← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/1920/2024dismissed

Rakesh Kumar Sharma v. State Of Punjab

2024-03-04Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat22 pages

  

   !"!#!$!! !!# !  %&



#''

 ( ( 

  





  

  

  %&   



#''

 ( ( 

 



  

 



  ! )"*( +(+(+,!-!  

      !"#$%$%$& 

'  (      !&)%$!$%$& 

*  

'

  

+     , (+(+,!-! . (% / 0& "

 -    ,,      .  ,    

!"#$%$%$&,1 23,45 /+3 /5 6(+ 

47 89 !&)%$$%$&,1+4/'/+':36( + 

47 8  3/9. . /  

  /   /,  01 + 23"4 ""

$%$)  &%# &45 &42 &5" "$%!61,  "24%  ,  6 ( , $ -01 .      ,      /    (          ,   67       !

     

        

 ! " 

#$  %

 #$  &   ' ( ) * +

,(  

-  . !' , $ /##* ,( ,# 

 

 ) - 0- #(

* (.1   2*

* /## * ( ,#

 

#31    !  " 0 

#0' 0 $  &  $& . &4&,0 0



#+%

0

  #

' 5 !, 5  &) *( , *    -

* 

#   ##*  #0

0- (

* ,(  - , *

 #4*

#

46 7

-  . !,5 (    

- 

. !  '  $   /##*  (   #  &   )

 0

0- #(

* ,(  0% *6 

 

#31     !

-

 .

*/##* . - 85  &9#

  # 

 !*     !-

4 !

 0 ,1 :  (    - 

. !  ',  (     

  !

    

*  

  

. ! #1 ,( ) *5 *

 *

# !  *  ##*  . -    0  !   " 0 

#0' 0   #  &    $  &  .  &4  &   **  00 0



#0+%

0



 #

' 5 !5  & * ( ,4 - 4 

**  # *   #  ! - 4  -  **  4 - 

# 4  4  !,  ;;

-- <  #   '*,    #4* #

46  +5'

 * ##* . - ,+5'

#=     #  +(0  +

4  #

    #   >,?,4 *

#

+5@  >    *  #4*, #

4

# 6 89  )2.15*&     *&  =>)2  ( .

0A  80  0

9  )  (   .  0$ 8 !   "  0 9  

  , ,  !  **         5  +5 '

  * #

 # , ,  )=     

**

   =>     )=    # , 4 * #  

  **   #   

 **     =>  * : & 6=?  )& 

   5* :   

   

   #   

  -    -   * B

4*

* 



, 

 # 







: +5'

# ! 5#*4

# #   *   0 *  

 * #*   



-

# +5'

 

 9      )    )2.15  *  &     *&  =?)  ( .0A 80 0

9) ( .0$8 ! " 0 9

,,** &   +5 '

# ,,  *   



**   =?  )

         #       #   

C0

**  &  =?4

*   : & =?  )& 6    5 :   =?, 

  

  # 

- - 4##<  4

4*

* 



,

 # 







: +5'

# ! 5#* 4

# #   *   0 * 

  * #*   





 - *  # +5'

 



; 89      )     )2.15  *  &

  = *&  ==)  ( .0A 80 0

9) ( .0$8 ! " 0 9

,,** &   =,+5 '

#  ,,  *   

"  -  0

  

#  +  0

      

**   = =  ) 

    4      *   * :     4 





 

 5 # D * #      ,   # ,       #   

C0

** &  = = 4

*   : & >  )& 6

   5 :   >, 

  

  # 

- -   4  ##<   .    ,     - 

  

 





 +5'

**    = #"  -+ 0



4

-   +5 

**

 4*

   )& =  ?  #  - 

  ,,4    89      )     )2.15  *  &    ? *&  =?> )  ( .0A 80 0

9) ( .0$8 ! " 0 9

,,**    ?, +5'

#  ,,4 *  &

0



#0 0

  

C

**

   ?  )  

<     4    * C   :      #

* 4  

  

#   ,  # ,       4  4 4   #   '

C0

** &  =?>  * : & >   5  > 

  

  #

- - 4##< .  ,  



 +5**    ? &

 0

  0   0

     

 4 

 *

4  

 #+5 

 

?   )>#  - 

 

,,4     '6 0 & )52  =)&/)?=)2.15 &/  2)15&/0$ (@+2&5  )  2      (   .  0A 80  0

9  )  (   .  0$  8 !  "  0 9     

    ,,  ! ** $

&  0



)  0

** & 6 4  *

 ,,, 4 * #* 4         .

