High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2000/2015allowed

Estate Officer Huda Kaithal And ORS v. Jai Chand

2015-04-20Mr. Justice Krishna Murari13 pages

!"# $%

# %& '$ ('

# )

# * ' ( )

" ( +! ,-+ .++. //

!/ +# 0 1#%(2 #'

# //

# ('

##"

#3 #4 #5 $"0 1'# 4%'2 "# ## ('

1 ( ##

1 ( '$$ 7'

( ( 1#4 3% % 81# /9 ( #( # ( ( +# ' 6% % 81# / "

7 ( 54 ' (% " ( ' ( * ( '

#% "

7 5 $1(7 :.

;%& '$ #

# 2 #(

' # " ( /"$ '( ( 1 # 0 (#4 <1

$ 7$$0 =4#("$ $ ("#

4 ( ( +# ' >% ?? .1 '

"$ / " ( @(

(54'

# $1#2 ((

( +# ' 3% > '

$ "# ## ( 54 '

( / "

# @

(54'

#""

$$ 1#2 ( ("# $%?

. 6?3 ? @ ( " ( $

2 #( # ( .

" #A% #0

'<1(70 - ?A (

( "# $% ('

#*. (

" ('

"# #

(1" 54'

B1""##0 .6?3?# ($$@!/ C '

2 #4 1 % $ 1 $ # '

$$ /( ( ' # ## ( '

<1(70 ( 54 '

' '

! " #$ % &#' %

)* % +,# $ - , #! (!

) % , #! .

% / % $4 7 (@ ( "#

"$ $@ ( 71

# $$0 "$ 1 ( # 1

=1 ( "#4 ( ' '

$ 045 " ( 0 #0

#( 7$4'

$ (( " (

#0'

#" (54'

1# - ?A%(

( 9D - 1 $#'

#150 '@'

""$

(

( (+# '3%>" (54'

# $1#@

(54'

# " ( %'

#1'#

150 (5<

7 $ 7''

#( ("# $%@1$(

$ # " ( '

#1 '

$ (' '

" ( '( ""$

( # '

"$ 54 ( " 7 '

=1 01 E 4 #??%'

@1$( 5 $ (

. (

", :1"#; - "#2 ' 1

$ (# # %#'

$$0 '

"$ $4 $$1 ' "$@ 2 $5$ #'

##@'

$ ( @ =1 ( # #

$F 00

$ "1#" '

# "$ 2 $5$ .

# ? ( % & '$ 1 ' "# "$ 5 $$ ('

# " ( /(

'$( #'

## 77#

(54 $'

2 #( ( 1#43% ('

#( #( (+# '6%'

0"17 (#( #( (+# '6%# ( $$@!/ C $$( '2 $$ ('

"$'

0"$

(

1 (

((

#( (3 '

$( '

7 (5 '8

# @(

( ""

# # 1# ($$'

"$ '

'$( #1

#$$ ('

"$ # ""

1# # 8"$ # $$ 7'

"$'

0"$

#( #( ( 3 ( 15 =1 #( # 2

/ (4 #0'

%& '$""

1#- (1 $#'

1# 5 $1 ' 5# B ( '

@ B ( =1 #0 '

# 7#( 7 0"$

(

1 $ 1 $ # '

' ""

1# '

1 ( # '

( ' @ $$ $$ '

"$ '

1 $

0 '( 1 ( 7 0 '

@## ## 5 ( 7 '

# & '$#3 ('

# 7

($$'

"$'

$0( #' 543 $$$'

"$ (

( 54 '

1# '

## % 'B1$'$$""

# #

1# 8"$ # # 0"$

1 (

"4'

#5 ' ( (2 #

#% %& '$7 "#"

"D '2 1$$4 ('

$ 1 $ #'

( @7#1 (:

;

( (+# '3%>1"'

$(54'

#""

$$ 1#

15$ 2

@ 15 =1 - (

( "# $ % %

)1+* #2!. !

