Raj Singh And ANR v. Ashok Kumar And ORS




   
 
 

 

 

 

 
  



 


  

 

  

! 
"

  #    

 !!"

#$!"



$%"



&'"

!"&#(#"

$

$ )

 #" #*#

$!"



$%"

+ # !#

 

#"- !#

$

 $ )   ....

"

  # $    /#

0  ", 1" #"  &

&  '3



("

" 4 &$!!5 &

"$

6  "13$    0 "11  1"  "

 1   

"2  

""& 

 1

,  " 1 "&  "  #    "

  

, "&  '"&#  8 '" %   "  " #%

5 9$ #

"5 8'

"& #

5 



 "

%"

#" 

" &:

$/# " (

7 "$("

" !!5 &

" 1

,# &"& #

'3

" "&

 3

,  &

 

#3

% "  "

1 "

  3$ ,% 2 3 % '3 

5 " /#  "

" "

1"  '3   %

:

 !"&# /# ,

 %

,"   '

#  #  "

 %   "

 "    '3  



("

" 4 &$

2

 "

1

# #

# "11 

% 

 "1

1 "11 /#,

' 

 ' %

" 

#"&# *

(1

-1 "'  "

; (1

 ","&

5 "

%

#< 1# 1 #

" 

," 

 2  '3 #

*

" '

," /#",& 

" "





3

"

'

'

/#3 1"

 ", ","&:

!"&#

' % "  "

1 "

#< # 1 #

 ","& 

  "

'3%

1

,   "2

""& "11 1

"

"& '3 #"

# 1 #

3



 6  "11 1" "

% 3

 ",

"

"& # 3"&

, %



, %  ",  "1" 3

," % ,

"1" '3 #*



$%#"# ' 1"

'3 #" *

6  )

,  #  

"&  #  

" $  #  1  %"&  "   %

  =# # "11"  

  "2

3 >?

 =#

"  

"1  ", #   ", ; "1> 8 @ 

 

  #   "  $  #  

"  %   &



"

" 



     1 #

"&

&, #

*"

"4 &$4"

("

" "

$  (

 7 "    2  

 6  #

 #

""&

1

," 1 "&

 "

1 1

, "   "& # "11 1

# &"& #

1 "

'3

" "&

 3

  ",

" ,"  9 && "  '3  #  2     $

 1





("

"

4 &$!!5 &

" 2 

6

" ,"  #  '3 *

' %  && " '3 $   #

'1" 

" 1,

% "   

A" "

  @#

  "

# '," "

 ,

'3

 1

" 

  

," 3

;   &

#   1  $"

"  %  



1 %

"2 ' :

$    1

'

  ! 6 #2 '*

 $9

 ! **1 " #"  &

',

2 #! ,*

1


           

  $1  % '3

1! "



     #
   

$

 % 

          

 "& $3"& # %

%"

2 $ A 1 %"  A"

'1

 6 B

 1

&

'

# #*

' %# 

-"

 "



," 11

' %

" $ - 2 '

#

" % &"

# 1 #

 #" 



3  #$

:

!"&#%

"& # 1 #

" 



3:

%

"


C<#"'"

(

,"   
C< (611 ' %

" $ %#"#$ - 2 ' %

"   *  1   0

&

1"

$

" 

,

' 2 

*"

"4 &# "  1 "

  0

 ",

 "," " #

"

" "

$%# % "

" "

' "

%  % 1

# %   # 

'1" ' 1"

3 "& '1 #)"



*

 #$ #1" "&

#"

" "

 




1" "& # 

'

" :1

#



("

"  4 &$  

 #   #     ,

"1"

 

," ' %

"  ,

"1"

$ 

- 2 "

1

# #

  0 

 '3



("

" 4 &$%#"## '

C<#"'"

;  0

%

'

# #*

' %# "&# 3  "

# 

8 B

 1   0 " %

%'3*

7# #" *

"'#& ! (  )

     

*
++*

$,,$ %# "

$

& " "

" "

 ",% #

'

,

': " # %

% '3:

D'

#3 

 #:"&#*

"-. & (  !&&  /   *0
+123* ,,

:

D' '

:"&#*

" #  ( 
# 



 

%    ,

4 5 6&&.  $%

#

&

" 

'$%# 

 1

" ,

'" "% 1 %

%'3)7# :"&#*

"07 "# (  07 -&& 65 $   4$ %# )7# 1:

D'B :"&#*

#  

  
  


  




 




 
 
 
 



 



  

    




!






