← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/177/2022dismissed

M/S Basavagro World v. M/S International Tractors Ltd And ANR

2022-02-10Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

 

      

   ! "#$

%&  '()("  * !!( +(, %&!( ! ( #!(-.!" " !/( * 0"!  

   

(!$ %1,0(2  ('3"# !3 (!/0!!( (#. (5"!/(,'/"# (#6   4 ( 6

!& " ! ''(" ' !!/("(" !"



 47,( 6 0 " 82  (" ""!  !(#! ,"'3 / (0,( 9/(82 9/ 9' !/ # 00  " !!' " !/ "#(" !" : ;3!/" " !  / 8"(#!" ! "0! <- 5/!/!( #,(!9!/ 0(" !/(.!/ (. !/ " !   .0,'" ("( (  !/ !( ! ,(/ 8 5 ', ( !& ".!28"!!/!, < 5/9!/.!/ (.!/" !  .0,'"("( ",0!!/"# !/. ,!3 '9/#/!/   =,"'.! " "#( " !" : ; 9 8 (!("&(" ,!. !# 2

( #! (!  " ! &0!!( / " 00" ! 0 !

&(0"! (8#.' ,!/(>"!#5! ( 3(# " 0 (   1 5  ( #!(  ? ( ! 5  1! ! ! 9  00!" !#5!  " !&(0"!    #"( !   (0"! &

 0 !

 / ' '(" ! ,002 !( #!( ! 0!!(&" " !   #("!3 ,(/" 8 5', ( !  ,. < 5/ ,( 0 !

  0( !/ !(.   !/  " 8 5 ', ( !3 (0"! &0 !

,00"!( #!( "0 (!!/( !0!!(&" " !

(. !. ! !. "  ,.  <3:@3:@&A  ", (. 0!!(& " " !!(0"!&0 !

)/0!!(&" " !

"!0 2", .,!30 !

5"!/ "8 5', ( !"!/( !!( " !" ; @ ! !/(,'/ ('!(" #(3 9/#/ 9  ",2 (#"82" " !  ; @!/(""" " ! . 5 20 2.!(! 2(02!!/ "!!( 0"!&0 !

!5,0!/. !!(9!/ ( 5 " 3 ' (( #/"!!( " !" : @3 9/#/  !,( !5 ,0 !/ . !!( 9!/ " " !& (0"!   + (, !!( 9( 9(!! ! " " !   82 !/ 0 !

3 8,! .!   !/ !!( /  8 (#" 8 #5 9!/ (0(! B( ,"!(#C!0 ""!/ !!// (.  " " !  "    !/ 0 (!(   0!!(& " " ! 3  .23 %(    = /  00   '#,9!/ #/!/( ( ,",!29!//"!/ 0 2.! !/(0"!&0 !

 @

0 !#3 !/ " " ! "" ! 0( ( ! #!! # . /2 9( 0(#"" ' !   " ("( " !" @ < "

;

 / ,! ( (#(2   <3:@3:@&A 9!/ !(! 9  "#("  ' ! !/ 0!!(&" " !  (  ,. 

D 3D<3<;&A 9!/ !(! E  F 0( ,. (. !/ " !   ,! ! ( > !3 " =,"'.! " "#( " !" : ; 47,( @6 0 "82 ("""! ,"'4163/ (0,(

 G

!!(&" " !  "  00# ! 47,( G6 ,"( ("(: ,@  (!!' "=,"'.! ""#( " !" : ;3 9/#/ 9  "." 9!/ #! 82  (" ""!   ,"' 41( 63 / (0,( " ("( " !" :G 47,( <6 <

' ''("3 0!!(&" " !  " 00  ' !("(" !":G 47,( <639/#/9 "0" " .0,'"("(" !" 

47,( 682!/ ("""!  !(#! ,"'3 / (0,(3 9/(82 !/,'/ !/   =,"'.! " "#(" !": ;47,( @69(! " "!/0 (!9( "(#!"! 00 (8 ( ("!( ,(! 

38,! #"! 9 .0"!/ !!/0!!(&" " !9,""0! <- 5/ !/!( ,(!9!/!/(.!/ !/0 ' !/.0,'"("(  

    !( !3 0!!(&" " !  9  ' 0!! ,(/8 5', ( !&".!28"!!/!, <- 5/ 9!/.!/ (.!/" ! .0,'"("( ",0!!/"#  . ,!#3!/0(!( D - (" #, ( !/ 0!!( (', !/ ! !/ ,(! /  09(!.0  #"! ((!('!/#  ((/ ('8,!!/ #"!.0"/ !8(  8 "! 9'!/(#(2,! !9,"!8H,! 8 (!/,(!!.0 2#"! ! 3,#/ !/0(!9/(! 8,!2# (!/ !(# 0(!,!9 (

#!",0!/0!!( "!/ .9 "#("    ,(   !/ (0"!&0 !

 " =,"'.! " !" : ;  ,00(!   /( (',.!3 / 0 #" ( #  



         4

6<1,0(.,(!  @

- ("#, (!/0!!( ,(!/( (',!/ !!/,(! # ! 7(# ! 09( ! 0,! !/ 0!!(&" " !   ,#/ !(. . 2/ !/

#! 0(=,"''!/#!((2"!/ ,! "(!, 2"#('!/,! ; - (" #, ( !/ 0!!( ,(!/( (', !/ ! !/  (" ""!  !(#! ,"' /  '(" !/ #! !/ ! !/ . !!( (' ("' (#(2  0"' "=,"# ! " #  2 8 "#"" !( ''  #/ 0 (!2  #/ # ! 0 " !/( # . " 2 5"  !(0(! ! " (# !!/! '9,"89(' ",=,!,0 2 0 (!2 /,3 !/ 0( 2(  ( 9!/"( 9    !/ / 2 #"!  .0",0!/0!!( :  '/ ("!/ ("#, (!/0!!(3'(," !!( (. ",!   

3!/,(! "=,("!/. !!(! ;

!/ (H,!  (" #, ( !/ 0!!(!  8 /. !5 !(,#!H, 0("'  # !( #,(!2H, !!!/ .,! ,'/! ! 8 (#("  !/ ,! 82 !/ 0 !

 / ("( " !"



3(0(",#"/(89$A B                      !"

!

    #

       $   %         

   %

        

%     &  !/ "=,("" ! ;

3 ("#, (!/ 0!!( ,'/! .( !. ! '! !(,#!  !(.   ("( " !"



  /0"#2 !/#,!9 9!/!/59"' 0!!(&" " ! "! (.!/ #!!/ ! !!/!. ' H, /' 0!! 82 !/ 0!!(&" " !  8 ( !/ ,(! 

3 !/ #!,.   0"' ,! ! / (0,( 9  0 "" !/ ! 0!!- ("""! !(#!,"'3/ (0,(/ ('/!28("  !/ .0,'" ("( !/ !  !/ .,!  ", # ' "   !/ (0"!&0 !

,##"!# .3!/ .,!9#.,!  ( < #(( !( # #, !'!(!  ", .,!"  !/ (' ,! !/0(.3!/#"!.0"82!/ ("""!  !(#! ,"' # ! 8  " ! 8 ,(  8 9/ 9' !/ # 00  " 82 !/0!!( "!!' "!/' =,"'.! " "#(" !": ; ,!# 8 ,"9!/!/ 00( #/  (",(!89/ ,!/(!2(",082 ("#, (!/ 0!!("!',/ 8!/ #! !/! !#  @ ." 

         )/!/(0 5'&( "$ & )/!/((0(! 8$ &