:1"#; (:

;''

71#'

$$ 7$$4 (" 7

0 54(

7' 5# $$$'

"$'

'$( #%'

##% % 'B1$ '$$ ""

# "

# 8"$ '

# /

0"$

1 (

'2 $ 1$$4 7 '#17''

(

.#'

$ 1 $#'

# 7#( 7'

15 4'

5 '

- %

)1+* #2! :1"#;

(%'

(5<

1$$4 (54'

71#"4'

- '5

(@ ''

81# /6'

# "#'

#" (54'

71#(

- # ($$@!/ CA '2 '

#( $ 1 $ # '

7' ('2 $7 '#17''

2 #4'#17'$4 ( 1$$4 6 - ?A $ (#4 #5 $"0 1'# 4 ( '

# * . (

" ('

# G5$ 1 <5H#4 7'1# $$@ 7(

@ (!/

' (

1 ( # .

9 '

- ( =1

>?9 2 #0

4 $ (/@ # # $$0 #

$ "$% '

# '

"1#" 00

(1# $# 1 $I

$ '

J '

"$ ('

(1# #$$0 '$$5 '

( $$0 "1#1

(2 #

7""$

#0'

#1 ''

#1'# 4 #

#2 "$1"E'

$"$2 $5$ #$$

#2 7#

$1( 7'1

@' 8 '

@1$( 5

#2 # '

% =1 ( 5

( 54 '

. 2 # 0 (F# 54 # 4 '

1'# 4%@' $ ( =1 $ (I

2 ''

# $ (""$4#$$0 "$$ 7@ ' 0 4 "1#1

"15$

(2 #

( 04 5 7 ""$

#0 '

#$ "15$

( '

'#17' (2 #

1$% '

""$4 7 ( 7 $$1 ' %'

"$# 2 $5$ #'

# # @'

' $ ( @ =1 ( #

$F 00

$ "1#" # '

#% '

$ ( =1 ( @ #

1 $ ( (1# $"1#" '

"$ '

'$$ 5 $$ ( $4 54 "15$

(2 #

( '

5 4 ""$

150 (54 1

I 2 ''

5 '#7 (#0 $$

'$$ "#

0 "15$

(2 #

"1#1

'%'

"$ $$ ( ( @'

# $ (#$ #'

# I ' '

. 2 # 0 # '

=1 7 1'# 4'$$ (2 #

$"$# $ @ '1 (1 7

"$ #/0#B (##

#2 7#

(

"$2 $5$ #'

#%'

. 2 # 0 # =1 7 1'# 4 '$$ "15$ ' (2 #

7 ""$

#0 1 ' 1

""$4 # $$0 "$

@ '$@I (

#% 0# ' E "$ '2 5

$$ ( 54 @4 #

$1( 7 '

1 '$$0 '$$ 5

$$ ##

@ 2

> ( F # 1 ( $$ #

'$(

$ "$ '

"$ F @'

$4 7 1" '

2 ( 54 '

G5$

1 <5 H #4 7' 1# $ ( #4 #5 $"0 1'# 4 ('

# * . (

" ( '

# - ?A - 1 $#'

'150 (' '( ( " ( E 0 4 '

""$

(#'

"$ ('

$ (#$$0 4"$ ('

#4 # ""$4 # '

$$0 '

"$ $ 7 @ 'E 0 4 @'

@ .

#@1$(5 $"

(54'

(F( ( @ #%52 F"$ B 54'

( F 2 ( 40 '

2 ( 54 '

G5$ 1 <5 H #4 7' 1# $ ( #4

#5 $"0 1'# 4 ( '

# * . (

" ('

#- ?A ""$

5$ '

"$ F@'

$(5 $ #

'$(#

$"$0 1# 7=1# 4#( K >F/ "

# =1# 4#( "

# '

4 ( ( >3?? ( ' "$

4 '

@ 1 ' ( ' $ 7 @ ' '

""$

1 ( #'

=1%1

' " E 0 4 $@#'@'

0 '2 $ #5 76( >#

$"$0 1# 70#$ 7 3?A .

# #5 % & '$ @ $$ ( '

"$ F $ 7 @ ' '

/'# # ( F 7 (

F #5 7 339( (6'

B 7'

0( " '

"$ 0"$

52 0 (

F # '

'( ( " %F/ $ %%F/ @'

' @ (1$4

( 54 '

( F $$ ( "$ 73?A%.

