Lovepreet Kumar And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!"#" $%&'' () *+ ,
, ,
+%
-( +'
,
+ ,(
!!!!
+ ,(
.
'
/0 " $$%& &' & "() *
"$+ ",&- .+ (+(/$($"
)0 1+*2
2 2 & &
-
& 2 & 0 # &
& -
& &"++
3 1'
24 $ & 3
& 3 5 .6 & $($"
& 2
6 && 2
& - -
&
& 3 1'
4 # & - 7 2 3 . - . 8
9& "
"&$($"
(%(:$($" 3 1'
,%, $ $&$($"
"%(:$($"
$6+6 "(;$ 6&$($"
$%(:$($"
'
:<+ "(;$ + +&$($"
(+(/$($" 4
:/:
+ =-
>& 2
& 2
& &3 1'
4 2
2 "(;$
2 2
& &
2 ' - 2
&
2
2 &
2
& &3 1'
2 & &3 1'
? 4
2 , -
&2
# & &
&)*
)*
)*
2 >& # 2 -2# &
& 2 0
? - & %
- 2 & & #
& - ."&$($" &3 1'
"+(,$($6 .+&$($"4 (<(/$($6 0 "++
& &3 1'
2 4
#
&
& 0 "++ 2
& &3 1'
4
& 0 &4 & & "++ & 2 & - & 6(( &4 - ' 2
& 3 1'
& 4
: & >
- .:/:0- & &4
#
-
2 & & 2 "() * ",&- - -
&
& 2 0 # -
& >& &
0
- & - & & & - & 1 &
& #
& @
& A
# B
- - & 2 & 0
"() *"$+",& -
& - 2
! ! ! "
/ - 3- ' -&3 2 ' 3 2 2 ' &2 3
& >- - ' :/:- & &4 2 - 32
&:/:
< C 3 &2 &
&- #
2
&
& - ' 2
&3- 2 &:/: 2 . -
:/: # 32
&:/: # > '
&
& 3 @
! "!#$" !% %&'()!* *)%"!+*",-
./ 0/ !% %&'1*( 2()& !%*"
"
!* ! , / ( (% 33 $#! *() & !%*"" %&'1%* ()& !%*",- 4.5 3
& 6*7( 8!&& %8!%*" % %8 &( &*)"*$( (9!()& !%*", :
/:
5 "( ' - & 2
&
7 "" D & &
&2> & * -& & - & &
F * 4 -& & - F )* "() *"$+",&-
.+&$($" - &'F )-* &2 F + "$
"$ 3"1"
0"
"$
- &
& - B
>
& -
&
-&
& - "$" 2GB
& 0 ;< * (9! &)!
() !%*"< %&'
$()1"!
*() !%*" / ( (% /
-
2
& -
&#
2 & 2
2 "$$ ' %"!!()* !!<( &"! ,- /. /0& & & &2-
3
- & 2 &
# -0 & H$%
&
&
' (
) & * + , ) - .
# "$6
2
2 &- 2 3 - &
- 2-
&
-& 1 ? --& "+& &' "$+ 3 & %"! !
7 ()(& !%*< 8%!(8%
&*,6*!= ( <%*" 7()(& !%*- .
3 - 2
& -
& 2 &
# -0 & /%$
. &
& !
%0
I "$, #2GB
&3 $( ()*1$ * ()& !%*"<; <&< ()& !%*",-00./ /34
2 -
&
&
2
--& "+& &'# -0 & /12
3333333
( ' & 4 '
*
&
&
& &
4 1% . "$% D & -1> > -
&
) *& - 2
--& "+&
&'#
&& & -
- -
&
# &
&
&&"++ & 3 1'
2 4 #
-
& & 2 &
& ,! 8
9:"!"
;"
< "6
&
& & ? -
& & 0-&&& & -
B
* (9!< %&'$(;#,03/ ( (% >-03 . 5//>03 5
2
& & - #
2- &G & 2 #
& B
2
& - 2
& & #
7 & E
& & & -
6
.
'
'
.
&
.
&
.
