High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/156/2015dismissed

Sikh Educational Council Guru Gobind Singh Khalsa & ORS. v. Sant Sadhu Singh Chela Sant Hari Singh And ORS.

2015-05-29Mr. Justice Krishna Murari17 pages

!" #$% $ $%& #$%' ( ) *+, -. / .

/" .0. 1 - * 2, 3,/ //2" ,/4.0" ,0.2, 50+,60* 2,0,4.0 -,0 7 0 8 * *-,.* 2,,/* 0* 2, -,0 7 4 $%9 #$%' ( )

50+,60* 2, -,0 7 0 8 *+,-. /.

/.0.1 -* 2,3,///2 ,/4.0 ,0 7 4

* * <<

0 <

03*-6/"-= 0,4 0 1,

0*.> ,5 "*0-=6,

0>3,0"-= <<

,0-06//-46=/ = 10 2 $%& - $%9 #$% ,= 2 0 . , > 0-0 -- &" #$?-> 2644/0 2.6400-04- 6 -0 . 6,/ -- 2 44/ .

-0 0-0 @! ./ $ - 44/ =/*. && #$@-- 10$9" #$@ 6->- =>10A" #$@ - ,044/ =/*. !@ #$@-- 10 A" #$@6//6- >10$$" #$@ 20 2 0> 5.

*+,-. /.

/.0.1 -* 2, 3,///2" ,/4.0,0.2, 004 -0* 2, 0-0 440 , 0=0 6,, , .15 >01,,."1000 1,,..0B.0- 1>- =/*. && #$@<*+,-. /.

/.0. 1 - * 2, 3,/ //2 ,/4.0 ,0.2, 50 +,60* 2, -,08* *-,.* 2,,/* 0* 2, -.0,0",4/ ,=.2,-/0 ,,, 4.1/ --*4>10$@" #$@4.1/,-1- $*-,. * 2, -- 2,-.0* 2, , 6440-/0 - / 2> >> *+, -. / .

/ //2-,=1 ,/- 10$@" #$@ -.1B. 40- 2 60 .// - =- - B. / 0/ 0 40> 5.

00 2 , - < 04 0 ,0 040 = 0

4/0> 00 2 ,> 2> C.

24/ $1 -.//->>1000> 00 2 ,> 2> .

4/ $ - -./ /- >>10 4/ ! 0> ,/- 2 / 10 , D40 , 0> , -./ /-

2> ",1 .2, =/ *. !@ #$@ /- *+, -. .

/ .0.1 -* 2,3,///2 ,/4.0,0.2, 0/*00

04 -0* 2, - ,08 50+,60* 2, -,0, 4/ ,= .2, -/0 , , , >> /- 10 &" #$@ *+, -. / .

/ *,0 .0.1 -* 2,3,///2 ,/4.0"> 2,0, //2 - *,2 * 2," 0 > /.00 44 -

0 4/,-//260+ 2 0 4/"440=- 1, 51

=0 -,- $A,= 02,"/0 0 00 ,> 2> * *-,.* 2,<4/ , .

/ *,0 .0. 1 - * 2, 3,/ //2"

,/4.0 -,4 -0* 2,,1 60+ 2 0/*00 4/ $ =-0-0--=>10A" #$@" 44/ 0 0> 5.

/- 1 4/ 6 ->- ,/- 2 , , / ,- 1 00- . 1 , /0- D

2>> -/ 40-.0,= 21 =0- 6,,

,4/ ,- 404-",4/ ,-.440-,>0/ *. !@ #$@"/-1,>-. /.

/ ,/- 2,, 2>>/- 10&" #$@, .

/6> 2,0,//2",44/ 0 0> 5.

6 //6- - +,60 * 2, - ,0 - 60 00 -0> 00 2 ,> 2> *,0.0.1 -* 2, 3,///2" ,/4.0640>10=-,,- < 04 ,= / - 0 00 , >>*,0.0.1 -* 2,3,///2" ,/4.0 -, 6000 -0> 00 2 ,60+ 24 -0* 2, 0/ *00=-0-0-->10$$" #$@ ,4/ =/*. && #$@ -- $ *. !@ #$@220=-1>4.2 -0-0--=>10A" #$@ - >10 $$" #$@" 04=/ /- 44/ 10 , /60 44// .0 6,, 60 + .4 >./ ./ 1 , -- / 0.-2",04.0->-1,,44/=-0-0--

&" #$? * , 0> 5.

0-0,1 20 - =.0 , .

/ ,0.2, 4 -0 * 2," 0/ *00" =- 0-0 -- >10 $$" #$@ =/ *. !@" //6 2 , 44/ .

-0 0-0@! ./$ - -,44/ .

-0 0-0@! ./$ , *+, -. / .

