← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1769/2020disposed of

Harkirat Singh Ghuman v. Punjab And Haryana High Court, Chandigarh And Another

2020-01-23Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu10 pages

    



 !



     

   



!

"

#$% & ' ( )*+*",



- "

"

/

&

&)* "

 0

 " #$ "%

& 

'

& "

#$ "%

&   & & 

& ' ( )*+*",

%21



  333 ()*+( &)*, &)+,-.

%  4*

* 

*1

,1") )* "

"

/

&

("1 !"

( 

 

56 ,

7

6"  28& 1 #

* "/

 *

     )  *

   1

"    *  :

 & "* 1 #

*

/ 



"

)  :9 

 *

" "1

:

/ "

/

&

&)* "

;  4*

 1

 )7 

* " -



$87

6"  2 11

:



  )"1;

  ,

  "

/("1 !"

( 

/#:

#  



",

 ,

) )/ 7 

* ")*

,1  ,

"

0" $   "

/("1 !"

( 

0" % * <*  "

/0" <-



;7

6"  2 11

:



 

    

  &

 ("1   !"

  ( 

 /#  :

#    

",

   , 

)  )/  7 

  * ")* 

,1 

,

"

0"   &

("1 !"

( 

0" % * <* &

0" < $ 4*

 11

  ,

 / * "

/

&

 ("1   !"

  ( 

  &

   *  ,  :

,

 / * "

/

&

("1 !"

( 

%

"

 , 4* " , :

,

:

"1

:

/  "

/

&

&)* "

; 284*  :  /

"

!

"

 = 4*

*

*

2 ) 

 >

"

/  0"

 &

 0" %  *   



" ), ,",, '  

56 ,



 #

0" %

 

7

6"  2

 2



 

" ), ,",=? , , '

*1  @"

# ) *

 

/



:

4*/ )

 # 0" 

,1 ,/ 7*

,,

  2>-,

A :% @"

*

 

:

,1  4*

@"

 :

# , '

 '*

*

#:

/ ")*

> ) %

"11

#@"



)=@"

:

)

/#*

> ) B#*

,



#

4*

)



6 , :

)

 

:

)*



/ @"

     1  

  @"

%  *  

  * 

1 

 *

    , '  /

 

*  1 9"/.

    *





4* ,

/



 *



11

"

* 04>7  8 &  )*

:





, 

  7 * "   , # /

#   " * 

1 

  "

/0"

&

0" :* *

:*





",

 ,

) )/ 7 

 0"   "

/("1 !"

( 

0" % 1

"

/ :



 



       

     

  





    



      ! " 



#

 

 $   !

%#  &  $'()*

+

#+  ,'()-.

0"  &

("1 !"

( 

:**

1

"   



",

> "



 

  



   

 

  

  



                 

  

              ! " 



    /

 "

   !

%

&  $'()*

+

#+  ,'()-.

0  4* ,1")





7

6"  2

 2 "

 2 ,1  56 ,

C 

711 ,

  "

/ ("1 !"

( 

2 D% 

 ! "#!$ $ % ---

0  1(2   

!

 

#

-3 1(2

 !

  

  

-



 45  

   

           

#

-6  !

         45  7 

  8    7

  9" 

   :  '(21'2 7 :3 :4 ;

  <  4   

       

     " ! 

#

-=    !

 

 

  :  '(2 1'2 7 :3 :4 ;

<4  

  

  ! 

#

- !  !



     

!

 !    ! 

#

-.

,1  56 ,

C 

711 ,

 &

("1 !"

( 

2 D% 

 ! "#!$ $ % ---

0  1(2   

!

 

#

-3 1(2

 !

  

  

-



 45  

   

           

#

-6  !

        7 

8  7

9" 

 :  '(21'2 7 :7:3



  

     " ! 

#

-=     !

 

 

  :  '(21'2 7 :3

1 

  

  ! 

#

- !  !



     

!

 !    ! 

#

-.

; 4* 

 )*   #





" ), ,",, ' :

,

 / ) )/  *  

/

1

 : 





B

* * " &-+ 2) &, (3

4% &2 2 -*7 9:;9 %%;

09;

&%%% 01%

 > 





" ), ,",, '

:

 

  ) 11

  "

/("1 !"

