M/S S.R. Engineering Construction v. Union Of India
!"
!# !$ %&'(
!
"
# # ')
*+ '#, , ,
$%
%&'
% ' ( (
)% #* # (!
"
# +++ , "-"-$,",!. /% * % 0 # '
%### 123%4# ## .
# % # %5%0&% 06
% 17% # * # % 8 #0&% # %*0 # '
# '
# % # ## 339 5%0& % * 5 % 0
# '
# /% 5 5## 0
- %:(1( * ; ''# $< = % # %/% '
% 5 >1132/%#'' '
# % ' 5 ?1 # 05
% /% %% *# % # 0 '
# -7%
# -7% # #05
!
"
"
# $$
$%
$& '(
)( * ( (
%&
+
(
(
(
"
"
"
(
-
(
(
-
5 ) % 0&% # % #
# % 0 1@ % A1 BC 0 % * .
# % # % 11 ' 0
# 1@0C#5 % %# ""%1 5 #
% # ''
#
%
# & % % # #% 19" # #%0 5)% ) # % /% # @
8 (C( ' % # 5 %#5 % #
% # ' '#0&% %
# %1 5 # '
# 5 %#5 * ####21?%4# 0(.
#
% # %
% # &%
# %1 % %##& # %
# % 0 17!
@, '% # %C
)
#
% # % ' # 0 # #
% # /% # 5
# #* ####72/% %#% )#
# & ## #%# 05 % /%
5 ##0 #% 0 % ' 5% %
( ( % * # ## #< /D 0 # 0 %% #
#5# # # # 8 % " 5 #% %#
% % 0
* # % 0 # 9@ %B9
BC< /D
#% ' 0 ?? /%%* ###?<
%5 #
% 0 % /% #
# 3 #% 1 0% * .
# @ * C % # %'*%
0 /% 5 # '
# 91 /%%
0
#% 5# 21 * % #
% /% # #
# 29%9
8 % 5# /% #06
# 17%
"
%06
5 ##%% #
0% 0 55 % 6 # #%%1
5 # * %#
/%06
5# '
#0&% 4# ## .
# % # %* ####2/% # * * -20%
% # &% %8 5 5 %#5 0&% # "
* 5%% 5 # '
#
* #
.
###2"5 %5* #% %8
'*#% 5 #0 0&%
% 0 &% 0 # 9 0% 8
5% % %0# ## 5 ' /% # # %8 970%4# ## .
# % # %/% #06
# 17 #5 % 3
/%;06 5 # '
#0&% 4# ## .
# % # %* ####132' & %
# % ' 06
# 0& % %# 0
# '
#0&%% ## .
# * ####% /% %
# % # # 0&
* *
-9?725% %5 # #* ####371/% ###132%4# ## .
# 5 #" 5 %#%%#
#' ( '
# #%#0
#5 % ##
%
# %06 5% %5 % % 6 # /% ' 5 ' ## % 4#
## .
# % # %
%# # 5 %5)
* 5% 0& #0&% ### 2 #%5 %
06 /%%4# ## .
# %
#% '
### '
%06
# 0&% /% % %%1
0%#
5 6#"5 %#%%5# # &0%
#
# 21%9 #%06
#0&%
# 17#5 % 3
5 ' 0
/% '&
%
@ C/%#
* #0&%1 # 0&% 9 @ C/% 5# #
#* # %
( '% % 0
## @ C/%5#0
#
#* # 0%
#
8 0&
06
# 17
4#
% # %
#% '
## #
#%%06
% %* %&0 # '
# " 5#
#%E
@ C
(
./01 .//% 2 /%9 % #5?9;
%'
% %1 #5% ' 5 # ?3%9 %% #*
5% %
#
3.
'
(
./4& % ./4&
./01 .1 ./01
5
6
./%.
0$ ./%.
7
#
(
8
( (
-
?3@C@C 5 % #
%%*
% ' %& 0 #
5% % '' #09 '
%5 #0&% /%9 %& 0 #
5% % '' # % ' /%E 5% %0 #
0) %*'' ## #
% 0 &%1 % 0
## # 0&, F0 ' '
/$!!0 +10#
# '
3 45 %( +10#6 %(
, 77"% 0 %#% *
' 0 5 #0%* #% '' ' %0 #
/%* 0 *
#
9 :$ .//% ./01 9
7
9 :$ (
( (
(
,
.//% (
( .//%
(
.//% 9 7.
