High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1112/2015disposed of

Ishwar & ORS v. Asha Ram & ORS

2015-05-21Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain4 pages

"#$% &' () *

$* +,$ -

. '* $.

/& (./&!&(&0 ( )&' .'/1'' . $.

&'/0 ( )&' .'/.1

&2/ (&

/1& '&.3 .'/) 4.'5146 6'/ .(.(&'(

01&(37'/&.

() 4.'3 808/.37'/&11)&' ( 37'/59 61 )/1' 1. ')''/.1 '/4'1. 1.'70 8/)/3 '..(8'/(1' '/.& 4.08& (5(

/1'' .:1& '(&4' .1.5& '

)&5 6'/&''/7&. 1 '/4'& ( .'/&'5 .'/& ; 7&.& 68'/'/4'0&11)&' 4 (..(.<=4

& ( 8&( /&.

() 4.'3 8 ( 6 )&

'/3& '/. 4.) .(1. (4)(37'/1'' .:1& '6.& '( & 4. '/1'' . &11&0'/ .(.1&(37'/ '.&) 4.'8&41/( /& .&( .(.&''& ( &'70& 4.'/.

)/& 6 8& 5&( 37 '/ .1 '/ 1 '/

1'' .8&3 '..(8'/0&11)&' 8&(9 61 ) /1 /&58&() (37'/) 4.'8'/ 4'1& 6& 71&9 .(.& (.) .( 6& 7.& '/. .

/435 '/&''/. 4 .) .( 1. (4)( 37 '/ 1'' .:1& ' )&.7 '&3/( '/.

1 '/4'1. 1.'70 '/3& 8/)/ 8& 6.& '( '/.& 4.

)&0'/&58&3 '..(8'/0'/ 1'' .&.).'& 7 ''( ' 1 )/1' 1. ')''/&5

411 .' '/1&0.& )8&1&)(41 '/24(65 ' '/ 4.'

.&5 & )/&7&'0 &. &' -5'

, 9/ 0 ===";%"%< <>

.'/&2 -/&5/.- 6/0"<%"%?> 6&5& ( '/. -5'

@/ & ( '/.0="% ,A< > -45./& (& ( '/. -& ' /@45&.& ( '/.0 "

%,&8.&(;B& ( &'/4 &5 // '4- 6/0 <"

%"%

'/ '/. /& (0 &.

( ) 4 . '/ .1 435''('/&''/& ( C4'

/.&.A?B) :/&..

/.1 '&4)/&. ' '.. ' '/1 '/ 1'' .:1& ' '/& ( (14'0/ )0'/. C4' 6.& ' 1 )/1 4.'/....(' '/9/&.&6.(&8&.08/)/ '&3/('/&''/& ( C4' 8&/ 8 &3& 2&.0/ )0

1 '/.

'./&. 6&.

() 4 .'/1&.'0 (5.' '/ 435 5&(37&.

() 4 .'/1&.' ' ' (14''/&'

& &11)&' (37'/1'' . . 0'/&.

( '.& ) 4.' 4 ( '/ 3& '/ . 4 .) .( 1. (4)( 37 '/ 1'' .'/&''/7&. 1 '/1. 1.'7 (14'0/ )0'/ &58&(.)'(' 31. ')'((4. 6'/1 )7 '/4'

/ .(.

'/'.&) 4.'8&41/( &11&(37'/.1 /&5 &''& ( &'7& 4.'/.&11&8&(37'/.1 / &11)&' 9 61 )/1' 1. ')''/1 8&(37'/ 1'' .&'/.1 8& 46/'' 3 '..(8'/ /&5 8&() (37'/&.

() 4.'3 8371& 6&).71') .(.

/ ) 4.' /&( 1 ( '/&' 8/. 4 ( &11. 1.&'0 1 ) /1 / 4( 3 6.& '(' .)& .(.

'/&(4.'/.3 1 ('/&''

< 8 4(3&' '&5) '.4)' '/1. '/ (

. )(4.' / ('/&' )&& .(./&3 1&( & 4.

&1&.'70// 4(8&''4)/'5'/&5 4'(& ('/ &( 1'

'/1. )(4.1. ((4 (..(.<=4 /.&('

3'8 14 '&)' .4' 6. 53.&)/ & .(.1&(37'/ ) 4.'& ( .)5 ' '/ .(.

.71. (4'7:3 4 (& (4 (.

36&' ' ) 5178'/& (D . 4.) 51& ) '/ .(.1&(37 '/) 4.'04 &.( .'&( )& 31.5''(' '&9&8

/ 8 /& (& ( &''/ .(.1&( /) 4.'/& /. '

1 8./ 4() 5' '/.)4 &1. 08/ 1' & .(. 3 6'/.&' (8'/ .)3(1 &' '/ .(.

/) 4.'4 (.' /. '1 8.)& .786.& '1 )/1'

1. ' &' '/

'/)& /& (0'/'& ( '/1'' .'/&'(1' 6.& '(37'/'.&) 4.'.'.& 6'/.1 ':

( (& '. 5 '.. ' '/.)4'&' 61 '/4'& (0 8/)/8&41/(37'/&.

( 8.&11&') 4.'0'/.1 8& 3 '..(8'/37'/.1 /'& ( '/.1 ' '/&' &)'0'/& (/&5&'

/.&.A?B) :/&.. /7&. '

'.. 6 '/1 '/1'' . '/&' &'5&70'/ 6.& ) '/1'' .'/&''/.1 08/)//&3 (.)'( ' 31. ')'(37'/) 4.'3 80( .(.1&(

'/.& 4.0 46/'' 3('4.3( /) 4.' '' 8&''4)/'5 '/ &'(& ('/1&.'7 8/ & 4.'/ .(./&3

1&(14/(' '/8& 7'' 6/5' &11)&' 4 (..(.

<=4 9 614 /5 ' . &' '/ .(.

-& )''7 '/ .(. '/) 4.'/&' 35& '& ( /7&.5& ''

3) 51(8'/ '.4''.& (1.'

7 &66.()& && &11. 1.&'.5(7&6& ''/ .(.

)' &0

)& 3& 8( ' C4' '/&537'&9 6&8 ' / 8 /& ( . '/ .& 5 ' ( &3 0 '/ 1. ' 1'' & 8( /5146 ( .(.1&(37'/) 4.'3 8'&( / &11)&' (37'/1'' . 9 61 )/1' 1. ')''/.

; 1 '/4'1. 1.'7& 8(

"&2/ (&% 4(6

".' 1 .'.%