High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCP/189/2013dismissed

M/S Allied Pharmaceuticals v. M/S Calpro Foods Pvt Ltd

2017-04-03Mr. Justice Krishna Murari15 pages

! "#$% &'( )*!&& %-

&! /

0! )*! &$% +! 2 + /

)# 32) 4))4 55

#5 )%" &6.- %77 %8 &'+1

% )%464 + '+1

% 55 ,

%-$ ,%.7, "!

"."+ %4

<;< "+4

":: ! '=>%!,% ?

3' !!.7, 8 "+ "7.$)*! &$% +! 2 +',

%% %%

?% "93' "

%5 " 7%."+ ! "

@ & $

!+ @ ! "&.+ "7 +-

++ @ 8, , !+.

%-$ "9 , "9 !% 7 !

+."+ !$% 1

"9& -

+@9!, !."+

7 !

"==5:=+

+ ".

%9 :' , 7 !

+ "9 ! !

+ "

.%7 ", "9 ! && +&9 "7 + " @.! "

!! $% !! "7 "+$%+.

" +% , &! " !

%9&

+ " !

.%7 "8 +- " !

4 %!8

'5=' "+.!

' ' 8 &, ,

% ! "7 + "

%5 " @.! "

!!$%1 + "7

"9 !

%1 ! "! 7"- 7 !' A ,.! "7 7 "+ B 7

%-$ "9%

% 0 +

+ $% & ' '

% 8

$$ "

! "! 7"- 7 "9 %

%% %9 & "+

%-! "+"+ "! "%$%

+ "

+ $% & ' ' $9 8, , , ! @

" $&

+ " %+ 5!$

%-! "+"+ "!

% 7 !

9 + $!

!= & "! 7"

% "9") 9')"

98 !%

,%.7, 4

"9 ! $

' !$"! @ & 9 %D

"7 "+!

$%+.

"+&&

" $%

+!8

!$"! @ & 9 !.$$&9 "7 $%+.

&"7 8 , 1., %! 8

% , "98 $ 9 C +-- !! "

%+ +.

" 4 " !

D "! % $%

% , ! -- !! " 8 "&.+ && C$ "!

!@%"

8 %+!7+8"% '7+8" "!.% '

9'8

%'!

9'& &

*% 7, '& , %7

"+ % " +

& C$ "!

! & D !

"9, +--

!=& !$ %-"

, "

%% %9

%8 @ , ! -- !

" 7%."+

"9 ! @ 7 -$ .%"1 "+ % "- ! +.% "7 "

"+ +) %,'8 !:=& !8, ,8 !7 "7 %!! !'& !+.% "7 "

"+ "7") %,'

%, $$ "+ @ !,

!" ) %,' !+8"& +%- &8 @!

) " !

%9 %$%

%!,

!+"

@9 "9 "

!! 7"

%% %9

% 8 % @ &8 - " -.- --

% & -!

% $%+.

! 8 7%!!&9 && "7!,% %$%F

"7 1

%' % '"

%3! % $%

"' -

% 8 ! 7 1 " +.

"! +

" @9 8 ! -.

&&9

"9 !, && $ -- !! ""- " -.-!

!=& !$ %-"

,8 1 -@ %' 8 ! .%

"9 !, && &! "

& G 9- "

" !

9 + $!

% , ! 8 " %- +@9 ,%.7, 5- &+

+1 -@ %>' $9 5- &+

+1 -@ %='

5- & +

+ 1 -@ % >' "9 , @

$$ "+ +8

5: !$&

+ "

"9!, &&$ 9 "

" $!

E $ "".- .% "7 .%% "9 "9'

"7 !

& G

"!'-- !! "' "

" "+%

!- "98 +% 8"@9

"+ 8 !.@-

,%.7, &!8, ,8 +.&9%

+@9 "9@F

,&9 !

"+ %

! 8 ! % + @9 "9,

%, $$ "+ +!

5=,

%!&

"! 7"-

"98

%- "

+8 .&9='

"9!

$$ +"! 7"

7 49!

- " %94

"%+ +% 8 "

%% H.

"9% F "

"78, , D$&

".&9>'

6 , 6, '6 "$.%'8, "4,4 !8 &' %$%

"+ )%%F ,

%9 '

& 4 ! ) % "9 8 $% "+ + !.!!

+ .

"+ "7 !!.

! ) ".

