High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/92/2021dismissed

Gurdev Singh v. Land Acquisition Collector And Others

2023-07-10Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu16 pages

-1-

!"# $% &'()* %+,

"( ./"

0" 00

! "# $ % #

! '

&( & #

)& $ * + , " 00 , # **- &

%* */*/ 0

& 1%2* 30 & # ! 4 5&5

' & # 1 6 73 # & 8 # & # &

8 & #

0 1 3 955 9 8

-2-

1 3#0 $ *+,1: #

+; &

0 3

1 -# < & &# %==> + ?# %=== *% 5 0 @

0 ( !

1 3 5&

*>= %% %2* ,A#

%2, &

*>=) %% %2* & ) $ %*2%A%-%>%=*%**A2,%.2*%B*,*.*B2%%,2%%2%%B2%2% *2%,2%>2*=*2*%/%%%*%,%.2%%=2**/*A2%,2*%>%=** *,*.2*A%B%A%.%-*.2%*-22=2*%/%%*/2**%2%,%22*=2% A2*->%,%.,%2%.B22*B2*.A22>2,=%/2%%%%*2%%,2%%=2% */*%**2%*.2%*B2%.-22%>2%%=2%*/2%.=22%2%%2,.2.2%.2* -2% >2% =2% =2*2% %,2% *2% *2, ,2% ,2*2% B/22B2% A2%2% *B2* ) 0$ ,*=) $ .B=2%) 0$ .-) $ A- ) 0$ *>) $ ,/) 0$ %%%) $ %B* ) 0 $ .= ) $ A= ) 0 $ ,B ) $ B. ) 0 $ .

> ) $ A> ) 0 $ ,> ) $ B- ) 0$ %*B) $ %A>) 0$ %>=) $ *-= ) 0 $ A, ) $ >. ) 0 $ == ) $ %*- ) 0 $ ,,/) $ .A/) 0$ B>,) $ >A/ ) 0$ A*) $ >, "&# *//=5%/ ( C# $ *./ : + !

D $ %>,A-

-3-

%==> +( !

/* /> %=== #5 0 0 0 # #5

& 1 $ ..,- */// D $ %>,A-%==>3 2# < "# $ *%%%=== #&0 # 0 & 0

*B /> */// 0

3# ! 0 # 1 3$ */=*>5*/=*=*///0 C E# & & /- /= *//% # *%5 C0 ,% %/ *//% 0 0 # 0##" & $ *%%%===1 4# < 0 0 & #

0 & :

"# $ *=.>*/%%#&

0 & *A /> */%.

F & "# $ *=>,**/%.#

-4-

&00 0 /% %* */%.0

6 ! ! 7 5# :

*- /, */%- & %%

? & :

# & */%, 1 6 */%,73 0 # & "# ,/> %, & 1,A 3

# & C 0 00# *% /= */%> %= ' */> .

B&1#*A3 &#" 0 #

0 ( !

0 & #

& 6# < 1 673 0$ ,,A*/ /= */%=15%.3 *, */%,

& & %BA%--/>/25 &

*/> .

B&1*A

@ & 3 # 0 0 5 0 & & & A. */%, 0& & -A

& & 0&

-5-

# &

# & G # & # " &

%* */*/ C

1 # 5# 0( !

1 3 & 1 6 & 73 %* /% *//- 0 "

0 0 &

=A 1%* 3 , < "

' % %/ & & 2

$ %-. *//A 1 "# 3 # & 0 & *% /.

*/%% 15A3 # ! 4

# # "

0 $ ,-A.*/%. & # & %* /% *//- < /.

/= */%B " 1

30( !

" 0

# $ *.*,*/%A0 0 %, /, */*,

# 0

! " #

! $

-6-

-# # &

*- /, */%- *% /= */%> */%, "

0 $ B,B*/%= "

& "# &

& &

0 ( !

1 3 4 1 ! 3 ,% /- */%= & "# & #

& &

23 0 # / 1 3 < 0 @ G & 0

C E# &8

& 1 3 ? & $ * + , 1 "

03 # & %* /% *//- 0 1

3 0 @%/ 8 &

0 H 0 & 8 * ,

-7-

1 3 ? " & G # 0

# / 0 1 3 < 0

/* /A %=.* %- /= %=., & 6$ %&7 &

( )*7 6 706 7 1 3 & 6+ # + +7 C 0 & @ # / 0 0 !- 1 3 < # 0( !

& %* /% *//- "

00 &

=A 1%*3 , # *+,#

& */%. &

& & G

1 3

# & " &

-8-

& ! G

( !

