Sukhdarshan Singh v. The State Of Punjab And Others
--
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH 1) Date of decision: 19.08.2025 Sukhdarshan Singh ....Petitioner
Versus
The State of Punjab and others
...Respondents
2) CWP-11674-2020 Prabhat Kumar Goyal ....Petitioner
Versus
Punjab State Agricultural Marketing Board and another ...Respondents 3) CWP-3736-2021 Inderjit Singh ....Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others
...Respondents
4) CWP-12689-2021 Kamaldeep Singh ....Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others
...Respondents
5) CWP-14481-2021 Jaswinder Singh ....Petitioner
Versus
The State of Punjab and others
...Respondents
6) CWP-12915-2021 Rupinder Singh ....Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others
...Respondents
--
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARPREET SINGH BRAR
Present:
Mr. Parminder Singh, Advocate for the petitioner (in CWP-3736-2021).
Mr. Vikas Arora, DAG, Punjab.
Mr. Harsh Chopra, Advocate and Mr. Satnam Singh, Advocate for respondent No.5 (in CWP-12689-2021).
Mr. Rahul Verma, Advocate for respondent No.6 (in CWP-1221-2021).
Mr. Ashwani Prashar, Advocate for respondent No.6 (in CWP-12915-2021).
Mr. Saurabh Singla, Advocate for Mr. Pradeep Bajaj, Advocate for respondents No.2 to 5 (in CWP-1221-2021, CWP-3736-2021, CWP-12689-2021, CWP-14481-2021 & CWP-12915-2021).
HARPREET SINGH BRAR, J. (ORAL) 1.
!"#$%&&%$&'&%
&
( &&)*&&+
, - .
/
!$'% &'&% && %& &'&'
( #$%% /
..
.
.
( 0''
(
,
2 3.
&% '& %456 #1 7
. 8$
-- S r.
N o.
Name of the petitioners Date of Joining Service Parent Department Date of Joining Board on Deputation Date of Permanent Absorption Date of Retirement 1.
Sukhdarshan Singh 21.02.1984 (JE) Punjab State Tubewell Corporation 16.03.2001 27.08.2010 31.05.2017 2.
Jaswinder Singh 09.09.1990 (J.E.) Batala Co-op Sugar Mills 01.10.2008 27.08.2010 30.06.2021 3.
Kamaldeep Singh 13.10.1988 (Asstt. Er., Civil) Sugarfed 01.08.2007 24.06.2009 31.01.2023 4.
Rupinder Singh 21.05.1986 Milkfed 28.07.2000 to 01.08.2007 Again on 27.02.2009 to 21.07.2013 22.07.2013 30.04.2020 5.
Prabhat Kumar Goyal 20.01.1984 (J.E.) Punjab State Tubewell Corporation 14.09.2004 29.10.2010 30.04.2020 6.
Inderjit Singh 1989 as Oversear ZIRA Cooperative Sugar Mill 01.10.2008 27.08.2010 Still in service
9
'4 '+ &'%&
:
#1 ;
<
'4 '+ &'%&
; ..
/ ; #
7 = .
(
>
:
#1
(
. #
7 = .
(
>
:
#1 '% '% &''6
;
&0 '& &'%+
.
'% '% &''6
'4 '+ &'%&
&4 '5 &'%+ .
*
#
7 = . *(
>
'% '% &''6
'% '% &''6
'4 '+ &'%& #
7 = . *(
>
.
#1 7 (. .
>
--
# < : ?
%45+
@?
%45+A
(
$; '% '% &''6
&''4
&'%0
&4 '5 &'%+
-
? %45+
7 7.
0% 'B &'%+
?
%45+
.
9
? &
?
%45+ ?
$ >
'% %& %44+
<
.
? +
?
'6 %'
&'%5
;
<
:
#1
=$
.
?
'% '% &''6
/
'6 %'
&'%5
.
&& %& &'&'
( #$%%
'6 %'
&'%5
'4 '+ &'%& &0 '& &'%+ ( #$6 #$B
&4 '5 &'%+ ( #$)
.
'& %% &'&'
( #$5
'6 %'
&'%5 ( ?$&*&
--
%0
$>
$>
/ $> '% '6 &''6
<
.
.
.
.
)
9 $>
.
'6 %% &'&'
.
+
9
$>
.
7 6&
#1 (. # (
%4)%
.
$>
$>
.C
<
$>
:
#1
'6 %'
&'%5 ( ?$&*&
(
$>
&''4
&'%0
<
$>
--
$>
> .
%'
.
?
?
%45+
$>
,
.
.
.
?
%45+ 1
.
%%
1
$> .
.
-
1
2. 1.
A 7
.
1
?
%45+
%&
3
.
.
$
.
.
-- .
(
.
%0
, .
.
)
%%
< >
A (
.
!
"
#
$
% &''()&* + ,,-,
8$
!"#
$"#%&' !( ( ! !
"# ) $"#"*'+ , ( !"#)) $)-)'
./ ! "#)# $ "
) ' 0
2 + "#3)45 $$ &&6 !"#3) $"
) 4' /048 9 2 !"#3) $&"""'
, ./ ! "#3# $ ""55'
0!(/ + !"##* $"
'$( : ; 8 "##"54
$ < -3"6 !"##" $&&33' 0 ;
1:= !"##" $))&' 0> ( ?(! +
!"##3 $%5"'$ ! 2( ./8// "##354!
$ $(4-%)6 !"##3 $&%#
) @ ( ! ( A
( 2'2 !
-- 2 ( 2 + A!(+ !
"# " $)-"' <( ? !"#3" $ )""4 + ( (9 2 !"#33 $&&-- ?>A $A A2 ! ( 5*# $ ! 2 ( ! ( 5*# $ 2 22 # (2 A+ !/ .( &**"&4 $<"*3- $46 !&**" $"3))' 2.(0
(A$/A &**"&4 $<""*% $46 !&**" $&5-5'
. + &**&&4!
$ $(4&))6&**&4%
$$53*6 !&**& $"%-*4'8(!
&**5&4!
$ $43"#6&**54- $$%"56 !&**5
$ 5-*&4 1 1( ,
&**%4& $$&#)6 !&**% $5&#"4 A A 2 A / 2 A
"* !(; < + "##)"4 $<%#% $46 !
"##) $ "%% ?>A ( $ ( 72 2 A AB 2 <?>A
($A 0#46CD< 4
- - A < A B 2 A A;(A ( %6
?
%45+
?
$
%45+ .
.
%B
, .
>
>
?
%45+
$>
%)
( < >
+
.
/ ) *#
% ,--0 %1 0'(
1.
8 D4
7 :
?
7
(
(
# /
E%45B & /
%5F
, 7
.
. .
. .
- -
(.
. %&
.
%5
? .
1.
(
23 #
"
)&''4*5
# ,,,
,
%+
,
.
-
.
)H
%5
/
# I :
.
(!#
.
7 7.
"
,1 7.
?
%45+
(HARPREET SINGH BRAR) JUDGE 19.08.2025 Whether speaking/reasoned :
Yes/No Whether reportable :
Yes/No