Bishamber Th Lrs Ramphal & ORS v. Harbans Lal & ORS

 
   
 






































 

 
!
 "

#

  












































$ 

% & ' 
!#

  



"   !"
"" #! $   $()*
+)*

 
"  ,,,, ""$%&'$($)*$

+$) 
- .

/00



+""#


#

"#1

 
+2& 
$
 $.


2 "

#1
  
"

+2& 
$.*
$*
$3 
$.*

##4

5
& 
 
6

 *
&7

7& 2"*

 
"& "

1
 
" 
)
"


 1
 
 

"" " 
"# 




 ##1

 
" 
)
"


 
 


+2& 
$-*
4  8
 
)#
9&1
9 )
  1 *


 
 
""#

 
"#
 
 "1



:/

;


#


<

=
1
 
&7


 ##1 
 
#

"*

 
1*
&#


6*

 

1) 8
 
; #
& 

  




) &
""#
#
8
 "# 

&"" 

 
 

 4
 
""#

 1
# &


1)1
"" &

 
"# 

#
)

#
 #

 !)1
" 
 
 )

 
; #
& *

" &#

 "#
4&#
1


 4
 
 
 
&

# 
4
#
 
 

 <

<
4
 ##1
;


&>&
& 

 


 
7&1 
8
) &

 
 

 # 
"
 
4
 " 

 
#


<

=

)&
  
)




)*
"


-*
4 
#
 ##1 

"#1
4 
" ##8
 ) 
8
 

"*
 
4 
 *
#

 =

.


4
"#
 
 8
4  #&
4 

 


 

#


4 

"

 #

&#)1
 
 
 
"81
 


1 

   1

4 

 "&    
" *
    *
#
 
" 1
 8


) #
8
""#

 
"#*

& *

) 1
 
& 

&

"

 
 
 
#
#

""#
&


3
&#

$*


 
 
"# 

#

 2
" " & 


 8
4 
4 

"

;


""#
4
#  

=

 

 
1 &
 
 
&
4

# 

 >&#
#
4
6
8
 
" /"# 

;

&
 
"  4 
4 

 
#&

 


0
*
    *
 
" 
""#
 
4
#

- +2& 
$*
 
# 

8 

'4) *
" &#

 
 
#


 4
 
8
)  4

1 1
&
#1



4 8
 

#
&#

) 
" 8



 #
"

 
0
 
"#8

 
""#
#*
 4

 
 
"# 

 
64#1

 
) 8
11
 4 
641
 
&

"

 

4

 
#
1
  1& 

&##8*
 
 "&1
 


" &#

 
"

"#
#
&"
 
7&1 



, )


 
& 






 

   

 !"#


 
 
#

 

 1 
)

 
""##
1

    *
 
&
4&#



#

#
"#
#
&"
 
7&1 
+"2
& 


$% 

% &  '
("

 
 
 8
 
 &#

##4

+ 
 1
&#

 
" *
 
& 


 
" 
 
 
 

 
8




 


)#
$ & *
.

=* #
&"
 
)

7&1 
& 

4 &
8
*
 )4

 
 
4  

 " 


<
&#
3
$*  8



" ##8
" )

 
" )
 

 
 #
 

*
 




##4
&#
  

&
#1

 


"#
  
 
& 

"& "

 


&
 

1
8
 +"2
& 

#
 

4

 
"& "

"8
"#

 
 
#8
2"
4 
4

&
 

 
" 8
&#
 4
& #1

  
4
  1
4 
4


 
64#1*
 
&  &#
##4
 

&


;


" "#
)

#
4
8
 +"2
& 

  ) $


* % &+   ) ,!-- .!

4  
 
2"

 
 
1
##4
 
 )

 
4
1 #1 

#8
4  
&
#1
4
" )* 
4


##4

#)
 )


& 

 

    



    

     

 !

"    #        

    

      

 # #$     %    

& $   '( )*+,+-  &  &   

&

-     

  

 .

  /        /   /

             $        

#     )0      -  1 #

      2#  +    #     /       3 4002$  &$  %      &       #  $ %  &

/&#"%5&  / $   

&  /            /       6  #

   

   /  $/       

      $ 

$  

  +  6 

   / 

  +6 

  6 %+ &  6 7  

 

  + #  

 

  6 %+        

$ #   %  

 

     / + 

  

  / /       +   6 00* +  4 '   &  $     85)80880  

      

    9 :

 ,  + $  8*8*0886$  

 

  0))088;

/# $  



85)808800))0887 85)80880&    #

   /  /$/$  

 $ $ < - 

   $   

          =  

 

- 

/   $ 3> 4?  

 &  $$

   6   

  2#+    $    $ 

# 

       

  

 

  +        /   4

  * -     

&       &       /   = 

  @( )*$ ##   $ $   /  = 

$  $  #

     /    

       

  

 



6   / +      

 &  



$

      $ #

 A +
*

 
" 

4 
 
4
#

 
8 

.

;


" 
4 
4##
4 

 
&



" 

4 6


4 
4

"

;


" 
 

&
4
 " 1


 
#
1*
)
4
#
 
""#
4  *
 )4

 
 )

 
+"2
& *

" &
)*

 
1* 

" 

+ 1#8*
 
 "&1
 
4  

"
8 
; #
& *

&
 & *


##


  
4 &#

 
" *

 
1*

) #8
&  
 
 )
)


1
 
&

 
&#


)1
 
""#
8
 
; #
& 


" 
)
"


#
8
 
"# / " 

&#
  
 
; #
& 



" 8

 


 
    *

"

 

&


 8

 
"& "
 1
 
" 
)
" + 1#8*
1

 

 
" 
)
"*
  

 8
  

  ?55+'+@+!0+ .$*)/.'

9A?B