High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2179/2021disposed of

Union Of India v. Sunita And ORS

2022-02-09Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal14 pages

# $

(

)!! *

% &"'

( !)

*) '

+%% !*+

)& , %-.

)& % %

)& %/)& 0&*+)& 1) )& %%0 )& & %

)& )

0)& )

)& -'2 )&

)& *

)& '

*) ', !

' +

! 5 6 )!! $

& ' + % 78 9 ) :

) 3;8

< 3;8) <

5 " =33) !! + + % 8 3;8) 333

5 %/

>0 >%

! + !!

5 5 ++ ' + & ! :

> 3 $ 8 3;8) 333 $ ? 3;8) 3?333 =

@ ) A83?A3= 8 4 :

37(

3;(

+& - 2

? -! 6

> 0 > % ! 9

A 59)"

9 ) :

" A ! &1

;

5 " ;8A$>! 5 =33 = !

! 5 :

!! ! :

& & - 2 4

% ! 8

!& +1&

5 9 ) :

< 9)"<

!!! B+

-C3%+ -C( %

-C= 5%

-C8)

-C7.

+ -C?

! B+

.+ %%#$C$"

- 7

!& +1& 5 !!

5 9)"!

B+!

> % #B %

) )+

+ & )!!B + &! 3 -C=$( 3=887 3=33 37

37$> % ! ==;;$> -C=$"

33A= 333 3

A$> % ! ==;;$> = -C=$ 38337 =333 3

A$> % ! ==;;$> 8 -C=$# 3?;

?333 3A7

37$> % ! ==;;$> 7 -C8$"

?=7A 33? 7

37$> % ! 33$> ? -C8$ @-C8$/ 333 A7? A;

7?$> % ! =8?7;87$> A -C8$# A37 3;$3 =8

=3;$> % ! =8??3=$> ; -C8$- #B-C8$0 A7? A338 =7

;A$> % ! =?;;$> #B-A 73?

333 =

8$> % ! ==;;$> ? "

& ! 5 !& !!B +! &

==;;$>

!!! !! A7D & ;8A$>! 4 " 5 &

5 7D

& +1&

A /

! 5

! ' + !

5 "

& ! &!! ,

+1& :

; 9

" 5!! A7D

4 + 3$=

+ 5

B+! 5 5 4 " &1 :

! 5

++ !! 4 B! !

! + % -

" "

% & +!

4 5+ % " - *

4 "

! B+!

! -

" ++

! B+!& +

E&!!

+1&

& ! B+! ! 5 +!5 :

/ " ++

7D & +1&

"! +!

' +

& & 5 ! 7D & 5 :

" E +

! !

! 33

& & ! B+! ! +!

! &!

!& 3

A7D 5 &

! :

& E>>& E

B+! ! 5 3= ,

+ )

!! -C8

& ! 7 : !

33? 37$> 4 !

33$>% )

!! -C8

7 : ! 5

+& 33? 5 :

/! ! + 37$> 33? !!B +? 5 % 8 3;8) 4

& !

! 4

5 "4

F "!

G +

& :

! + % -

" " % - 2" ) ! ' + !

5 9)"% )

5 +1& ;A7$> !+ 5 +1& ! 5 5 =A7$>! ? 38 ,

& :

+! 5 1

5& +1 & :

5 1 !

B! 5

+ !

! B! 5

+ / + 5 !!!

+1& :

+ 37 6 +9)" 7D & 5

! ' + !

5 /

) 1 +2 3( *++ )456,

4347 ..-4 &

> F C3

.+ %%#

+ ! < 5 5

& :

& 5 +

5 + 4

%/ * .%

-@/ 96

=8 ! 5

& 7D &

+1 &

& !

! G 3?

& +!

& 4 +

& 5& ! 4 +5

4 + & 5

E ! :

% ! + 5 /& " 1

+ ! 3A

(

' + !

5 /

< ! ' + " ! ' + !

)8+94 )456 6+ 3( ) 1 89:

6+856 '

;

4347 ; .%

< %'

< ! :

5 &

7D +

! &

& 5

5 !

4 "

;

4 " 1

+ +5 " +!

!!4 " 1

& 5 ! +

& 5 :

3; .!

!!! + 5 1 "

5 !

(

+ 5!!!

+1&4 !

!! +1& :

)! + 5 !!

5!5

+1& !

