High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/540/2017disposed of

Mahender Kumar Singh v. K.Vijay Raghavan And ANR.

2018-07-10Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh4 pages

!

$!%&'&"() * *

!

"$

# %

"&'() &*#+'

) ," - '

%#.'()&*#+'

) '$$("+' 0

1#.'()#"

.2&34)

#/ 5"# +-#(#6.0

#"$

#

'7'")

) ' "#'(5 '"

+-1

)

#8"$

#

'.

" -"

'$$("+' "# "

/# 3$ "# / #3 $

#'( '$$ '+ #/

%,'

%$)

.)

+-#(#6.) ""

'&

#/&"'),-#-'

';

#*

'/

#/ #/ "7'. '6-'*') ,-# ,'

"" "'((.

"3$( '& & '

# '& -'

%$

'%'

& # < '.

/# 3$ "#/ #3$

#'('$$ '+

#%6- " - ("6- #/ - /'+ -' -

&%(.+#3$("

&," - '/

6"*"6'$

"6 # -

#8><'&=.

"6'#

* &'

2 :%

04'$$ &'(#6," - -

'$$("+' "# ?#

# 3 & " - '$$("+' "#) - '3 "

'((#, & 3$ "#/ #3$

#'('$$ '+ 6 & #

,'

%$)

.)

+-#(#6.)""

'&

#/&"'

1#.'() #"

. 2&34)

#/ 5"# +-#(#6.0

#'&

'7 '")

) ' "#'( '"

+- 1

0

# 8 '

$

" $

# "

+#3$("'+ ," - -

&'

&>><$'

@

+#%

(/#

#

#AB>-'

#,&%(.+#3$("

&," - '&" %$$# #/ -"

'

"#)- $('+

("'+ %$# -

&'

8><2 :%

04/"( &'(#6," - - '//"&'*" #/

,'

%$)

.)

+-#(#6.)""

'&

#/&"'),-"+-#

"*

#8>< 'C%

"#= "6'

;

'

#,-.-'

=

+#3$("

&," -'(3# '/

+#3$( "##/ -

.

)' //#

=

3'& =. - (

+#%

(/#

=.3';"6

/

&'

&8>< -' -

'3'

#//'+ )6"*

"6=. - #"

.2&34

#/ 5"# +-#(#6.0

# # <B) >A '& >A'&# -' ='

)-'&$ #+

&# - '

%3$ "# -' -

+#3$

'% -# " . # & +"& +('"3#/ -

'"&

'% -# " . '

,'

$

3"6 -"

&% "

%&

' "#'( 5 '"

+- 1

) ,-"+- ,'

%&

#( #/ - +#+

& #"

.2&34 -'

/% -

:$('"

& -' # - ='

"6)+#33

' "#'(5 '"

+-

,

+'(( & /# '& # +# "&

' "# -

#/) - 3'

,'

%( "3'

(.& +"& &#B

-' " ,'

& '( =.

#),-#,'

#"

.2&34)

+-#(#6.) ""

'&

#/&"'%&

'=#'

/"& ("

/ -' - '$$ #$ "'

'% -# " . - 3'

#,-'

+# "&

&'&$

"6 ,'

6"*

=.

#'& -

'/

)' ';"6 #

%( "6"& ('."+#3$("'+ ," - -

=. -"

/% -

-' /# -"

"# &"'

& ('.# - #/ -

)'%+#&" "#'('$#(#6.-'

&)'

/#%&"

'0#/ - '//"&'*" &'

&8< ) -

)$ '.

#"

"#'(#0+#3$("'+ # -

'&" ,'

%&

'=#'/"& ("

/ -' - ,-#(

+"

"6+'

&#%

'6'"

&'$#(#6.#= -'(/#/ -

"1#% #&'.'&=.

"6 -' -

)-'*"6#,+#3$("

&," - -

=. -"

) %(

& # - 3= &"

+-'

&

),-#'$$

"$

#)'

-' '#0 ';"6 #

," -#% & '("6," -'(( - $( ) ,-"+--'*

';

=.-"3" -

+'

),-"+--'

'& - ,

' - "3 ,-

"6,'

& #-"3 ) -

) +# 3$ #/,-"+-"

'(( &)-'

# =

+#3$("

&," -

-'* +# "&

& -

3'& =. -

'

, (('

(

+#%

(/#

'&#+# "&

"6 - '"&

)'3#/ - +# "&

&*"

, -' "/ -

&'

8><$'

&=.

#"

# ' ';"6#

)" "

#$ # -

#+-'(( '3 '

&'

&AB>

-"

,#%(&# (";

#+#33 %$# - '"& + '&" ,#%(&= #$

# ';

'(( - $( ,-"(

+-'(( 6"6 - '"&#

)"/ #'&*"

&

6'

3$ -'*"6 =

+#33"

& =. -

) -"

' "

/"

&," - -

$#

# -

# '"

"#'(#0+#3$("'+ # - #/ -

#, *

) -

),'

*

.

+( '& "3$( ),-"+-&"&#

C%"

#=

3- .

,

C%"

& #+#3$(.," -" "(

'& $"

" '&"/ -

'.

&#%= ," -

6'

& # -

) - . -#%(&-'* 3#* ''$$ #$ "'

'$$("+' "#=

-"

,#%(&# & (*

" # -"

'

+ #, *

) ;

$"6 " *"

, - "# &"'

& ('. "

+#3$("'+

) -"

*"

, -'

-

-#%(& = +#3$

& /# '3 '&) -

) -

&"

& #$'.+# #/ )0 # -

," -"'

"#&#/# 3# -/ #3 #&'. " "# '& &"

$#

&#/

%(

& # -

'& &"

+-'

& ,-.

/

0 0

12! 2!3 '4!5&(673!'"(!$) !'7"

12! 2!3 !4"3 8-!)

!'7"