High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1012/2016allowed

Kishan Lal Vig Deceased Thro Lrs Ravinder And ANR. v. Sunder Lal

2023-03-15Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu10 pages

! "#$

$%&'& ( )

!

*+ , ,

,

#!

$%&'

( &

#!( $&'

( &

,

,

( )

!

* +,-) ./( '

&012 3 '

4 $"

5

$

2 *&6 ),

'""

'

,

"

""

7

08 9&"

), &: ) ;

7

"

!

2 '

8

$ " <

6 =

&!

(

$, 7= $ 6 1 8 2 8

>

(

"

& $ ,& ?

$ &6 $

& "<

.

"@)

" "

?&

( $

"

-"

&

""

""

( & "

" $ ( & ( ,

" ," $ $ $ $ A

$ " <

6 )$ ?

) $""

"

( 5

"&

-5!&)

(

' )$

"

6 ) ?

&6 )

),)( ?

) &

"

$ B "

)

-5! $

"+

",

$ "

) C ) " )

&

$

6

=

!! "

!# $ !# %

!# & ' !#

! # (

>

"( & "

B$

B 6 & $ ,&! ? D=&""

$ D= &?

D=2& 5 D=9&;6! D=*&$ ? 5 D=

,

- C &

B$

D=#: ?>A& D= 5

(

"?& D=2 $ $& D=9

!

$ & D=* '$ != $& D= !,$ = ?& D=1 "!&D=8%"!&D=0

$ )

$ .

> ($

, "

& "

& $ ,&

"

$ &) (

?

6 )

'

)

"?

$

&

6

"

$ & 5

$

08 9

( ( " "

66$ $ 5

$ > 6,

6 6

"

&) (

"

"( $ 6 =",$

", "<

:

(

5

$ &

"

""

$ 6 6

),

'""

'

,6 " $"

5

$

2 *

&" (

,= +

>

D= 5(

"?6 D=9!

, $

?

& 6 )=

& "

6

& $ 6 "

$ @

, )

@ )

'""

'

,

"

$

"

"

( &

$"

5

$ , )

:

'""

'

, $$

( 6

(6" $ 6 )

) "",

", "<

/(

$ &6 ""

D=9& $

)

$ . ,

"? !

$ 6?& : ) 4& " $ ( " $ !: &!

*&: )

,&

"

(

5

" " "

$ -5! & $ ,&(

@

6

$ " B &

),

+, /

$ "

= & "

(( , $ @

& ) ) $

, A

6

0 /BD87

"

,

-5!

$ "

& B ,

) '

"(

) $

$ 6?@ !: &!

*&: ) @

) )

'

"

( 6 ) ?

?

E $ ) &

!

)$

'""

'

,,

@

&

), 6 (5

'

& "

, 6 "

( ,

$

)

" $-5! +

"

&! A "

"

6

),

& & "<

.

" & $ ,& ?

) ' $

?

$ 6

$ ' "

" /B =&

, "<

" ) =7*1&>A& : ) & $"

6"6

), >

"(

"

,& "

$ ""

D=

(

"

'"&&?

""

6 )B D=2 )

( D= !

& D=9 5 6 "") )( 6 &

"

?

( ,

"@ ) 6 "

$",

' & "

)

( ,

),

& )

$

/(

&6

6"

$ & $ 6 = )*(+((, -

-

-

. # / (0 - -.

( 1( 2-

.

. -

# / (3

.

# '

4

/ # "56 # /

( 7( , . - - 8# / (6

(9

A )( 6( =

), '""

'

,6

" ""

6$ = 1( !

": ;

!

$# /

/ . . !

$ # / (2-

.

!

" !

$

-

( 0

!

"

!

$ .

!

$ (0

( 0

!

"

<'

= -

-

-

(> !

$ <'

= - ' -

-

( ?

# 1 @ = <'

= (2 ' -

7AB( ?

- -

( 2 -

28 2 # ( $%$1 "BB% <'

= # 1

(? - /-

28 2 28 3(@ #(:(@ - - 7("("B"(

CD( 15"( 0-

. !

$.# 1

CD(# 15" -

7%7( ) -" "

$ ()

& ,

) "

,

" " <

), & $ ,& ?

!

$ ),)( ?

6

& $ )

, ?6

),

6 :

& $ D= 5

(

"?6

=D=9!

B

= 0/"1$$2$$3"4 )++(6

.3(# /

4 0/ ,5(6$7+"8#$("(#! ++6

. 3( # /

, ."B"4 >

,"(

"6

-5 ! < & "

6 $ " "

') $

"

-5 ! 6

0 ( ( 2928 9

F ( -55 !G/( 6 &$

" "

6

8@6 &

" $ &(

0 &

& 6

$ " ,$ B +

& )5

),

6 6

$ &66$ & " $ @

""

,

&

$$ $ A &

"

(

"(

),-5! 7 6 ) ?

), ?

& ) )

' &

) "

& 6 & +G) !

" = )+(? '

(

(0 -. -

.

-( '

!" #$ %&#'((()*6 ),+G) !

" = )0 - '

(9 - A & ( 6 $ ), D= 5

(

"? D=9!

&$

), '""

'

, $ D= . D=2 $

(

' &

), '""

'

, 6 (

,

.

>( 6 )( & & .

" "<

), &$ ,&?

, )

),

) ( ' & 6

),)

B ( ,

", "<

&) $ "

" "

6

"6

), "

,& " (

"

@ $"

$

2 *"

),

'""

'

,&: )

' & 5

$

08 9 "

),

" "

6

*2 2 ,

,

! ! 09$#9$7'3$"4&(:;7$"'

($6 $';

09$#9$7$3 7#"<8$ $';