High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/165/2006dismissed

(O&M)Som Nath v. Pb.Wakf Board And ORS.

2019-09-11Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

#"$ !$%& '( )" " *

! "

%&"

& $'(( )

% '

& ++++ )"+, " *+ + $ &" -"&$+ '( ./ 0$ 1 !$%& '( )"/ .

&+ / (1 1" *"

%$ 2"

* $ *"*", + + +, " 3/ 2 ++ +" 4 35 . " / *+ +

% ( $ *"*", + " &$ +" 6 + +" * " 6 5 75 6" " "/ " "" * *+ 8+1 11"2/ *+ &"$1 $ 9$ : , & " $ 6 "+" *1

&" 2+ ;$1 ;" 2 &$ "" 21 & , &, / 6 """ -"&$+ $" '( . 0$ *" "" +" " ;$1/ 0$

/ *$ **" + % 6" / 1 $ :" +/ $ 6 &+/ 26 "2 $"

'( . &, *+ $* 6"1 "* &" +1 $< *+ 2 , $ &"1 $/ *+ +( +$ $ $ $ *"*", *"+, * 4 $" +, " =3 6 5

/ *+ * $ *"*", - 6"1 *+ % & *,1 " + "1$+"+, " $ 6"1 6 + * " 6 5 75/ 6 ++1 6 " " &, *+ + % ), 21 **+/ 4 $ > +

1+ 1 + *+ *", ? + + 6" / (1 2"$ +1+ *+/ " " 1 * $ *"*", 6 ++ &, !$%& '( )"< , &1 6

6" "

"+ / 2 ++ "" =4

@ &% "@ 6 $ 2$" &, / ++61 "

, "$ 1"$ +" $ *"*", " "$1

"+ "< 6 *" *+ / +,/

!"( / &"2 * $$"* $ *"*",/ 4 + 2+ $ +1 6 2 **+ $"

"" 4 $+ ! "

1" " %$< **+ " 1" "

%$ 6 * &, "+ $" 47

7 $++,/ *" *+ 6" "" " ""1 $ *"*", $ *+ + % ( $ *"*", + ," / 2 ++ "" 5 " , 9$ 6 ++

*, + A 3 *"

."1 $ / *+ 2 , "1 " " 6 $ *"*", $ *", " + $ !+ + "*+ 8" *+1 *"/ ++61 $ 6" " ' " *+ * $ *"*",B

' " *+ + "+ *" %$ *",B !!

4 ' " $ &+ *" "

! 5 ' " "9$" $"

'( . 6 "2 $* B ! ' " *+ +$ + *" $B ! ' " *+ $ + *" $B ! = +

- !" 6" " 9$ **"$ + 2 $**" " "*2 + ." "1 "1$ / -"&$+ $ / 4 1 *+ 2$" :$ 5 6" + 1 *+ 2$" :$ 6 1 *+ 2$" 9$+,/ $ *+ 6 6 &, -"&$+ / 2 %$1 " 8+1 11"2/ *+ **" $"/ &, 6, +1 *" "2 */ 6 6 12 "*3/ 6 2 **" "$1 $+ : 2 " +" $+ " *" & 11 "$1 "" - -"&$+ &, *"*" **"+ 2 "" "*" +6 "$" 1 *" ++ ""

7 CD!/ $ *"*", &"1 ( " ):::7/

$"1 9 ,"/ 6 ++ *+ + % +, " 3

1 " " *" *+ + % * + $ " 5 =/ 6 6 $ 3/ 2 "* CD!= .*" " / *+ + % * 3 + $ 4 = . " / + $ & * &, ++ 44 =4 "6" . $ / " * & $$ "E ++1+/ 2/

$ " ( "1$ *+ * $ *"*", 0" -"&$+ $" " &"2 C !$%& F"& " . **+, '( *"*", " "/ * *+ 2" *"*", 2" &, ++ "" CD! & $$ "E " " D*",

" + " ** *,1 + $ *"*", " 44 =4 $ +( ++1+ $* & + + " 1" *"

%$ 1 "$ 6" - -"&$+ $" " &"2 " *"*", 6 *+ CD! D* " 2" ++ "" CD! 6 ++ *+ &, 6, , ++ "" +( CD!/ $1 *+ + % $ *,1 " *"*",/ 2 " "* . $ / " ," 7475/ *+ + % *, " " " ++1+, $* &, 6 " +$" *+ CD! 2" &2 " ++ 2 ++ "" CD! - ""/ $ *, " &, *+ $ *"*", 2" &2 *"*", 2" ++ "" CD!/ * & $$ "E " 7475 $ $* & + + " 1" *"

%$ 1 "$ 6"

" ," 7475/ *+ "1 " * *$ *"*",/ 6 6 2 ++

&, - -"&$+ $ *+

"1 $ " 1" *"

%$ $" " & & $*" $ *"*", +6$+ " ' + +1 6 $ 5/ -"&$+ &"2 *+ "2 $", $" '( . $* &" +1 $/ $ 6 &+ *+ 6 2 +&+ & "% &, 2+ $" *" *+ +1 6 $ / -"&$+ &"2 *+ +$ + *" $ + *"2 $ "E +6$+ * 2" $ *"*", 8" +"

"/ $ " &"1 $ $+ " *" """ %$1 +

#$%&'

()*' #) +,-./012304 $**" %$" -"&$+ $ $" '( ./

", $ 6 " +, 2+ $" $+ %$ *$ - %$1 +* **++

$ / "" * &, 2+ ;$1 ;" 2 (1 "" " "" $ -"&$+ $" '( ./

"" * &, " ;$1/ 0$ "1" 6" ++1 &, *+ ? &$ &, %$1 " * &, -"&$+ &% 2 & ( &" -"&$+ 6 "1" %$" " ) *" + 2 $+ " *" " "1$ &" -"&$+

. - %$1 * &, -"&$+ 6++ "/ & $* *"*" **"+ 2 "" "*" +6 - " ++1+, " "

, 6 *$1 %$1 "/ 6 1 2 ++ " "" &, D"1 "2+ %$" . $ / 1 " "2 */ //

" (1