← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCP/35/2015disposed of

Olympus Imaging India Private Limited v. Olympus Medical Systems India Private Limited

2015-07-06Mr. Justice Arun Monga9 pages

      

  !"!#$%"& ' 

("!  !%)% *+ , -

 "&!.(""!/ *+ 0!"% )1 "12 "&!.3( %!)"4 1,    "&!.(""!/ *+ 0&!.! .(56(.("% 7!"$!! * 58.39).(6% 6 #%(:";"# /( ) !//.3( 8<!"%"% !/.3( 8+ 

58.39)!#%(508)"!.) #%(:";"# /( ) !/!!.3( 8<!"%"% !/.3( 8+ *= ;0>;    



 

    

     

  

     

    !

" #$%

&#'

&

 

 (  "  )# &#'

  " " % &#

*

+  >;4 ;

  

 

 %

- -.

( #&-/0 

 



  &





%

#

1#2  3

  

  



  

  

 

 (

45&6

6

&



 &"78 &7  &   





(  

" #  

#



 

   (  '    2      

   #2   1( 3 .1( 3& 

'

5  

 



  (  '

  



 2    #2   0    9  '

'%

#

  

'   94.



 '   



(  ( 

:

;

4/'

  44 4/&

(  

   ' 

 

<, %  

=  ( 

  %   

    

&         

 

        &  



 



 * 



 

&

(  '



 94 4/

  8

 &"

 

(

#

&:

*

+ 

 

 

 

          

   >?   <2

> 1<

3>@ >1A  3  B:(8<

   *

7C

%

A   

'



  



)    8



*

+ 8

 



 (   % )   

 

  '   

   ? 

94/4/



'

&" 

  #D  ( ' &  8

  &  :

   8

&  "

  

(

#

 :

;E-

 !   



         

        

    

!

  

"#$%   &   !

          '   '(   

  (        



(   )

      (  

 

             !

     

  

 

   

   "  



          

         

       

  )                 

          '(            



         

   ' * '  

   (

          +

   '  

   +        

 (

  '          ) 

  ,    '  '(      ( 

 )        

     --./-.  (   '  

    '  (   ? 

 ,  

8

 

'

&  " 

 % ) &  #

C  8  ' 

  

  

'

-404/ (   %

)     :

&.&/E0

 

.

    ! /  0

 ,  

   1/2 /-#    (   "   3   

  )         ,         !

   

              

     ' * '  

   (

              4'   (       5" 3   

( 

 )./-. 

  , 

     (  (

 6 '  . 

'     

   ( ' '

 (       

        3     

   '    

     

 "#$  

    

 

    

  , +

   '

 '

7'

         

  ,    

  

'   

            

      8'

   !

" 

"#$ #  '

(  

         9





   

      



    : 

 !

  

('    ,  $       (  '(   



       !

    + 

   (  '(               &   !

   

     ;

 '            2//-.    4 5,+ %/451<%.   ( 

/      =

    

    

  --/-# 

        )          

 !

   '   2 

       

C  ' 

  

  

        ,  

8

 

*

+  

 

 

 40494/     '



  '

"B  7 E( &(  # &

(                            

 & 

     & '   :

.E/

2  



(  # %    ! .

  1>  3

 ? 



   

'    

'     '(  

 



/#-$/-#

 

   )   )'  %/       

'        

(  9% "  #$ %&       

   '

       

  ( #$ %           ) 

  

       *   )

  & +   ,   

   

         #       ' @     1>  !  ;

( 003 /#7' /-.  (   9 & '8' '     5 /  

    

  (

'

0  (    (

  

 ' (  



 



(

 (   '     '

 ) (   >   

 (     (* 

'  



 * 



' '

 '   ) 

   (       

'   / ( A

'   '  '

'     '  )  %) 

) '

'

      ''

    (  '   

     '

'

   ( 

    



 '

 

         '

      '      '

  )  )

' 

(   3 .     (

      B   

(

  ('  

 )

       



   3 $    

1  /-.1  /-

-

- . (   ( 0  (      /. ./- #"/# -$ <'



   /.## -2 %%% * 3



%%%    --- --- 22$ $$$   /# -$ C&            /-.

      = '

 +

   7         ' *  %  '



'

! 

  + 3' ' '

     



  

(

>(

 

 

 ( 

9  '   '  3 "      1  /-.1  /-  



 '

' '  C# - -.# .

# "#

 '  

 '

 D/ $"2    22/ // 2 2# #$  $ # -- •  =21  /-/   ,    '  '

  

'     5

       )  ;

'

 ,' @ 

   

         '

  5

     

    '        @ +  '( 8'    

  (

   @ + (    

 

(   

  



 '    (      '   )  

  1    )  (

 

 '

'

   (  '              

 

 (

 ( 

  

      D   '    

 

  '     !

 '



"$/                    = '

+

 7 '   ( E'

    '  

  '    

 )

 '  

     

 (     '    ( 3 $  /  ( )     )"  0

1  /-.1  /-  





;     $ $#/ # "# 22      %%%   / $ /.2  $ $#/  ## #$ ./.

•   (  

'    (       4=;  (

( '



  

' 



  '  + +4(

  

        + 

  '  '

      



'           + '    

     

  3 $ ?

'   

 





  

 %

#

"

' & 







    

"*#



( 

  

   '

 2 



"

' & 

(    ) ' 

 (   %

#

 A& 

    '

    



 %"

' & 





 

(  #   

      

 & 

    

 

   '  

         

' 

     %

 /

/

( #&-/0  

  

 

 '  

  ,     %

- -.

( #&-/0 '8  

 

 

   

 8

  &  :

   8

& "

  

 (

  #

&  :

      *

  + &  

- %

#

  

     & 

 

   '  

   (      

 (       

'     ?

 



 %

#

40494/

%    



  ( &  

'%   &( 

   +

  



%

#

      







 8

  

(  4

 



 # 

  

  

>? <2

>1<

3>@ >1A  3  B:(8 <

  *

7C

%

A  #

     

   



1 3   +   

   

   '

 

 

8  4&444B  ( 

6# 

*

+    %

  ( 





   >; @40&4/