High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1845/2013disposed of

Surender Pal v. Raj Singh And ORS

2017-01-11Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal13 pages

!"!#$%

&'$ ()& * & *

!

"

#

" $$$ %&'

() *)&( +

,

- .

/ 0

! +

" "

%*'

" "

" 1 &

"!+ 2"

3

1 * 1 *

+ !

"

4 "

+ 1 5& !+ 2 16570 "! "

! " &(8)))))45

9

+ 1 * ! " &&:7)))45

! ";

"

"

< ! 9 2

! " &=>:7)))45 +

" "

4

%('

*> && *))8 1 & "

4

+

9 !

"

"

"

4 +

)?

*))> &8 *))>

+

!" ! "- *))>"! !+

3

+ 1 &" ! ; 9

%='

@*& *))>

" !

"! "

+ 1 & ! ;

! "! "

4

2

" !

!!+ "

+ + 1 & %8'

!

! " + @ *( *))>

!!

"! +

!!

9 "

! +

+ " ! " ""

!

! 9

B

+

"

,

>"

"

"

&:>(

"

%>'

+ " 5 "

!

"

""

!

,

9 + + , "

%?'

"

@ && &* &=

&8& ,, .

&8& ,,/ C

+ 5

"

#

$

%

&' (

#" %

$

# )

)

* ) )

$

#

+ ) ) ,

$

" -)$

# .) )

) / )/

& 01 )

+ ) ) $

" 2 ) )

) ) *)

/ ) ) *)

) ) + *)) ) 3

$

)

#$

"

$

#4 < " + "

; !

" 1 & %7'

<

+

+

" + "

"

"

""

""5

"

+"

<!

! + " ; !

" 1 & ! ! "

""5

!! "

""

!

@+

!

+

"

<

,

() *)&(

<

! +"

%:'

2 "

%&)'

3 "

+

"

+ !

"

"

"

4 3

,! ; 0 C D

1 (&>8 &?

*))> !"

"" +

+

+" "

"

- *))8 *))> +

+ " 1 * " *))8 "

!

!

"

"

" & "! )> *))8 (& *))> + , " ";

""

+

" "

4 1 *. / "

!

%&&'

3 "

+!

,

"

9

"

"

"

"

+

" +

,

%&*'

3 " @&& &*,,

!

"

""

, "

! "

<, !

" ! "

"

!

+ " ,

+ "

" "

"

"

&=@&&" ,, !

+

" " ,

! "

+

" "

!

9

,

, !

!

%&('

3

! "# $

@ && &=,, !

;

"

;

"

&**&*( &*=" 2 D

@ && &=,, "

"

"

"

%&='

3 " +!

9 + +

!

" " " + " " + +

9

%&8'

@ "

!

+!

9

&8& ,, !

" + " "

" 9 +

@&& &*,,

"

+

, "

" "

3 ! A

+

"

+ <

"

@&& &*,,9

"

" %&>'

3

"%& %' "' #(' '(' "' #('

)! * *'!

+

""

""

!

" " "

1

9 +

"

5

%&?'

"

! "

+ +!

"

!

"" + "

,! 4 !+ 2"

3

. 1 */ "

+ * 8 ( 2-4- *))8

"

+ " "

+ !5!+

+

"" ""

" !

;

=58 ! !

" * 8 ( 2 !

""

!

+ +"" "

"

""! !

&=>:7)))45"!- 1 !+*))8

"

! !

D "

" > !

""

"

" "

"

5,! "!

""*( *))> !

+ ! + + ! "

" ! +

9 <

"" "!

9+ 5,!

)* )* *))>

"!

""

9

!

+ 9+ ;

"

3

"

5& "

! "

* ( ( < + + + B& %&7'

3

+ !

" "

"

+

"" ! "

1 +

"" ! " +

" !+ " 1

+

;

" " %&:'

+ +!

"

0 "

"

"

""

" "

"" +

" "

D

E

2

" "

+" 2

@""

"" "

A

" "

5& <

+ "

5*)&

+ " )?

)( *))> "

" * :8 < "

"

"

() )( *))> <

"+

"

"

""

+

" D

" "

! +

"" "

"" ! ! " !

!! F

+ "

! + "

+

!"

""

<C

1 5*)&

"

*( *))>" !

""

%*)'

3 +!

""

+

+ +!

<+

9

" ;

!

!

"

!

"

"

4!+ 2"

"

,!

%*&'

" !"@&& &=,, ++

, "

"

" +

"

"

,' , '' - # ' ".

& -

"' * ''

/ ! - -! ) $ ! A

"

" +

+ !

"

"

+

! <

! + ;

! 3

012 * 3 3%( '

) ! - -! )) +!

; " +; !

+

,

! +"

!"@&& &=,, 1

9 ""

+ + ,

%**'

2 +!

! +

"

%*('

C! ! + "

2"

+" ,

"

"

" ,

"

!"

@ && &* ,, 9

" "

"

"

+

"

"

"

1 ?"

! 5 6 7 / ) ) *)) )

# ) 8 2

6

) ) /

* ) ) /

1 ) ) 9

)/

)

*)

)

/ /

* )

*

)

)

)

)

* ) * /

3

)

* ) 4 " "

"

,

!

!

" @ && &* &= ,,

9

%*='

2 3%( %(' 3%(

/! "# $$$

"

"

! " 9

< ;

+!

&**&*( &*=" 2 D

<

"" &*"@&&,,

"

" F &="@&&,,

9 + " +

F &* " @ && ,, + ! "

2" " + +

" "

%*8'

+

!

+ ,

! !

!

"

2!

!

!

"

" , "

+

"

""

" 1 *. /"

!+""

2

! "

+

<

" ++

, +"

!

"

" ! +

" +

<

!

" 9 ! "

%*>'

!+ !

"

+

,

"

"!

<

,

"

+ "

+ " +

! + , <"

+ + " ! +

"+ <

,

++

"

!

"@&& &* &=,, %*?'

2

" "

"

+ & *, && *)&? -.

.// "#01"2 3!#4 "1 -.

.//2/

56 "1