← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1730/2010dismissed

Bishamber Lal And ANR. v. Arun Kumar

2026-02-20Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal12 pages

 

      

    

 !"#$%&'(%"

)" *"& %"&+& ",

-(         )"

"

&$." /."%(0/1 "

)"02/%(0/

"

%3&# !/%(0/(

"

." 4"5/%(0/"-"

"

% ." /%(0/""-(    

 ! 6""050"(" -( !3  &"  $"(  "$$"/ 1/ 0( '&(5 ((  " (!3%--$$%&"3 0('&(5 ((7  8

6 "-($($"( ( $(  '  - 5  -"/ 0""5 "   11"($($"(- ($(( -/&(--4&"&(1"(4$6$"/ $13 (/ 1 "" """(   9 ( ( -" :  ; 1 &"" "(  -" < 

 !" #$ %&' ( !     ( ( -"  &("  "$ 5"    $3 " 

   ="!&("3$5$ >'  1 &5   5"&(  """  " "  -"(  

  ?

? &5 /7=/&!$5 (  -" 05 &( "$ $"   ( (-" !30"5-0"(( "55 1( (-"  ;1$$5(-"<  (-"(1-( -" 0&" .&"("+& "/&!$ -"< /1&31" "-($($"(   6 -" $( " ' 1"   @5 -"$ "3 !' "5"(5 !$3/  

/ &  / --$ (  "-($($"(  05 --"(  &" 1 $(  

 "/  "$-  $($"( (  1( (/1"" 210"/1"( """"($"(3!("( 6&  ($0"5-( (-" -" < .&"(" +& "/ 1 (( (  1 "(   ("13( (-"  ;1 &""0""(-"< (@"- ""24/%("$$5 "@(&" 0$& 1"@ ;1$((3$"(! (( (-"   

  !   -$(5   -"/  $$15&1"" (!3"$$"

 "# $%&$% %'()*+%*&' % ,- %&)-%%.%/&%+ )*&$%0 )1*+)2*)*3(45%*&)2 %*&6  7 $%&$%  &$% %'()*+%*&' % ,- % &) -% %.%/&%+ )* &$% 0 )1*+ )2 '1-3 %&&,*0 '  %0%+6

 8 $%&$%  &$% %'()*+%*&' % ,- % &) -% %.%/&%+ )* &$% 0 )1*+ &$& &$%4 $9%   ,5(, %+ &$% 9 1% *+ 1&, ,&4 )2 &$% -1, +,*06

 : $%&$% &$%(%&,&,)*,'*)&5,*&,*- %,* &$%( %'%*&2) 56

; $%&$%  &$% (%&,&,)*%  $' *) )/1'3'&*+, *)  $' *4 /1'% )2 /&,)* &) 2, % &$% ( %'%*& (%&,&,)*6

< $%&$%  &$% (%&,&,)*%  ,' %'&)((%+ -4 $,' )=*/&*+/)*+1/&&)2, %&$%( %'%*&(%&,&,)*6

> $%&$%  &$% (%&,&,)* ,' -+ 2)  *)*3.),*+% )2*%/%''

4( &,%'6

? $%&$%  &$% %'()*+%*&' % %*&,& %+ 2) '(%/, /)'&1*+% %/&,)* 6

@

% ,%2 ?

*( "(" ((    /   "$$"/ $$1(  0 -   5"&(  &!$5 ("5-"0( (-"  1-"(1  %--$5("("1 $ ( ( !3  %--$$ %&"3/ 0( "(" (( 7  8/$(5$5"0-

;0"($"(&$"-"  #"( ." &$ "-"5  -" &! (!&"5"0$3""($(5!

A &!$5 ;!&! (((&$3! -"0(  ""(  !  !" #$ %&' -" < (.&"("+& "%&' -"< /(   " "(/ 5 "!3  3 1"05  '   ;  ! &! (   1 ""&$3 ""(( !3 ! &"   ! " (  ( -" " "(/  1&$( ( -"0(  3 (  -"   #"( ." &$  &! (  "$3 05 -" " "(/ 1&$(  (  -" ( 3 /-"""(" ( "-&"-0$5 0$!$&("  ; !"5&(0-"0"$/!

"( /1"'    #"( ." &$  &"" &! (  "-( (-" !31&$(  &&!$5(&!$51&$(0 !-"0(!3$(550( #"(."&$  &"" &! (  0  -$(5   "5"( 1" &/ "/  ( 1" ! 0""(   B$&0 -   ( ( -"  ( ! -"( 1 " ("  #"( ." &$  &"" &! (  &("  "& /  -$(5 1" & (/ ""/  0 - &$(  0 !$$1(  #"( ." &$  &! (  &(& "$1-$(&-  >B!