"78 +% 8" "+8 +.

8% "7 "%- &

%8, , !! 7"

+@9@

D "

.! % "++ @ @

+@9 -

%% !$

"+!,

% , ! $&

" 4

-@ % ' ' % @%D .

" )% + !, "+"'

! "7 -$ "9 4

%9' 8, 8 "+& "7 -

%"@ &

!.& 8, ,% 7 "

&! @1 +&

%!+

+.&9>'(7 &9@.%"

"+-.

% ' 9$ +$ ! 5> 5(, @

$$ "+ +! - ".

! +% 8"' "9 8 ! & $

!'='(:*5 !'='*5 77%

"7 !:''(>*5 !".&9>' " 1 -@ % ' '

% !

- "+ $ !+.

!, !% - "+ %8 !!

,%.7, 5- &

&"78 "!& +

!".&9'8 .% % "

&.&

+.$ @ %'$9 - "+ %, @

$$ "+ + 8

5 , "9+ +" +.

-."

- "+ !!.,

!!.

! %

%!"$% &' ."+ % 4

"! : %

+ 8 , 4

" :: && "7 .$" $ 9+.

! !:'':=>*5 !"1 -@ %' ,.% % "

IE.$

$ 9- 8 , "+ 9!

"!& +

!"1 -@ ' &! -$ "

$9 "+"

, !@

$$ "+ + 8

5 "+ "

&! !

,%.7,!$

+$!

"$% &' !.@!

+$&

!, !@

"$&

+"% %+ 5, "

8 &!!

!% 7 !

.%7

!%$%

8 &, , "+"

, @

!%$%

' 8 &,

&! ! %

%!8 & 1 "9, ! " @

" %

.%"

! ."+ & 1 + , + "+ "

!% 7 !

+ , !- @ D8 $% J"!., %-K C !

%7 "

$.@& !, + ""

8!$

."F @ 6 % 3 " ) 9 ' ! &

"9 , 7&

"+ $ +-

-."

+ @

, "+ 9!%-

!!.

+ "+"

."+ %4

":: 8 ,.

"9!.@!

& "+@"

+ " @1 @ D7%."+ !+

"9 !."

$ @ "+ !& @ 8."+.$."+ $%1 ! "!4

":;

+8 ,4

":: "1 8 -- & "!&1 "9 @ & $ +-

+ + @ !' % ' 8 && @ " "

%! "+ % !

,&+ %!

"9@ 8."+.$@9 , !.% ."+ $%1 ! "! ! $ "".

& %

.%" +

+ 4

-@ % ' & + @9 "98

7 !

%-$ !' 7 !

+ "9 !!,8" @

& ('!

&%' +5 ' 2 9' ' .%7 "5 ' @.

% !

"+"

."+ %4

"::

@1 ++% !!' !%

.%"

+@9 $!

8 %D

J"!., %-K C !

++% !!A @1 +@ D7%."+

"9 !" -

" "7 !% 7 !

7 !

++% !!' ,.! " 1 8 !

+ %.-!

' 8 && @ F.!

"9@ 8."+.$."+ $%1 ! "!

":;< , "9, ! & +8%

D "7.$

$% & - "

%9 @F

" ! " -

+$% &', !@

+@.

! $&

% ,

&& 7+! "9"

%-! "+"+ "!+

+ "

"+ !:' "+

, @

"% %% ' &&

-$ "9'

% , + 7 1 1 % .! +

%! "+ + !

% @.

%! "+ + + " % $%

+! %8, ,

%8.&+@ !$"! @& "

%-! & .!

+8 ,& .!

"+ !& $

-."

"9' 8, , "9 ,

+F.!

+%- 9+ $!

%' %+ "7&9' !" @ & 9" "9,

% !& !=(>*5@ ! + ! "

%- "

", ! "9, ! -."

!=(> !"&9

+F.!

!=& !!

9+ $!

!!,8 "7 & @ & 9

% !!,8" " 5 "+ "!:' "+

+! !&&8!#5 J: ,

"! 7"

8 &&7

" %- "+8%

%+ %! %- !

% @.

%!*

%* %! % "9 .!

- &"78 , H.

*.&&$ 9- *$ 9-

+ & 1 %9 , "! 7"

8 && $%1 + % "

- %D

! 8" % !D % ! % -- "+ + @9

!- % "8% "7 $$%1 &@9 ,% G %!" $% " $ &-$ "9

, % " $ & -$ "9 !, && " @ , &+ !$"! @& %

% "9 % & % 8%

-- - %- % &+!