"6"
4 & & $$%& &' 0 1 - 2 - &
& &
3 2 2
-2 & & & ' &4 $$%3
6$ "6$
& -2 &
6,<)"*
& $"&
B
2!( (9!< %&'$(;# -03 . 505 4
& $$%& - &
- & 2 2 $":)6* & > && &4 &E 2 & $":)6*3 ( &(&'() "7& *2"! %*-05. /03 $":)6* & & & -
& .2
& & &
&
2
& 2 - A 2 - 0 - 2 &- B
1 !& &6&
&!("?8!
!$+ & !%*"00 $
- . 3 & &
%)"* & -2 "6%$$%$$:& & & - & 1 2 &. G -
# 3 ?
2 0 2
& # 3
# # 3
-2 "66 D -1 -
0 - > 1 & -2 # &1 ? 4 0 & 2 & -2 & $$%&
0& & - ' ' &
& &
0-& ) 1":"
:"
$
!1 9#
:;
"# = $
"+
-& "() *"$+",&- .+&$($" &
2 - - 2 2 2 -& # -
& # - 2 & 2 # & G -& "+" ' %&'
)$()(& !%*<1* "!( $* !7 ()& !%*", 3- . 52 2 8
&
6/& #.
"<,< 3 "$0
2 H7 (
" : &
"
;"
:& & "
&
< ( .
.
< *
4
(
= !
:
& (
1>
.
: 4
4 :
*
7 (
* &
)
(
4 6 4
"+$ ' %
$ * %* &*"""&8 &(&'() ()& !%*"< % %8& %9$ &*7$ !&* 7&'() ()& !%*",- 3.5 5/ 3 2 & #
&' "<<: - & "+6 B
!7*(&<( &(&'() , - 5. 0 2 #
- &
#
. ) . ?
@
A 15B9
*..
>%1
4 1%
4 1%
=
!
4
7
4 1% ", ' ,''
"#"$>5 $"
)#
/7 , 6& 4A 3 & 2 &
& &2 2
2 '
- & 2
2 & 0 - &2 &
&2' - & & ","
' &7
&7
< %&' -05 .
/, 0
2 > 2
& & & &
&3 &
&5&& 3 2
'2 2
& "+ "% >
# 3 - /, 4
&
4 1% 1>
4 1>
C
*
. 4 1>
4 1%
4 1% 4 1>
4 1>
4 1% 1>
@
8 )
+ /
#
7
"
?
/ #
<
D
7
4 1%
4 1>
4 1% 1> & *
*
&
7 *
4 1% 1>
=
;
)
4 1% 1> ",$ '(%2()! <( &(&'() ,-054.
4
B
0
2 && & - & 3 --& "+2
#
2 & G 2
& B
/E3
4 1% & *
"
6
4 1% &
4 $1
4 1%
/
#
D
4 $1 @
!" " $
%)A "% D - & - &
& &2 2
2
' - &2
2 & 0 - & 2 & # &2& &-2
& 2
7
22 '& 2 2
&
2 &2
2 && ' &2 2 &
- ' - & & ": &-G B
<(()( () & !%*""6 9!&$* &'1%* ()& !%*" / ( (% 00 - -&
& 3
G 4
&J $(",-
&
3
G J 34 G 3 - & B # &
2 & -0 & 2 0--1- #
& 2 02 6(( &2
",(
,& & H
& I& --1- 2 - & 4
2
1&&
2
& 2 0 >& --1- ' -
2 & -2
2 4 G 3 - 2
2 > 2 2
1&&& --1- 1&&
2
& 2 0# D & 4 &J
- & -
# & &
& 2
# & D
1&& & --- & &
&
& 0
6$& 5
&
&
&& --1- 2
& 2 2 & & 2 0 --1- 4A - 2 & 0 - &
7 2
&
- --& "+ # -0 &
4
"
& "
( 6 *
* ) $22>
*..
0B1
* @ ? 4
@ $211
> *..
92B .
"&
* )
* @ = $2$$
1E *..
%$2 .
* '
"+ ) . * ' ) @"' *
* & F . =
4 15B1
= .
'G
. 'G ;
'
'G
&
/ * )
* @ = $2$$
1E *..
%$2 .
;
*..
