High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1129/2017allowed

Anant Ram v. Mahaan Devi And ORS.

2019-05-22Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan3 pages

!" #$%$&' ( & &

)*" # % "+ ,-.,/ % $$& % 0 ,

& 2$*" # % "+ ,-.,/ &", % %3&" &% 1' 4/1 5/

% &'

1 &6 2

&"$7"2# 7!, 3 $$& % 11 $% 7"2# ! %3&" &%*$+*$$$+778*$+ &"8*$$+ 9999999 5/7* /+ , 3 % &3 $$&$%"$ # " .

$&%, " "

" 8 7 %% ":;, ""$$& <$2$<-". * &$$2$%$&+7 %-;

*!%,7, $ <-+7,-.,=,$#, & 33<$# $&!$< ":;, 3< $&$!!& &

) *%$&# " # % "+*&= 3 % & ":;, 3 $$& %+7-&" #$&%( &"

(8 7!# #$&$&, " # !, $ <-"

" ( , % : &"$%)$%% " , !

#%7$&:$ !7=,$#, >-$ ": &$# "! "6-"$# $&.

-3&, 3 % &3 $$& , & &

)!$< " %-$% ?$&., $&

" #< $&, !! #, , &" %3&" &@" ! &"

&$", $/ < : " #< "6$&=& %$&3%% %%$&, A &!@(,%, $&, < &"

$< " &" " %#$: " $& , , " & ! , 3< $& *! %,7 , %-$ 33 ;+,-.,6-".) & &"" # "

" ( , ! % $"%-$ = %" # ", %3&" &%!$< " & < .

$&%, ! % $"6-".) &

&"" # =,$#,= %"$%)$%% ":;, 33 << -& !-, < = % 3 ! " :; , %3&" &% , ! 7 & &

) <$B ", , = = %$&, ! % $"6-".) & &"" # =$,

CD .

", " %#$3$&!, %-$33 ;, < &"" %#$: ":;& &

)

@@*E +$&, , "& !,$%3< $& <%) &$& "$&, 6-".) & &"

" # = %$&!

#: " %#$: " % @@*E + &", 5, % * E+ , ": &$& "2 &<;) &$& " % E##"$&.<;7& &

)!$< "

& 33<$# $&-&" #$&%( &"(8 !# #$&!, ! % $"

%&%-33!,$% %% $&%7 <&.=$,,$% 33<$# $&7, 33 &" ", < 2 & 2 &- #" ,-.,, " -&" #, << &. , $ <- ## 3 ", 3 ; ) " :;& &

)>- , < &": " %#$: " %?, % * E+:- !-% ") ? , # #$&>- E?

<%!< &"=,$#, ##"$&.&

) = % $& # &.< &" & # &.< $% $& , % #$#-)% &# %, , 3 % &3 $$&, %: &!$< " / & "#-&% <!, 3 $$& %%-:)$%, E?

<%!< &"

" %#$: "$&, , "& !, 3< $&: $& # &.< = &"$%$& !

#$& # &.< &"$&, .

" &$&!,$%-= %" =& , 33 &" " 2 &- #"$%!-, %-:)$ ", , = &"$%& < &" $& # &.< $& 0$<< . 5, &.= $7 ,%$< %-;

7 $%$# %,$ 3-=,$#,= %$%-&" , =& %,$3! &;!, 3 $ %, <$$.

$& &%3$ !% 2$# 7&& %&: , <!! %3&" &%F7 (7 *$+ *$$$+7F &"

%3&" &%7 *$2+78 &"E= : ! , $ < - & %-:)$%%$& ) " :; < & " #-&% < ! , 3 $$& %7, $% 2$# = %" ": "$%3 &% "=$, / & "#-&% <! %3&" &%*$+*$$$+778*$+ &"8*$$+ " % & "$%3- , ! %-:)$%%$&% ) " :; < & " #-&% < ! ,

C8D 3 $$& % &2$ =!, :2 7, $)3-.& "" 7, A &, $" % &" # #$&$&, 6-".) & &"" # "

" ( =$, .

" " %#$3$&!E?

<%!< &": $& # &.< &"&$& # &.<

7$%% %$" %-< &<;7E?

<%!< &"=,$#,$%" %#$: "$&, 6-".) &

&"" # $&>- %$& @@*E +=-<"&= " % @@*E + , 3 $$&$% <<= "$&, :2 )% ( C 5/D %, )%, G, , %3 ?$&.@ %& "

%@ G, , 3 :< ' %@