← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1239/2019allowed

M/S Atul Coal Traders Through Its Proprietor v. Union Of India And Others

2019-11-04Mr Justice Jaswant Singh,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra3 pages

 

        

 !""#$%$&'( )   

           '(  *+

 ,,,  *+

 ,++  

    $%&'()(! &*(+,!&'(+-!&&'')%*',-

$%&(.!).,!+(&(!,'(,.!,*(.&!,)*&,%*',( / 0   2/

 

$%,'3)!,,-3!,*&(!,*((!,.(+%*',(

$%(+3!&*+.!.(-)!+''-!-)'+!)+-(!)3-*!.&()%*',(

$%.&(3!.3'&!3'+'!,'*.*!((,-!,)+*(%*',( / 4 1  !/ "

 21    !"

   *(.&+ *',-

,3+3+!,3'*!+(--!+((.!3+.*!33(-!-,**!-,)*! -,-3!*.*-& *3.** *',( /4 !"

 /   $%)-)*!.(33!.(-&!+,*)%*',(  6    $%,(3+%*',( /7

8  "!"

   -&., 

  /   0  

,(.,+!*3-(,!,.*+(!*-)'-!*-)+(!*33)'!*3(,3! *3--)!*3('&!*3--.!*3(,(!*-'-.!*3(+'!*-,+.!*3).'! *3)*+!)+)-!(,3&!*,3.,!*,('*,*&+.  "/  

   9:

9 )..3 *',(:

   4"/

; 56 /

 9:

 ..3)!+*',!-(++!,((+.!+&),!+.('  7

!"

 0   $%,'(-3!(+*3!,'3&.%*',( / !"

  $%,.*-+!,..3-!,.++.%*',( ;/   $%*(.&+%*',-!,3'*%*',( 

;/ !"

 5 6 0    $%-.()%*',(  6 7   $%,+*'+%*',(  6/ 2!"

   *)-'(*.&'& <=0    )..3 / 6/6 !"

; 41 4 1!"

 4/ !"

 

*-*'&       

 9:

&(3,))',) 6 7 

!"

 

((-, 4 1/< !"

  4 >  

*-)'- *',- 

 /

;

!<1"

0 ! ?

1    6 40 !  "

0 !4 2 /  20  !/ / 

 ; / 4"

7

  5 , & $%&*(+,!&&'')%*',-!

$%.3'&!,.++.!+*',!+&),!3'+'!+.('!+(&(!,*(.&%*',(!

$%+''-!)),-!,+*'+!).))!.&(3!.&()!)3-*!)+-(%*',(

$%,'*.*!&*+.!-.()!,'(,.!-)'+!&**&,!(&**%*',(

$%,)+*(!,.*-+!,..3-!,3+*,!,3+((!,((+.!*,'&-! *3.,,!*.*-&!.)-)!*'+,.%*',(-

    , & ,3+3+ *',(   , ) *,3.,*,('* *',(!

  , & *,((*!*))-& *)).,

*',(-   , & *(-.* /  !/ / 

  21 5



!"

  $%(33! .(-&!&(3,!)',)!)+)-!)-)*!..3)!-&.,!+,*)!+(--!+((.! 3+.*!33(-!-,**!-,)*!-,-3!(,3&!-(++!,'3&.!,'(,.! ,'(-3!,*&+.!,*(.&!(+*3!((,-!,.*+(!,+',3!,(.,+! *3--.!*-'-.!*-)+(!*3('&!*3(,(!)..3!*,3.,!*,('*! *)-'(!*3)*+!*3).'!*3(,3!*3(+'!*3--)!*-,+.!*33)'! *3-(,!*.&'&*-*'&  !"

 0  5 * & $%&'(+- &'()(%*',-

4

!"

 

&(.!).,!)),-!..3)!+*',!+&),

+.(' @@@ ,,.    !  "    )  /  0"1!"#2&34$"% 5!+!0 &$&&0$  1%

,,   ++   5"67"1 ).   

  ! "#$ !