← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/19/2016dismissed

Kamal Gupta And ORS. v. Ranmeet Batra

2017-05-16Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi13 pages

    ! "

  #   

$!%& #  '()(* +

,  

   

 -).)     



 

 

   

 -).) 

 

 %* / 0%  % 1  % 02

)* 



    

  !  



  

"# $% &'$( 



"# &' &'$( % 1  % 023   $ 4& )   *         

   

  +   "   

# $%

&' &'$(+  



*

     +

  

  

       , *

  !     +     "# $%

&'$( -         

%$'&'$.    / +!   * *

   &(%&'$0 

"

 1  *   



"

 +!*!  *   

  

     #  

* ,          

   *   1    

,+,5

$  6)( ( )&'(

789

$#4((:.&3 4 88 ;;

 -)  ;

 2.) <    

 2   =  $2  >  (: .&3   8.:

8  -)  

3  '(    

+ $%  )(:.&3 $ &+ =5

$  $&$ (:&-) %) 8  2 '    )&3  '(    + 

 $#4(  (: .&3     $ #&  +?,   

 @   8.:

8  6) 

<'( .

;3

+$%  )(:.&3

$ &  +=5

+  $%5   7      (    (  6)   )

(> $ 6&0&'( ,689

$#4((:.&3  $ &

B5

$ A 2)4 6) ' ;

# ()C )!

)&'(=

$#4((:.&3 .( 4 (: 6)

.(4  2.8 3  '(    =,

=  $#4(  (:  .&3  ))4   7A')06#6 > )%() 3

+$&  8

= ?B 3 :7 46 ;

( $# &3

$%  )&= 3

+ 

+3 '(

+ 

  $ &==5

B$-(A ;

.4 (6) (> !)&3'(+ 

$#4((:.&3     

  !

  

  /  



 

  1 

! *

*     +

,  +         *!1  

  +   



 

23$ 34 

   

* 

    

 *

5 

!   

  

    



     !1 

       6         

 

  +!

+   +

 *

  +  !

  !  

     

3  

,!     1   %$'&'$.7

23(8 +!

   / +! * +

  

  

 

  

"  

# $% &'$(





"  

# &' &'$(

   1 +

    

  +   ) !  

       

      *

   *    /  ! *    3

) !!  +

  

  



?

,      

 + 

    



 

  

 



"

 

 



    *    

+

  

  

+

*

  !  )  1     /   +   ) !



 

+ 

   )*       $'

   ! 

  

 *        

      

 +!  

*   

 

 



9 :$$ "

"   1 



    *

  +  *

   !  

 )       *  

  +

    

1       &(%&'$07

23 .8     *   + * 

   /      +       1    

%$'&'$.7

23(8,  *  

  



  &&: "

   

;

 

 

 

  + 

 

 



23$ 3(   1       /  *       !         

1  +

    /   !  

!1   )   < 

+ 7

23$8 

+     

 * 

    !+!



 

$('""             5   

  

       3

  

    



      *   *+ 

    !    

 





  !    

3     

    

 +    

!+  



   ; *  +  !     3



+

 2 



  

 

 

3  

 + * 

+ + 



 !+

!,  "

  

  

  1     ! 



 

+ !  

     

 

   ! 

5  ;

   

   2  **  

1 

    / *** 1  

  1 

  + 



 

+ * 1 



   +



         

+ 

 



"

 

  *   !     







*       !  +  +!

 

 



  



 

 "  

   *  *  +       

  +

      1 

       !



    

5   

 +  

2 1  



9 :$$""      *  2

   *  

5    ;   



   5 

  

 +         

    

 

  

9 :$$""-  

!*

       



  !

 

  

78 7 8 $$""  

 +1 

2 

   ; 5!  

       

   *     

+ 1      -      



9 :$$""

     =  

 

 *      +*

!      ) 

 !

 +  !  



     *

;  +   *  +

 

    

  +

 7

230  +

  8    *  

   

    

23$ 34 *  !   

*

 1 

  



   /   

 *  *    

, +



 1  + 

 

    1  

 

  

    +



 

 +   *

*  , *

 

  1 

 +

+ !    