*  +



 -

#    #  ,

  ** .

*  31&'23   ** 8** &  9

  =, #- # ,,

4 4     )  ?=    

   *

,  

*    =,*

 #    *   **  *  # ** -- < , ,   

  

= 9  )   =   )  & 6    )2.15    &/   2)15&/0$(@+2&5 )2  ( .0A 80 0

9 )  (   .  0$  8 !   "  0 9    

  ,,   !    ** 

 0



#A%

0

**

   ,  4    *

  

,,,* #*    .

* 

 ?



 -

# 

  #   ** 4

*

  - #  ,,44 4  )&  

 =

  #  **      # ** 

 0

  

#  A%

 0

  5 

* #    =

*

 #

#   *

#

     *  ** 

#** -- <  , ,>       89  >   )  &    )2.15    &/  => 2)15&/0$(@+2&5 )2  ( .0A 80 0

9 )  (   .  0$  8 !   "  0 9    

  ,>,  !    ** 

$ % 0



#00

**

   =>  4    *

   ,,,4 * #*   * 

#

 -

#    #    ** 4

*

 / # **   =>  #      **   

$ % 0



#00

, ,>,

>  4 4 4 )

 >  5 

*  > *

 #

#   *

#

     *   **    *  #    **     -- <   ,,?

?      89    =  )  &    )2.15    &/   2)15&/0$(@+2&5 )2  ( .0A 80 0

9 )  (   .  0$  8 !   "  0 9    

  ,>,   !    ** $

! 0



#)  0

**

     4    *

     ,,,    4     * #* 



 -

#    #  4   *

  = ** 4

   3   **       

  ** 

 ! 0



#)  0

- #  ,>,  4 4  )6

  =/

  *

, 

*        =  *  

      *,   *  # **     , ,=          

  '

 3) 89  

 )  &/  )=  )2.15    &/  =   2)15 &/  &

  ?)2  ( .0A 80  0

9  )  (     0$  8 !  "  0 9     

     !  



** #'

 3) **   = 4 -  



  #+  -"  #

 ,,

+  -" C0

** &   ? *44 4 )



 

  

* 

 

, ,

'** &  , ,?,  **   &    =>,  >,  

** &  , , ** &   , , **    ,4  -     5   -

 #* 4    ** 

 =>5   -*

  #

 

 *  -  *

# !

 3) 

  

 &(



* 1 4

 

 +  -" C'

  3)**  = 4*

 



4 *

  9   

 )  &/  )>  )2.15    &/  =   2)15 &/  &

   )  2      (   .

0A  80  0

9  )  (     0$ 8 !   "  0 9  

  ,,  !/ == ,  # ,, 4 *  0!4 " 4#  #. 0

    '

     3)  **     = =,  4*  4  *

  



4       #  ,  . #

 *



  **   8 = =9   4 

   3) **  = 4 -

 

    3)     #0!4 " 4#

#0. 0

,   4! -E 

  31&'2  #   

   3)  **  

 =   '

 0!4  "   -         !  8* -  * 9      

   

  *

# 

  *

     #

4

 3) !

- 



 - * 3   -  # 

*  == ,# 

  .

*+

 ! " 0  -  * # ,,

** &   ?  ,,  ** &   * * - - #  *##< 

  

*  

 * : & ?  4*- ,,4  0!4 " 4  --   - 

,4* 

  - -,4*!  

 3) -*  # 4*4

 0!4 " 4#  #0. 0

 89  ) )&/) )2.15&/  = >  2)15 &/  &

 ?

)2  ( .0A 80  0

9  )  (     0$  8 !  " 0 9 

,?,  ! 0! 0



#$

!0

  1)&  =  3)  **   &   >=



4* * -  ?

   4*4 #  - 

 



, 0! 0



#$

!0

  3)

 * - 

6    #

 **     >=#  

 * 

   3)  4     #

    #  

,?,

 

3) * -  

 3) * -  4*4

  *  ,       

  

   #    .

* 

 *!  # 3),# -

4 -#

4* ,



 4 --   )       # 3) * -

64  *  , *  

*   !