8 ,% %+

+ @ "

* % "

!* +F.!

* @%

* !'$% "

2 8%

"+.- ! 7"

+ @9 %

%* .

,% G + 4 7"

%9 % " $ & "9' 8, , - "! "+ 1 +.

& $ &"7 , "! 7"

!$ "!

" !, && @ 1 & + %

"9!.,& -! ,

&&+ !$.

!.@F

&, .% !+ "&9%@

"& .!

8 && &! $$&9K !$&

+ !$.

"1&1 +%+

%- "

% ""

%1 %!9

%, "1D F.% !+ 1 &.% "" $%

."+ $%1 ! "! ! " +-

+ & @ & 9 8 %+!

$&9 "7"- !' %

"9 " 1.%

8 , " .% %"

+ $% & ' ;

5< , ! @

+ , ! @

!$"! @ & 9 - %D

"7' !

$%+.

!'&&

" $%

+!8

"9"

%-!"+ :

+ $% & ' ' $

% 8 7

%+ %!

!,$ 9- %8 , H.

!*.&&$ 9- *$ 9- "!

& 1 %9 "+" "% , % !+

+ "

!$"! @ & 9

%, % ' "9'8

!$"! @ &

%."& !! "+."

& ! $$%1 +@9 ,% G +$ %!"

"9 , !,.&+ " , @

"9 .

"+ "7

-."

"9" !.$$&

"&.! "

% -$& + 8 "+ ! & + +8" " & .!

+ $% & ' ;

5< , 9- -- !! " %, %7

% ! "

%-!& .!

$% &'8, ,%

+! !&&8!#5 J ,

"! 7"% 8 && $ C + -- !! " E ;

% + +.

" 4< " !

D "! $% "! 7"

, !!, &&@ +"-"

,&9 @ ! ! 8 , " + 9!

% %

7%!! !

+! %- "! 7"% , -- !! " !, && "&.+ && C$ "!

! @%"

@9 "! 7"

"+.

8, , "&.+ !" & -

7+8" '7+8" "!.% '

9'8

%'!

9' & &

* % 7, ' , & * & , %7 % " +

& C$ "!

!K !+

"9, +--

!=& !$ %-"

,'! "

%8 $$ "

+% 7+! "

%-!

$% &' "+8 !% !$"! @& % 8 !+

!$"! @ & 9

"7!

! "

%8 !% "9 8 !+

$%+.

! "98 && "7!,% %$%F

" 8 &!+

- C -.-!

!% +.

!=& !$ %-"

,8 1 -@ %' ! &!

5: 5= "+

+$% &' 8 !!$ &&9+

9 "

E$ "".-" && +@9

%, 8 !"!.,%

% " 5:%$ 9- "

E $ "".- "% ! "9 !., +

& "

! , @

" "

!! "9 , !@

! " 8%D "7 "

%-!

5' "9

%- "

+8 .&9='

%% "7 5>

5( $

" "7 !

!' , ! @

" $&

+ @9

!"."+

D "77 1 "@9 @.

,% 9

% -$ !

&& 7+! " %

% +"

%-$ "9!

@9 "9 !+

!$ - ".

!+% 8"' "98 !& $ 9!.- !:''(>*5 !".&9>'

, !@

%% + " 8%

"9 ! & $ !=(>*5 "9 "

% - "+ !$&

+ "

"' , !@

"& % + " 8%

%8 ! "%-

58 !" %%

% !7 1 "@9

, !8"% !D "+% !$"! @ & 9 "

%-!"+ ":

+$% &';

5<2 @ &

!:''*5, !@

"9"

@9 "9, !@

"+ + ,

%, +@

"7 1 "$$% ."

& F "+ % ,

%, !% +@F

"! 8%

& - "7

"9 %+% !&.

"% ,% G

, !@

! 7"

+@9)%!, !,6.- %'8, !" %

,&9 % + !

%, +@

+@9

"9 8 ,.

"! "+ % & .!

(

+$% &''

%-$ "9, +@

"+ "7 -"

,&9* $ % + !

% -$ "9 , + @

"7 -."

, @ "D!

%, !@

"&!

