High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1755/2010dismissed

Bhushan Lal v. Amit Kumar And ORS.

2026-04-06Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl21 pages

! "# $"%"& ' !

(!% ) *%)! "! '!

! ("++!,# # ! !

! -./% #-! , "! 0%"$# ! "

! ! 1 ! 2"03#-! , "! $"0( ! (!"2-%!# !!

'!+! "45 '+45 "+ " ! $!6 2+!%

!+%) 6" !

"+ " ! ! ".%+)

60 " !! 8," 60! %!-

"9!0:!64 !

;

4"! !!!! <

<5!

) !&4 ! ! 60&<5,, "+ ".%+) ," " " 60 " !# ," , ) ! "

! !

! ,%6

#,)=% "+

!! >" %!

" "

"+!%%6

+ "+!%) !) !)

"9!0:!64 ! ;

! ".

) &$"%"&!)-" % '!$?!#)6

#!+!% >"

!!.%+) 8, "! !

"&$"%"& "! "

" ! !

0 "!, " ! "!) " !) " " + ".%+) >" 60 " !

$"%"&, ".%+) #

!," ! !0@ ! )% 60") 9,!# "

"+!%%6

+) ! ) !) ,% " !,!

"! ") !), " !) "

!) " " + ".%+) >" !

$"%" & "+ " .%+) " !! % "! 060+ " !

>" , !! 1 8 +, "!!

18 !! + "!!, 6" ! ," " , ) !! 7 7 + "!!#! 17 "9A6-% !)%!

, " .%+) 1 >"! !

! !! " !

.%+) 1 ," " !

" !)=% >" 9A6-% !)%!

!! 1 1#! ".%+)

1 !) ")

! "9+"%!

! " " !

+ " !) =%

%!% "!! ")

!" )% 6! "%!

&! %!

!"%6)

" ! # "%+"! +!%!

,! 26%

"06!!0 "+!%%6

+ " +!% ) ! ) !) B " !

" +!% %6

+# "6%6)

&, " !) "&"%6 !) " ! !

$"%"&#,"6! "! &

%6)

" "!"# , " !

! &" "+ , " ! !

0=% " ! !

0, % "!)*! "$"%"&," "

, " ! ! !" $"%"&

%6)

"+ " !! " % "! 0 "

!0 &! %! !""+"+"

"! # ," ""6@"6 ;@ 'B$# ", "6

) ! # ")"6+60$"%"&

%6)

!+ "," %) ,%", "$"%" &,", " ! ! ! "!)," " !)=%

"! %6)

" ! ! " !% %) 8 81 ," ""6 !% ! ! !2C'DA " %) , % !,"" ! ", 6@B !% " %)

,%", ")% 60$2! , 60 ! "!+,! -) -" 3

%6)

! ! % &"6 !% ! !60 ! "%# " %) ," ""6 !% 60 !"),%%!

"! ! &, ! , !"!)," ",

" !)=%

"!%6)

! ) *%)!

! ! ", 6@ ,-%6""# "! " ) *%)!#,"" ! ", 6@'B !

@) "'B # "'B " ) 0 !0

%6)

""" !

@) " 2, ," "! 87

8# *! " $"%" & ,! " " %!

)

$"%"&*! "" ! #"" &,

!+% " % ! &,

" !)=% , "!," "" 6 "!+ " !

"%#%6)

"+ "

!!, " % "! 0 "% !! + "! !+ "

! , "%# ! 6 &! %! !"%!

"!%6)

"+!%) !) !) !) 0 )% " !

%6)

!% ".

)

,%", #, "!

"+!%) !) !) # "!!) "6) @

0 0," "+" 6)60 ! ") !)! "!0 !) 0% "+,% ), " ")+) ! ) !)

%6)

"+ " !! "

6% 0 !0 " E! %!

" 60 !!0!+ " B $"%"&#6! B ")

" ! @) ", , !) ,!6!260"), "% 2+ !)!) "!

%6)

!% " ! ! @) "B ,%", % ")"6) "%# "6 + ) 0 !!6)!+ B

%6)

# "

!!) " !)=% % 6

&!-!%! "! !# "!"#"%6)

6 "%, "!

+ ) !) !) "6 !!

