High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1868/2015dismissed

Krishan Kumar v. Ramesh Kumar

2015-05-21Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina10 pages

!""#$%$&'

'( )*

+

,"%"&!'

#$%&'"($ ----

. ) (!

*

!

"*+ , -",

" " .

/! 00 &1("

2$ -

!

($

!(, 3..

45 6 2$$ !

"" -",

" "

! "*+ 0 " '!!

00 '+&1("

2$ !!

0

!

!

", *( "-",

" .

/! 0 " 00 2" "

) $ 2 2

0"0"*

0 " 00 002 0

"! /77. ,

$ !,! 87

3$0",

3) 2 $ " &/

2 /

3$0", 32$*

$ "

5 !

2 /

. 3$0", 32 $$ $

! ) ! 2 "*

) 0"0", -

!

," !+

2 .

79

"!

** , "0!" "$"" :

"! * "

" ;$ $2$ '

2! "' 0 3 " " !

"$0$"

+5$ 5,$ 2 00

$ "'$$*+, 2$$" $

!

< $ 0 " !0+*+ =,!0 =

"! *

+ *$=8 <

$0", 3" "0 "+!"

"!8

$0", 3;

2 $ 0"0" " ($

"! $*0+"$ $ "

0 " -$, 0"0"2$ "* 00 !

",1 " "

0< 8

!(00+ 0 " 00 "

! 1 2 0 " $( 3$ !" "

7<.

;2"

"'

0"0"

< ! "'>3 "

!0+ ""

"! : 0"0" *0

00 , "

!

(

2 0"

/ ?

" 00

, 0 $ 0 ! ",,, $"2 00$$ !

-

!

0 " ($

"!

("

!, "-",

" " .

/ ," !+

"!

0 +2 *+"

, -

"!) !!

0!

, -",

20" 0 "'!!

00 '+& 1("

!, "-",

" "

," "2 ", $"

"*+* * 02& $

!*

*+ 2+ (!

$" * * 02 0 : " ?

" $ 0 !

2 " "

$" * * 02(0*0 0 2 0 !

" . ) 0 " $ 0 !

$ "

" ", $"

"*+* * 02("

!, "-",

0+* " "$- $ * , , 02"$

*0 + 02;

$ * * 02 ( 2,0+ $"

",2 ," 8

2 /

.&2 "$

+ ("

$ !!

/ ",0

"

'@- &'@ "

4 "'@.'

A, ! =0"

"!

2 /

.; $ 0"0"'@ $

3 "

"

"! $"

" 3

, $$ " $!0+2

'"

"0+&$ 5,

:

"!"*

*, $"*+ ! '*( " 0"0"$0

"

"!2

2 /

.&2 "!

!0 &0

"!2<

2$2* : 0+ $

5" "!"

!<.

4!0 =

"! *

+ *$=8<

$0", 3 "* $ $* ,$ 2 $" 3

$!0+$$ "; $ $& 0"0"*, 0 $!

3

, $!0

&1

+ 7/ &777 &77/7 "777

>3'&>3'7& >3'

">3'

& !

$( 0+2$2",!

"

"!

"$$! "

! !

"* "$!

, >3'>3'

* "

=

"! *

+ *$=&*"

0"0"*0( " *0,!(

!

"!

$0

"*+ 1 20 ,00+*"!(

: *+0 ",$, ""$

+ ("

$

$2$ ! $ " 0 "") 0 " 00 " 0+ 0 "!

'@- 20

$ , $$0

"!2

$0

0"0") ! 2 * ",!

0'!

"

0

"!

"! "

0"0" " !! , * "!

"

! ( 0"0"1

* $"

"* *$!$!0 * !( 0"0"$0

"*+ *+!"$,

$" 0*0 & $, " "$

+ ("

$ A

'@ "

4"'@.'

A, 7 A "

"

*+'@- :

"!

&

$*

0"* *",! ! !

) 0 " 00 2,0+ !

!( A $." ;">("

$ '$20 =,

'@- *",! ! !

"

0"

"!

A $.

'$"

"

) $, !( A $ '$& 00 , ""

* "

*+ !

!$

",, 9*+ ! ( $$ 9*+ !+ "*- $ "*+!

2 ( "; $ "&'@- " 00+

$ ,

" $B",2 ," * $"

"

0+ *

! !"0

; $!+

, >3'

+ 777

&

"! $"

"

) 0

"

*+ 0"0"2 ," "*+ 2 3 "*+ $( "

$2 ," $"

"

*( ""$

>3'

&2$2*, $"*+

0"0" *

0 " 00 ; 0, *( "$

"! 0"*

: 0+&

", $"

"*+* * 02

!

"

2 3: 2$*

$

2 "

"

*+ 2 ," (0") 0*

2 0 " $( +

"$$ 3$ !+

$0

"*+ 2

; 0"0"$0

2 .

7) " "

"

2 ," /

0< 8

!(00+

. 00 A&$ "$0

" 3$ !+

8

"2

/

) 0 " !"$ + "$

+

("

$ !

! "0 "+!"

0"0"!<.

$0

"*+ 2

A "

"

*+ 0"* (0" "

&*0 0" 0 " $( + 0"0" $$ 00 , " 3$ !+

$ " 0 "!(

A 2 ," "

$"

" ( !

" , 0"0" < ) 3,"2$ 0"0",

-

"!2 0 + 1$0 2

0+'

! " '$$ 0 3 1 : "

" !

* "

0+!

"$0$"

+5$ 5,$ "

$ "'$$

, 2$$ ) 0"0" !!

"'@ $ " 00+!! "( ! 1"

0+'

0!!

"'@$ 1

!"$ " $! 0 !

, $"

$ :0 $>3'< >3'/<>3'< '/<$0 0+ *0

$ " 0"0"! " '>3 ;

0"0"2

" "

" !

, 2 $$ *+ !

,

$ "'$$5>"$0'$"

+5) $& ,!

$!0 * "

":

"!; $ ( +! $0" 2 !*0

2 ( (0*0 "!0 ) ,220 $"+ 00 , "!

0

" 0"0":

"!

0 "

"2+0 ( 1 ;2 "$+ 1C*0 '!

3"

0( "

;$ & !

" ," 0 *0",2

0"0"6 2$$! !!

00 "

0!! )

2 : 0"0"6

$ 22 "'$$ ",2 ;$ 2 0""

D

!"

# $ ! !

! # % % !! ! !! !% !!! % !

"!!" " #% !" !! !! % !! &'! ' ' ' !% $ $$ !! $$ $ $ $ !" ( (% !! )) ) )% * ' ! +! !

7

'! ! " ! $ !! ! $" ! !! ! ! !" ( !!"

!, !! # ! !! "%"

% ! % !! &% ! "

!! ! - !! %. % % !! $ ! +! " !! "% %"

!" ' ! " % !! & ! ! !! ! !!! !!" #!! !

!

! !! ! " ! " !! !&!! % ! "!! #%!"!!

/ / ) $ ! $ " $ 02$ ! : "

$02 $ A $ 02

00+!!0$*0 $ " ; 0, *( "$ ", $"

"*+* * 02 0"0" * "

0+ :

"!

0,2

"'$$ 0"* $ $"

! 0"

$$",0+ ;( 2 *( "$& (!

," 0 + 0"*

0 A&"

" """! " $$",0+ A$ (!

*

"! " $ 00 !!0$& +&0" $00+"! (,*

"

" $

,$/ )*

" ! EF 5

@ -",

0"* ! " %, EF 5