"#"$  % & 
 $ 

  $


  


 '    

 !
  () 
  $


  
   $ 


 


 )    

  

 $$





 $
 


 $


$



  
 $       $
 )  





  







 '  $





 

 $

 (  :

D'<*

" '    (       $% 65  , $ # #   &*



$ +!
 
$
   $    


 

 

$   )
,
  


 $ +
,  !

   -.#/

01233-     

   

 )
  


  $ ,  !

$ 

 5--&& (7 0&&8 %%

"" 

% 9127 


 

6   
 $ 0 
+!

5807 "# (7 07 -&8 65 $  4$  $

0 
 

 
     


$

   
 
  


 
   

 

   
  

  $
   

4 


 
   

  $ 
        $$ 

)

$$


    +!
    $ 


 






 
    

     

 
5$$
 

 




 
   
  $  

   


        
    
   
) !

,   


 - 1.73#0 
387-

     
 $


  
 


  




  


 

    


  
 

 


 ,

)'  $



  

  %  


     

   



     $



9 
   

'  $


 
 

 


  

   

    






   
 




 


 '  $  

 $ 
 $
 

) 

 
 $$   

      $$




  $ 

  $$


 ) 
 


   :  + !
   
        



  $ $4  " $ 0

  


   $ $  

  '    

+!
$ 4

    $$


+ !




( 9 @ "  %% 

 %

%# # ' 

$

1" "&$  " "

$  

' %  $  &#$

%  , 3#

'

% # ' ' 

'3/-*# $4" #"  

 2  " 65 $  4$ , '

$ 

,""&1

" 

' #,

"

3 #

"#" 

, #

" 

'3 ' "

3'

'3 /#A 1


"   3 %#

%  "

C %#

%  "

$"

'#

" "

&"

 ",

 3 

' " "

" #1  "

 =# "  3  "

#A 1


 

" 



  $'

#  

" , '

,2 #,

"

   #  "

  #$

"  A $ "

1 "" 1


 :1

" # %

%'3*

7#

#" :"&#*

"+ :) 5#;(  : (  # ; ,*'
++*

 %# "$"

# "

;  

&2 3# );
 

!
  

 
 



      


            $  -/
   $ 
  

-  


  ..$ !<!

)
  


 



 



   
 



  $

  

 
   !



 
  '

    
  

  $



%6

 .$4  ..$  6
 -$






      

    '   

      

 
  


  $



     


   $
 
    

    
 
 $

 
     



 $



)

'


$  

 $4  ..
  $$

 


    )

   

     $

$ 


  


 $  $


 

4  ..15 

 $
 
       


5      






 (  @ #

 "&,

, 1 1" 1

# &"&

  #   2 %

'

)"



*



" ," "&

#" &

 /#  2 "     '3  #      1

  0 1*

7# #" *

"'#& !
!

"  "&" #   $

""&

2 # ' 1

,

,

1 $'

# #1" "&  #"

" "

%  ",#

'

" #1" "& $"



'#

"

 ,

'  %#  #  2 1  #  

 *"

"  4 &  " 

  2 #  "  $  %#"#  %   "

   1

$  

" " 

A"

'

1

#" "

"  

" 

A"

'#

,  B

 1

&

'

# #*

' %  #

  ,"

 ," " #  

,"   


C< (6$"%#"#$

:

!"&#% &"

# 1

"7

, "&'"&# 8'" % $%#"#"  "

 

"

," # ' " 

=

"&

,"   
C< (6# '

3,"

," " #",& 2 

6 '3 #

*"

"4 & 11"

'3



("

" 4 &$!!5 &

"$ 2 

6$%# $  1   0

&

'

# #*

' %# "&# 3" 

$ %#"#$

," 
C< (6% &"

11

"1"

," :

&



," 
C<  (6 30 # #

% &"

" , "&'"&# 8'" % $ %#   0 "11 % &"

60 # #

 "

-

,, #

"& # 1 #

 #'

# #

 % # &

,

"1"   0 "11 % &"

;06 # #

"

, "&7"&# 67" % $%#"#" :

!"&#

&"

06 # #

# 12,

&%"

##" 0;

 #

"

 #% &"

 % #"

16'"&# ;'" %

2  '3

!'