4  

 

 

- *  #   

*    !89 = 

) &/F)2.15&/6 2)15&/6&/)  ( .@)(  

6 ??,?=  !6)

 1 : *  

*   

 = 

,      +5  '

   

  **    ,   % 0

, ?,??,=4  -  ,  ! * -

#4*

4 -   

  %  0

,    * -  4

#    *   4,  

*   

  !





  

31&'289  ?

)&/F)2.15 &/6 2)15&/6&/)2  (  .@)  (        

6    ,?,=  !6)

 1 : *   

* 

=?

,  +5'

  

**     ,  $    0

,    ,?,=  -  ,  ! * - #4*

4 -    

$  0

,

 -  4

#    *    4,      

*       !





       31&'2  1   

, :  

 ## 

   :  *

*  #     *, 

 # 

   ;;

 # 

 ,    

 -

  0 ! " 0  .

*+

  ##*   & 6>  >        

  >     > 00 0

**   

-  #   

*  #  !*   #

   ! *

*  

: ,4*- 

 -  

 *  #  ;;

  *  

 

*   5   !   

!

 #

   

 

    *  *     ( %  

-   0 *   *  >  

-  *   #  !  - - 5  !-*

   -

  #

  - # ,   *  !

4 - -   -

-    

 * *  

  * - * 5

,4  :   # * 

   *

  #   1(  #

 -

 4    !C

 #

 # 

 *     !     #

  

       

 *

 

 4

!1 :  

 #0D!.

,0

+

, +   &   ?=?,     --      &   /##*       !  #

 !

  !  







 #      !,      *

##* #  -  *

*  4

 ##*  B !,@ ##

,) *+

.

( ,)    ) 7  ,    

  !"#$%$%$&   //   ,,/ , 1

  !  ,/  *.

, // 

 1(

  7  ,   ,1(

,,01 . ,/ /! 

    *.   ., / / /   -     1  8  ,    

  &"!

    

,,   

   01      

 / , ,/ %$/ %#

               /         /.,,

/  ,  & 8  ,  , , 

   !&)%$$%$&    ,  /9  / / ,/ 



  !                 .  

     ,,/

:                   /  ,    ; + "4$#"$%$)   .   ,,   ,, 

     

/   &45 &421 .   

: 

 . ."%%< , -  . ,       !   

      ,,/ =  

 ,,/      ,/ 

7   ,   . /    8  ,   ,/ ,  ,  ,>  ,/    /,  ,   ;,     ,          

  

!"#$%$%$& ,   , 

   $4 ,/      ,.!

 1 4

# - 

 - 

- % *   #      *  #  

     * 

 

     

 

; #  -

 * **  

0  0

,     B ,    -  . '4&  #  !, .

*+

#

 * *  # .

*       - -

#  ** ,* 

!,

 4

 *

# *



, - 

,* 



** 

  - #  < * # 

  '4&   -*

 )  # .

*+

*  

<   0 , #

 * # 



   .

*  +

   -

  +

,  #   #  # #  ##  **  # *   

**

4# **     

4

1)  #4* #4*

-  

 - 

5 

1)  <*   * 4*  -

 * C 4

#

 #

- 

#** 1 * ,* -

1) 0$,  -        - 

  0A , -   * **  1# 

** 



   4

4

   <* 

1)4   5 31 

 * -  #  ) * +

#   (    

- 

. !  ',  (   8  #

       -   !95 - 

  -

# -   ! 4

!

 -  # +

   #

#31 & =       - 

 4   -     .

* +

. - .

* # * -   !

< 14

  

  *  =, - 

    * **      0  0

    - . - .

* # * -   ! .

*+

 - *

 5 ) *+

4&  /##* # .

*,  -   . - .

* * *!  *  / * *!

,4#  *       #     *  4    >,,>?  

 # ,4 #   * 

!,   

   >,,>?  .  4  -*

* *!

#*4



 #  , ,>?4#    *5





 #    ,=,  4    *       - 

 *  # * 5 # , 4*

  * *!

   !     -  4# 

* - *  '

**  

 *    '

     3<   ) -   8'3)9,  3<  ) - 8.& *** 4/- 9,

 3  '8 '9,+ 5  '

 3  8+5'

9 *

D * 8+5 '

9  5 # ,       * -    #

   ;;

   #  -- <     ,,  4    (

*  5 #   4 *  

 * *!