0E
/0E
&
* 4 &
'G ) ' &
- .
"&
&
H* '
+
A 15>E *..
F: *.
>I
C
. *?)
* J J $2$0
$ *..
>%0
&
.
"
;
* J J *..
>EB"
E5
/95
34
A
( *)"</<*$
:,+*
!
4 1% .
* "
* C *
* *
4 1%
3<
&
&
-
&
*
HA
- , . 1550
*..
%55D) 4 * :
.
F $229
*..
>$9D= K ?
:
A $21$
*..
1DA J
. $21>
% *..
$0> ;
$21>
*..
:K*
>%2D* +&
) = : $2$0
*..
>0% I
4
"
4 1%
;
D
4 1%
@
!" " $
%)A "/ '
2 # & 2 35 2 & - ' <%21 " !< %&'6.
/ 2 , 7.
3
& 2 # 2
&
2 2
# &2 2
2 - - & & 2 # -0 & /02 2B!*- .@ 2B!* $ (< $# 8 %*< 8%&
"" &(,- 0.5
A .
?
/ #
-
&
)
/ #
/ #
0%
2B!*@ 2B!* $ (-/.<$#
%*< 8%&
"" &(,- 4.5 5/>- . - + .0
!
. + + ,
/# +
19
F
F 2B!*@ 2B!* $ (-/.<$#
%*< 8%&
"" &(,- 4.5 5/>- . - + . 0
A.
"<
- & 3
! "!#$-"$ *. 3
& 2 2 3 .6+
2 66 2 - 5
& 2
# 2 2 # 3
2 & - #
F ( 1> $21$ ( '
" 9
( 1> $21$ (
1>
&
4
* " 9
( 1>
!
-
"<"
' !* < $*%"!*"),- . 343
- - &
- &
&& &-
0 2 ' & - 2 &
& 2 & "<$ # GB
&3 (%"!1$ * 1"!7 ()& !%*"< &$ !" %( * =7()& !%*", 0 - . 504-
& -2 '
& 2 2 2 #
1 2 $(K0 & -22 2 2 '2
& 2
2 && - &
# -0 & /0%
*
. (
"
+ )
J , ) HA
J , ) $22>
*..
EE5 ;
$22> *..
:K*
$$9I G
"
4 $$> 0$ . "
$( D -1 -
& 3 2 2 ' &2 3& - '
&2
&
& &
#
& ?>& & & &&
&
-&&
- -
#
& & - $" ' 0 3 ?
& ?
? 1 ' 2 & 0 - 2
& 2 & 2 - & 3
& 3
&
- & 2- &0 -
&& 2 -
6
-
& > -- & &
$$ D - &2
)* 3 & & 2 2
)*
3 2 )* . &
& 2-
& - & &
&' )-* 3 &
2-
& 2 2 --& $"& &' )-*
-& -
& &
- )-* C0 & &2 $6
- - &35 .6&$($"
& &3 +)*+,)*& $((:# - &35
&- 2 0
&35
&- /) *#
2 "() *#
2 '
"$"$>
$:
0" :
80 3
" $'
' '
"$"$>
$:
0" :
80 3
" $'
"," # - -
-
- && &
&& &
& & & & # & ",$ # &
2
2
$ !
;
!
$!4 = "$# 9$ "11 :.
$
!! 9$
$4
# $.
=
#5
!
00"
:
0< 0:
$ ?
!09"
= $ '
$ "11 :
;
!
$!"
'
$ "11 :
;
!
$!"
' - & ' - &
& >& &
& >& &
0?
0?
- & ?- & & - & ?- & & ? - & ? - & 1 & ) * 1 & ) *
& &
& & -
-
-
-
& 2 & 0
& 2 & 0 D & 3 5 - - "$+& - 0
H $ !
;
!
$!4 = "$# 9$ "11 :.
$
!! 9$
$4
# $.
=
#5
!
00"
:
0< 0:
$ ?
!09"
= $ I
35 # 0
35 $+ 35 2-
2
&2 )*
)* 3 #
7 )#*
)3#*B # 3#
>& )* && # - )-* =0 )-* 8 & &
)-* 8 & & & )-* '
&
&
$,
"() * - 2 2
", - - &
& >& & 0?