(
(
(
+
; +
-
(
(
<
9=
9 7.
" 9 :$7
,
( (
"
;
- (
( >
(
(
-
9 7.
.//% ./01 (
9 :$7
(
(
(
+
?
:
.//$ .//%
.0 /
.//$
(
- "
% %
%% %% *#
% # ' 0 10
%
% 0 # #0%4# ## .
# * % /% % 0 ## % '
## #
*#0&% /% %# #
# % 1 11 '
0 ,5*% '5 # '
# 5 %#5 21? "'&0
&# % % 5% %%#% 0
# #%#% /% ' %*0
8#
8 ( # (5 %%
8 (
+ 9 @ 9
9@+
! , # AB 7/ & /:
+ 6B
9 6
( !<+ 6
'
. , (
( 7/ & /:
7 , C '
; 4 ,
(
; +
"
C'
4 0 /:
,
> ? ' 4 0 /:
-
8 (
+ 9 @ 9
9@+
9 6
D # 7$04C
9 0&C
9 ) A
' ( . ! + 9
? A
)( +
# A 7
E
> D
# A 4
DF
#
5
@ 0 )
5
6 ''G+,+<# !
9 +
./01 9 9 ) 9 A
) ' 9 > ?
(
+
) A 9@+ 4C/ ' B
5 "
9
+ (
9 +
5
4 0 /:
9 @
+ - " % % %# '*# % 5 %#5 %
% % # ,5* %###21? &' #% %
# %1 # '
# 5 %#5 /%
% 5 #%5%
#
5 %#5 5 % '
%
% % #
%#
# %%% 0 # #% '< %E % 0 ) ' 5 %#55 % '
%
#% 0 # ' '0&% G
* < %% %0#, % 94341
# 45 3414:
87.
%
494;40( % %#% '*#0&
5 %#5
5 % 0& %
5# 0&% 5 % 8
&
#
'
%
%#5 #0
#0
5 %#5%
5 %% 0& %
/%
##%E
#
..
+
(
< 6 ..
(
< 6 ..
H ( < 6 .7
"
;
E
E
"
(
+ ? # ( ? # +6 ./47 ? .$$ .
I < 6 .7
;
(
I .7 9 ( " , > J ( , ' G" +6 ./$.
? &.$
@
D > > 6 ( 6; # 6 +6 ./7% "
(
-
.4 + H 9 ( 9 9 A( +6 ./&1
4:7
D '
,
@
; + G A ;
( ) '" ./47
.4$ + .%1
@
D
I < 6 .7
(
'
(
+
I .0 + (
(
< 6 .7
+ ;
;
+
E
< 6 ..
,
(
< 6 .7
(
( < 6 .7
.
6 .
<
(
; (
(
,
7:
/ ./%&
(
.
6 .
< (
(
(
7
6 .
<
.
6 .
<
;
"
(
( ; .$ <
6 .
7
;
(
< 6 ..
" (
< 6 .7
;
,
(
< 6 .7
.
;
.% + G
*
+6 ./&4
./$
@
( "
(
(
@
B I,
I
(
+
; 9
( ;
(
< 6 .7
,
(
( " (
G
*
"
@
( " G
*
.& +
;
@
;
( + (
9 6; 9 ' ( > 6
+6 ./$0 @
>
+ E
(
(
(
(
( @
(
(
( "
( (
" 9 ' 9 ( < <
9 ,
?K
./%1 6( A 7$.
(
;
+ (
( +
(
( ,
;
(
( ;
(
+
< 6 ..
+
(
;
( 9
(
(
"
( ;
- "
% %%0*
0%#%% %#0 # # % ' ' 0
#%1 %
%%
%%#&#%%5 %#5 %#5%
% % ' 6 #
% # &% #
#
%1 0% % # %% %# # %
# % 0 17 !
@, '% # %C )
#
% # % ' # 0 # #
%# /%
# 5 # #* # ### 72@
8 (2C <% % # %# #%
% # &%
# %1 0% 0(.
#
% # %/% %#'#%5
.
2 <''
7
; 2 <'6
9 9 @
+
2 <'6
6 - ,5*% # #
&
- #%#% %# 6 # & ## #%# 05 % /% 5 ## 0 # % 0 % ' /%
% E ' 0 &% 5 ##
# "% 0 %# '## 4 < =94"
# '>"
:4
!3:!341 !"