/ ,0.2, 50

+,60* 2,",1 ->-=-0-0--=>10A" #$@ 1, , 44/ ,= 1 --- 1 , /60 44//.01 0-0-> 21,,44/220=-40 50+,60 * 2, - ,0 /> 2 ,>/= 1 , , .

/ ,=/-6400= 4 > -,0 1=,, =/ = ,=1 + .42,0

0, = ",0>=/*. !@ #$@ $%9 #$@01 2+ -0 0 6,,, 44/ *+, -. / .

/ ,0.2, 0/ *00 4 -0* 2,,1 //6-1,0/.0 -,/6044// .0 50+,60* 2, -,0,=4000- 0= 4 $%9 #$% .

-0 0/ 9 , . -,// 2 2,0-0-->10$$" #$@'

<$#) 4-1--/=/.-2'* 0= )"0,, +0 -0-0--

&" #$?'

D.0 <$$)4-1-- /0.-2//6 , 44/ .

-0 0-0 @! ./ $ - 20 2 0> 5.

=.0 4/ < 04 " 00 2 , - < 4 0 0> 00 2 , 60+ 2 , 4/ -. .

/" >

0 00/= 0,- ,40 0, ,4/ E04 $",*+,-. /.

/.0.1 * 2, 3,/ //2" ,/4.0 ,0.2, 0/ *00 00

4 -0* 2,"0,0F,.

/:",-/-.0-/0 , , , 2 >> /- 10 &" #$@ , .

/.//> 2,0,.

/ -*,2* 2," 0 > /.00 44 - 0 4/ - //2 60+ 2 0 4/440=-1 51

=0 -, ,- <4 0,= 2 / - 0 00 ,

2> , . 1 * *-,. * 2," 4/ < 04 .

/ 6// 60+ 2 *,4 -0 * 2, 0/*004/ <04 $ -,60+ 2 00 2 * 2, 0 4/ , //2" >

0 , 4/ < 04 / .2, 40> 5.

00 2 , - < 4 0 00 , 60+ 2 4/ < 04 $" >

0 , 4/ < 04 0/- .4 , / >>10 /- .

44- / ,/- 10 &" #$@ - , 004 , 6//-1-6,, 200, 51

=0 -,/,/-1- , 200 0> *,4/ <04 /0/-.4 ,/0020- 2, -> ,/00,0.0 -- 10$?" #$@ ,0 #$@<$?1/0 .

-0 0 0-01/,,,4/ ,-1 40 2,.

/,00-,=1 0/- .4 , 004 6, , 00" -. 40> " 520, 1 , 6/ /- 1- , 4/ <04 6 / 10.2,, ,0/.01-440 2,.01.,

02 G , .

, //2 1 4/ 2 00- , 4,204, 1/, , , 4/ < 04 ,= 2 40> 0 2 ,0 =.0 /> 5.

, 4/- 2" 00 6>-4.1/0./0 , 6440 *4>10$?" #$@ - *4>10 A" #$@ 6,, 5 * 2, ;//" - < 4 0 ,--/0-40/ 40/> 2,,--

,= .,0..,/ 6 00,40= , . ,//2,06 0 0,- < 4 0 0 2 40 / 10 , D40 .0 40-,40=. 2>>,06 0 0, - <4 00// 2,>02 > 210,D40 ,40-, 2>>H,/,40/ ,- 1 - 1 , 4/ < 04 : .

/" , - < 4 0 ,- 0 =- 404 , - 40 , - <4 0,=>- 0>+40///>>, /0- D 2 >> 6, 1/B. >= , 6 >> ,- 1 .- 6,, , >>10 60 /- .

44- 10 &" #$@ , - <4 0 ,- . >H,..,0,//->02 > 2 -2.- 6 > 020- , / 40 6,0 , / 40 ,- /0-1 -1,4/ <04 6//2-2 , - < 4 0 , , >- >4 00 , > 2> , 4/ < 04 6 />- , ,

- <4 0,- ,0 0/=0, 2>>

0,- , 2-6,,0.

2,0,//2 ,- <4 0 ,060 > 6// 04/,44/ 0 0> 5.

,-+ -, ./ ?" #$@"0B.6>=-1 !>>10,. / -.1>- , // .02 > 21., 4- ,>,- <4 0.1>-0> -0,4/ ,0.2, 5 * 2," /0+ *,0 .0. 1 - * 2, 3,/ //2"

,/4.0,//- .02 > 2 *4>10@" #$@ -4- 0/. ,.

/ 6>>> D "02,, > 262= 5* 2,;//,- <4 0- - ,D 0/. 020- 2,40/> 2, " 8 0,*0060 =/1/ ,40>6,> ,040 612= ,- <4 0/>-, ,6 -// .02 > 20,6/0,//21., 4.04// 2> 2,- 1 -/-1,>6=0", ,-2= C0> -0,/0+,//2,- < 4 00/-.4 ,-=,/0+,,,-0=-,

-0 , -0 *, *.05 * 2, -,6 6, 6 , >>10,>,- />-,,06 0/. 020- 2 , >>10,4 , 40 6, 1> >>10 , >> -60 /-0= 2 0/1-4 2, >>" 02,0 00->>10, 2>>

, > .>10,>>10, 2>>60 0B.0-1440=-1, 2>> , D> 21.

