Ram Sanehi And ORS v. Manohar And ORS
!"!# $%%&& '#( !#"!# $%" )# # #(*+",+# # -!,"+",+#!%%&& .!""/%%&0!1("0 " "# ""
%" -2 ! ""& # 3("0+ 4!-"+ " 0 ! %%& 0 ! 1("0 ""#""
%"-2!5(#5,&3("0
3(#,+4!-"+,"6!!!(#"&# " %# 1( &" -2 ! #%"%&+ 6"#"
4#!7,"+%#!&& -###"%#!##0&( )& & " - 6# % "#%#&&" (&&2"#-"!%&(" '&&09!(+.!&9!(+#4!-" .!2(0! "&#!&!!!#"#""
8 !" - -" -2 "" : 8
-2- &&(6!"": +,"6!!"": 8 !" - "&#" (%2 " 6# ! ( &" 6 &&0&+ ,"+ 6!( 1(#" " 6+ !##+ -"0 ! #0! ! %& ; 6 & " ! ! #(& ( :
" 8
86&&-&-" 5<(&#& %# 1(##0"": 8# ##0!(&,0%!%&,#! (&""# &0!"&"+6&(0! .!#"#""
86&",#( 0#(" ,= + ! ""# ! %& !,0 - 0,!#: &" !' >-" ?#,!,0-"(%! +#<(#"-2 !%#, !)(1-.2 #!# @!.2/?%#& !#(0!6%%###,+ -0 ,0" ("# ! .2 ; 6 (#!# ,##"!"": 8!"& "!#%& !!2"!#%#"#+6#(&,0% ! ( &"
: (%2 . "+ !##+ !2 (&" - "#" (%2+ 0!#-2!!"�, -2 "" : "" : 8 (%2 "6#!(&"+6&&0&"#-##2 ; 6,##"!!%&6##&"-A&(, %!##!#%#!(&"
; 6 & " ! ! "&# 6#!% !,0<(#"(%2#0!+(&"!,-0,-2
-3- ! 5&&#+ ; >#"+ " 6 &2 ! 5,& 5(#+6!!!"!1(#"0,(!"&#
; 6 ,##" ! ! "" !#" ##!(&,0%!%&,#! ( &"+ 6!##+ ! %& -" ! % ! #,( ##" " 76 -( ! #"# ""
8 !,0 - %"
B"# ! #( + ! (6("
": 8&"16# #0 # %#& #2 -1 ; 6 ,##" ! ! %&!" #0! !&&0!#"#""
8 !%&6%#2!"& #0#" ! &" 6" " %" -2 ! %&+ 6 ,##" ! ! %& !" &" ! ( ! 70 #0# -1 ( ? + -&2 " ! %& !,0 %%#!" ! 5(#6!&!" +6#&7 #+ 6 ,##" ! ! 6#0 ""!" %&""&&!##%#! &" !' >-" +-20,0!#""# ; 6 "" ! ! %& !" - #," ; 6 ,##"!!%&!"#0!&2-%#""0A
," #"# ""
8 " ! 6 &&( 6! "" : #"# ""
8 6 """ " && !# ,# " ! %&+ 6# ""
4# ! %&"0 ! %#+ &&60 ( 6## "
-4C D!!# ! %& # &" # "# "&#%#2"#E))
D!!# ! %& # &" # "# %# 1(%#2"#E)) D!!# ! ( ! %& -&%## E) D!!#!%&!,( # &!%#(E)
D!!# ! %& !, ! 5(# 6! & !" " !, (%%#" #&# !5(#E)
D!!#!%&#%%"&! %#(-2!#6""(E)
& F
)#&"!##%,," '"1("0 ""#""
+!#& 5(# "#" ! ( .! %%& %###" 0 ! " 1("0 ""#6" "-2!#%%&&5(# ," 1("0 " "# ""
+ &"0 ! &0!%%&
;!,!#"&#"(&#!%%&& 8 G#" (& # ! %%&& ! #((&2 (#0" ! ! "0 ##"" -2 -! 5(# # (-& * (- ! #, !" "(&2 - " (% ! %& " &2 # ! (!#2 #" 6 " -( ! + 6# ! %& %#"" 0
"!#"#""
86%"
G#" (& (#!# (- ! ! ( !" -("6!!%#"& +#+!#"# ("# !&&0 !" - %"
8+ 6!# ! (6("
-5-
G#" (& (#!# (- ! , ! #"# ""
8 6 ,"+ ! (&" !, - !&&0" &2 6! ! %#" & " !##
; (%%# ! + &#" (& ! %&" #& (% ! 1("0 ! */-& (%# 5(#
! "#$ % #& ' () ) "(& * +#,' #& )' -".