0 60 " !! ,60 " % "! 0

%6)

"! 0 , "!)*! "

$"%"& % " !)=% ,!

% "0!8,"!B" ! @) ")

"!),!+ !!) ) @ "0!

%6)

!) "

# ! " %+"

6!60 ! ",!

) ,!6% 0 !!

"!!+% !% "! ;@ 'B$,%", "" "! # "6 ") & "!)!

$"%"&, " "!,=% ,! +& 6

"!%6)

"!@ 60 !

!+!+ "

"!%6)

0! # "!) *! "$"%"&" "!6", 6 ! !

!"+! 6" "!)

"!%6)

B $"%"&" !

@) "%!

"!)

")+"

"+ "!

6"6! "! ) )"6! "!&%

) "" ""2 "$"%"& + "!

%6)

!) "6

# ! , &,", " !)=%

!) 0 ! "!)*! "$"%"&, !) "%#+6 "%!

! , ",! 6% "

%6)

" %!

,"@!

+!.%!

+%!

.%!

60 "%!

) % !

" !+%) #""!% ".%+) 60 "9A6-% !) %!

! "#$%&

'(& ! !

)*+' ,

"!%6)

! &, "%6

+ !60 %6 ", !

$"%"& " @ % " ! !

0=% "%!

"!%6)

" "6! "!" !, " ! !

0 &! -!%"%!

"!%6)

! "

+!%) ! ) !) !# )! 6 % ")% "B" ! @) ")

""!) ",!" "%

" !)=% , "% ",!

%6)

"6! "%!

! , "

,! 6% " >"%!

""!! %! !, !! %!! " !%

"! ! " !!

% 6! "%!

" %!

"% " "

!!) " !)=%

,+!% "+!%%6

+ "+!%) ! ) !) "+"6) " ,+!%6"

" ,+!%," "%!

,% ! ," "! "

!!! 6% "! >"! +!%," "!=%! 6 ! " !

," "! "

!! 60 " !!, 60 " % "! 0 "+!%%6

+!=%! 6 % "! >"! "

" 0-" , "0,! " !) =% &4,",! ! 60"&#,""6 ) ! 5, " !)#," "

, 2! 60") 7 8F !) " " !) ,! 2 ! 60 & "!%+" !

$"%"&

,%!

"! ! -" "@ !+6") *%)!"!+"! "6 B@ % 60-" "%!", "+! -" E%!

"!-%6""++!, ! ,",

" "-" ,) !

>"+!%%6

+,! !45

#," " , &"%6 "" =% $"%"&, "% " !) ! 4 "!5 &, ! +

# %! !"6" >" !

!#,", "+%6

#" "

* ,!

) ",!

) # " 260 !, " !),

!)60 ") *! "$"%"&," "$"%"&, " ! ! !

, "&" !, 0 "!

% " !)=% ! "!# ,*!

"$"%"& "!)#,", >" !!!! 8#"%!

% "!,! " ! 6 , !

% %! "!"

" +!% %6

+ , ) % :! " %# , 6! "! 4;@ 'B $5"6 !! ! ! ")#&, " ! !"

", "!) *! "$"%"&,@

"0!8

,%!

"! &," 6

$"%"&," !+B " ,!

) " &" !, "" =% # , ! "&"%6 "" " + "" "$"%"&

>" % "! 0 .%+) % " "+%!

"!+ !!% "+ +!% %6

+ >" ! !

" 6! % "! 0!! !% "!6,

"#$%!

& "&

()(*#$

!+ +

& ( - - . %/ !

01 -& & 2 3. 04 !! & 5 %/& !

% (

"& / * 1& &

! & "& /('1&

% &

6&&")!!

+!&(

&)"7+% &8&(&&%

9 %/!!

&& !

: -

;

&6&&"1% & 2 9 &

9 (( <& !! %

& = 19 -&/& & = - -&/6&&"%< 9-& !(& (

& = ;

&6&& "-

(

& / *

(*# 91 &

&(&

9 &-&= ;

&6&&"- . 9 &

/ * = &

1 (&9 . &

&& (&&2 !&(

% && % &

"1-& /&(' <%0

% &!!

! &2

9/99& & 2 !

/ 99 & 9 % - &

1&91& !

