+ &%!'- #%&3+ & !* #%"" * '$ & *%&%'9 +'# * '# !+ !" !* %' $!'' $%!'

7%8 8 $!'* $- &8 66 ) * " ** # ! 7! *)%* !*& !'

*)%* !* ! ) '!=%'

# ), .-

'# 8 !8 * 7! ! ) '!=%'

# ), 8 1 '#!*0 ' 8 $ & !" 8 & %# !*& '!

9* %'9- 8 ' 8 = * 7%66 ) * " ** # !

+=3%* ! ) 33!%' # ), 8 *)%* !*& %' 7*%%'9 ) "!* 3*!$ #%'9 7%8 8 * " * '$ 0 8 *# !" 8 *)%* !*&- %' 8 : ' !" 8 %* '!

9* %'9- 8 *# !" 8 =3%*

33!%' # ), 8 = &8 66 ) "%'

'# )%'#%'9 !' 8 3 *% &0 8

*)%* '# * $!'$%6% $ >> &8 336, ! 8

*)%* %!' 3*!$ #%'9& '# 8 : '+ E+*%&#%$%!' !" 8

*)%* %!' &8 66 ) %' 8 .

!" 0F

%&3+ *!& =!'9& 8 3 %%!' *& 66 8 8* : '#!*& %'

@+ &%!'0 ' !' !" 8 $ & & %':!6:%'9 8 : '#!* 2& ' '#% !'&+6 '& *%:

/%=% #- ' !*# * &%=%6 * ! 8 %=3+9' # !*# *- 9* '%'9 ? '&%!' !" %= "!* 3 &&%'9 !"

*# ), 8 *)%* 6 *%)+'

6 7 & $8 66 '9 # ), 8 3 %%!' *& %'

!0 A !" - 78%$8 7 & # $%# # !' G0H0 '' ?+* 0 %= 7

? '# # ), '!8 * "!+* =!'8& %0 0 8* =!'8& "!* $!'$6+&%!' !" *9+= '& !' =!'8 "!* 8 *%)+'

6 !

''!+'$ 8 *#0 *# * # # G0H0 7 $8 66 '9 # ), 8 3* & ' 3 %%!' *& ) "!* 8 !'I)6 .+3* = !+* '# 8 * #=% #6, & '#& # $%# # :%# !*# * # # 000 & 3 * $!'& '&+&

**%: # ) 7 ' 8 3 *% & ) "!* 8 !'I)6 .+3* = !+*- &!6 *)%* !* 33!%' # %' 8 & %# = * !"

2& ' '#% !'&+6 '& ! $!=36 8

*)%* 6 3*!$ #%'9&0 6 :

' 3 * !" !*# * # # 00 3 && # %' %:%6 33 6 !0 A !" %6 # J .3 $ 336%$ %!' '* . '!8 * : *&+& 2& ' '#% !'&+6 '& :0 /#0I %& * 3*!#+$ # & 8 * +'# *( 8 !+'& 6 "!* )!8 3 *% & #+*%'9 8 $!+*& !" 8 *%'9 8 :

$!'& ' # ! 8 &+)&%+%!' !" 8 ?%&%'9 *%)+' 6- ), 8

33!%'= ' !"

.!6 *)%* !* ! $!=36 8 *)%* 6 3*!$ #%'9&0 ' ? *$%& !" !+* 3!7 * +'# * . $%!' > !" 8 '# !'$%6% %!' $- >>

= '# #- 7 8 * ),

33!%' +&%$ 5+*% ' !& 38 #0- "!*= * E+#9 !" 8%& !+*- 8 &+)&%+ *)%* !*- 78! 7%66 $!'#+$ 8 3*!$ #%'9& %' $!'%'+ %!' "*!= 8 & **%: # - '# 3 && 8 7 *# 7%8%'

3 *%!# !" =!'8& "*!= 8 # !" * $ %3 !" 8%& *# *0 8 !* = , #%* $ 8 3 *% & !

##* && "%'

*9+= '& ;

8%= 8*!+98 8 '%* * $!*# !" 8 $ & 0 8 33!%'= ' !" 8 .!6 *)%* !* %& &+)E $ ! 8 # $6 * %!'& ) %'9 = # +'# * . $%!' !" 8 *)%* !'$%6% %!' $- >> 7%8 * &3 $ ! %'# 3 '# '$ '# %=3 *% 6%,-

'# 8 )%6%, ! # :! &+""%$% ' %= ! $!=36 8 *)%* 7%8%' 8 3 *%!# !" =!'8&0 8 *)%* !* 7%66 $8 *9 " & %'

$$!*# '$ 7%8 8 !+*8 .$8 #+6 !" 8 *)%* '# !'$%6% %!' $- >>0 K #%* $ )!8 3 *% & ! @+ 66, &8 * 8 " & 3 , )6 ! 8 .!6 *)%* !*0 8 3*!$ #%'9& 7%66 ) $!'#+$ # %8 * :%*+ 66,- !* 8 & !"

*)%* %!' %' 8 .

!" 0F

+*%'9 $!+*& !" 8 *%'9 %' 8%& 3 %%!'- $!'& '&+& 8 **%: #

) 7 ' 8 3 %%!' *& '# * &3!'# ' !0 8 +&%$ 5+*% ' !& 38 #0 "!*= * E+#9 !" 8 !'I)6 .+3* = !+* ) 33!%' # & 8 &+)&%+ &!6 !* %' 8 3* & ' = * & 7 66 %' 8 & = *=& & %' !*# * # 00 %' %:%6 33 6 !0 A !" 0 $$!*#%'96,- +&%$ 5+*% ' !& 38 #0 "!*= * E+#9 !" 8 !'I)6 .+3* = !+*- %& 33!%' # & &+)&%+ &!6 *)%* !* %' 8 3* & '

* & 7 66 %' 8 & = *=& & %' !*# * # # 00 3 && # ), 8 !'I)6 .+3* = !+* %' %:%6 33 6 !0 A !" 0

/%& %66 )*+ *, - +#9 rts K8 8 * &3 ;%'92* &!' # (

&2!

K8 8 * * 3!* )6 (

&2!