!$ ?0 34;40 "? 11%
#
#
% # &%
5 % 0
'
& #
&5% % 0"
E &%
5 %#5 5 % 0& %
% #
# % /%* 0 *
$ !
<
6 .
4
(
'
+
,
4
6 .
< D
"
+
8
(
D
6K
H
( ?
D
./:/.
'G@ 0:1
@
> D > ( )
+6 ./:& > 70%
(
( + (
@
> D ( 70:
70/
I +
(
+
6
8 E
(
E I ,
E
< 6 .
4
(
'
4
+
(
4
;
+
; 4
6 .
<
(
' (
(
; ;
+
(
@
> D (
I
I ,
(
;
( ; 5
" ; D
- "%###21?% % # % # % '
# # % 0 ' & %
%
#
5% %5 # 0 #% ' # * ####72 5% %
( ( % * # ## #< /D 0 # 0 %% #
#5# # # # 8
%;
%
<
%5 # 0
? % 0 %#0 #0&% # % #
# 3 #%1 %
% ' 5% %5 # '
# 91 /%
%% %# #%
# %1 '
%0%'
%9
,)
% ' 0
#%0 #%*0 # #% '% ' %
0
#%1 H% %5 #5 % ' % ' % 0 % #
#
3 # %1 %
% ' 5% %5 # '
#
91 "
% '
% 0 %# % % 0 #
%#'' #
%
# %1 11
.4 / .//4
'
%0%'
%9 #% % #
5 #0 * #0&%1 # %9
# B #
% % '&0 #%% ## ' < /D 0
# ( # .4%11CC%%0C:
H
, > ?
'
) <
.40.1&
''<+#,?#, <5 6H+,6,<6B #< DF .0 <5 /1 /.
'6<J# <5 <55+69 # 5<6 )H , 5
D#A+)6D A 9
D69 (
' +
F
?C 9 6
7$04
9 0&
.%110& #A D69
( &1 +5 770/
(
9 <
8 #A D69 5
@ " ( " F
! + #<
,D65<6
(
+ 9
E
**
8
(
.//% '
"
L
# 9
G )
-
-
# 8F ** * H G # .4%11CC%%0C:
A
1.
5 // G+9, <5 A+9'!,9 H
C 6 G+?9 <5 !#+<# <5 +#A+
( "
"
& :0 111 11 J
(
.$ 11 111 11 111 11 + M .:N < (
# /%##?
<
% 0
# ( 6)+9,6A >#<GA)?#, A! D E * H > D ADO '< # A ..11..
7:
9 # .4%11CC%%0C:
H
6 6 9 '
C< ) < .40.1& ''<+#,?#, <5 6H+,6,<6B #< DF .0 <5 /1 /.B '6<J# <5 <55+69 # 5<6 )H , 5
D#A+)6D A 9
D69 (
' +
F
?C 9 6
7$04
9 0&
.%110&8 #A D69
(
&1 +5 770/
(
9 <
#A D69
( E ;
8 #A D69 H
, > ?
1.
5 // ;
1:
71118 #A D69
#A D69 5
' A " ( "
F
! + #<
,D65<6
(
(
&1 +5 770/
+ 9 ;
(
E
**
.
(
.//% '
"
L
# 9+#D
G ) B ** ** * H G # .4%11CC%%0C:
7:
9 G+9, <5 A+9'!,9 9 # H
C 6 G+?9 <5 !#+<# <5 +#A+ .
( "
"
& :0 111 11 J
(
.$ 111 11 <( 9 *H* :
%4 .:% 10
"
.1 %&7 .$ $ 9
"
"
0%1 11 % + M .:N (
# & 111C
"
'
% % 0 5 E # 0 %%
5# #%# #
8 ( % # /% * #% ''
## # E #%
( (% %#
( '% % 0 /% 5 5#0& %''
## 9 ##
# <
% % 0
#% '% 5 /% ''
5% %%*0
8#
8 ( 9 (7 # (?% ## #05
8 (9
6
# ' B A ) 9 74:0 9 6 #)+#6+#) <#9,6!,+<# 9 9DGG6<<5 '69,699A <#,6,
6 H6+A)9 P H!+GA+#)9 D
< ' < DG96 A!6)'!6 .4 ,F'!6 H!6A# 99?
6 # )6CC.0C7/0
A
. 5
,
* H > D
ADO '< # A ..11..