# # 1 3 ? " ,% /- */%= #

& #

& &

8 & @ G # 3# C 4# ;

0 #

0*/ /= */%= # 0 5

! ,-. /012-.3421 51 '+6,/-" * 7 ! '

( " 1 " * 7

(

# !" ( ( " ,-42 ,--8,-48

! ( 40"94"::"-.-; " # $

%& '(!$ )& ) *! +,!& &

# ! ,-. 3 = /0 1 2-. 3=421 + 6 !

7 (2-"--"49-; *

1 ! # (:".-".."0/-; % 5;" 6 >

5 ! # (:".-".."0/-;

-9-

$ 1 ?@4A '

B 4,C ;2-@2A 6 ) 4--C (:".-".."0/-;

5 @>D'D)A (40"94"::"-.-;

! -%./0 - 1@ $ 6 ,/;./;,-42#(4;49:489 2-4-,-4/A ! # 4- " -

B4,C;2-@2A 6 7 6 ; 44@4A " ! *

! " 48,0 1*23' # 4*++* # 5 ++* ++3+$ # *6+ 12*'27+/ '3+ 12/$ *6+ /*+ # 8626 *6+ 4*++* *9+ +##+*:: 6; 11 *2 +*

# *6+ 3*

# 1+ *2 "?;40 7 6 " $ 6 /;4;,-4:)E@2A4,9:/2-;4 4-:,-4.* !" ;,4 %& ; ! " & ! ! "

! " " " F ;& )

/8,-40 %.+ # *

-10-

G "7 " # * G +

( ;* $ 5 * @ A " & @;7A @ A

7 08,-48 " /8,-40 ( 7 6 > " # * G " 7 4.0,-40 %.#" # *G +

;

5 * @ A & $ @ A "

7 08,-48 " 4.0,-40 ( ( 7 6 > 3 'H 7 ' ' " @ ?6/4,-4:A %.5? " 7 ;7 G " G * " 7

,,-8,-4/

%.6

* G " 7 ,844,-49

%.2

G #

*G @&)A ! 7 )

* G 'H ' ! 'H ' ; " ! ) " @ A > 6 5)

# ! @(44 # !(,-40A

-11-

) (

I 5 7 " 7 7" * ) 7 ( @* 64A *1# !" 7 @* 6,A ! >*(

'H " # G @ * A7

) " ! 4 ,

# 7" * ) ( " 7 @* 6 4A * 1 # !"7 @* 6,A

" 24:,-48 %.;

! > > " 1 6 092,

%.951 5 * @ A *1"7 ) " 7

08,-48 #

@A 44-9,-4. 6 092, @ )) $ 2-44,-4:A 5 * ) " # ! @ A > 65)

# ! @(44 # !(",-40A" ( 6,/,2,-49@$ I 5 A %.' 'H 7 ' ' " ) " ( 7 'H ;'H7 ' ' " 1 ( ? 7 7 6" " 7" * ) 7 ( " 7 " 7 # ! ! " 7

'H7 ' ' " ")J#

-12-

!" " " 1 ( ? !&

@ A > 65) '" ( @A>65)

# ! @( 44 # ! (" ,-40A ?& #@ #

& # "

# 0 & # "

0 ( !

5 8 "

"# & #

& : #

& $ BA,*

( !

H 0

#00 # ?&$ (<

& &

& # " 0 &

5# 5 5#

8 #& & $ *+, 0# & & & 0

# 0 "

-13-

6# 0 & /* /, */*, %/ /.

*/*, )& ) 5&5#5! # 0 C & @ 5 ) 'H " '

( " 7 ) * @ ' ( 7 A ) '( "7 "

! '( 7 " < => ( % 5 1 " 29- ( %5+ # "44,2 ( % 5 + ,,- ( % 5* 6,4;1#37( 4/-2,-,2 '( 7 &

% .

8)9 1

> ( ?" '

( E " 1 " *7

# ! * 1" 7 6,4* 4/;2;,-,2 < (68,;,-,4@$ 5 # A E 688; * -9-2,-,2" ! 494/: 5 1 " 44,2 5 + # " 29-- 5+ 3 ,,- 5* !

-14-

* '

( 1

; ( ?" '

( E " 1 " *7 * '

( "1

# ,4-8 5E 51 494/: 5+ 3 29-- 5+ # 44,2 5* ,,- KKKK ,4-8-

7L*5 6/,044.;4,;,--- 51 0.-- 5+ # 29-- 5+ 3 44,2 KKKK

4-0,2

;

; * ?" ( ? '

* ")7() '

* 64")7()" 1 "7 # < 1:$; "$<=)9#

# ?

0 0 # 5 6 6 L; / # ! 4.8/ ! @A 4 82.-' ,4-8482: ,88 , 4,4-24:-04828 ,-- 2 4.20;;448;484-,,-448/, 200 / 4.2.448484-,,-448/, .8/ 0 4./4;;448;484-,,-448/, 8-/ <

= .

< = @ > > < .

> = = A . ,:4 ;448;484-

-0-448// ,,- *

-15-

8 49/:;)E0.;/-,2.

-944480. 424: 4- ,:,0)E))9-;4:9-.

2--9489- ,.-9 44 ,04/4E))9-49.-/

,--9489- 42., 4, ,..4;)((E,9-;4.089 -/-:489- 288 42 4:2:)((@EA294;4/,,/ 48-/4894 2-9 4/ 82,0E))@2A9,;2,.:/

4.4-489, 4-4.@+ 4/- @ + 3A 40 /;4;,--:4E@2A8/004:;4 ,:-2,-4: ,9

# < 0 & 5 5# #0 !

# &

# & & 0# # *- /, */%-15>3 & "# %=*A ! & 0 0 #

& %BA%--/>/25 # 0 & :

0 0

0 & 0 0 0 0

" # C E# & :

0 @

8 & # @& #

-16-

# < 0 # @ &

-# '

2# # @ "# @& 0 0 0 0

" #

3# $ # # & # @

& &

)* %+,

- " 00 # $

2 I $ # I $