( ;5
"+ #&( +#,')'
! &'/ ( & )' #& ' ()
55 & 5
+ " #" 9! 1("0 ! 5(#
. ( +#+#,')"(+#& ( "( 5 5,&8 ; !, "#" ! (- " -2 &#" (& # ! %%&&+ -( " ! - "," # .!#&5(#A "!#,(##""& "0,"0#0#"!& !%&<(!# 6#!%"%,#!(&"
;!"#" %!5(#+!""0#"&""0 6##02##-2!5(# #0#" ,&"2 #"# ""
8
HA!-)
+6#0!&2&(""-2-!5(#! ,6!&6&"-2!5(#"(+#& (". () '
( +# #0+ 1 ..+))+ # ( (/ #
5 5,& ? '+* '
( # ) +# #0+ 1 ..+))+ # ( (/ #
8 )G
)* 49? #+ ) #0'
#
8 )G
?( .
#0'
/
) 1+)'
#
5 5,&
" +1 )'
+ ) +# #0+ 1 ..+))+ # ( (/ #
5 5,& +(%2-"&#"
-6- 6#&2-2!5,&5(#"-2!#,(5(# ; 6+!##+#0!&2("!!#,(5(#!"%" #"#-2"1(#"
4(#!#+6#0!&2("!!# !""#!""!#"#""
8 4(#!#!( HA!-)
")
""-#! ""# ! "" !# %# %& ; A%&-& !6 6!( !# -0 2 ""# ! ( +"6##,"!6%-& #, ! "" !# " (-(" #, 6 #<(#" - ##" .! #& 5(#+ !##+ #0!&2 "#"!("0#"!&&60#& $$
)&: " #6# I &" -0 J !# I &" %#2"#?
- )& : 8 6# I &" %#2"#
)&: 1-&6#I &"
%#2"#
" )&: *#16# I %#2"#
)& : # A&(, % &" (#0 7!# :
JJ +
%#2"#
)&: :# !##88I #&"
0 HA )
6!( 1(#"+ (&& " ," "!#-2" F
.! # %%&& 5(# A " ! # # !##%#%,"#0!&2# "!"0##"" -2!#&5(#
-7-
#0#" ! ( & + ! 6 ,# #" -# ! 5(# -&6 *6,#+ -0 &0& (+ - #" 2 0 %#(& ! %& !6 ! !" - ,##" !
+ "" : 8 !" !#" ## ! (&,0 % ! %& ,# ! ( &" # 6!! ! %& -" % ! #,( ##" " 76 -( ! #"# ""
8 !,0 - %"
B"# ! #( + ! ( 6 ("
92#! 0-"!! "(!"-&"-2"!%#"& +! & %#" # &0 ( # "&# # #& !G + 8+6(&"-!#2## ! 6!!#0!(#( ;# #& ! G + , ( & # " #( # "#+ # #" #+ - &" 6!%#"!#2## ! !%&# - 6#!!&! 7&& ##
&#"2"+!%#+!#&2# !""!"!#"##!% !%&+!(6("
.!(6+!##+ 6&&6!&
; !, 0 !#(0! ! 1("0 #&" (% -2 &#"(&#!%%&&+6!!%# #&2"&6!! (& ;,6!-,"0!( & +!"1("0 6(&" !"! %%&&
-8-
; ,6 ! # " " #( + ; " " 2 # ## ! %(0"1("0 ""# <(+! %%& (" - "," # " + #"0&2+ " "
)"0 %%& + 2+ & " "%" 2 3
" D!!#%70J#"
KJ: D!!##%#-&
KJ: