← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1493/2019dismissed

National Insurance Co. Ltd v. Manju Malik And ORS

2019-04-23Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan4 pages

       

 

 

   !   " #$#%&  '   ! "#" $%&%'(

$")'*%%+",$-.*/0)(% $(1%)++%22)'(  ())*+,+-.,/ 0 1%  )3)$*  *)(%*     4  +)&&%*  56 (1%  ($  00-*%'( 2)-7&$-5,')2.)'-+)(8 $&1$(. (1%$-5,')2 91)&5%%')&&)-2%*56(1% -'&,$%$    )'(%$  5%)$-':  $%:-&($)(-'    ;<=;<<  81%$%-') (%$ $% %$$%*()& (1%

%'*-':/%1-02% 9 1%'26:$-%/)'0%$)-&%*-'(1%+$%&%'()++%)2)((1%(-7%

)$:,7%'(&-&(1)((1%02)-7)'(& )-2%*(+$/%(1)((1%)00-*%'(3)&$%&,2(

%'*-':/%1-02%)'*1%'0%'(%'(-(2%* (07+%'&)(-' 1% )0(&%7)')(-': $7(1%$%0$*)$%(1)(' < >.

)(-' )2-?8*%0%)&%*9)2':3-(11-&7(1%$ )2-?3)&:-': )'-+)(( %21-1%63%$%($)/%22-':-'"0$+-5%)$-':$%:-&($)(-' ;<; 481%$%-') (%$$% %$$%*()& "0$+- 9 1%"0$+-3)& 5%-':*$-/%'56 )(-' )2-?A1%'(1%6$%)01%*-' $'( ",?1*%/

1)5).)* )'* )(-' )2-? 3)& ($6-': (0$&& (1%

/%1-02%.31-013)&:-':)1%)* 1-7.(1%*$-/%$

%'*-':/%1-02% &,**%'26(,$'%*(3)$*&$-:1(&-*%3-(1,(:-/-':)'6-'*-0)(-'&)

  $%&,2(.(1%"0$+-&($,0? (1%5)0?&-*%

%'*-':/%1-02%  )(-'

)2-?&,&()-'%*-'@,$-%&)'*,2(-7)(%26&,00,75%*((1%-'@,$-%& >=*)(%* 4 >3)&$%:-&(%$%*)(2-0%"()(-'. ,$(1)2'(1% &()(%7%'( )2-? 1%$-5,')2 $)7%*(1% 223-':-&&,%& B A1%(1%$ )(-'1)**-%*-')')00-*%'(0),&%*'

< >3-(1/%1-02%5%)$-':;<=;<<

*,%  (  $)&1  )'*  '%:2-:%'(  *$-/-':    $%&+'*%'( C

  -&&,%'-&+$/%*.31%(1%$(1%02)-7)'(&)$% %'(-(2%*()'602)-7.- &.(31)()7,'()'* 317C

 A1%(1%$  (1%  -'&,$%*  1)&  /-2)(%*  (1%  (%$7&  )'* 0'*-(-'&    -'&,$)'0%  +2-06.  -  &.  -(& %

%0(C

 %2-% D 1%  $-5,')2  0'&-*%$-':  (1%  )0(&  )3)$*%*  )  &,7  

 .<<.<E;)2':3-(1-'(%$%&(F=>G+%$)'',71%3'%$.*$-/%$)'* (1%-'&,$%$

%'*-':/%1-02%3%$%1%2*@-'(26)'*&%/%$)2262-)52%( +)6(1%07+%'&)(-' A-(1$%:)$*(-&&,%.(1%$-5,')20)7%((1%0'02,&-' (1)((1%)00-*%'(3)&$%&,2(

/%1-02%1%)++%22)'(-&)::$-%/%* (1% -'*-':&$%0$*%*3-(1$%:)$*( -&&,% %)$*2%)$'%*0,'&%2 $(1%)++%22)'()'*+%$,&%*(1%$%0$* !%)$'%*0,'&%2 $(1%)++%22)'()$:,%&(1)()&(1%"0$+-

  &($,0? $75%1-'*.(1%*$-/%$ (1%"0$+-3)&'(7)-'()-'-':(1%&) % *-&()'0%.1%'0%(1%)00-*%'(3)&$%&,2( (1% *%0%)&%*5,(($%&&1-&)$:,7%'(.1%$%2-%&,+'(1%*%+&-(-' A;

-(%'*%$8*$-/%$

%'*-':/%1-02%9.31%$%-'1%&()(%*(1)((1%)00-*%'( 3)&$%&,2( 1-:1&+%%*)'*$)&1)'*'%:2-:%'(*$-/-': (1%*%0%)&%*% 3)&($6-':(/%$()?%(1%

