← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/149/2015dismissed

Kishan Lal (Through Lr Ranjana Devi And ORS) v. Mahesh Kumar

2018-11-13Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal8 pages



      

    

      

  !"#$

% &&& '"

   (")   &&& "* $"    !"#$%&'()$ % ')* 

"" + ( & ,"* -$# . "$ ( & !""# $ -$# . "  

"*"

( &!0-$# . "/



"* $" & 111      234& 

#" ." "$

$ 35&36&6738 *"$ 90 # $ " :"

 # %- - ;"

"90 ;

**. /"$90 "*"

;"

"$)"$ ; .

& 264&  "**. ;/"$/

 0  ".

/ )

/"$"

63 "<=-<> "$; :".

383$ 3<3  & 

 **.  ; /"$ $"

 :".

 85 "$ ; :".

383$3<3 90 " /

""

9""*"$ )"

& 2?4&  **.  ;"

" .

" "$90 " $".

"" $"

"**. ;"

"/"$

$"0 ")

$

" )" ;"

" 

 ) 9"& **.  ;"

" 

**"$ 90

" ;.

$.

$.

&  ;

&



"; /&" " / /"$   3>&36&677> ;. ;"

" $)"$ 90   

 6>&7<&673?& " **" /"$ 90 " "  " ; $)"$90 "$$ 

.

$ "- 

 36&7<&6738& "

"/ - #$"

 $ "$ ?7&75&6738- "

! ; **  "$   .  ))

 "@".

" " $""$  /#

" $".

""  $"

& :" $""$  &??5 $ 75&7=&6738;"@".

"$$ "  "$/#

"" $"

284&  # $ " :"

 # %-  #$" )* "$

 $ "$ 35&36&6738 / "   /

 *"./.

)." ; /"$ 90 " * //A$".

""  $"

      76&73&3>>B& "/"$  **" "$ $ /"$  ;

" ")" &/ . /* //C"#$"."-$"/"$ #"$ "#"

 **

 " /

 "$  $"/"." "#$"."- 9  ) "0- /"$

 "$ 0 "#$"." $ ; *

.""$"$      #$"

 $ "$ 66&33&6773& $ )"  $ $".

""$ "$76&73&6776;*"$90



"90 $".

""  "   "$"/"$ $$  ;"

""$

"$"/"$

*"

)*

/.

.

90 " " $""$  /#

" * //A$".

""  $"

;  "" )  /

) " $ / *  / !$ )"  $ $".

""/ "."#  "9."".

$"

&

2<4&  **. $"

> "3? ;/"$ 90 " //

"

 $" "!$ )" $ $".

""& " **.  ; $)"$& "

"/ *"

;/"$90 "" $"

6<&78&677>& 

." / "@".

 *"

 ; #"

; /"$ ;.;"

"$)"$90 ""@".

 

 6>&7<&673?AA?7&7<&673?& " **" /"$   " $

; $)"$90 "$$ 

.

$ "- 

36&7<&6738& 2B4& 

 ")* "$

;

$ "@."*

" /.

 *"-    )"  ;"

"$ $ " "@".



 $)"$ " **.  ;  .

&?777AD

 9" $"*  "$ "" :"

#." $& 254&  #"" $" "$.

"/

"*

"& 2=4&  " "$.

"/

"*"

"

"       

 !"# $ !$%&# '

 9)

$"

:".

666% /:*"./. ""/ .

""@".

/$".

"".

9"  "$"$  "   *"./.0 * 0"$  "   ;" "", 

""/ /*"./.*"

)." /.

.

90;0 /"@".

" $""$&   

 .

 ""/ "   )"  9

"$  ) / :".

 666% " :*"./. ""/ .

2>4& 

 "/

"$!$ )" ;

$ 

** ". ". "$* "."$" $"$ (  $  

"!#$!$%&# )*"

E )

" )" ; "$"

"$ ;

"/"

"."

" *

#  

) /:".

666% ":*"./. ""/.

&"

;"

"0 * *  +&* * ,%  -    .&

!# $ !$%&# '

/ "$ " 

 .

 ""/ " /$

)) #"9"*

0-9!".

)

" "")" /

" "  $

;.*"./.*"

)." .)"$-" "* " ")) #"9"*

0 *"./.0* 0"$/

& (0 * !1#;"$

9"

**.9"$ ")";"$

9"*"

E )& 2374& 

$-" "$.

"/

"* $"

""$* 2 2  &(

)!#$!$%&# "/!#  (  .% .3 

!4# $ !$%&# / !#  % 5(   6 78

 ! #$!$%&#)"'!,# 53-&  9:-&2 -&  ;'

 ! $#'' $ 51     %    

)!# ,- ) / $ .

"$"$   *  +&* *,% - *!1# "$09"""@*"$  "/

"$!$ )" ; "/"

"."

:".

666%$ 6= ":*"./. ""/.

