High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1994/2015disposed of

Jagjit Singh Kohli & ANR v. City Mission Hospital

2015-03-20Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina9 pages

!""#$%$&'(

" !# $ !#%# &##'#(

#( ') *+

-"%"&!'

!)% *)+, ( !# ....

/ #! +#( #(!

!! .& ( !# #

! # %/ 0

(## .& ! !

!*" + 1

,/ ( ! ,/

( !# # !/ /# (! /# # 1# ,, (

%/ 2

(## .& ! )((

)% !&* " + 1 (( ( ! #(!

!! # .+ #%/ 0

(## .& ! !

!1##/##

,# ( ! ! ! #(

! ! !

!%#

1##% !3 4- #, !.

!%#. !%5 (! ##.##561# #.

.&'!/

* !.

-!%#*" / /!& '!/ *1 7(! &% - .%

#. !%1#(! +%# & 1 .&8%! ( 1 # 1 1 .&/ ! %!1 % ( - ! !%

! .% . ! :* !;"%.

!< * " , % /# (! /# # 1# (! +%# &+ ( !.&8%! ( !

!# ! (!( !&* #/ ! %! # #,# %# ! .% .& ( ! ) !! + (! /# #* #/ 1#! % ! #( #=# *

:( !/ 1 , , #/ = >( !%/ #& !#! ? # # #* %# 71# #. (&.

! #( #61# %! !,# ( ! ! !

%/ / , #, , # (%.

! * / , , ##%, #% !#%

7!& ! . (!+ 7# ( &# !(&

, #! #. 7( - ( !,% 7 ,% #.+ #( # , / , , # ,% #%

, ,,//- ! # !

#(, .% , : 7( .+ #

, # 7, ( /# (! /# # - ( !

! @%! /# (! /# # !#1%# ,,%( #.+ #*1 , ## # ,/ ( A 0 , *! #( #( !# ! (( !

0 6 ! ( & & ( !#, !.

. !% 5(! ##.##561# # B!8%! (

# !/ ( !!%#61# %! !(

! #( # / ! %!# 1 !(## ##

(!( !& *

?.!* !

C * !; "%.!< *" / #%!0

#@&!# ! #

(!( !& ? .! = #0 *

: ( ! #@ &! + ! / #

)#%/ # ,#1#(# ! #/ & # 1#. 7 ,% %(9

* 1# 7 ,% # #/ ! %! !

%# 7 ,% #/ 61# # ! !%

.+ #.% , % /# (! /# #1#+

( !(! +%# &.&8%! ( ! /# (! /# #1# ! % ! #( # = # *

: ( ! / !

! #( # ! , ! = >( !%/#

( 61# %! ! !,# 1 /# # (1# % /1#. ! + .& / !1,##*#, 1# !!%# 1!/ #(%!(# ! #( # ,

! ! # ( 1 8! :+! #* (!+ ! 1 % ##1 !# % !* # , 1# # ! , 1 / ! ,, ,! , ? # # #

#1 ( 1!< . %!# 1 / ! %!%! D%! !1!, !#1 !

# ,!, 1# # , %#

! #( ##( .%# ,# .+ # ! ! +

%(! /# # (61# 1 ,#

! ! #( # ! # /% !/

( ! !61# # /# # (#! @%! .& ( ! !#( !# %# ,,%( !1#( #( #. %# !## ! #( # E ! !

! ! ! ! ,%# (! # !% ! ,!#*! ,! #

##% # +%! !,, (

( ! ,/ ! #( # !/

/# # (+ /(% %/ 0

! + !/ #%/ * ( !# # (!

!! (( .

! ! )((

)% !&* " *1 1##/## + %/ 2

9 ? ### 1 %/ # + ! .& . %!#.

1* ( !# # + ,/ %(.

! %!.&1& #! +#( 2 6 + ! ! ,%# ( !# # + #( !%# ! ,!##+ .

F ! ,%# ( !# # # , #! ,! .&. %!#.

1! 1! #1

, #%#.

& # 1' #

!# &!% ( B!8%! (

1# ! 1 !! ! /# (! /# ## #%, 1#%.

+,( !% ( !#

, ##&*.%. %!#.

1 + < # ,

(## /(% %/ #- # %! ! #, #( ! ,# !* &##'#(

#! # ! .&% &! # ! 1 %. #!!*" %, < ! # ! .&,#% !. #% !% % !G ( !#6

,# ! # % #. (## .& #&## '#( ! % !G B! 8%! ( # ,/ ( )#( ! ! ,!#* ! !

! (! #%/ #! ,! !

! /# (! /# # 1#< ! .& ! #( !/8%! ( ! (!( !&1#(%!, # .&/ ! %!1 % ( #/ ! %!# # .% / ! #8%! ( 1 # !/ - (! /(% %/ ! !

