High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2427/2008allowed

(O&M) Amar Singh v. Mool Chand Etc.

2018-09-19Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry6 pages

!" #$ % !

&!' ($ $!

)

! * +, !$) ! !"$$-' +, !

!$./'$.+, !$!)

!#' 1!$!*'# 1!!,2$3'# 4 #!( 5 (!) ! $!, ) # $!! ) 46 $ !((!+ # $ ))( ( '

" 7 $-!6 8!4 !( 9, +

$! !4! !!:$ 7;+

! ))( 5 (!) ! ( ))( ( #$$ !) (4(4, )6 ! 1(( !) $'4($$) <' !) 1$' $)! (! = 1 '!$!)( $ !) ( $

$ ,!$) !) > 1$'$ )! (!) (!)(6 $$$. $)!)!6 )' ! ! $( (! -1,!+$'4 $$$) )'$ '4( ,'!

!) !) $3 !) )! ! ) $!))!)'!' ! ( 6!)(6 )!" 7 $ 7+ ! ! $!#$'

!$(!'4(1$'1! (!+ $ $(4(, " 7 ($(#!'

1$$$, 4 #'#$" 7 $ 7 ?!'

5 (!+ !!)!,$$)! $4 '4(+ $? (!. $-!6 9(!6@!1$($ (!

!) ((

- '!$!($($ !) $

,$ > $((#'4 ) $(!64((+$$(()$ = $!1!+?(',

$((#'4 1)!,5 (!( ? ,!'$!1 )!,$'4 6 ) +1$ ))! $1 4?+$ $ ? $ $ $ )!)!! A * /$

# B!. 4' > )! ! ! = ! ? + $ ((6 $ $ .

1 1$$! )! !$) 1$ > 1 ,! ?' -1,!+ $! !

,('

!$$!)! !$)?'41 $)! 1$$11! 6!4. > +, ))! , 5!

!((! $ ) '!

#!'

#4 #!'

A* /$ #B!. 9(!6

> ?

7 % !$ $1 (# %! $) ( #! 1$$$

)!, B$ (! ( ))(+(!

))(('$!6

! $ #46!! #$$4)!,$$ $ )!1$$(#() !#$?(',) $4

!! $'4 =1 '!$!$($$( (!$ ( )!, 1$$! $ )! # $ ) '

! 2$'! '!$!$($$(!

> ?

(! ! $! " 7 $ 7+ ?!4,+))! $$)!

4'4(1$' $1! (!= $ $ $$! 61! "(( '!$!+

#+!) $ )( $ !) )! ! ! )! !$) $ 4 )!' ( ' $ 4

)!')!,$A*/$ #B!.)! !$)

! 9(!

> (( $ )!

=1 ?)( $1$ (!

!) !'

# ! $ )! )') $ (?)( $ = 1((($'4( )! !!! # 41 $ '4 2$ '( ! (, (!+

$ )!, $ $ $ )! 1$ $ )! $ ) 1$'$1! (! = $)! +$ $( , )!,$ $ $)! 4. '

)'!$ $ !(!( !($4 )!'9?)!( , !) $!1 + , $4

)!''4+$) !( (!$ $1 (#+ $1,!+$( (!

4?)( #,, = $

C )! +$ $. ), $$$ '> $)! !=1 )!,$ -1,!+

, $!#!$4 )!'$!$)! !$)

!4. '

$,4 )!')!,$ 5!

))(('$!6$( 4!,$)! $(#()

4)!,46$( (!5 (!$)!,$ 46))! # $, ? #$

( ! $9(!6@! )!,$(!

(( $)! +?(',(6 $

> = '$' + '$ !) ?)( $1(!

(( $)! $

> !$ '

! 41 $ '4 +!!! # !, 4 )!'46$( (! 5!

'! $, '!$! !! 4!, # $ 4' 4 #!'

A*/$ #B!.

#+$! !+'4( # )!,A*/$

#B!. (6! '

!1$$4' 4 # 'B$!'

#$ !4' $ )!,46 !) ($ $!! # 46$ !((!+!( !! ' !(64'(!

# >

2$!

4 <' 2$!<'! (1$$

'4($ )! 1$'1! (!1! $ , 4 ( !#!$, $)! + 64

$ $( (! $ )) $1 4? $ ( ? $! !1 =1 ?)( )!,$$! )! /) # ,1 $ !+ $ !! '

! $(( #

4' - +$6! , ) ((1 (($) # (( '))( + 6+!) + ,1 $4,3'#

"#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./