High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2014/2015disposed of

Ramesh Chand v. Janki Dass Kapoor Memorial Hospital Sonepat And ANR

2015-04-24Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain3 pages

" #$%& '( ) * !

%+ ,-%..- / ! "(+ %/0'1'"!'2) *'( /(3 0 ( " / %/3 (456'/2) *'( /(3 / !0") "(! '7 !3 ")' 3' "8 " (3 0/ ! "( 0 ( " ! ( (3 /) / )'( ) 20'!! )9:(3 '/" )*5/(9 ;2;3 / 9:(3 0/': /6') 9: (3 0 ( // !(/'( (3 *(/ *!500:2) !*"" *( )9:(3 / !0") "(!<'")/)!2;'!) !6 !! ) - '/" )*5"! /(3 0 ( " /!596 (( )(3'((3 0 ( " /

'!30 "(3 0/ 6 ! ! / !0") "( "/ "( 2=<0 /6"(32;3 *3 !9 "85! )'!'6 ) *'!(/ !

"* 5:2 >>?2 " (3 '8/ ) ( /6! 3 )/58 * "* ! '

) 50( @ ? "

A 2/ !0") "( !!5 )"( * /*'"* '( (3 '! 2 ;3 *3;'! ; )9:'"(3 /"( * "?@ 3' "8 "8(3 8'

(3 '

/ !'

) "( * !2 (3 0 ( " /

) !5 ( " A@ B/ (( "

!('( 6 "(;'!

)9:(3 / !0") "(!" A B3 (3 !5 (;'!

!( 0 ") "82(3 / !0") "(!2(/:

"8(('1 / *5/! (5"

/6 '"!'")( 05(0/ !!5/ "(3 0 ( " /( '*'( (3 0/ 6 ! !2) !*"" *( )(3 *(/ *!500:2;3 *3 !(3 9'!

*'6 "

(:2'!'/ !5( ;3 *3 (6':"( 9 0!!

9 /(3 0 ( " /(!(*1'":)/58/6 ) * " 2;3 *3'/ (9

!(/ ) '( ; ( 60 /'(5/ 2 3 "* 2 6': 9 5"'9 ( !500: !! "( '

6 ) * " !((3 0'( "(!*6 "8((3 3!0 ('"*'! 2(3 / !0") "(!

( /6 "'( )(3 ( "'"*:= '! 2(3 :" )(

'!5 ( /0!! !!

" 3 0 ( " / 3'! '/ '):

) ' !5 ( / "75"*( " *'

"8 (3'( ( /6 "'( (3 '! =( "'"*: !9')"'":*'! 2(3 :3'

"/ 83(( ) !*"" *((3 *(/ * (:6 / :9 *'5! (3 !30 !!

(5'( ) "(3 *60 C (3 3!0 ('( !"((3 *'! (3'((3 0 ( " /3')) '5( ) (3 / "

0':6 "( '! 6" :/(3 *3'/8 ! / *(/ * (:*"!560( " " (3 (3 / 3'")2 '/" ) *5"! / (3 / !0") "(!

!596 (( )(3'("* "( /6! (3 '8/ 6 "(!

8" )9 (; "(3 0'/( !"

2(3 / !0") "(!3')(3 / 83((( /6 "'( (3 !'6 '")('1 0!! !!

(3 0/0 /(: ") !05( 2(3 0 ( " /) !"(3'

'":/ 83( ;3'(! /(*3' "8 (3 '*( (3 / !0") "(! "*5/(( * ;'!

" 9: (3 / !0") "(! 9 / *'"* "8 (3 * "* 8/'"( ) ( (3 0 ( " /;

/23 ) )"() ":(3 '*((3'("!5 (( )'( 3'!9 "

) 9: (3 / !0") "(! ! 1 "8 0!! !!

" (3 0/0 /(: ! (3 0 ( " /) !"(3'

'":/ 83((/ ('

(3 0/0 /(:2(3 /

!"(3 "8 8'() !*"" *((3 0; /!500: '/) '/" )*5"! /(3 0'/( !'")0 /5! )(3 0'0 / 91 ! !*'

6 )2(3 0 ( (3 !5 (0/0 /(:

/65:2 >>?3 *'0'* (: ";3 *33 "'")'!(;3 (3 / 3 3'!/ 83((*"( "5 /"( !(3 !597 *(<6'(( / ) !05( 0 ") "8 / (3 (/ '*5/( 3 0 ( !/5""

"8'6 ) *'!(/ "(3 *60 C (3 3!0 ('3 0/ ! "(0 ( "3'!9 "

) 6058"

"8(3 /) /0'!! )9:(3 *5/(9 ;2;3 / 9:(3 '00 *'( "

)9:3 6 / / !(/'( " (3 0; / !500: ) !*"" *( ) 9: (3 / !0") "(! ;'!

) !6 !! )(*'""(9 ) !05( )(3'(0; /!500: !'9'!

*'6 "

(:'") !0 * ': "'6 ) *'!(/ ;3 / 6'":6 ) * " !'/ (9 !(/ )'( /:

;( 60 /'(5/ ( !"((3 *'! (3 / !0") "(!(3'((3 0 ( " /3'!

) '5( ) "0':6 "( *3'/8 ! / '! / * "* (3 0/0 /(:3 !

*5/( !"(5!

"8'":!0 *

*;/)'!(3 !'6 !!597 *(<6'(( / ) !05( / (3 *5/(9 ;2"'6 :2'!(;3 (3 /(3 0 ( !'( "'"(/

D !! /' * "! '")*"! E5 "(:3 !/ 83(!3 0/* ) "8!3'

"( 9 " "

'( )9:(3 / !0") "(! /! 1 "80!! !!

(3 0/0 /(: "

*'! 2'**/) "8((3 62'

( /( /6 "'( (3 '8/ 6 "(9 (; "(3 0'/( !2(3 0 ( " /;'! '9 ()

/(3 0!! !!

"9'*1"* (3 0 ( (3 0/0 /(:'")/5""

"8'6 ) *'!(/ 2 "6:

0 "

"2 ) !*"" *( " 0; / !500: 9: (3 / !0") "(! ! ((':

5"/ '!"'9 3 :*5))!":9 *'5! (3 !30 !!

(5'( ) "(3 3!0 ('*60 C (3 0 ( " /3') ") 0 ") "(0; /*"" *( " /6 ; /.500:/0/'( "2(3 !0/9 6;5)"(3'

'/ ! " /(3 / '!"!6 "( " )'9 2(3 6058" )/) /0'!! ) 9:(3 *5/(9 ; !! ('!

) 3 / !0") "(!'/ ) / *( )(/ !(/ (3 0; /!500:((3 !30 (3 0 ( " /3 0 ( "!('")!) !0! ) #'7 !3 ")'& 5)8