? 50 !3 -" < /  " " &( !3   5  (" -"3  2 &!     "(   1$/ "5((&$3!(!3     1 "&5  !& "   ( ( -"    #"( ." &$  $ &! (  -"< /(B-"(("(/3( ! "( !3    #"( ." &$  &"" &! ("-($($"(((&$3!-5 "" -"(/""/&("  "& /  1 --( "  "5  -$  &!$5  ; &--"   /  "$ &-  '&(5 2:!$.&-" &"%915 ,%+! &$ )10$  ' ' = * & 5&!

#@@<!#  7;A B' $ &  %' &+ ' ,2% *'1 */% ) () &,)* )2 *+,

#@@?!8  # (  0    &"   , $*+'*= , *+)&$% '

#@?;

7! 

%*&!877 ( .5$    &"  5   '

'$)&5   #@>> 7! %*&  <?<A   ,*0$ ' '$)C 15

#@@@ 7! 

%*&! :;8A .=*&, *+ *)&$%  ' 1 &

#@@D #! 

%*&!:;A .,*+%

'$+*+*)&$% '

9%%* 15

 #@@7 7! 

%*&! #;D *+ 1 =*& ,*0$ ' $ , $ ,&,   #@??

#! 

%*&! <@; (  .5$ $25&"$*+% ,'$) %$ 5 *+ *)&$%  ' $ ,5&, 5( &,  #@?8 7! 

%*&! <;7

  )" "/ $"( &$ "  "-( $($"(&! ("$$5$3(5 ""(( !3 ! &"  ;  ! "5&(   ( (&$3 ! -"0(  ""(  - ( B$&0$3 ! -"( 1  0&"      -" < / 1 !  $" "    >B! ) 8 50 !3 -" < /-" ;!"5&(" 0" "5"(-"5-"("" "(/((&$3!-$((0-  ( ( -"  ( ! &!

$/ 1 $&(  0" "5"(("1$$  #"( &$  -( &   ' " "(15 (!3-""& 0 -/ 1 ( $ ! ( !3 ! &" ( -"0&$3/ " 1" -" " "(/ 5 "!3/!"(1"-"  #"( &$  "5&(  &!$5   $(  !1  -" ( " / 1   !1 " (  (/ ""/  &   -"5 1 - " ("/  0"3 (&$  -"0 #"(&$&! (& "!-"0( $3 !

3  0( -"(&(  ""( (  (5 "&   C$"""5"$((& "30( $(""(/-$$3 )C  %"&+& "()C.(-+& "/!

  &   -"5 1 B$&0 -/ (&$3 ( -"0( "$! (  >B! ) 850!3-"< " "

;$! &! (   -"0"3  ! 1    -&5( "(" 1""5 ""  "0$ '&"(  ; &--"/"$(&-'&(5  2:!$.&-" &")0,*+% ,*0$)+$,'5 1

7DD;!#  8#A $, - $*+  *+* '

*+$,  $*+  1&& #@??!#  8?8A .,& ,*0$ *+ *)&$% ',& 5*+*)&$%

7DD?!@<@@(

%5

C'$'*&)'$15 ,*E)*' 

!*+*)&$%

7D#?!#7  <8> (  "(    &" )$ ,

5

,%+!  '

5., '' *+ )&$% ' $,9'$*C    ,%+!  ' 5& 5  *, *+ )&$% '

7DD< :!  ,9, ! ###A

&,'$&$ *+,  1 &, $C1 $45 .,  1'&!'+ 5*+)&$% '

7D7:

#! 

%*&! 7<DA 5 9&  ' 1'$5 15 , *+ *)&$%

7DD> :!  ,9, ! #:8 (  .1* '' ' 5& , ,*+% 1  *+ *)&$%

 7D#7  * ,*% E 7D:7; ( .5$

  $ 25 &"  1 %*+%  ,*0$ $+$ ' 1-$'$$*+,*, 7D7D 7! 

%*&!;:7(' 25&"$*C  'B)$ ,*15*

'+' ' )2&4 4**+)&$% '

7D7# #! 

%*&!#@;

; 0 ("( &!  ( !3 $"( &$"-"

7  ;1&$(!$ """" " 1" (&$3 ("( (  5"&(  "$ $" 1-"(/"&$1/01-"( 5"&(&!$5$  .&!$5  $13  $( ""5  !1(&! ;$13(!@ $($"( D(""& /-"0-"51 B$&0-(/"("/&5 @/&5/"E&" $1  !-"0(!-!$B C    " 1""$$5(0&!$-" / ! $$ "(&$-"0  ;11$$ $(&!