!* # . ! ,! #1 !#% #(%)C8%! ( *

! ( #,!! , #(& ! ! % !

& (! /(% %/ ! )((

)% !&*" *#/ H! #( # / ##%! #! ! ! / 1 1# . #;7I).! ( !%# #! ! / / ## 1# 7 ,% . 1

&##'#(

!% # !/B!8%! ( - #(!# # .# !+ ((

/ ( ! 1

( !:

! /%, + , ##%

, (!+ ! 7##!

# (

! . 1 (! # #( ,/ #

!/ /# (! /# #1# % ! ,0 ;#"%.

J!. #!,),)#( ! ,00 #),*

!/&(( & !

! !! !! , (% ! (## ## ,# ! # .% *

! @%! # ! #1%# ,,%(#( ! (!+# # ,* !,/( ,/

!/ /# (! /# # !% ( !# , ##&6 #! @%! #%, !# % . 1 ! /# (!( !&@%1 ## < +, !

!/# #%, ( .& ! +,

( ! # !/ /# (! /# ##

. /.

#( ,/ #( ! ! ,!# 1# .&B!8%! ( # !/ &## '#( ) !/ #%, < #% #+ !&/%, % !G

#%, < ( - % !G #%, < ( #! @%!

#/ #. .&& /. !:-!%# !%# !

!/- #.+ # ! ! / ;7I1# 7 ,% . 1

! #( ( !

!% # !/B!8%! ( - # #! ,!

! ! / &##'#( 1# #.

& !

/ /!& '!/ ##%,

.+ #, ! ,%# ( !# ##

. .

#/ # ,

2 !

( !# , ##&

! #( ! /# (! /# #* #. , .& ! ,%# ( !# # / ! %!

& . ,/ 1 ! .% 1

/# (! /# ##(! 1 #

#/ + ! / #

?%# !1,# ( ! # # 1#% / & 7 ,% .## #! / #

#, / ! %! !

%# 7 ,% #/ -

, ! ,%# ( ! #.! ( # ! #( ! # ! @%! /# (! /# # ! ! 1 %# ,,%(

( !# #.! ! ,!&,+,!

+ , #.

!#( * ( ( !# # / ! %!1 #

% /# (! /# # !

+, !/ ( ! # # #%.#

! ,! !1 (!( !!

+ , #%((! 0 ! *! ! #.

, !! @%! # /# (! /# # !1%#

! 7(# / , , ##/ ( *

! #( ! 7/ B!8%! ( * !/#)C'

.!% ! ,! #% &#1!

+;7)C:),!(!

,##/ ( D%! ! #( , ! ,!

+!%# / ! ,%/ # #%, # ,(& !%# 2

;7)*# ( ;7) *,( # 1, @% #;7)0 ) *# / ,,%;7) *, ! , . ! #;7)9

F !# ( ;7)2 )C % ( # % & #1!

+;7)C :) #,!!.! + !# ( !

, /# (! /# ##! @%! .& !

7(# / , , # (!+ , &

% !#%7!& (%.

, ! )C0B!/ %/!# /( & #,! ' .!% ! ,! #% &#1!

+ ;7)C0:)# ! .% / , ,% # /( &

( ! - ## , ( ! # , (!+ % !#% 7!& , #,, ##

! #*1 + 1

( (! &( !## )C , +$#)+, 1 ! # / #% &#1!

+;7)C :)

, % !%# ( # * ,,//+ .

( ! # #%

, " # ! . !

% !#% 7!&#, # , #! + .

(! /# # ;7)2 # (!(# # (

! #( ! !% G /# (! /# # ! #.

% !#% 7!& , & ! * ! .% &( ! ! #( ! (( ! 1 ##.7#C'# # / #%( /!< /# (! /# ## ! @%! .& ! 7(# / ,

, # ! # ( # . .&

( !:

!%# !## ! #( #

1! # / E1! ! ( !# , ##& !

@% /# (! /# ## !# . #% # # ,,//##%.

! #%# ,,%(- #.&, /& !/!#% # /& !+ !

,# ## %(.& !- %& !

!# &# #1 !

( !# , ##&@% %# ,,%( /# (! /# # (!

( ! !# !6 ,# *

! @%! / /# (! /# #.& !#,

/ - # #/ , /# # (# #% #/ .% 1 #. !% (! # ##%, #,,% #* /# (! /# ## % . /##%.

( ! 7(# / ,

, ##%, #% !#% 7!& # 7(# 7#( &# !(& , # 9 6 .+ #,%##* # ! +#( #

. + &/ !*###/## #(# ,,! &? /(% %/ #!

,!! ,

!/ ,,! & (

-$0 -. !

!! (! !#!KL #:

C ! %/ # % . ! (! B #KL #: