Nachhattar Singh v. K.A.P. Sinha And Others
! "# ! "#" $%&%'( '% $()%*+$(,%& !$%% &'&()!*'+ ,- ),&,&+-'(%.*(*%(,(,'*/%+0,'12,/ 3/0,&4%0,%'-% ()% $0%$0+(%0 56
*+&&%047(),&-3$(,'8
)% *%$+(,:%*+$( ()%&+,0$0%$,&$%*$03-%04%/2 ;--$0,'1/7<,'&(+'(*%(,(,',&0,&*&%0 2,()+0,$%-(,'
(
,-,+/$%&*'0%'(=&>(/?,'(()%1$,%:+'-%&3' /0%0 47 ()% *%(,(,'%$& ,' ()%,$ /%1+/ '(,-% 0+(%0
=''%@3$%A >+'0((+?%+-'&-,3&0%-,&,'<2,(),'+ *%$,0 ()$%%.'()& $.()%0+(% $%-%,*( -%$(, ,%0 -*7 (),&$0%$ ' -+&%< ()% *%(,(,'%$ &(,// %%/& +11$,%:%0 +'7 +0:%$&%$0%$*+&&%047()%-'-%$'%0+3()$,(7<)%&)+//4%
+(/,4%$(7(+**$+-)(),&3$(B ''(,-%<&)$($%*/7472+7 +
,0+:,( ','0,(+ ,($+< "< ,$%-($<0,:,/"3**/,%&+'0'&3.%$
+,$&<3'C+42+& ,/%0 +''%@,'1$0%$0+(%0
6
&*%$()%&+,0$0%$<,'&($3-(,'&2%$% ,&&3%0(*+7$%(,$+/4%'% ,(&(()%*%(,(,'%$)%$%+ (%$<:,0%$0%$0+(%0
D
<(),&3$(0,$%-(%0()%$%+&3$7
,-%$($%/%+&%()%+.3'( <6 <D EA(()%*%(,(,'%$2,(),'()$%%2%%?& ,$%-(,'&2%$%+/& ,&&3%0(--3'(+'(%'%$+/=F><3'C+4( ,'+/,&%()%-/+,. ()% *%(,(,'%$ $0%+()A-3.A$%(,$+/1$+(3,(7+&2%//+&()%*%'&,'+'0($%/%+&% ()%4%'% ,(&2,(),'+*%$,0 3$2%%?&)%$%+ (%$<-.*/,+'-%$%*$(47 2+7 +
,0+:,( ','0,(+ ,($+<"< ,$%-($<0,:,/"3**/,%&+'0 '&3.%$
+,$&<3'C+40+(%0 69
62+& ,/%0<2)%$%,',()+&4%%'
&(+(%0()+(+.3'( /%+:%%'-+&).%'()+&4%%'*+,0(()%*%(,(,'%$'
D
()+& 3$()%$4%%','
$.%0()+($%(,$+/1$+(3,(7 6<9D<95 EA +'0$%13/+$*%'&,')+&4%%'&%'((()%*%(,(,'%$ &4+'?47()% ,&($,-( $%+&3$7
,-%$<"+'1$3$ ' D
6<'()%2$,((%'$%G3%&(-,$-3/+(%0<()%*%(,(,' 2+&+0C3$'%0'D
6<+1+,'+2$,((%'$%G3%&(2+&-,$-3/+(%043(()% $%&*'0%'(& ,/%0()%-.*/,+'-%$%*$( 0+7+1+,'<()%$%,&''%'4%)+/ ()%*%(,(,'%$ ':,%2 ()%$%*/7+'0()%-.*/,+'-%$%*$( ,/%0<'-+3&% +-(,'&3$:,:%& $*3$&3,'1()%*$%&%'(-'(%.*(*%(,(,')%*%(,(,' &(+'0&0,&*&%0 (,&+/&.+0%-/%+$()+(,'-+&%()%$%,&+'70,&-$%*+'-7,'()% $%*/7$()%-.*/,+'-%$%*$( ,/%0<()%*%(,(,'%$&)+//4%+(/,4%$(7( $%:,:%()%*$%&%'(-'(%.*(*%(,(,'
9 '-+&%+'71$,%:+'-%&3$:,:%&(()%*%(,(,'%$<)%&)+//4%+( /,4%$(7(+:+,/$%.%0,%&+:+,/+4/%,'+--$0+'-%2,()/+2 +!$%% &'&()!- '.)%
D
.?
8)%()%$&*%+?,'1E$%+&'%0
%&E 8)%()%$$%*$(+4/%
%&E