Kec Metallics Pvt Ltd v. Kamal Encon Industries Ltd




   
  

 !!"#$#%&'()
  & 





* ++
,

-+

 





 


 * + 
 ,
,+

 





 


.....  & /+

 ,
 *,*

 
 ..... 


 !
"#
$%&#
'(

%
#
$%&#


(
 


) *
++',#
$%&#
'(

)-
+(#
&,
.!$
.....

*,*

 
0

(


,$
!$
&
/01

/02

(


&#
1034
5
(
6(
&78#
$!,
!

$
9

$%

(
 

#
*+
&

(
&( 

,+ 
: "!
 1;
5
(
6(
&( 78

(


9<&


 
=






$,$

(
 &%
 $!

$
&,

&#
'(&(

"$
'(
(


"!
 
$
 2#
 &%, 

(
>+$
&

(

1 

$





? !
+#
 

(
@$

)&

(

1 

$

 
(%


%$
(
&( 

(
 &%
9$
+
(,$

/AA4A13




(

 @$
>,!

"$

"!
 4
=
 B#
 &%, 

,#

 
$




($


&($
(
!
9
'




1B2

A13
$
%$
$
$

A01AA13
(#
(,$+

+

(
.!
((,$

(

$


$
&!$
$

(




$
C&!$
$


1 


'
$ $
'(

'
,
$$
(
&
(


&!$
$

(

1 


#
(#

+

.!$
(



'
$ $

&&$+, 
&

(


'
!$

AB1A13

(
>+,
)&#


 
#
$
$
(
&,
.!$
$
'
,
$$

9
!9,($

(
' #
 , #
6 $
"

7
:+,(;
$
6D7
:$;
9(
 
$

',,


(
&,
+E

% 

 
$
'
,
$$

9
!

,$$

(
&,
'9

(
&,
.!$
(
$
$
(
9
&

,$
'(
$
(
$%

!9,&
$$
12/A14
(
9

,&$

&$

(
&,
.!$
(
,$
(
 
$$
4A2A14

(
&,
.!$#

(
9

(
 


-D
=
&#
($
&&!#
(
$

9<&
9
9%+
(
(


(

&

($

9
&$!&$



<!$&,

(



 9#
$


(
!9,&

,+

(
&,
.!$
(
,$
 
9
'


 $%

-
(!%$#
>+,
)&#

 (
>+#


 
#
'
),(#
$$
3A2A14
(
9
,&$

&$#

'(&(
(
>+,
)&
(
$
9<&


B
(
(


(


%$
(
&( 

,+ 


@$

+
(,$

/A4A13
9!
(
>,!
: 


12;
(

9
,$

(
&

>+




'(
(

&9$
 


(
,
$


B:;

(
 $%
(
(
&

(

%$$
(
%,!
 

(
9

(
"&(+


(
,

$
,,'+
% 



F

(
 $%





 



   

   

          

 

              !  " # 



    #  $  %  &  

    

'

()())*+

 

 ,*  - .

    / 0

"1

 2$+33+ 4+)        

 !  

 "   5 





 

 5  ,*  -.# , 7!/  ,*  - .

    /2





   

  5   8 .

+#

8

  



: # ;


 

(
$
9%
$
9
(
>+,
)&


B:;
=
F

(
 $%#
><$
(
$(#
)&

(



(
,$
(
$%
$$
A3A14
'(
(
,,'+
% 



) 

  

 



  4(  5  < +,= )     "

 " 

 % *

4)( !

 >'%? =@3(  

 <  ,=+) 

 5  

  A >'%      "

 5  

!

8

?2 (  !

  

 '    

"# 

  # $ % &       "/'

   

 
  

()())*+

 



,* -.

   /  

  



  

       

 " " # 



     '



 2$ +

3A3+ ' 2



 2$4+)



# " @ 

      ! 

   # 



    02  1 7 8 "  

 

B 

 

 

  ?+

  $ 2  <   

 < 

2  2 %  +3 # 021 7 8 ()( (*$%*(+  3+ # 021 7 8 ()( (4*$%*(+  4+) # 021 7 8 @( ()*$%'*( +  

   

  4@( 7

 # 



    7 8 

 "  "



 '

 8   





 2   (     ( A  B    "



"

 C  5 " 4( 

    5 !

    



 

 5  8

?C; 3 



   

  4( 

 # " "

*  
@

 8     " @(D

    

 "    

      

(2    

 5 2

E



!

5

 E

 ,  

 "  #C  3 

"



 % 3)  433 



  "

 



 (D



      

     (D 0   " @(D1



 

 A "

 8"   

  #

"   

 

 

  8

?#  

    

 #

 5 

 "A

!

* 

 

   2 

 8    "       

  

 

5 

  "  



 6*B      

5


 

(
9%
$
9
(
>+,
)&


B:;

(
 $%#
><$

 (
$(#
)&

(



(
,$
(
$%
$$
A3A14



F

'(&(
(
(
$
(



 !

   5  " ! 



'

    %   '

 " 7

 # " !

  " 5  "

 "   

!

   4 <   

   '



#



5 5 

 

*  

5 

  5  " !

   

 '

   :





5  8

?C 

0#
(
(
!(
%$
(
G

   

 

 '

   :

 E



  



 

 "  





"

    

;  

,
%$


11
(



 !

   

  

 

 5   B



 

    

 5 

 

  # " 7

 % @)

(

 

   ;

(
9%
$
"

,
!9 $
9
><$
(
$(#
)&

9(
(

$



9
'

(
$%
$$
A3A14

'(
(
.!
$
9
(
>+,
)&



!(
!9 $
9
&!,

(



(
(
(


%+

&$+
+
(
 


!$
&
/3

31

(
&

!$


(
%

(



&#
1034
$




,&9,
%

(



&#
A1/


(

$
(9%
$

(
&$

,,
(
,%
&
$
(
&$!,
.! 
&

,$
!$
&
/01
=
/02

(
&
$

  (
,%
>!,
$

$!
&$

(
 

(
>+,
)&
(#


 
#
'
),(
$
&,
.!$#
(
&( 

,+ 

(9 &$
$


!,
(#
(

$
,9,





(,,
$
%$

(



$
(



(,,
9
$,%$
'(!
9+
'!$


(
&( 
(,,
9
9$+

(

$

#
(
 &%
((,$#
&$
$
,,
&&$


 ,
$

&

(
&( 
9
$'

&&$&
'(
,'
$

&$
&

9
,$
'(
(
>+




'(
/A
$ 

(
$

& 

(
 


&

(
$
9
!9,($

(
' #
 , #
$
"


:+,(;#
D
:$;
9(
 
$
$

(
&,
+E

% 

 


 
$
(,,
9

,9



,

(
!


$&:;


,'

$
&!,


 
$



(
(
 


'!,$
%,!,
$ 

!



1#AA#AAA
<,

(



,
!$
&&!

(
&,
.!$
'(
!
'*
(
 

&& $
) $

&&$+, 
 *,*

 
 '()  

 WHETHER SPEAKING/REASONED YES/NO WHETHER REPORTABLE YES/NO