( 

/

* 

/ )

 #  "

/0" 4*

:

C#

) "

 >:

*  ) '

,

:* "@"

)*



"

 # * 





 *  ) '

*

 

(

#:

*



:



 0" %/"

#"11

0"

:

 

   4* 

 6

 ,* ."

),

 "

 2 D$-  

   1(2

 



 "

  

 7 3! 4 

  

  - 

  

1(2 ! " 



  

! !  

! 



    !   " 

-              

 

 ! " 

-  

             

-  

  

    

! !  

 

 -

 >-7  

!!  

             

      

- 

  

 

   

-? 635   



 @

-7 45,((AB?

?

B,1!  !

 % C,($--7     

 

 !

    



  

      

      7       !

   

              

     ! !       !   

 

   5        

-  

!      7  <

<

 45! #    5 7 

 )D -7 8E@AA',7 >>( %AA'B7

1>/! < "

 %# C3     !

      

  !    

!  

 !   

   

     !      

      

            !  

   



!-  F                !  - 

 

   

!   ) 

 

! 

!



!  



- 





    

!- 0           

        !       



!    

-= !  !                

 

!

   

!            

!

!       7

 

   !  



  -= 04 7 -< @7A>/7

7

,>'%<=?A>/7 (1B    !3 8  

! 



 " 

!

  !  !

  " 

   



 " 





       

- ,(>-? !  5  63 )



 ;-?- ) -;-?-@,(((,7 B$ !  



    B/!   !

%# CB/-D )- -7 5     "

                

!  

 !



   

      

        

  ! " 



    

  !     - 

     



 

!  

  

-C ,(A-<  

5  < "

    @     -  F

  = A/A,7

,,>%<=?A$(7 B'7 F-4-

-4

 A$'7

,/$%<=?A$'7 '/B 047 -< @7A>/

 7

  ,>'  ;

  @  -  )  D  G ) 

 <A>/B7

$,$%<=?

A>/7 >$$) @7   -F

 = AA,7 '1/%AA,7

7

'A1%<=?

AA,7 ;-4 7

  -7 ) AA117 BB7 ?

?-7 -H-D-H AA/,7 ',1-AA/B7

,'B%<=?AA/7

B$>F

 =  -G- AA>   /B  %  AA>  B  7

 /A1    6  3 

  ''! 

   C!   

                

 

 

 !  " 

  

 

-C? !   5 ;

3

    

    H

  7   H -  7 

< ,((,,7 ,>!  ! #  %# C=  



              !              

 -= !    !           

  

!                    

  

  -=   

 7 

 )D -7 8E@AA'B

1>/%<=?AA'7 (>>) D <

!  -  3!  4  )   8 ,((A7 ,-C ,(-&  !



!"

 7 ) <

-&    

  

            

 

 7      -=     !       

 -C A-&         

 

  

 



      ?           

    

   -457 

8  7

 ?       



 

-?

 "

 

-!  

  ?"

 

-? 7?7 -7 ?5<=?A/$7 A( !

 

3   !

% C$-&    " 

 )- G- - 5   

 

    

   

  

        

  

  

 

  

  

   ?-&      -=      

 ?

 ! 

   

  5

 

   

 

-3      

 

   

 

    

   !  

     

 

-=  

     

 

     



  



  



  !

CD 5 

;

 ?

 -)-3- @ A$A,7

'(

   !

% C,,-  !



  

  !

7D

< B(A    



         

        

 

  

         !

     

        -   9"

 

      

  

-=   !     !



  

 



  D !;

   F

;

 -C ,(-=

!   

 

    !     ?      # -  >



) 

)* ,

 2 >- * 

/ * * 

, * * 1



"

/ * )  "/,

# 1

,,

#

   &

  /  1 ,

     *  ) 

   *

" ,

:*

 

 @"

#  )* * ) 





  "/ > ,





7

6"  2 * * ,

/



 # )

0"

= &)* "  "

/

&

0)* > ,

0" %

 4*

,,"

# *



 

:**

%*

# 

"

(



04>7 %8 >711  7"* #:* $

# "

4* $

#1

#  61

>:

" /



 11

** >711  7"* # *

 )* ,

")* 4*1



)# 1

 

'

& "

;

  & &  ;

 

 

*- (= /.

 )

* (1

' )90

* 0  /

9