9B
''<+#,?#, <5 6H+,6,<68 #< DF .0 <5 /1 /.B '6<J# <5 <55+69 # 5<6 )H , 5
D#A+)6D A 9
6
)6CC.0C7.$
71 #(
.//:
.4%11CC%%0C:
. 5
// E
9 ( (
;
(
+
( (
D
E
"
;
D * 9 , "
L
5 ?C 9 6 #)+#6+#) <#9,6!,+<# B
.
H
9 9
< '
C< ) < .40.1&
5
'
A -
8 (7
6
# ' BA ) 9 74:0 9 6 #)+#6+#) <#9,6!,+<# 9 9DGG 6<<5 '69,699A <#,6, 6 H6+A)9 P H!+GA+#)9 D
< ' < DG96 A!6)'!6 .4 ,F'!6 H!6A# 99?
6 # 96CDC.0C7.$
A
71 5
,
* H
7
> D ADO '< # A ..11..
9B
''<+#,?#, <5 6H+,6,<6B #< DF .0 <5 /1 /.B '6<J# <5 <55+69 # 5<6 )H , 5
D#A+)6D A 9
6
.4%11CC%%0C:
41 <
, "
(
9
./01
A +
9
(
9 ;
" D(
E
9 ; , "
L
5 ?C 9 6 #)+#6+#)
<#9,6!,+<# < 9 B
.
H
9 '
C< ) < .40.1&
5 '
A 5 ) 5
8
--I!(F G+9, <5 A+9'!,9 .
( A
"
,
'
G '
"
(
,
"
"
# C?
$ H
% #
& #
:
?
C
"
/ ,
.1 +
M .7N
K
( M 7.N
) 9 A-
8 (?
6
# ' B A ) 9 74:0 9 6 #)+#6+#) <#,6!,+<#
-
9
9DGG 6<<5 '69,699A <#,6,
6 H6+AD9 P H!+GA+#)9 D
< ' < DG96 A!6)'!6 .4 ,F'!6 H!6A# 99?
6 # 96CDC.0C7/1
A
7% A
,
H
9 9
< '
)
.40.1& 9B A+9'!,9 '6,+#+#) ,<B #< DF .0 <5 /1 /.B '6<J# <55+69 # 5<6 )H , 5 D#A+)6D A 9
6
$'C.:44C669C1%C:
& A (
A
" , E
D *
E
9 <
(
$'C.&..C,>HC70:
7$ . 7111
" ; <
9
E
9 < @
711.
; 2 (
E
D *
(
D(
E
-
(
# 96CDC.0C7.$
71 .. 7111
; , "
L
5 ?C 9 6 #)+#6+#)
<#9,6!,+<# B
5
'
A ..11.1- ,5*%
( '% % 0
##/%
'%
% 5# /% 0 %
##% '
( '% %
#% #
# &%# %5# 0&%
% & ?3 #9% 5#
.:
#A D69 9 )A A (
# 96CDC.0C7/%
.1 711.
E
(
!
;
! +
./ #A D69
.1 711.
B
! +
E
.% 711.
+
-
!
! "!
! + ; C
.1 @ 711.
#
.% @ 711.
'
$/
#A #<
+ H6+)A+6 9+#)D
9
(
" (
9
'
A
(
%1
#A #<
+ A< D6HL "
5+#G 6A
- , F0% ' % #&
# %
&
#
( '0&% 0 * 5 % %0
# # #% "
# $ % &
'(#)) 5
0 *#
# 9
9 7/
( ( Q 9 7$
9 477 R
-
-
-
,
(
--
<
; ;
(
; + ( (
9
+ <
G
( ) 9(
, ( 9 $00
.$
.$
=
(
(
( + (
9
"
(
6
(
-
-
;
"
9 ..
; (
(
(
(
- "% 0 %#% (
# %
( '5 # # %5# #* # "
*+$ # $ ,
% -
'..(/#)). 5 0 *#
#) @ +
)(
"
D
# 7&% ./:1
-.
E
D
( + # 4&:1 ./:.
< '
# :.
./:.
.:
:
./:.
# .47 ./:1 "
" E
"
< (
+
" E "
!
"
+
"
,
"
.
./:.
# .47 ./:1
D
"
-
(
"
.:
:
./:.
< '
# :.
./:.
(
.:
:
./:.
(
.:
./:7
(
+ # 4&:1 ./:.