# #5 %& '$ ' 5

$$ ( 4 "

# .0 '

/'# #

$1( 7 &# ' << ' $# (4

$$ "# "$ ? '

% 1 ( # '

( F 1 ( # '

7#5 (

2 ( 54 G5$ 1 <5H#4 7'1# $ ( #4 #5 $"0 1'# 4

#*. (

" ('

#- ?A # 1 $$0 "$ 1# 7 0#$ '

>F/ "

=1# 4#(

#( 7$4%'

(54 ( F (# <

( ( F #

( $$ 0#$"$K >F/"

#=1# 4#('

@ "

((4#0'

( '

#( #% 7 @'

0 '( '$$ 5 (" (54'

1# 0"$ #( #D "

#1$'

52 (#(

0"$

- '

7' '

'$( #F # " ( ' 5

1$$4

( 54 '

7 1# '

"@ # 8

71#@'

' 0"

75 4 ('

"$ @'

''(5

(54'

#@# ''

"$ /# " ( '( ""$

(#'

"$1 ( #1

=1 #?? #0 ( ( '

5# '1# '5

(54 # $1#@ $$54'

$$ 1#'

" - ?A@<1(70 # 0 ('

(54

' '

1# @1$( # 4 4 #"

$4 ( @ $$ % 4 0 #% (

7' '

" ( / (

'$( # =1 ( 54 '

0 '

5 '

% '

70 - @1$("# <1(

7$# 7''

'$( #%1 '( ( 4 #0 4 #( #( ( 1#43%(

.##( #( (+# '6%# ## ('

52 %

(%'

#2 5 # (@ '54" 7(

#2 #4"@ #1 ( ##

1 ( '

0 (" (54'

71# 21# "# 1# J # 0"$ '

0 5 '#' ( ##4'

$ 7$"#2

(

2 #4 0 4 5

(54## #( "

#"#2

# (@ '"#2

#( # 1$ 36 "

#"#2

#( # 1$ 3 %

(

<1 @'

''( ""#1 45 7'

( '@ $$1$$4 (5 4 %'

045

(54 '0 '

"#"

#4#54'

$"# "

# #( # 1$ 36 %@'

""$

(

"40 0 454## ((

$"# '

(54 7

( 5# $$ 71" '

0 ""

# 5 '

1# "

( ( '@ 1 @'4 '

'1$( 5 00 (

$"# ""

0( 5

#%'

1# 0"

@## ### ( 5#

"@ #1 ( # #( # 1$ 36:;

71#

# 0 4% '

0 (" ( 54 (

7 '

##""

# 1## 1 5$ #( # 1$ 3 "#2 '@'

(

'$( #( "

'2 7'( ""#1 4 5 7'

%@ $$1$$4 $5 4'

F <1 '

045

(54 '0 '

"#"

#4#54( '

<1(70 ( 5#

$"# '

( 5# '2 $$ ("$3?A%.

#%& '$'

# " ( 2 $ 6( (+4%>

(''

71#'$$

1# '

" 21# '

"$ / " ( 54 # ('

7 '

'0 '

"#"

#4 '

<1(70 ( 5#51 "

""#1 45 4'

#%'

7 1# 0"

$$ ( ("

0 % '

2 "#2

## ( (

$ "# '$$ 5 (" ( #0

#""$

5 4 (

#( (' @ $$5 5$ 7#4#'

# 0"$ '

( ( +# ' 3% > $ # ( "

@ #% '

# $ ""

#% % & '$ ( '

##% @ $$ # 0 0" ( "1#1 '

#( # ( +# ' 6% 5 #2 ( '

( 54 (" 7 '

0 '0 % @ $$ 5 "

'$( # ""$

54( '

(

#@'

'@1$(5 ( ((

(54(" 7'

0 (1 "#

(1# $@ #7 7 ""#1 4'

( 5#

0"$4'

17'5

( '

"#$4$$@ (% # ( #0 "# $% :++.; <4