.,0/. ,0 , 020- , - < 4 0,- >- > >>10 , . 1. ,0 >>10,4 6 0>- , > 2 , >> , - ,- .-

6 > -- *4>10 &" #$@ 6,, >>10 60 -0- -4 ,0 >>10,4 0 />- , 6 1 40=- 1 =- 6, 60 , >>10 , >> //2-1,- ,0/.0 ,1,40>>0/=/1/ ,00-0>- 4 ,,- <4 0,- =0 1 >->>10 ,>>0.

,0, .

- 2,,4/ <04 ,=240>0 2 ,0 =.0" , - < 4 0 60 00 - 00 , 60+ 2,4/ <.

/ - ,60+ 24 -0* 2, 0/*004/ $//,- , 44//-1,- <4 06->-1 ,/6044//.0=-0-0-- &" #$? 40 > ,0,0=/*. && #$@/- 109" #$@ 0 -,.6/-1 50 +,60* 2,/> 2,>/1 ,.

/00 ,- <04 $%& #$%+ 2-/0 , 00 .>10* $A -$!--*4>10$@" #$@4.1/,-

1- <04 $ - , 64400-/0 2, -/ , 2>>4/ $ --/0 ,/ -- 10$@" #$@6//2/,4/ ,0. - ,044/ .

-0 0-0@! ./$ - ,-/>-,,

6> 6,,,>>1060-0--4,0>>10,4 4.040-,=1 .-1.

/6>/- -,/ >>10 ,00-4.-1, 2>> 0 ,0 6 0/. 020- , - , , > 6 440=-1, 2>>,0/.0=-0-0-- =>10A" #$@00=- /. ,40>+,60* 2, ,- /-, - ,/ , -,0>>10 ,- 1 -./ /- 1 , - < 04 ' $%& #$%),44/ .

-0 0-0@! ./$ - 0-6,* $%$ 60- 2/->- > -,0 1=" 50+,60* 2, -,0 ,=4000-,0= 4 220=-1,->/44/1 ,/6044//.00> 2,0-0--=>10A" #$@ 0-0 -- >10 $$" #$@ *. && - !@ #$@ 04=/ * , = $%9 #$%,1 + .4 > 0= 4 ", ,=1 + 0> , =/ . > -,0 1=

H,, .

/01,,40",=2 ,0.2,, . ./*+,-. /.

/6,,6 020- .

-0 , * 20 2 , 15" , >>10,4 .

/" 460 , .

/" - , ,

0 " - ,0 100" > 2 , >>" 0> " H0+ 2 >>" .

- - >- D4./ >>1040,- ./", 2>>6 /- 10 %" ##A 6,, 6 ,= 2 .0 % 0 // 10 ?" #$@,>>>>100. ,0,//2 >,=1 /-00/. *4>10 !" #$@6, , .0,0>>,- 1 >4/- 0>"/2/ ,->>,1 -0-1,/6044//.0 ,0/.010=-//6 < I@@ H,.2 2 0=0"6,,0//- 0B. ,/- , > 2 -- ?9 #$@ 6 =-0 "6./-1>40 /+ 6,,0 6 /2/ 0 , ,0 >>10 ,/- 40> 2 --/0/ ,.0 , =6 , . , *+, -. / .

/C//2- 40>*/ 2,/- > 2>> D - .0 >4/-".

/-> 2>>-/=- 0 >>10 .1>- ,0 02 0 , 0

=- . .

-0 , 40= , . 1 10 2 2> - > " 0,/ 1,/-,0 , 2 ,/,6, .,6- ,0,>>/- , 0 ##A6-/=- 0>>10600>=- 1 >4 .,0 0 02 -" , , 0.> ./- 0, / 1 ,/- , 1 ,/- 2 0, / 0 , 0/. //2-/ 4- 1 , 40 44// // > 2 > , >>10 6./- / 1 >40 /+ ,0/. 00/. --@! #$@6,,//2-,=1 4- > 26,,640--=0101D* 2,//

0/ ,0 >12. ,6 01D * 2, // ./-40-=0,> 2= ,0 /+- -0,+02.> ->- ,.,0/. 64-1// 2> 2 6,, /02 .>10 44/ 404- ,0 2 .0 - 440 , 4 0/. " , 6./- 1 >40 /+ 6, 6 , - + ,> 20./40./, 4 , 0/. 6,, , 1

D-

D.0 <% ,/2,6,60/=-

,/ 6>>- > D //, 5* 2,;/" *00,//1 /- // , > 2 60+ 2 >>C > 2 >> - 4.0. // , /2/ 40- 2,0/. - .,0G 5 * 2, ;/ -/0 / , > >> , =0 1 , /> , 44// ,=-,0/. 60/=- ,/- / - , / 6

- 1. , 0/. - ,6 .,.,0,= 21 2= 5* 2,;/ @? , >40 -.> 6,,,1 ,=/ 0/-.4 1,44// 0, 2.- , 6440,4,4, .- ,6 > 6440--&! #$@,1 4/- /

D.0 <&6,,020- 2+ ,>>10-4,>>10,4//$$! #$@ -, ,1 2.-.