5 8, ,@F

"! 8 " + ,

" %

%- 1 %9 @ 7 "" "7'

% 8 !"&9 "! 7"- 7

"+.!

$%.% %+ %!%!.$$& !%- + !

% @.

%!*+

%! "

%+ %!

% ,

%+ "7&9 !.$$& + 7+! !

+ + !

% @.

%! "9 4 ! % $%

! .!

+! %- + !

% @.

%! "+ + $!

% , !

8 " ,% G !

+!+ %

&9 "9 ! %% + " F "+

"9, +-

%% $%

!''>*5+ %

"9 "!

+ + $!

"7 !

%% "7 5'!

$$ "+ +8

' "9, +F.!

-."

!=& !"

-@ %' "8,

8 !"

". "7

"+ 8 ! " $

8 ! +"

8 ,.

"%-

"' D"8& +7 % "!

%, & -

"" @ & "

@ ! ! "+ @%

+ !

5 8, , ! " " "!"

8 -"

,&9*$ % + !

! "

+% 8"".&9>'8, ,8 !! 7"

+@9@

$$ "+ 5>!

% .!@F

", !@

"% @9

+F.!

-."

!= & ,.

"%-

"+"!

% , &!@

"$&

% 8 ! " !$"! @& $%.% %+ %! %- + !

% @.

%!*+

%!.$$& 7+! + !

% @.

%!*

%! !$ %+ %!$%.% +@9 !!

8 +.

9 !% $%

! "98,8 H. % + $!

% )%" & 6.- % 77 %8 &' &

+ ."!

& %

!1 &9"

! +-

+& @ & 9" @ ! ! !

! +- !! "! - " 8%

, ! !., !& @ 8."+.$ "

%+ 8 ,& 8 %, "+'."!

&% , !1 &9 .%7

" + @

!!.

% !

" " @ ! ! $&

+ "7!' ! " 8, "9 ! & @ 8."+.$" , 1 "7@

"."

$ !+ @

!:''(>*5 , ,

%+."!

!8 && !."!

& "7 , ,

"! 7"% "! 7"

5 ! " + !$.

+ , "

! 8 "+ "7 .$

$&9 & +@9 "9% &

+ !$.

8, ,, % !

"% %+ "7 "% "

&% 7, !.

%& -!

!.- !:''(>*5 ! @9 % "98, ,!,.&+, @

"$ ++ !$

"+ "

, 1 "7 @

" !!.

&"7 8 , !

, "9, !+ @

! "7 & -8, , ! " "

!.-

!=(>*5'

+F.!

!.- !=& !8, ,8 !+ $!

+@9

%8 !!

% .!+ !$.

, !@

+8,

!@91 % 8, ,

% -$ "9 .&+ !

&& 7+! " % 8, , 8.&+ @

"9" %+ @

!!.

, % !

% !."+

"@9

%, @

+@9

"9 , & -

% " @ ! !

, ! @

" "

+ @9 "9 , !-

+@9@ @

+" @ ! !

C !

*""5 C !

!- @9

%, + !$.

+H.

8, , H. % @ +F.+

+.$"@ %

%% 1 "7

"&.! "8,

!& @ & 9

! ""

%-! "+"+ "!

5 "+ 8,

5 , ! @

" 1 & +&9

%- "

"+ !'8,

8.&+@

" % 7, !

"7$

! , $% + !" $$

@ 8, & @ & "9 ! +-

+ !!

+$% " $& & 8

"."+ %4

":;

< "+;< !-

"@ %-

@ 8."+ .$ 8, ! +-

+ & @ &

! H. % @ !&+ !

!9 % %!' + % ."!

+ 8, 8 "+ "7 .$ $

" ! $$ &9 " @"

+ "+, +@

"% !%

"&9 $% !!.%

%- !@9 8 !

"7 %-!."+ & D $%1 ! "! ! ' !

!,.&+" @ &&8 + !$.

+ & -!

"" @ +F.+

+ "8 "+ "7.$$%

+ "7!, % '+" "+

"9- "

" "1 8 + %.-!

!'+" "+ "97%."+ 8 "+ .$ "9 ,

" ! + !- !!

+ 8 ,.

$% F.+ & & % 7, !

% -$ "9 % "% "7

&@& 7

"! % ! "7.

+$% &';

<@9!

D "7% "+ " ! $% &'( ;))4< !

"F A,

%!$

D "7*%

+# !* A,

%% $%

# !*