< '
:.
./:.
.:
:
./:.
- +
1 ) 2 3
$ # '..(#)) , F0% ' 0 *#
#
=
(
(
( + (
9
"
(
6
(
D(
- / % ' % 0 *
4 0
"
-
'../(/#))55
) + > '
' ( 9 >
9 41
+
( (
(
(
;
+
+
( (
E
+ A 9 ( 9 <
(
(
9 .%
+
(
(
(
+
(
+
S = 9 41
(
;
"
+
;
-7
9
+
(
(
;
; C
( ?
(
; + > J ) ( 9 )(
P ' A
,(
"
;
+ + <
G
( ) 9(
;
E
"
+ ..
.7
9 &4
D
D
,
( +
; ;(
+ (
-8
..
.7 +
"
;
D ,
..
.7 D
6 % 9 E
;
(
;
D
- "
% %
'
% %* 0
## #% %5# # 00 #
; 9 0& '
#' #& % % % %
#% 5#0&#
%
# 2%1 21 %9 H% % # #
# 29%9
' % 5#% #%06
# 17
5% %%*0 # '
# 0
(' 0 /% % # 5#
%% , %
#%%% , % #%* % 5#% 0 %
#
#%*
%1 5
%6 # ' (#0 06
# 17% #
* # #%%5#
& "
"
!"
!$
"0
# 'A # 4B41 45 3 94"
& ,!" 6 % (%##(6 88 % ( 8 5 %#
#
A4
! +
;
E
9 0& (
' 0
! +
;
9 .&
9 0& H (
(
( ?
(
%1 41 .. .//1
E
( ! +
% / .%
, E
(
< E
( ; 9 .&
;
;
E ,
(
, 9 0& "
"
9 0&
;
(
9 B 6 9 ( ) 9( 9
./:0 0.$ +6 ./&% ' ;
D /0 5 H
9 D (
H
+G6 ./$$ H 4:%8 A 9 G
( 9(; 6 A( A @
+6 ./7/ G 77:8 ) 6 @ 6 ( 6 A 9 >
+6 ./40 G 0/
A
)
( >
+6 ./7.
9
.47 (
9 0&
E
.&
G
? G
( 9 G
+6 ./%& 9 .7448 )
6 9 ( )
6;
+6 ./::
' 77%8 ? # A( ( 6 # 9
+6 ./:& ' ?
( ?E
+6 ./:/ 6; 6 9 ( 5
+
'
+6 ./&/ ' ; ..%8
! + ( ?C ; ?
'
+6 .//1 H 0$
E
.:
;
"
; 9 .&
; ;
(
;
"
;
;
; H
"
@
(
"
E
"
(
,
(
-
"
,434 C41 340 "B B "2?6 'A #
# "
!"
!$
"0 %4 2>114(6 %4 2>114( % '* 55 #
#
& ? )
;
E (
+
;
"
8
E ; "
D
' 6 ( ? A(
+6 ./::
9 71$ D
(
"
"
(
:
<
+
? ;* +
'"
* +6 .//.
9 /$&
(
(
,
(
( 70
47
( E
+ ?C > '
" "
@ (
H
(
+
(
+ ' H
* +6 9 4.:$
9
-
! +
E ( 9 +
(
(
(
+ < '"* +6 ./&% 9 .&0$
9
(
,
9 0& '
E
E +
@ 6 , * +6 .//% A ./.
9 0&
! +
A( H A D / E E
(
(
(
, ;
E
( 9 0& (
' +
;
D
(
(
E
"
;
( 9 0& (
' -
/%
#%9 '&0%5 "% 0
%# 4D "034 =454
# ##'#
!: 3 %( +10# "9@ C # "B 31 :
,!
>1 !"
1# +10#
# 94"4 93 213!"
+ 1 09@1CH<417%%*
17;# 7 %* #
# 29 % 9
# ' 0 5#5% %
&0%
# %'
'#
#%9 ,5* "%*%#%% #
5 #0
* #0&%1 % 0%#%* %
%% % %
#% 5#
#% 1%1 % 06
# 175 #0' 0
#
&% 5#/% '
#### 123%4# ## .
# # '
%06
# ###339# '
%* 5% # /%5#
#0&% 0 ##0
#* #"5 # 0 %' % &%' #
5 % %
'
% 0 % #
%
% , , (
H%%)
# J
H%%0 J -