-0,2 .0 , 40 4/ , 5 * 2, ;/ ,

0 4/,//2 >4/ -.

/, .,0G-2=., ", 6./-,= > 2 , .0 6./- ,= /+ , 4.1/ -./- 0-0,/-/

1 2 />- , 4.1/ -./ - 5 -- A! #$@ 2 ,6 , , 4.1/ , 1 >- .

-0 , 2 .0 5 * 2, ;/ *00*+,-. /.

/*,0.0. 1 - * 2, 3,/ //2" ,/4.0 0./ 40./ , 4.1/ 6./- 2 ,6 , > - ,4.1/ ,,D 2>> >4/ 2 .0=0 10 #$@ .,,> 26//-0-. 2,> !! #$@ .0,00- 2, 2,6 , , 4+ -4/ , =0 /"

> 440 ?! #$@ - %! #$@" 6,-06 2 > &! #$@ -= 2 !! #$@" > 2 ,01 , 1 6 , 4.1/ 5* 2,;/,-/0-/ ,2= -/-4020>>,6,/ , 1 -.- -, /B. 1 60- 6,,0 5 * 2, ;/ 6 .,0G- 4.1/, 4020>>/ /. 6,,=01 ,4601 2=-6, 5* 2,;/-- @! #$@ - .,0G ,> 2 , / -.- * = , / 0 - 1

-.-40,4020>>6./-,= /2/ // @% , 04 ,= / 4/- 00-

.>10 -.> ,6 2 , , ,= 1 >+ 2 02./0 004 6, , .

=0 ,=1 - 20B.>.

=0 400./,/1 10.2,, , .0,//,-.> 0.-C2 -1,

2>>6,,* *-,.* 2,,

= 2/-.> ,1 10.2, 00-1,44// ,6, ,4 > 2 0 / -/ 2 ,= 1 -.- 1 ,> " , .0 , -0-4 ,/0 -0/.0600 ,/- 2,,/->>6, .06 =0" 6 ,= 2 0/ =0 , > 2> , //2 ,40 44// J ,,.01/6 ,1,-.> =/1/ , 00- ,= 00=- 40> /. , , /- >> 6, .0 6 =0 6 ,= 2 0/ =0 ,

2> , //2 - , 4 0< - 60 > 2,0,.

H,, .

/04 0<- ",= 2 ,0.2, , -.> , 40- 2 , > 2 , .

/ //2- ,= 1 = - *4>10 @" #$@ .

-0 ,

,4 01D * 2, // - ! >>10 .

/K 4.1/

--*4>10A" #$@K

D.0 <@--*4>10 $@" #$@ - , ,0 /2 16 , 40 , /> , - < 4 0 6 , ./ ?" #$@ , 0B. 1 ! >>10,.

/62= , // .02 > 1., /- -0,>,//>-,, 0> -0 6 2= , 4/ ,0.2, 5 * 2," /0+ , //2 -,,,-//-,06 > 2 *4>10@" #$@ -4-0/. ,.

/ 6>>> D ", 02,//,> 2>>62= 5* 2,;//, - - < 4 0 / 1 440- , 40 /- ,0 =- H,,0 1 >0 -4 , >>" B.0,.>>10,>>",1 -0- , /2, , . 0./ , *+, -. / .

/ , , .0 1/6 ,=" , 1 , -.> =/1/ , 00-" 00=- 40> /. , 4/ < 04 $ , 2 >> -./ /- 10 &" #$@ -> 2,0,//2 -,,- -

,= 02, 00 , 2>>

,*+,-. /.

/,4 00 1,.0 , D00= /5.0- =0/>-- - 20.

00 , 0-0 4- 1 , .0 1/6 , , 0= 4 0->- 6=0" , 0 5." 0-0- , , 0/ .0 ,// D4-./ -- , 4001/ 6, 40- ! > ,0,040-4,0-010=-, >> ,0,60+ 2,-. / . " 6//14 ,.

=00,,2,0.,0 0= -+ ,+,. - -1"+0=>,- .0,60+ 2,-. / . -0.4-, - ,0-06//405.-,02,,40-.0 2,.0 0/

!" #$% '

*) 5