← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2017/2015allowed

Satbir Singh Saini v. M/S Chawla Plywood Traders

2016-09-09Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal8 pages



   





 !"## $ % &'%!()%!



!

'

* +, )-../-0'0 '

 1!0 !

+"

    

       

    

 

                   !

%&'  !   ()  *()  +&'  !  )       

,&'  !- !()./  0 *()

 )!

(12(! ,--    )       3    4()        $5 $6

   3        $7

 +

 



!  !( '(1,5--

  +&) 3 & /+ ()     '         +    )   3  $7

1$5 $6

3 4()       +    )             !   +  !   !        (    

5$ ,28          !) +     9  6  :    (    $6 $% #$$2   !!   !

!

  (

,

   +&(3 4()   !'+ +   +

() 

$2

 )!'!

(12(! ,--+ $,

  )       3    4()        $5 $6

! ) 3 $7

&' !-( +! + !!'+ ; (!+&'/& ) )   !) ! + (  !

'(& (  

%

<!

+&'! 

 !- !()./  0*()  $

,

!

(12 (! ,--

 =3    +()<4+/

  +  ( ) $

,    ! !!&  !  ()*() +   +  !  

  &'   !+  !!  -(  

%

 (&

  &'& !(! !( >

 !



 (    -( !!+ )$

$2 7    

  

 



  



 

  

  



   





 

 !    

 

  

      "

"

     



  

       "

     

    



   



  

%  &  

    

 '

    

 

        

  



  "

  

        

   !    

 ! ( 

)     

  

 '



   

 

 ! ( 

)  

      

 

     

  "





  

 



  *+ 

,%-  

 .

 

  

  

/

&  

 .

  (    

& %

& 

& %

&  (    

0 %

& $

0 %

&'



(    

0

& !  .

  

    



& +



   

 



 



 

 

    "

 .

  

 "

   

"

 

      







  

  

   

% 

0   .

 

 

( 

 "

   "

 .

 1

(!(!=3  /++! ) )( 

$%

 < (!!



  ++2 34#+5

 5$ 6+75 ,+ 2+ 5+ )8 )+!94 )4#:8 5$ !++)8 ;+ 3+4+<!

54=+ !$8 6+75 ,+ 6+7273 #+ 64 6+75 ,+ 64 7#5 37) #769 5 9! # 279+#4 9+!+=+ ;8 54)4 5++6 ) 9+8+ := 8+4 ;+ 9+ 587)84 5 ,++!

)766$# ;+ 3+;+ .$,=  5+ !+64 ;+)+# 54=+1 )

"

 "

  '

) )

)   

   

  

 

"

  

 

 

  

>



  

"

 

)?

# 2'

,)?

@

1

(!!!  )(<4+/ + )   )(;

  / + $7

(!+4 ) )(;

  !!) &! )(  !+ $7

+ ('  +( )(+'+ !!)!'  +        (  <4+  /  <

! ) $%

+ !!&'

/ + (( )  ) ! 

 ( !( (;

A 

  (  

   

 

@

  

    B $,,1

 ( &    ! +  /+(( >! ) +    +    +   &' '   +  !!)  (

+ 

= )(  !'<4+/ + ) )( <4+/  ))+! (  !' +! ((&'( ) )

 + ! )(&'!

   ! (;

 /+3

 < !+  ++   )+$%

!&(/ )  $7

;+ &3

 +

         +  !!)!'  

!!  (!

.

3( 20 

 ) !  < +   3    ## $"

,  &     !  -(      + 4(    #, $2 ,  ?  #, $2 ,      + 4(    #6 $2 ,  ?  #6 $2 ,      + (4(#6

, < !-(+ !

& $

,+  &+ !&!+  ;

 !&&()++ &' !-( ' ''

 +(!

  ))( 

<@( +(+   )    +    )    !  (  /     +    1    + +1&)   = 1A 1(  (!&)  + )) 1/.+ 

!' 

0 B(! !

( 





   !

""#$% $&'#"



()**)+,-..(!  )(  



,

C )   !    +  (!

(( 

 &!   +!+(!!') 33 4() &(+! !!)! ( &! '!+ 

%

?  &  

 =3$7

@(3 4() $5 $6

&' !

-(

()$

,&'  !

- !  ()  .(    0  *()      

%&'  !  ()*() &'  < !-(  + (  ( ) &  + !+  $2 $2  5+% 6 , 

  D8/ ) E8; D&! E8;