$5$(""5 / $($"(/  /!$1-"( 1-/&&-1 ((&""-"01-3/ &!   B$&0 -   ( (-"  ;!30(/&!$51&$(!

&,'$&$ *+,  1 &, $C1 $45 .,  1'&!F'/'% &-"/1"&011 @  6 ( 01 1 @/ 1$ "$35 &- " '&(5 &".=*&, '1( !; / 2:!$.&-" &"(@01"!@  

%5

C'$F' /'% '1( !/ 1"  2:!$

8 .&-"  &" $(  $3  $ !&"(  -"0  &!1B$&0--"-"3/1   $($"( (  &  -"0 &   1   !  -"-("  -"!!$3  ; 1 &"" $(   $($"(   -"0   /     (   &(/  !&"(  "!&    $     ; 1&""$(0"3(&$"$($"(-"0/ !3("0(/""5" "&("(5 !1(&!(B-"&$" &-"(-3  (!3   0"5      -" /  (&$3    ""(  !

 " (  ( -" " "(  >B! )  1     -" < /  1 (/1">B!) 1 -"< (  1  210"/ " " "( >B!  ? 1 -"(&(/ 1 1  ' " "(  6   1/ 10"/-"-"(A  ?   &"$5 0-/1(!

 ?

D(" "& / ! &" "5$3 ("((  ( " "(  % "5"(  0" $/ 3 (  ! -"0(  "( 1 $1 (/ ""/ 3 1" "5$3  ("( A 6 -"0  &   -"5  -/  $($"(--(1!B)C (( 3 1"( !&   05 -"( 1 B$&0 -  0&"     )C.(- +& "/ 1

 $ (  0 @1 ! -"/ $ (  ! -"< (-"< /1""(5-"$3( (-""((@ ;1&""( -"< 1(5-"!&24/ %("$$5 "@/ 1( 1(! 55$("3$(" !- 2(&$3( -"< ("1( (-"  ( 1B$&0"$(-

-" <   < $3 / C'&/ 1 --"(  !$/(-"< (( -21@(1$3"/115 " ?

6 $  &/ ! &" "5$3 "$( &-    50 !3 -" <   " / 1 ( ! -"(&(  ""(  >B! )  ; 1   &( !3 -" < / 5   +& "/ $$55   +& " 1 $ &5     = <1 %&' "3 $"/ 1 1 (-0$3  $"       -   = %&' "3 $"  ;  B /  (   ( ! (5  !&  "3 $5 !3    ( 3$  = %&' "3$"/&(%("$$5 "@ .-< AA (A?"$3"("$"1(5  !&."- ( (-" ." -  ;  "B /  (   ( " -       ( 3$  = %&' "3

 $"/115 ;0"3B$/ (   ( - 1 !5 "& !3   210"/   B 1"$"(5  !&."-/-$$(!(1 -"0(   ( -  ( ( -"  1 !5 &-(!3 -"<  

;"-$(5""(/1(&$3 -$(( !3  "-($($"(   ( ( -"  (!&!$ .&!$5 -"51-" ("  >0 "1/ & 3-" $ 01 (&$(!@  ;    )0,*+%  ,*0$ )+$, '1( !/  2:!$.&-" &"(( ""(  ! " (  1" 35 -"$3/  &$( ! $&((   1 -"0(    ( -"( 1 -  0&"     % "5"( "3 (" $/  2:!$ .&-"  &"/ 1$ "$35 &-  '&(5      $ &  %' &+F' '1( !/ $(   ""5   &!$5   !

& &("  &&$5" "&("(5!1( -"1 -($0"((""& (!(!@$($"(/$5 0"("""5-$($3 ;1$(   &  /   (&$ "  $($"(  -"0 !3 ("0(-"1 -"-"3(! &!

  1 ( !3  2:!$ %-B &"     " '&(5   5& .-, 1 *+* 'B'$)C%', , E)/ #@?@!##@( *+* '+$)

'$+ ,+4 #@@?!<;>8 7 F&""/$1$$$(( /      (  "  3 "! ('&(5 )$ , 5F'/'%

&-"  < $3 /  -"0"3  &(    -&5( (0(1&""(5 ( $10 !""((/1""5"""0$'&"( 8 ; 0 5 "&5  '&(5  "$( &- !3 $"( ." &$ "-"5  -"  1$$ 6"!$&$3(-&"$((1 ('&(5  210"/31&$( ( -"/01-&$"-"( '&(5 """(-"(5-"5"-  6 !5 /   -  &(  ! (0( "( "(5$3( (  )(5 --$ /  3/ $$ $ ( (-(

  !      (  C"-@5="( G=< C""-"!$ G=<