M/S Osho Gears & Pinion Ltd v. M/S Emson Gears Ltd
!" #$%& !"
!"
!
# $ % ' ( #&' '()'
*!&+,-.' ,,,*,'/0
)
* '+,.' ,,*,'/0
*+(
,1 +2/$ 3,
, 4544$ 3$,&/,6'/
, 7082',$ !(.92,
,+&$-.
&/(2,#:% 6:% &'/ $ % ,&,$;& ;$2(02//,<03$&/, '/8)#&' '()'/01*
&&'/
<4 &/,6,,,'/0& ,, '/0 , ( &, ,/3 ',2' ,( =>&&/01* 5!$ 56.
,/3(0 3,,&/&& ),& /,6,,,,,'/,2.2&
24<$&$&/>&&42,&2, & 5, ,, & * !& +, - .' ,,,*,'/0 * '+, .' ,, * , '/0 $ &3 //,3 & #&' '()' 3 ,(2 =2, 6 6?$ ,/3(0
,(,$&/,'/&//,&&2,<0 ()'/0
1,,:
/&,&()')&920&,&(,<&& '/ >, / >& ) 2, 22, ,,<&&'/>,,<&( :
& ,/, ') 2, 22, ,, <& & '/>,( =2,6
6 :
,/8#2, ,#2,<& ,,$ 3$>&>, //&,'6&,',3)&') 2,22,,, *!&+,-.'$&3 ,/,&<&,,, *!&+,- .'@/,'/0 $'(0$24<(58 #'((2,3(/'58$332,&&' '()'&')><02,,,'(0 =58&3)2)'2% $:%A*6 (( 22, ,,&') &'&,332, &&'&3//,3&&''()'>&20 '
, &7 ,1<&,#&,'$ 3$>&>, //&,'6&,',3)&') 2,22,,, * '+,.'&3,/, & > #2, ,, * ' +, .' @ /, '/0 $'(0$ ((&<58#'((2,3(/' 58&3332,&&''()' (( 22,,,&')$2>&& &3/& &'>&20'!/,&3 & # > 2 & )(,,$ ,0,/, ,$>((& !(.92,>(,,</2<(&;&,<2;
)(&;24<B,;
$&(+C&# 24<&,,,&<'/(>&3 &&</(,, 2,2&,$&!(.92,&/(,, &,/,A%
<0>03 B&2,3$ )( ,,$,&, )$ ,0,/, ,$/,
: $&&/&6
! " # "
$
% # !
&! %
$ '!'&!(') * + # , #
- .
. ! , / ! * 012,2342)5&2)'
'!'6!(')
!78 .# * +# 5*# , # . % '6!'6!(') * +# 7 .# , # 0
+
5*1 . . .
%
%% +
( * + #96#7 9 * +7 :
/ !6(
7 9!:
# +
% % . # . ## #
# %
%
; < ,# !" # "
$ ".
% 2
* + ! &!(.92,&(2<'&,/,2<' &2, :%
)&,&3>&<,3
& &,, 2 )3 # 1 & ,/,$ & '()'/,642(&,&,&(,$/2<( (,)$,,&,32 ,),&<4,/, 3 A%
& )(,,$1'(B2',&(($,, &,,'/0&2,8/, &3 ?
(<0&'&((&,0/,92,,(,
',2' ,(- &((<8&,, '/0&(('/(0>&&/,3&'= $ % & 2('&,2,(0)2(2<0& ,3 58<),,)2(, &<36=/(2<'<0&,,& /,6,,'/02(0'>&&92,,<0 )(,, ,),&<4,<0&((92,& ,/, 2<' :%
$ 1'( B2', &(($ ,, & ,,'/0&(3 :
)&,& ((&2),&((<<,3',(0<0& ,,'/0 &/,6'/&3,'&&,, 3),/,)/))&'2,# : & ",&,,6,((& ,(3&/,2,(,92,''/(2,# :% :% &'/ $ %&,(3 2(2 , & ,/, )( ,,$ ,&, )$
,0,/, ,&!(.92,$&#&' '()'&,<0&(<(& ,,,'/0&((3&,,'/0& ,,, '/0 &(( < (3 >&2 <) >2 2/ & ,, '/0 &(( < ,92, '/(0 >& & /,2,( ,92,'>&,),(, ! $((/2( 2,&'= $ 2)#,2<0&2 &,, 2((&'/(,,92,< <,3,'&)2(2<0 ,358<)
,,)2(, &#&'&((<<)&,,,,, '/$&,,/3#&,&(,$,,((, .,'(,,&#&' '()' <,>,>&(>,/0<(>&& ),,'/>&:
0,'&,/2& ,/0 & ,, < /2<(& & ;& ,<2;
)(&;24<B,;
$<&24<&( +C&+3,'24< 0/,,&((<(<,0//(0&2, ,0, /,(> /,)(0
4&5( 3 72)