&" $$ ;53 -&0 *!1#;"#"

. "$9"/

"

$" ;  0 * !1#&  "  

#   )

:".

 666% $ 6=?% " :*"./. ""/ .

-   . 9" ** ". " /

"$ E"  .)"

 9" $"9 "$  53-&0*!1#;"

"/  "*

#

/ :9 :".

 ? / :".

 6= " :*"./. ""/ .

 C9"*"@

/ ;" "

" "/"# "

""/ /* " -:".

66 ":*"./. ""/.

.

9" "$    &   

  $ 

7

4 "$

<    3 2   $".$"$ 75&78&673B ," ")"#";& 2334& 

" 

$"$  51  

 * !1#- /*  +&* * ,%  - * !1# $  0 * !1% ; $0 "@*"$& ;"$ :".

66 ":*"./. ""/.

.

9" "$  ;":".

6= ":*"./. ""/ .

 "# " ""/ " &  .

!

 "$  / 9

"*

# - )/" "

. 0  "

.""$   ""/ /)"$)" /* - "9"."

""/  ") $ "/

"- "* //""$

"",)"$)" &""$""$ "$09"""@".

; " #" "

2364&   "   / /

"$ "  *  " 9!".

)

.

*"$; /.

." "."- .9"

."$

" $"/"$  ; *

.""$"$      66&33&6773 $   !$ )"  $ $".

"" /

 *"./.

)." ; *"$  76&73&6776&  **.  $"

> "3? /"$90 "!$ )" $"9

;$)"$ $ ")"

"$/ 0&#" /"$ *

.""$ ;"

"$)"$90 ""@".

 

6>&7<&673?A?7&7<&673?&**"; $)"$90$$  

.

$ " 36&7<&6738& "

#" "$0

"$ / 0& **" /

)

$ "!$ )" $"9



   A*"

 $  

 ;  .)

.""$  900" )"& 23?4&  ".

."* // 0 /!$ )" 9"""@*"$ 90 " C9"*"@

  $ *& 7  +% =-& *  >  7  

!"#$!$%&#));- ;"

" " )@)         

    ; .

$"

""//".

"   ) "$/    "

.0 ")"$"  )"  "&** " 0- "**. $"

 > " 3?   /"$ 90

 ; $)"$$ ")" 

"$/ 0&:".

$0-

 /"$ $   "@".

 ;"

"   $)"$ $ $

;*"$**" 36&7<&673890 "$$  

.

$ "- & "." 0

* E"

  )"  " /   &  $#"

 0 ")-$"*

" !$ " "  "  .

 $ "  9" "

 )

*

" )0 ")  /"$ ; " )  .

 $". & *" $

/

/

**".

$9" *" /

$  ;.;.")

";

  " ."

0  " ".

  &".

.  ".

#"

09"

;"" "*

" )  .

)"

  "$    )"   " $  "

 .

 )  9" *"

)

 .E " / 0&   ;

$ 9" )*

 "*

"

/"**. / **. 

""$"*

."&  0 /!$ )" 9  "0)*"

#" $ " .

0

."$

"/ 0 "!$ )" 2384&     

 $ 0 " 

 " " $" " .)"   

 $ ; 90 "    *

0 90 # , 

." "

-"#"/ / 0 / )"  " /   & F" .

9  " /

"$ "$".0- " 

 ;

$ 9" /0 ! /"$  "

  * #" .

 ;" " "  *

." 

 #" 9"" 9"$&  .

"  

  #"

0 #9"* .*" /* "."$" ;..

9"$"*

"$

$ 0. .) ."&" $$ ;  !

# -  %  ?  &  $ ((  7 &?@ 3&1!;)/#4 $$ 4$ ?A

 %  $ &&*

&   

!

# $ !$%&#"/ .9" ""$ "/

"$.

"@ 23<4&  " 

  $ 

 9" )*"

"$ 90 0 "..

" $    )" / **0  * .*" /      " )"   /$)"  * .*" ;.  

" /;"  / 0   &"/

"$

  #"

 **.  $   "  " " :

"  $ 9"  "$

"     $  "  $ 9"

#"@"$ ;." "   ")"." /.

&  "

"$* .*" /; ""@".

 

.

9"0

" $".

""& " #"; "@* ""$ 90 "  C9" *"@ 

  * &   * 6 *

&   < ! $#

)!

# $? )  ;  .

 ." ; " " "

 #"; "@* ""$  7,<3 2.6& (   ;;

 $ ))&#"; $$ ;,3   .% , !

"#  $$ ""

- ".. .$"/" "";.$

"$/ 0/ $)

"**. $"

> "3? $/ $)

 /"$ 90 

  &)0.

$"

* - "

9"E"

"   & 23B4& 

" 

$"$ "

"9 #"-  "# $)"$&    % ')*    %&*$ 3?&33&673= 

." F"

" "$A:*",  "A F"

"*

9"  "A