5 & + & +5

5!! 3 "

5 " + 5 1 5 ! &

B! " > +

& 5

5 5 :

! 4 !

!!5 " =

*) ' 1

$ H $ !5 H $

Sr. No.

Case No.

Petitioner's name Respondent's name 1.

RFA No.2179 of 2021 Union of India Sunita and others.

RFA No.2212 of 2021 Union of India Savitri and others 3.

RFA No.2211 of 2021 Union of India and another Jagdish and others 4.

RFA No.2210 of 2021 Union of India and another Kanwar Singh and others 5.

RFA No.2209 of 2021 Union of India Santosh and others 6.

RFA No.2208 of 2021 Union of India and another Kanwar Singh and others 7.

RFA No.2207 of 2021 Union of India and another Rai Singh and others 8.

RFA No.2220 of 2021 Union of India and another Rai Singh and others 9.

RFA No.2219 of 2021 Union of India Vikash and others 10.

RFA No.2218 of 2021 Union of India Har Dayal (deceased) thr. LRs and others 11.

RFA No.2217 of 2021 Union of India and another Kamaljeet and others 12.

RFA No.2216 of 2021 Union of India Vivekanand Siksha Samiti and others 13.

RFA No.2215 of 2021 Union of India Vivekanand Siksha Samiti and others 14.

RFA No.2214 of 2021 Union of India and another Omparkash and others 15.

RFA No.2213 of 2021 Union of India and another Smt. Sushama Devi and others 16.

RFA No.2228 of 2021 Union of India and another Smt. Indirawati and others 17.

RFA No.2227 of 2021 Union of India and another Dilbag Singh and others 18.

RFA No.2226 of 2021 Union of India Smt. Hardei and others 19.

RFA No.2225 of 2021 Union of India and another Mahabir Singh and others 20.

RFA No.2223 of 2021 Union of India and another Satpal and others

21.

RFA No.2221 of 2021 Union of India and another Smt. Urmila Devi and others 22.

RFA No.951 of 2020 Kanwar Singh and others State of Haryana and others 23.

RFA No.2257 of 2021 Union of India and another Mahabir and others 24.

RFA No.2241 of 2021 Union of India and another Om Parkash and others 25.

RFA No.2240 of 2021 Union of India and another Satpal and others 26.

RFA No.2238 of 2021 Union of India and another Mahabir and others 27.

RFA No.2237 of 2021 Union of India and another Mehtab and others 28.

RFA No.2236 of 2021 Union of India Smt. Bimla and others 29.

RFA No.2235 of 2021 Union of India and another Sat Parkash and others 30.

RFA No.2234 of 2021 Union of India Balwan Singh and others 31.

RFA No.2233 of 2021 Union of India Balwan Singh and others 32.

RFA No.2232 of 2021 Union of India and another Jai Narain (deceased) thr. LRs and others 33.

RFA No.2231 of 2021 Union of India and another Smt. Vidhya Devi and others 34.

RFA No.2230 of 2021 Union of India and another Mehtab and others 35.

RFA No.2229 of 2021 Union of India Roopchand and others 36.

RFA No.952 of 2020 Vivekanand Siksha Samiti State of Haryana and others 37.

RFA No.1007 of 2020 Smt. Vidhya Devi and others State of Haryana and others 38.

RFA No.1008 of 2020 Mehtab and others State of Haryana and others 39.

RFA No.1009 of 2020 Mehtab and others State of Haryana and others

40.

RFA No.1022 of 2020 Kanwar Singh and others State of Haryana and others 41.

RFA No.1024 of 2020 Vivekanand Siksha Samiti State of Haryana and others 42.

RFA No.1032 of 2020 Kamaljeet and others State of Haryana and others 43.

RFA No.1034 of 2020 Vivekanand Siksha Samiti and another State of Haryana and others 44.

RFA No.1035 of 2020 Savitri State of Haryana and others 45.

RFA No.1036 of 2020 Kamaljeet and others State of Haryana and others 46.

RFA No.1037 of 2020 Kanwar Singh and others State of Haryana and others 47.

RFA No.1038 of 2020 Savitri and another State of Haryana and others 48.

RFA No.1343 of 2021 Sunita and another Union of India and others 49.

RFA No.2148 of 2021 Om Parkash and others State of Haryana and others 50.

RFA No.6289 of 2018 Ajay Kumar and others State of Haryana and others 51.