*

** 4*   

  4 1) # - 

* ** 4   ,    

*   

  *    . !  ' 

,

4 #3),2 * 3), * '

, .

!,**  *0 ,4  *    #

= -   !  ;;

 

%  

 ,,  

/ 

- 5

,  -   -

4      (

*  #  

  

 

* 

# 

 #  !G ;,      ,     

 

  !&)%$!$%$& ,   ,/ ,  ,  ,>  ,/    /,  ,   



   )5 ,/  

  ,.!

2* *##

*

#  '

1)

     *  -

  *    .

*  +

,

 +

,    *  5 

 1)  

<*   * 4*  -

 * C 4

 #

   #  - 

#  **   . *  #  '

1) 444  1) )   5 *

 

  * **   1    * ,  * -

 1)  0A -    - 

1)0$-  

* ** .

*+

  ! " 0 0 ,# * - * 

# 

 

 

   4

4

   <* 

1)4  #

 *

 5  4   :     

  31    4* 

    ;  - 

* 

> **     

    - *   *   '

 1) B ,-



# - 31 & =, . !    

- * 

 0 *

 # ( %

-  0 *  *,>#

 

#         ;;

  #    **  #

 

  ** 



1     

  #  

* ,    ( *-  ,1    #   

# *** # 4*       ;;

 - 

* ** 

 * #

 *  * 

<   4

  



   * , ( *-   

 1   *  - 

* **   ;;

        

 *

     ** 4 -

 

0 ,  * 

 #

 4

    - ,     ;;

 - 

* **  7(A.'1+/&2@ 

,   

- - *-   

 #   

4*  4 

4 4 ,  ;;

 -- -   - 

 ** 5

 ##

*      

  31    

*  5 - 

!

--  H         *

 

-   * - *

  4    

    -

 -   

   B ,      4

         - 

 4  --   

   -   #  (

-

 

'

 - 

 



:   +   -     -  

!0 ,#  ? ,# -  

  - 

#

!, *

  4

! 

 -  #

! * ##

##

 * +

, -

   -  

   -  # 

!, 

   *   #     !   *  * - ;     

# *

 - *   #4     0- *

#  '

1)   * -

  

 *

/

# 44

!*3

#3

, *      0*

 .

!  84  *    

9

 

, 

 . !  - *  #4 #

 #   * - 

**   

*!   * *    :   

-     * -   $  -       -    ** 

- *

1)& 0A   - 

- * ! 

!          *

1#   

 

    *   *  * #   *     ;;

  

 - 

       **    -  #      0*

 - -      - 

* 

<     4 $

C   - 

  - -  0*

.

!   -- 

 

   # 0 * - 

. - .

*, - 

* -    ##* #* 

  4   

 % *    

     .

* +

8   - 

92



- ,  - 

 #

2-

 0 #--  3



  * 4 ,4   

 

!

4 -



   #

!   -  #4 *0 #--  3

 * 

<    

<    ? 5   # - 

* **       #    (

  .

<  4    ) * +

8* -  9

4&  /##* # .

*,  -   . - .

* * *!  *  / * *!

,4#   .

!8+   ( 

9*

 #  *4 >,,>? 



# ,4 #   *

!, 

>,,>?.4 -* * *!

#*4



 # , ,>?4# 

  *5 

 #  ,=,4   *   

  , - 

 *  # *B  : 4   

 #    - 

4



 <- 

-   * 4

!  

 5 - 

!

 *!

# 4 

 

  

  4

# - 

G 7   ,/,  ,

 ,   

 &#     

   ??,/

+,/        .,, /

    9 ,/  .  /       .,,                      / . 9   1    ,   ,       

  ,  ,            - #*  .            ??,                      

  ,/. ,.  &#          = 

    

            ,  1(@           1  ,1(@  A,    . ,/ ,   ./       



      /  ,,1(/ ,//      :.       ,  

.

  .    6    .   = 

. ,  .   

 /  

 /  ,,                

   .  . ,/.,, / //  ,   

 ,     

    .  6  6   ,  /       "% -   .  /,   /         ,, /   ""

( 

( ( 

%(+(+,!-!&      ; > B>+ ;  , B>+