- & ?- & & ? -
& 1 & ) *
& & -
-
& 2 & 0 3 2
& - 35 2 - ' -2&22 3 & 1 3 2
2 & 1 &2 &2# & &
2 & & "() * - $% D & -
&
",&- - - 2
& & 2 & &
& >& &
0
? ?
& - & # & - &- &
&H I
& 2 & 0 #
- -
& 2 & &H
& I ' & 2
2
"++2
&3 1'
2 4
# 2 - 0
L - & - & & >& & & B ?M- - & & & - &"++ & &3 1'
2 4 "++ 2 0
- &3 1'
# 2 > & & 2 & 0
# ",
- - 2
-
&
&
-
& 2 5
& & & 3 1'
2 & & "++
4 #
-2 & 3 5 -
&
&
& & 1
& &
- 2 & 2 & -
&
& & & & 2&& #
&
& &3 1'
4
#
&3 1'
4
2
& &3 1'
2 4 #
- 2 &
& & & &3 1'
2 4 ' 2
2 2 & #
& 3
! "! #$ ) *
& 0- & :/: #
&:/: "++ 2 & &3 1'
# & & &4
& #
&
& '
2
?
& #
& 3- 2
& 2 - ' & - & 4
&
2 :/:#
& :/:
2
"++2 2 & & &3 1'
"++ "/K&
- # & --
-- 2 &
&
2
- & #
2 & &
# &4
& 0 M3 2
-& & - > 2
$($"
$($+#
- & 1- &&
# &
-
&
- & 0 & 3 <(()( - $ *. & & 2 &
&
&- & 2
& &2 &
&2 '2 -& 0 & $: - 35 2
& 2 &2
& #?3## & # - & 0
L - & - & & >&
&&
& & &&
",&- &
& >& & 0
- & - & & & -
& 2 #
0
H
& I 2- & 0
&2 H& -
I"0# 14 0
H I 2 0
>& 0
- & & - & & 0
H I
2 0
0
& & & , ! $:14 0
H& -
I
&# -
H I " $ - & # & && 0
", -
&&& &
-
- ' "++ 2 & & & 4 0 #
-
& 2
>& 2 - - & ?0# &-
&
>2 -
& >& & D & ",
&
& 2 - & 2 2 & & 2 &
& & #3# '
2 2
& 2 #?3#2 2-
>&
& 0 ?
- &
& >& & -
-
& >& & 2 & 2 #
2 & ", 3 $(;*<%%(< %&' % (9(.
/62 , 676.
'
&& # 1&& - 3& - # - & -
& & 0- # %
*
- . 'F= @
B1 $$"$"155E
'F=
'F=
7
'F=
'F=
' " ,
. ,
*
& 6 .
F (
F , 6 F , (
F
,
. ,
* 6
, (
&
,
* 6
*
@
$
,
.
,
.
4 4 F , (
'F=
(
6 'F=
;
/B
4
3
&
'
4 6 6 * .
!
4 6 6 * .
"
4 - .
'F=
'F=
'F=
. 'F= "
"
7
'F= $$"$"155E
*
&6 .
7
7 'F= 155E
1$
?
'F=
'F=
&
-
.
.
.
.
.
- .
F . 'F= $$"$"155E
'F=
4 'F=
.
.
&
.
1%
7
- . , )
4 6 - .
% &' < !9 &*"(
@ % &' < !9 &*"(
, / ( (%45A, - .
'F= ;
/15
"
!1
&
6
. 4 1> .
@
@$(; *<%%( < % &'
% (9(, 3 ( (%67)/ 0A,@) $* )!* < %&' % (9(, 3 ( (%67)
A $/ ' 2& -
& >
- 2 2 )* &-
&
&7 & - -
)* 4 2 -& & -
&&
- )*
"() * 2 ",& - - 2- ",
- )-* - &2 & & 4 $: - 2
2#
"++ &
&4 2 :/:'
&&& 2 & #
2 "++
0:/: # &
2 6
& '& && "++
0 2 / + ,(
$6(,$($+ 4
? N ?. 7 ( L!@