RFA No.1413 of 2021 Virender Singh and others State of Haryana and others 52.

RFA No.2476 of 2021 Surender Singh and others State of Haryana and others 53.

RFA No.2478 of 2021 Rai Singh and others State of Haryana and others 54.

RFA No.2481 of 2021 Sanju State of Haryana and others 55.

RFA No.2510 of 2021 Rai Singh and others State of Haryana and others 56.

RFA No.2512 of 2021 Urmila Devi State of Haryana and others 57.

RFA No.2513 of 2021 Mahabir Singh and others State of Haryana and others 58.

RFA No.2516 of 2021 Satpal and others State of Haryana and others

59.

RFA No.2517 of 2021 Satpal and others State of Haryana and others 60.

RFA No.2538 of 2021 Santosh State of Haryana and others 61.

RFA No.2539 of 2021 Santosh State of Haryana and others 62.

RFA No.2678 of 2021 Dilbag Singh State of Haryana and others 63.

RFA No.2180 of 2021 Union of India Balwan Singh and others 64.

RFA No.2181 of 2021 Union of India Smt. Om Devi and others 65.

RFA No.2182 of 2021 Union of India Smt. Suman and others 66.

RFA No.2183 of 2021 Union of India Savitri and others 67.

RFA No.2184 of 2021 Union of India and another Smt. Nirmla and others 68.

RFA No.2185 of 2021 Union of India Balwan Singh and others 69.

RFA No.2186 of 2021 Union of India Om Parkash and others 70.

RFA No.2187 of 2021 Union of India and another Karambir and others 71.

RFA No.2188 of 2021 Union of India Smt. Rattan Kaur and others 72.

RFA No.2189 of 2021 Union of India Rajinder Singh and others 73.

RFA No.2190 of 2021 Union of India Smt. Kamlesh and others 74.

RFA No.2191 of 2021 Union of India Dharambir Singh and others 75.

RFA No.2192 of 2021 Union of India and another Anand Singh and others 76.

RFA No.2193 of 2021 Union of India and another Sanju and others 77.

RFA No.2194 of 2021 Union of India Mrs. Rakesh and others 78.

RFA No.2195 of 2021 Union of India Kitabo and others

- 79.

RFA No.2196 of 2021 Union of India Satbir Singh and others 80.

RFA No.2197 of 2021 Union of India and another Kanwar Singh and others 81.

RFA No.2198 of 2021 Union of India Vivekanand Siksha Samiti and others 82.

RFA No.2199 of 2021 Union of India Smt. Shakuntla and others 83.

RFA No.2200 of 2021 Union of India and another Pardeep and others 84.

RFA No.2201 of 2021 Union of India and another Kamaljeet and others 85.

RFA No.2202 of 2021 Union of India and another Surender Singh and others 86.

RFA No.2203 of 2021 Union of India Balwan Singh and others 87.

RFA No.2204 of 2021 Union of India Indra Devi and others 88.

RFA No.2205 of 2021 Union of India and another Kanwar Singh and others 89.

RFA No.2206 of 2021 Union of India Roopchand and others 90.

RFA No.2222 of 2021 Union of India and another Ram Kishan (deceased) thr LRs and others 91.

RFA No.2239 of 2021 Union of India and another Ram Kishan (deceased) thr LRs and others 92.

RFA No.2224 of 2021 Union of India Jagmehar Singh (deceased) thr LRs and others 93.

Cross objections-161Union of India Jagmehar Singh (deceased) thr LRs and others 94.

RFA No.2533 of 2021 Bimla and others State of Haryana and others 95.

RFA No.171 of 2020 Rattan Singh (deceased) thr LRs and others State of Haryana and others

96.

RFA No.1430 of 2021 Dharmbir Singh (deceased) thr LRs and others State of Haryana and others 97.

RFA No.954 of 2020 Balwan Singh (deceased) thr. Lrs and others State of Haryana and others 98.

RFA No.1004 of 2020 Balwan Singh (deceased) thr. Lrs and others State of Haryana and others 99.

RFA No.1014 of 2020 Balwan Singh (deceased) thr. Lrs and others State of Haryana and others 100.

RFA No.1033 of 2020 Balwan Singh (deceased) thr. Lrs and others State of Haryana and others 101.

RFA No.953 of 2020 Balwan Singh (deceased) thr. Lrs and others State of Haryana and others

*) ' 1