Preeti Gupta And ANR. v. Agya Kaur And ORS
!"#$%& '(
)
&"*%"!+!",& ""& -&* ./!0!*&+",& %1"
!" "!# $ %&
2,",& %&"&#!%!%&3!/4!51"",6*1.3"7
4&&&1"", %&"&&"7 8 2,",&",6*1.3",*14&%&"1",."7
&"$ 9&3!&-:(1#!"( &",%""& 9&;5!"!(1#!"( &&%1" <<<<< "!# $
'()* ,%""&=!*#"%*&#,!&!&!..&1",",& 3%*.1 &1&( ( >*& = 1!"1 )?
8 13. ", !%%#!":.&"&!"",>#*"%""(>*& =
1!"1
13.",>#*"%""1!*"!1>*&
=81!"1 )
1#.",%&3"%&1",!"!# .&3"!4*& 9&3!&-:(!&1#*!%%!&.4,!", %""& *43" ",!" ", %""& !& ", !*#" %*&#,!& %*&*!#"",>#*"",1#&1!"1
!%&%&"/ 1#&41",!*#""#1!"1 '
85",5.13!&#!"( ( !"$
!1 2"$ ./!0!*&51",4",1 :!&3!@'AB"C
&",$ &3!,!"!
;*",$ ,*%1&;.,.",4",1 ) :!&3!
@ A "C ,!&3"1!*#"5!#&31!1",! #&"#!"1!"1B)
5!*11#&4.",5.%&%&"/$= D
!
"#$ %
& '( ) '( *
+
, ( - (, ( (
./0*1 *012 ..3
., - ( %4, (
&!
5 & 5
)
"6**$ 6 9 6 4
6 6 ( * 3
, ,
) :
( ) .02*001 ; <3*000( ( ..= .<<<
% > & ( !
, %
( %"#$% , , % ?
*&",&*43"",!"*3&*46#"5&1(4*"", !35&131!11%"13!",46#"(",",&1%!&"/ #, " ", *" !1 ! & %"" :. ", *%&"1.%5&",*&"(5,&"5!#!&1",!"",& 1%*"5",&.!&1":,!&!?
8,>#*"!%%#!"5! !"1&
!11%"&#&1.",%&#",#* &",1#&=,1&(",!35!131!1",&!&
+ 13!",!35!",!"#"(
A=3%11&1&1!"1
)
,!1"41%"1*43"",!"!!%%#!"& &"&!"",>#*"!%%#!"5!1(4*"",!3!3" 5",",!3!"13%*.1&1&>*& =",%&3",!"
",!%%#!"&&"&!"5!"131!##*"",= %&#",!*#"%*&#,!&&",&#*4*"1*"",!*& ",&%!&""&#",%!1",&1&1!"1 )
1#.
",!"!#",.&3"!4*&,!"4!!14/.! !%%!*43"",!"!%4!""3%",!43!1"",5!&"", >#*"",1#&!1",!*#"%*&#,!&#!"4!*"15 ",%&%"*!.",46#"!1!&**",%&%&"/ &3*E!1(",&&(%#,%5*14&F*&1&", %*&%"!:.%(#",46#"&!&"!:.!%4 "%"#!*3%13"!1,1&!#>#*"",1#& 9&;!5!"!( !&1 #* !%%!&. 4,! &%1" =46#"&*43"",!"",&1&*1&#,!.1" *&&3!/.!"/!1%&&"/,%!&"/(5,#,11"5", 1&#"%/5",",&1&",*&"(,*143!1"*& ;#",!*#"%*&#,!
&11"1%"",#"(3*#,11 ""!:!/#""%""!:",%(&.,"/",>#*" !%%#!"!1&"&!"",&,!14131,&5!1 :.!"!#",.&3"!4*&!",!*#"%*&#,!& 5&5!5!&","!"*!1!"*&",%&%&"/!"","3 %*&#,!.",!3#",%&%&"/,!141!"!&*"!.!1( ",*(*&.",*&"&13!",&%""5",>3%!
, ,!,!&1",!&1#*&",%!&"!1!%%&!1 ",%!%&4: "!3!""&&#&1",!"",%""&=1#&,1&!& ,1&#&"#!"!(>*& ='(!>"&!#"1!4&%#" !%&%&"/1#&41!4(",*(",&1%*"5",&.!&1"", 1#&%"A1"#!"",%&%&"/ 9&3!&-:1*&.",#*&,!&.(*43"",!", #"5*11%"",#" (
A="1!/"("4%!1"", #*%%"",.,*&"&=#3%!#",1&#"& %!/3"(
A="",#*&",46#"&","&!*&"3/ 5( 4",",*&"45,*1 ",!131",>#*" !%%#!"&5!"#"(%!&"#*!&/",%&#",#*& ",%""&4*",*1,!.&!"1!",&%%&"*"/",!"!" 3!/(",*&"1!.5",",&"&!"!%%#!"51", !3%*&!,!414/",>#*".*&"4/,1.",!"", &1&1#.",!%%#!"31&%&1.",.&3"!4*& ,! " 4 !%%!1 !1( ",&&( ", !*#" %*&#,!& !& " "&"1:.",>#*"3/5(*#,!&!."/ &&*4*"!!#*,>#*".*&"!&&F*&1"",!"", 6*1.3"!11#&",*&"!&,*&1!1&%#"1(3*#, >#*"1!1",!*#"%*&#,!&&",1#&=,1&,*1"4 ",&5*"",3!&!131(!,!4"#1",3%*.1 &1& ##&1./(",3%*.1&1&1!"1)?
8@>*&
=C!1
@>*& = C!&,&4/"=!1,>#*" !%%#!"&"&1""*34&;#",&!&!1/&1&%#
,%(13"!%%&%&!""1%",%&"&%""5", ",5.1&#""","&!*&"$= !C ;#",1""/!11#&%"",%&%&"/" 1%*"(!,!4"#1!4(","&!*&",!* 5!&&!" % !1 %&1 ! %4 ,% !1 !"!#"",%""&4/*.!1&#""",;9 !1;*%&"1" ###&1"4%&"!"", "35,",%4."!:(",!"",& ",&!""",!14&"/",,!4"!"",!&!(3*#, ",!*#"%*&#,!&&",&!4*&G 4C ,"&%&#"!:.&",%,!4 3"&14/",;9##&1(5,,!*&",!"", 6*1.3" !1 1#& >#*"1 !1 % ,!
4 ,!11&"",!*#"%*&#,!&,&!"&(,,! *43" , &%&" " ", ##&1 >#*". *&" & !%%&%&!"&1&G #C , "&! *&" 3!/ ! "!: ", !"!# ", &* #& " % %" !1 1"/ ", %&%&"/ ! 3"1",!#&"#!"!"","3>#*"", 5!&&!"% H4&"/.&!"1"",%""&"3!!%%&%&!" !%%#!"#!#&"!#".#(5,#,3!/!& ,%!&"(",&*.,",&#*(!&1&#"1"!%%!&4& ",>#*".
) -(.$ / '"!# * ()01 %&