% (

-(2

&&29!9/1%9 & /&

- .

9 * 1& & / ( 8- 99 .( 9 - &

1&% &

6&&")!!

9 +!&(

&% &1 ( &

%/&& !

"> 22222222

4 -

"&29!9/-

= ;

&6&&"1%1 /1-16&&"1-& ! & !

: 1&1-

& .!-&9!9/& ! & !

1-& &!

% ( & %

99 ! 5

7 7 '!% "6,%", " % "! " 0 !% "! 4;@ 'B $5," ")

, 6 &# "%+" ") !! + %!$"%"&

,6! ") "!),

) "! $"%"&"+ "! 6" 6" "!)# "%#"

, *! "$"%"&

,%!

B $"%"&" ! @) ")

!) *! "$"%"&,!+ ! "0!8

# "!, "+ ", "!),@ 8# ," "0!# "! ,@ % ,%

) !

0# ") ! @) B "

")+"

"+ "! 6"" 6! "! &,

,6! , !

,& "!) *! "$"%"& ,

", "$"%"& ", !)=% # " "+!%%6

+ ! , "!,0 !)+! 60 !! " %! >"+

! , ",! 6 % " !% "! ," "%0@"6 ;@ 'B$# ," "6 "! %! !,!!

%! "! "!% #", "!

%)," ") , 6% >" ) "6% 60" 6 & "!) *! "$"%"&!$"%"& >" !+0 6-" " !) 6 " #," "# "

%+"

" 6@ 6" ! # # "!) *! "$"%" &, # ","0 ") ,) + %) & " ! ! # "! !! "!) *! "$"%"& >" %! !""+"+"

! "6+60$"%"&,"! "+ %!

"$"%"& !# ",!G H) " !+!# ! "$"%"&" + 6" "!) *! "$"%"& !!# !+ "! ,% !0", & !)=% E%!

"!#) !

0# "$"%"&#,"" !B #" " ! @) %6 6 6"&#""+ "! +!) "%!

"! & ) "" =% "" 2") + "! +!) >" !

! @) %!

"! "!

! &,",

" !)=% %!

"!", "+ !! " % "! 06 !% !%

" ! ! 0# "B $"%"&"

! @) " " ) 0

" 0) ! # "%+""0 ")

% "" "%!

"! " ,!," "!" ) @ 0! ) !

0#"%!

"! ! @) #" ")

"!) *! "$"%"&,!+ ! 8# "%+"" !))6! " ) " >"%#!) 6# ! "!), !+ ! "0!8 ," "! ,@ % "+"6", "%!

! "0!8# "!),@ "% 6! " !! "

% 6", 6 !!!+ >" "B "6 ! 60

">! $! " "%!

>" ! !

" B ! !% "!6,

&2 /99

! !9

! 5 !

9% !% &% &"1 ( &

(

(&" 9 & &!& &5 (&

(

-" 7&&!/

;

! & 9

9 ;

& 6&&" %/ -&9&

(

8& -

(

& &6 &

" !

& ;

&6&&" 7 1 >"%!) !% "! , "

"6B # ! " !60 !

, "!

"!)6+ ) 06 "

&, !!) "6! % "! 0 "

$"%"&"+ "! 6"&" !%

6!% !) ! ! !!#&#,", ! +

! E%!

"! "66!60 % "! 0 'B "+" % !

"! "

" !)=% , % & "0!8 "! ,+60$"%"& & " %0 + % "!!# " + %!,! % 60$"%"&6"& E!) 6

%) # "+ " !! % "! 0 " &6+ !!) I ! &, # " " " ! ! ",!

) ,," !+ B ",@ % " ! !

0 "!6+ 260") " ,,

!# !% "+ "+!%%6

+ 8 >" 9A6 -% !) %!

! " )!

+ "6! "! .%!

"%!

! )

!)% "!!,!.%!

,% "9+"%!

E%!

"! ! $ " "%!

#</; &

<'(&&

) +"-

*"6! !

6 , %6

! !!+) "! 6 % ! ) ! " !,"

% " !) !

," 0" " !) I " !" )

"@ % " ! !

0# " !")

@ " %!" " ! #"6 "!6# " ! !" "@ % " ! !

0 ! " # "

!0 , " %6 " !) " ! > ")!

