High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1478/2014dismissed

Rohtash v. M/S Hindustan Rollings And Wires Ltd

2015-09-17Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih7 pages

!"#"$% &

' (

#( ) +*#,# -.#"$ ,#

$//"$0# $ 1"*#2 /(" )#3$ $ -% 42-522 *#$ % -*6"

7,6 *8 /9 :!

"$* -*"*$ *5"$0( 95$"* :!

( -* <"$ * ,/9 :!

(*#3$ $ === 1( (* *3* *# /!

/ 3 3*# 6 8 > //; # (<, 06$ ?

>* ** (*3* *#*$ ? 5 @ 1( (* ( <, 06$ #(,/ > *3* "$ "0# ? === 22A* /B +" * * >"$0 ## "/ 9

@9 *$ * >8 ":"/ , 0 A5* ":$B9 5$3

6: >8 "$*3/

* *# *

( >$ "#6"## # ;"

( * ;$ $ @ &

C9 ( #"$!>$ "#6"## $

"$6: >8 "$*3/

"#6

(( "/ #,"

*#3!"

"!3* *6 $! 0*6$ #//

5"$!9 "$* ( 33$ > 0*"!,/ ,*"# >8 3* ##"$9 (

D$ #6 / $ $ * / / # ; '

0*"!,/ ,* /3,*3##"$:"// 0( /D"9"# *"!

- # 6,$ A((

"#0 *(B *6 $ 5,*$ * #$ " ( 0;

$ A/##*B ( 0":$ ( *E,"#"

("# !,$#/ "/"$0

##,* $! 0":$ >8 ("# !,$#/

(;,/ >"$ *6 $ ;($("#3*#$! ;,/ >*E,"* 9(;$ ("#:"// 0A( /D"B"#!,$#/ $:* 33*"# ("6

!,* $ $:* :$ !$

* ;"

( * ;

/ "

(* (,0(9 3 "$* *6 "$ *0,/ */8 "$ !$

( ("# !,$#/9;(

/#/8"$ *6

;*3,*3* /8 >"$0 "F "$ (6

* **": *6:"// 0( /D" $@

$ $/8 ($9("#!,$#/ 33*"# ("6

("# #,"

( >$ "#6"## (,#9 ("# !,$#/ 3/ 8 , ,3$ ("6 "$ !//,#"$ ;"

( # #,"

;

( * ;$$@ &

C9;"

(, ("#!$#$ $ *#3$#9

:*6$ # # , "$

"$;* $" ;

(*;

#$ !//,#"$ > ;$ ( !,$#/ ( 3/

$ ;

# "$

( * ;$ ;"

( D$;/ 0 $ !$#$ "$* $ (,#9

"$;

#/"

>/ > "#6"## $ !$#" *

( 6

* "$ "##,

/$*!* 9 *"

/!,* !/"$ (3* 8*6 >8

$ !$!/, (,#%

# !

$ %

' ( )

# %

, - )

*$ %

&* /

- )

/ 23 4

1 6 $

& + $ % 7% %

&* *8

&* 6

&* : % 1

/ !

/ 5

1 6 $ %

;

+ &

" $ %

&* &*

* &*

< ( : ( * / *$ !,$#/ "# 3*,# 3*>D *$ !,$#/ "$* #"63/8 #D# *"

(#,>6"##"$#

;* :

$! > * *"

/ !,*

*<!

!63*($#": !$#" *

"$//;(

(,*0 "#

(3( !38 !* "!

"##, >8 (* 6 $!(

9( /D"9#(;#

"$* ( "$

D$ $ / # #6 / $ 9

(* *9(;

#$ 3(8#"!

//83*#$

5$3

3,*#,

' $ , (,0(

,/ !$#" *

*"$"##,9 6 (!$#" * :";

"$"$ $ "# ;(//8 :" 6*"

$ "# (,# /"

>/ > "#6"## (* #$#

*>"$0*!* (*"$

* $! /89

#,"

3####"$>8;

8 #3!"

"!3* *6 $! 0*6$ #// $

( "##,# ;* 6 $

C9 ( 6

* ;

# /"# * *!* "$0 3/

4# :" $!:$F( ,# ;33* ,$"

"#>, 8 / $ :" $! !,*#9 ( D$;

( D"$ */"

( ( 3* 8 *9 :

/*6 !,* ;

# *E,"* >

(#,"

;

"/ ;"

"$ 33*3*"

!,*

;

# $/8 ;($ ( *#3$ $ 6:

"$*3/

> "*!

"F 33*3*"

!,* ( 6

* ;

# /"# * *3/8 ( # "

*@ &

C9!,$#/ "$*6 #

6$ $ ;"

( *; ( * * *!* "$ ("# *0 * 9* (,#% !

" *

+ . * $ %

* $

; &

C F

!"9 ;

# 0 "#6"## # ;"

( * ;$ $/8 ;($ "$* ;

# !$ *$ ;"

( #"

"$9 ;(* 3,*#,("##,"

9(;

#*E,"*

"F :

/*6 !,* ($/8 / *$

": :"

"$9;

( * ; (

>"$0 #9 ( 3*#,63 "$9

3*6

( *!* 9 "#

(#,"

;

# "$ ;"

( * ;$ ;"

( (!$!,**$! $ !$#$ "$*!0$ * !* ">/ 6

/ ;

# >*,0( $ *!* *>, ( # " 3*#,63 "$ 5 6,!( #9

* *# *

#,"

;

# 6: $

* :* ; 8 *# "#6"## / ( //0

, ;

# 3/ 8 ,3$ "$*>8("#!,$#/*6 "$ ,$#,>#

$ *!* * / !D !0$ :" $! $! /89 3 !$

("#!,$#/$

$ (;

33*"#

(#,"

9($:*"$"

$8 !

"$# ("#!,$#/!63/ ;

#:*6 "$# (!,$#/ :$ ( *,$!"/("##(;#

(:*#"$# , >8

"$* "$ ("#

"$ / !D# !* ">"/"

8 $ "#

*$ /8

/# :$"

9((

D$#6/ $ $/ #

:"// 0 ( /D"A((

"#0 *(B

;,/ $ 6

($:*!

5$3

:*"$ (# ;8 *# 3,*#,("##,"

("$0 ;

# >*,0( $ *!* #(;

( :* #/"!"

#*0 * # (#

,# ("##,"

*6("#!,$#/ (*

$ ( ;

D ( 3#"

"$9 # # , >:9 $ *$!"#;

** 9"$F*!"# *:"#"$ /<,*"# "!

,$ ** "!/

($# , "$ $ "

"$>"$0 :" 6*"

"# !!* "$0/8 "#6"## 53 6>* 9

' < A*,$ //"B , 0