High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1653/2017dismissed

Tara Chand v. Cantonment Board

2025-03-05Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal5 pages

! "# $%

&'!()*+, "+! # #,-,&'.(/!0( + 111

+0+!!2 !!! 3

/4,# (0!5 ,.!0.6,!2 0 ()*+,!&! 4,+.!78 +

(&2& 0+( , !.5.!78 ++. 5 .! 7 ++! 95+ 95. 5 +!

&'!()*+, &+2,!, ! ! ! , 5 !!! 0! :,!2& !!

/4,# +!78 ,.!0.6,!2

0 ( )*+, ! 5 !! + +. 7 !! ++& 95. )( ! 5 &+.! 5 ( 4, + /4, # 5 .!

<50( 0! ! !!

/4, #( .& ++.5:!78 +!'! /!2.8( 4,+5!&!0! &+,2!!!!3

/4,# .!2.2 +0+

=++!7 . +!!+0

> 0 !.!,. +

?! ,. + ,7&! 4,2,20.8!!&2 4,+ 2 :,!2&!!!!

/4,# (.!,. ,7&! + :,!2& +2+ 5+0 !2 ++. 5 .! ++& &+ 2,! 7, .,!2 + :,!2&( 5 !! ++.7!!++& ?!,.,7& +!@,!,!02 ! !!,.8:! + ?!,. ,7& 4,2 , . !! ! & & 2 ++0 ! !&! 4, + ?! ,. ,7& 4,2, ,.! 0!! , ! . :,!2& ! ,.! 0 !! 4, ! !&2 4, + > ,++ ( .! ,. +.! . ,+ :,!2&!' ,

( !"#$%%"

&'()&'&*+$,$ $%%- > 0!! ,7&&!78.!,. +7,! &7!0!&

=5 !! , ! .! + 5 .! 7 ++! 95. &+ 2,! > +2+ :,!2&!!(5 .!,! A"

!,+ 008 +. 7 ++0! 78 !+& ! , +. .! .& .++& 7&+2,! +.,!78 &+, 8(7,&+.8 ++&.5,! +.78 !!5 ++&. ,!9, -,& &.

&! .!!

!0 5!! !&! 4& 9, -,& &! .!!

! 5 8 +.5!+.8! .2.2 B, !&! 4& .& +. ++& &+ 2,! 5 #+.( C( 8 B &&!( -!8 9!( ).( 9 3/( !2 &&!2 & 78 !! '! < , !&! !!'! ,!8...!8:2 .& +. +.++& +.&+ 2,!"

D ), ( +2+ ;( 5 5 +0 + :,!2&(5 .!,! A;

>05&8!220 !,( , +.,!! &!!5 +. 7 !! ++& 95. 5 !! &+ 2,! , ! 7++!

).72! !& D /+,. +2+ !; 5 !.8770!78 , ++.5.! .& .++&! 5.!++& &+2,! .8 7, 570! 78 , ! ++. !7++0!78 &+, 87,&+.8 ++&. !7,! ++.( 5 ! 7 ,! &..8 ,! +5,.!, !02 ++.7, ..8 .8! 5,! +!!!5 ! ++.

+!!! !,.8 !! ++. ! :! & 0! ! !!

/4,# E! ,&(..2.87! 0 7&&!78 4,2,!&2 4,+

> 5.. .! 4,2 , 2 78! ! ! 0,5 > 0+,! :,!2&.!,+78.! ,. + > ! ( 0. , ! 7 .! !. + 5 .! 7 +&! 70 :,! 9#,:7!2 & +& 6, C2 5 ..2.( ,.. ! 0! , 5 !! ! ++. .! 78 9 #,:7 5 !&! / 4, + 5 .!

9 #,:7 .! 7: > 5 ,7&!7 4,2,78 9#,:7 5+ &.86! 92 !9592 !7+&! +6, C2&+. ! ,,7: ! 8 5,.! 0 + F,.82 4& 5 8 &+&(.25 85,.!70! &65 92 5 . !! 7, & !! ! & .!! 8 . B@ ! 5 , +&! ), ( &- G+.5&, 7.5 8.!( ( 5 . +&!

>, 5 &! 4, +! 4,2, .! !(& !8 +& ! >+78! F, !720 ! !.5.8F,!+& !8 !2 F,0!!!.52! 57 +0 7: 5( ( ..5! ! 4, 5 !&! 5 .! + ++ , / ! ' (5 .!2 !,!78 ,.! 6,!2++.( .! +! !7,! + 5 7 !! &. & 7 8B@! +&,.!7! !7!

E! ,&( !' .! !5+& +& ! :, ! 7 +&! !( ( ! 4,2 , 5 ! :,!2&( !! + ,( 5,.! & ! +(( +( 7! +!2 +2+ ( .8 ! ! 7 ,! 5 ! +++&&+7 9, ++&(,( !7!5 ,.+0 .0& .8&!85 +5 ..2 !0!5 .& !7:!!

+2 + 0+ > !!+ ,( 4,2, !! && 8 ..2.8 !&2 4, + !:2 .& + !7+! > 05 70( > ! ! 8 & + 0+! &!2.8!&! #!2++. (8( ...!!+!

./(01, 1 , 022 Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No B +7.

H%=