# ",,60 ! $ " 5&' &

4&5;& &

*) + " 42 #

'& ; &

)+) + $! !

+, " ! +!%# 6! % ! !# "!!+%) !60 !!6+ , ""!6, &! %! !"!% %) 8 81 ," " 6 !% !2'D B "!

")#% 0 B !

@) " " 00 "+6% "+ %!

"!2'D 0," "! "+ %!!"!

E%!

"!# !% " %) ,%", ","! 6 ") "! 6+ , "!

!)=% ! "),6+ 6" "!)!

$"%"& E%!

"!# !

! @) 'B

-%6""

"6"+"+"

60 "! %! !6% !% " ! @) 'B

,%", %++ % "'B

, ," *! "

$"%"&,! " !0!# ," "'B

" ", ,! 0! #, %!! +

#," "+#"6%60 "%!

66 ! !

! ! %) !0 ! !# "),% ! !! 60 "%!

"6 "

"+"+"

6" !

!+0# "+!%%6

+% " >" =% !! ! "%!

," "! "

!! "+!%) !) !)

! 6% "! -

4545

," "

!! "+!%) !) !) !%!

6 !

=7 !% " 6 ! ,%", ! ! 2

# " 6 ! "

))

! % )) % "

!20 ) !) !0

"%!% 0 "6%+=% "

# +!% ! " !+! "45," "! !% "!6,

-.5

! 6

7 !% "6,%", "+ !%

%! "+ ") !)"6)

",!

) # !" 0 !!0+% 0 !%

%! "+#)% "# )" "% % 0 !) >" !!"6!

", 6 , ,!)"6 )" 60 !# "%# " ) ,% )% ) ! ) !) >" % "! 0"6! $"%"&#," !+ , B #"" ! @) )

, !),!6!2 60"), "% 2+ !) !) ! "%# "! ) !) " % % 0 !) >" + " % "! 0 ! !% "!6,

G6&&"-& !!

(& - %. 0 ( & 9 & 9 . 1 9 ( 9/ && -& -!

% (

) !

% 5 %/&

* !

;

6 ! %

'?@) ?##

; !

( &

29 &( 7 7

") 0!+%60 "! %! !

% ")"6)60$"%"&B )% "

", ,!)"66!260") &! %! !"! "!"+"+"

!) !

@) "B "

C ,!+

%++ ""!) ",6 , 7 )2

")+% A &!! %! "! " 66 "+"+"

0 ) !) ! @) B "," ) "

",6 , ,!)"6 6!260") &!! %! "! ""+"+"

0 "! ,"! "6 60 "B "" "%

! "! !"% ! 0 ", !,! !! "!!# ""%

!" 6

>"% " + " !! " % "! 0 "

!!6)!+ B )"6,!+0) % B # ," ") "B " ) !

!) "

"!,! +0 !%

%! "+) ") !)# ! "!) ".

) #)! +"%

! ,!," "! " !! 6 6

," "20 ) !) !0 "%!% 0

"6%+ "+! !"6"+"+"

", "% % 0 "6%+"6) !) !0%)+

!"6 "!," "" !! -

"+ " !!% 7, " % "! 0 "

) 0 !!6 )!+ " ! !# "%# "+! 6

!+0 - "%!

"% " "+ " !!

" % "! 0, "!

"+!% %6

+# "%, "6) # "!! "

!! " % "! 0% " " ! )

>" %!I!! %'!, "

I!!DD

%'!) +

('!2"3 $!#! 9% '%.6")6

! 1

1 &!! %! " "%6)

"% ! !!) + ! #," ", !60 !%!

#.%+) ! 1 " + " ) " 6 , "!, 60 !

"!%6)

",! ";@ % + %!

!! 8 1 "6! , "! !

06.

," ""6# "@ % + ! +

! %!

%6)

" "!0 + "!! "%"2 , "!, " ! , "6!

0 %!%"!+"

6! " %!

,6!

" ! ! !%) 8 ), "!,#, "!6!

) ! "%!

" ")! !+"

" # ," " ,% 6 ! 0#

! , ",60 "%!

! !"!+ " !

'+ #0# !"#$%& '('$

6 B" "! 2+!

J B" "!! !