 + !    +

  ;     

*       +2

 

    + !  !

  1  *       

  

 

   

  *         +!    ,

>+    "

  

8 ).  $# &-)   8(4 . )3

$=& +==3( ( -) 8(0 4% ' )3

?

$=& ,+3  ()) -)%44(;

)3

$&  ,+

   ) -  )(0 43

B$ & +== ?  *

  

  +  !

+  

 +! ,

@+"

  $$

$&

  1   6@78      * 

 6

@78



;!@78 + !  *    

A3 

     



 

 

 

     

               



 

 

               



 ! 

 " 

    # 



!$   



 

 



  

      



    

               



       %     

  &      

     

 ' ( )

 



&  











 



 

!   &     

'(

)  

 

       

'

(

) "    

   

  

   

   *  



    

    

  

     

" #  

         

    

 

+     ,            

        (-.  -     /    -

- 0 

/( 123-,245)

6



/ 7

7

/(112(2)-,,44)

    

  8

  

 # !

 "        

9

  :

; (1<) ,41=(>;)&

 > ;,    "   

  



 

     & 

 

8  

   

 8      

+

 



 







 8    



  

   

   ,

       

  

     

  

   

&   

      9

   ; 

    &   











  

     &



    #       9

 ;

  



"

 

  

    



         9

 ;

    "  



   

-- /  ?0

 &(<<2)-,,5=  3&

   =,      

  

  

        

          



   

 

    





 

/ , 

            

$      

   

   

8#  

 8





    !  ,     #

  &    

          &             "     

         

8

    

  ! 

    &     

 " #

  '

   

   

;  @

7 ,;?> (1= ,5A5

 52)&;0

7 .(  4,% 7) B# 

& &   



     * &!  



9

 



 

 



   #         

          

 

    

 "B 2 >/

 7C

,(15<()

14); 

(   15%)&B; 

$                           

      +   +







B0 &!

- >;? -

 (D)(15)*;<2 .(

54%)B/  & &  

 "  ;!   



 B 

& 

 >

    E   

 E (15()*;=A5);0 

.(  52 ) B#   





  "   

  

 &

    "



 



 







B 5, 

 8

&  

  

               

  

 



7   



 



      =# 

;7



   



          



.

(  F  ,#& 12-,23<



    



   

  





   

  

  





            & 

 

  

&     

( 

,G)

     

 

      

#  & 

 



  & 





 

   B

 B9         

"

&  

   

  

  







  0        

    "

       

      -6



?-

 ;

0

&(<<4)A-,,5=&

3A%34&

=%3B ; 

  

+     



    *+ +! !* 

*    

+ +     

+   

+    ?

2   * 1  

    *     

?

  *   !   *

+    1 

 ?

  

+     +





   " 

+    ;   *

 !   

 

 

   * 

+ ;

    

 

  +!

 

+

*

+        

   

 +!

+ 

+!



*

+ ;

 *   

   !  ! 1    

 ) *   +   "

   

   * 1 ,

@+"

 *

   ,  "

         "

    

         

 !

 "   #$  !

%& '( ) * ' + * , - '    .""

 ,    // 

 0  +)  1 " +)    2$ 3 , 33 -" //0 &  0/ 4  5(    1.    //0 

  (

& +*6  -.   7

.  /0

  (

&  8  "

 + 

. '   9:; 65:

1<    /// -,

2 %

+"  6)   .  '  -   +

   :  // !

  (

 ;  5!  

     

  *      1 



!    +2

 

 

     



+ 

  

-  +1  9 :$$""      

+*  ;     

  

   

 )    2  *

9 :

$$""

   

  !   +

        +  2    

?

     

+ 1

 

  

  



9 :$$ ""  +

3     *  

 

      

     

 *    * 

+  1 + *  





1  "

 

  

 

  

=   

  

+ 1    

 )    /   !      *  +

    *     1 +

+







  + 



* #

 * "

    

   

+

 * 

 

"

 

  *  +

 

  

*

!



+   

*

  !+     #    +      !

* +

3 +  

 +

 

  

 



* *

   

 

  !

 

   +

, $ % 1  % 02& 8>) # ?

 B

CB#

?

  + CB#