%'*-':/%1-02% $73$':&-*%)'*-'(1% +$0%&&.1%&($,0?):)-'&((1%5)0?+$(-'

%'*-':/%1-02% 1%0'(%'(-'$)-&%*562%)$'%*0,'&%2 $(1%)++%22)'(2)0?& 7%$-( 1%2)3-&3%22&%((2%*(1)(',&,'*%$"%0(-'<< (1% ($ #%1-02%&0(. 44(+$/%(1%-'/2/%7%'(

%'*-':/%1-02%)'* (1)((1%)00-*%'(3)&$%&,2(

/%1-02%-&'(1%02)-7)'(&,$(1%$(1%$%-&'01)22%':%((1%+$+&-(-' (1)( -'7($)00-*%'(0)&%&(1%',&-&'()&1%)/6)&-'(1%0$-7-')2 +$0%%*-':&1%-&&,%-&(5%*%0-*%*'(1%(,01&('% +$%+'*%$)'0%   +$5)5-2-(-%&  1%  ",+$%7%  ,$(  -' 1   "    &   " + &  '  2        & .    / 0  '

'

/ "034  / 0', 3  / 0 ,56/  0 *

4  1%2*)&,'*%$ B')&-(,)(-' (1-&')(,$%.(1%$-5,')21)&$-:1(26 ()?%')12-&(-0/-%3 (1%7)((%$(3)&'%0%&&)$6(5% 5$'%-'7-'*(1)(&($-0(+$ )')00-*%'(0),&%*56) +)$(-0,2)$5,&-')+)$(-0,2)$7)''%$7)6'(5%+&&-52% (5%*'%56(1%02)-7)'(&1%02)-7)'(&3%$%7%$%26 (  %&()52-&1  (1%-$  0)&%  '  (1%  (,01&('%  

+$%+'*%$)'0%    +$5)5-2-(6  1%  &()'*)$*    +$

5%6'*$%)&')52%*,5(0,2*'(1)/%5%%')++2-%*D

  $7(1%+%$,&)2 (1%)3)$*.-(-& $(107-':(1)( )'@,

)2-?3)&(1%%6%;3-('%&&((1%)00-*%'(/%'-'1%$0$&&;%H)7-')(-'. &1%&()(%*(1)(&1%3)&($)/%22-':3-(11%$&'-'(1%"0$+-)((1%(-7%

)00-*%'('1%$&()(%7%'(.(1%3)&$%:-&(%$%* )2-?-'1%$ *%+&-(-'1)&02%)$26&()(%*(1)((1%)00-*%'(3)&)$%&,2( $)&1)'* '%:2-:%'(*$-/-':

%'*-':/%1-02%1%$%-&'*%/-)(-'-'1%$ &()(%7%'(7)*%)((1%(-7% $%:-&($)(-' (1%)'*(1%$%) (%$31-2% *%+&-':5% $%(1%,$((1)&5%%'0'&-&(%'(26&)-*(1)(31-2%(1% *%0%)&%*  3)&  ($6-':  (  0$&&  (1%  

%'*-':  /%1-02%.  (1%  *$-/%$    (1%

%'*-':/%1-02%&3)6%*(1%/%1-02%(3)$*&$-:1(&-*%3-(1,()'6&-:')2 "1% 3-(1&(*  (1%  0$&&  %H)7-')(-'  )2& %$  %/-*%'0%  1)&  '(  5%%' $%5,((%*56)'6&,5&()'(-)2%/-*%'0% %2-)'0%  '  (1%  &()(%7%'(    A;-(%'*%$  8*$-/%$    (1%

%'*-':/%1-02%9*%&'(%'1)'0%(1%0)&% (1%)++%22)'()&)+)$( 5%-':)'-'(%$%&(%*3-('%&&.1%-&)2& )0-':0$-7-')2+$0%%*-':&'&,01 0-$0,7&()'0%&.-(0)''(5%%H+%0(%*(1)(1%3,2*)*7-(1-&$)&1)'* '%:2-:%'(*$-/-':)&-(0%)&%&1-& )(%-'(1%0$-7-')2+$0%%*-':& &1)*30)'5%0)&(,+'(1% -'*-':&$%0$*%*56(1% $-5,')2'(1%$)&1)'*'%:2-:%'(*$-/-':

%'*-':/%1-02% 1%)++%)2-&*-&7-&&%*"-'0%(1%)++%)21)&5%%'*%0-*%*' 7%$-(&-(&%2 .(1%I,%&(-' 2-7-()(-'-&2% (+%' /())*+,+-0 ,7-)

 

7?

A1%(1%$&+%)?-':E$%)&'%*

%&E A1%(1%$$%+$()52%

%&E