4 &
! * $ 2

6$ %#"#$

," 
C< (6# ',

"1" %#"1

,"& # '  * 3  # " C<  ,% 11"

2 
C< 6

2 ' %

" #

" 1" "

3 !% " ," 

$ 3 %#"#  "  C<     /#  , "     1      1

 " 

 '

#  #  *

 ' %  #

-

"

1

," ,

'3

" $ 3 1%#"#" C< (;

"

5 6

"

$"

'

  E6 )

$ 

= .  

  
  $ 

*> $

 $




 


  ? 
= 32. 3*> )$  $

    $? 
= 3*.

    $ 

= .+
4   
$>5.2  $? 

= ....>5"

..##.5.

   
  

 
 
   
 )
      
 ) 

 
 

        
   
   
 $   
 (

:1



3 1

," ' %

" $%#"#" C< (;

3 # % 

# , "& '"&# $6'" % # " #

5 ;

6# ' 

:

!"&# 1""3$"1 3$%

',

&

1 #

6  '

"&  #

 5 6   "

 #  '  "

  " 

,"  



 #

5 
  #


%  ' #

'3 # :

!"&#

A 3" # 1 #

/# " 

'

"


C< (;

*

,"  
C<   (6$  #  "

   %  &"

  # 1  #

   #  "

:

!"&#% &"

;'" % 

," ' %#

," % $

," %

"1" 2 $ 3 1%#"#" C<  

$"  , "&'"&# 6'" %   0 "11 % #

' % 1;06 # #

:

!"&#

#

' 

, ""&06 # #

# 12, & %"

##"  %0;

 #

"

 3  #

" 
C<  $ 
C<  %

11"

2 
C< 6/#

  



("

" 4 &$







 E3> )
  $
  




$      
 
  

<

$$ 
 2@* 
  



 
 .>. >*  
    2@* 
 $ 

$

  4

 
 ?


 )  

 
      



  
     


   
  $    $ 

 

 $  1   ?

    


    $ 
 

$ 
$


 .@2
  $ 

$  
$


.@2

   4


?


 
$+
4 $ 



 
$ 

$$  )
$
 
$  $

 
 & 
   $ 
$ 

$$

$ 

   $ 
%6

<3%6

!A

 $  

   $ 

$$ 

$$
 
$2@*




+
4 $ 

 
$.@* 
 

$ 4


?


   ( 3.

    

  2* .3 
 ? 
= 2*.3*832. 328 
, 

 %6

<.$
 
.788587

 
 ? 
= 2*.

        $  4

 
 ?


 
   

 
 ? 
= 3*B     $ ?



 
 ? 
= 32. 327    $+
4  
  
%6

!A %6

 <3  +
  4   $ 

        

 
 ? 
= 32. 3*> 
 *> 



$

$  

  $? 

= 3*.     ? 
 = 3*>   
     

$$  ?


 $
 

1 ?

$ 



$
 


$
 +
4  $ 

 $
 



$$    $




   


  
$

4
  +
  4   $ 

  

  $
   

$$$
 

 


  $1 ?

 


  
$ 1

  $

  
$  


$ 
$       

  
  

6

<

$ 
 
  

/
 

 
  )
 !

 

 
  $     1 
1 ( 6 /#"  2 
C<   6  #

"  1" "

3  ' % 

"  &

2 % " ," 

C< '3 #" *

'

# #*

' %" 

"

"&

# " 
C< $ 6

"&# 3 

 "&#

 #$1" "& ,   $ ,"

" ,"    "&,"    "

 $"1 3$

" 



"&3 
@@5(CFF=B  4G(FC <

Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No