High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/437/2020dismissed

Sohan Singh (Deceased) Through His Lrs v. Rachhpal Singh

2024-03-20Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal20 pages

!

"#"$%"&'( )

*+" $&"$(

,*'-'., "/"*#"&+,$0.,1$# 22"33*'+ 4"$#0# */,,2*3-'., "#2'&"'+ (51 16 1

$"#"'+( $ *'7*8*-'#9&%/*+"9 $ $#,-#,*'&*9&%/*+"

$+,"*22"33*'+ $07*'+02+*9&%/*+"

$+,"$"#2'&"'+

!

"

"

# $%&'

$$%%&" (

) *+++!

',

$%-".

.

/" $"%%'

0$%%%'

1

23 4

!"#

#

# ! #

! " $ #

# ! ! ! !

"

% #" $

& ! ! "$

# !

"' "( '

"$0 $$&

.

/" $ $$%

5$ $&

1 23 )"

$ !

'"*+,)-.+ , //.

"

" $

! ! ! 0"1 !"

$ #

2

" "

! #

!

2

! #

3 1

"

#1 ! !

!

# #

4

! "

1 !

! ! 0"

5 " !

&

! ! "$ #

!

% !

#

#

! 1 !

"

"

&

#

2

#

# !

" !!

!

!

7! "

76 "$

! ! !

7

! "8

#

2

!# "9!

!

&

# # 7!

! ! " ! ! 76 # "

*"

!

2

!

!

!

!

#

2

)-:,

# # ! 1 !

%

! ; !

" #

"" < => '" ., ) )-:,"

9!

! !

)--

# #"8

!

""

!!

2

# #

" $

2 5

#

! 6 ! ! "

,"

$

2 !

! # "

: ?

! #

" ! ! #

7 # #

7 " +"

4

!5

"

$ !

% #

! ; !

2

!

#

& !# #

# #

! 7

4 !# %

! "

!

!

!

! "

! ! #

!

! ! #

! # " ."

#

! !

#"$ !

!

# #" ?

#

7 ! "

"?

#!

2 " :"

$ # ! " '

; "( 0 ) $&$ $%

6 .

23 @

! ? ! , 8 ! /):

A ! 2 "

"

$

!

! ! & ! '",)///-"

"$ !

# ! ! #

# # % #

A ! #

! # !

!

!

#

A !

!" !

!

2 B

#

! !

! #

# & C

! <"B #

!

%

# !

#

C

# ! !

!!

"

!

# <# "

"

<"B : B /)-"

*" < !

: /)-

# !

! <# "( " ,

6.

7

&$ $%+

6.

5

& )

!

! # # !

!

, %'% !""$$83 . !

( 9 !

:

;

< :

= !

>

+

<

<

> + <

?

@ !'$$83.

!

! # # !

!

"

"

!

55

0

+ <

'$$%-

"$'%-5

'$$%- !

.

/%' %-5 $%-5

;

, /"-5%-5

0$%%%' + <

/00" 5$%%'

0

!

0$%%& + <

/ $$ &$" $$'

55

0

!

0$- $$% - #

> 6 .

)

$&$ $%

1 23 )" $

! ! ! !

"

5

! # )- -

! " ./A5

# "$

# !

!

# 5 #

5 "

" $

*. A

# #

# 5 5 5 &#

"

" $

# !

!

! !

!

! !

"$

! !

!# ! *. "

$

A

! !

2

! ! & C !

! # ! 2 !

! &

3

# #

2

" *"

$

!

! "

! '"

*,=DC EA )/>

AF

"AF # F

! ! " DC EA )/

! #

!

"$

!

# !

"$ B A6 !

DC EA ))

" ,"

$

! #

!

!

"$ # ! #

! "$ ! !

"$ ! #

"$ ! '"

*,=DC

>

DC

A # #

!

! ! ! % "

0 !

'"),! '"*, #

"6

!

! '"*: )-5/5)- /DC

DC A ") //"

?

! '"*: ! !

6 ! ",,//A51 !

!

' !

'"*,"! '"*: #

! F

"F

'&

F

! ! # # ! # 6 6

"# #

! ! '*:

*,"$ ! !

! C "$ !

"$

6 !

)-*,5*+# # ! '*,

"$ A

% " ! '"*,# #

! )A

F

'" ).)

)A+

F

'".

,, :+

,0

! ! ") //A5

! #

"1 ! ! #

!

# !

#

# ! #

"

1 A

!

! ! *,#

#

! ,F

,0 $

$ 2! G 0 2 DC )

DC )A #

#

F

* 0 =5*> ! " $ ! *,

#

! DC )" #

A

# ! "$

! ! "

! ! #

" ./"?

! ' *: #

,,//A5

! '"*, ! ! ! " ) //A5 $ A

!

! ! # ! " $ &

/.5/5/)- # !

&

'"

H5 I$ 0 # ! ! #

# # % #

A ! #

! # !

!

!

#

A !

!"I $

& !

#

" $

! DC )A

#

! ! '"*,DC EA )/$"

$ ! 5 "

'#

! F

!

5 6 !

#

!

! ?

2

#

! A 5 6 !

F

!

!

'

2

% #

5 F

! #

D F

!

! #

# ! "' F

!

DC EA ))$

! ! ! 2 # / A

!

2 # / A

F

!

#

$

#

2 # /"

D !

)-,.5,:DC EA 1 # / # !

#

2 # A2

/ ! 2

!

"$ A

# ! A " +"

$

!

"

"

1

1

! # #

#

2

#

!

6

6 !

! # !

) //A5"

5C !

! ++F

)*0 # ! !

A "

!

#!

!

2

F

F

!

2

"

# !

! #

"$

! '"*,#

!

!

!

! ++ F

)* 0

! "

$ 6 !

8 "$ ! ++2

)*!

#

# ! #

A

" #

#

!

2 "$

!

! ++F

)*0

# !

"?

# ! #

"

$ # !

! # "D !

!

!

6

#

:

!

#

! !

)! " !

# % ++F

)*0

#

# ! #

" ."

$

! "$ ! !

/ "

!

)-)

!

!

6 )- / ! *:"$ !

)/5/+5)-.) ! "# #

! C !

!

" :"

$

"# DC C . " !

!

! DC DC ."1

# " $

# "$

! #

"

! !

*/*

D

"( %

; $ + 6.

7

5$ $&

5

/ 5

.

+ 6 .

) $-$0 $% ,A

?

6.

@

6.

' A

1

>

B

, >

+

33

9

0 A 1

+

+ <

>

>

!

55

0

+ <

" A 1

,

$'$%'$ + <

%$ $'

!

# # !

! . !

>

+ +

+ <

5 .

C1,'

<

,

+ <

>

+

$$-%0

!'$$83 + <

%$-%0 .

+

C1,0

!

/

> ?

@

%"&3"- C1.*8'

>

C1,"8#.

# !

%5 35'

%5&35- %&&3&- %- 3-'

%-&3-- %% 3%'

%%&3%- $$ 3$'

$$&3$- $ 3'.

& + 6.

+

3 +

3

)

-

5

3 +

55

0

>

3

7 )

+

"

"

6.

% A

&

#

!"#$%&%!'%$( ) *+ *',' % !"!

$) %*'

-

+

$ A

-

9

.

+,*$/,9

16 1 '+

=,"+,"$#2"*7-'.>$"*#'"& (!> =,"+,"$$"2$+*?3"

(!>