High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2135/2015disposed of

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited & ORS. v. Sheela Rani

2015-10-08Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih3 pages

!" #"$%&%'( )

* + ! , '$* + %- . /%.%!"#0 ,/ +#0 "1 "2*% '# !*"+& 3"!%!%'"+& 4"+&5& ,*""2 '% 3"&6'#"'! ( 7 /, // +"&"'!( + ,* +. 0 #8$ !" +!*"6"!%!%'"+& + +5'* '#+ 0 #8$ !" +!*"+"&6'#"'! 999 :*"!*"+ +"6+!"+& 2$ 2 6 6"+& . ; <" 221"# ! &""!*"=5#-."'!> <"+"

"++"#!!*"+"6+!"+&+'!> :*"!*"+ !*" =5#-."'! &*52# <" +"6+!"# %' !*" #%-"&!> 999

// + 2 8%'- +-5"# !*" . !!"+ ! &." 2"'-!*0 2" +'"# $5'&"2 +!*"6"!%!%'"+&0'%'&!+5$!%'& +.+*%'#"+0 , 0&5<.%!&!* !!*"6"!%!%'"+&<"'2;

+#"# ;" +7& !%." ! 8 $ !" !*"#".%&"# 6+".%&"&0 & !*";#'! 1%&* ! 6+"&&!*"6"!%!%''."+%!& !%$" .!%' + +5' * '#+ 0 #8$ !"0 6+"&"'! %' $5+!0 $$"6!& '!%$"' <"* 2 !*" +"&6'#"'! '# &5<.%!& !* ! *" #"& '! 66&" !*" 6+ ;"+ !* ! * & <""' #8 '$"# <; 2" +'"# $5'&"2 + !*" 6"!%!%'"+& '# 2"! ;" +7& !%." <"

-+ '!"# ! !*" 6"!%!%'"+&!"' '!& ! * '#8"+ !*" 8 $ '! 6&&"&&%' !*"6+".%&"& * ! <"%'- &0 !*" 6"!%!%' %& #%&6&"# %' !*"

221%'-!"+.&( % 6"!%!%'"+&!"' '!& &* 22 $'!%'5" ! $$56; !*"#".%&"#6+".%&"& + 6"+%# '";" + +.!# ;%" 56! ? @A %% !*" "'!%+" ++" +& +"'!0 % ';0 &* 22 <" 6 %#B#"6&%!"# <; !*" 6"!%!%'"+&!"' '!& ! !*" +"&6'#"'! 2 '#2+# 1%!*%' 5+ 1""C& +. !# ;0 %2%'- 1*%$* +"&6'#"'!2 '#2+# &* 22 <" +"" ! "D"$5!" !*" +#"+ "8%$!%'A %%% 6"!%!%'"+&!"' '!& &* 22 $'!%'5" ! #"6&%! !*"

5!5+" +"'!B."&'" 6+ %!& %' !*" < 'C $$5'!

?F E@0 .65+ *520 ,

0<;?!* "8"+;.'!* '#0%'!*""8"'! "8"' &%'-2" #"

52!0 +"&6'#"'!2 '#2+# &* 22 <" ! 2%<"+!; ! "D"$5!"!*"+#"+ "8%$!%' +!*1%!*A %8 6"!%!%'"+&!"' '!& &* 22 #"

+ ; !*" 1 !"+B "2"$!+%$%!; $* +-"& + !*" 6"+%# !*"; 152# $$56; !*" #".%&"#6+".%&"&A 8 6"!%!%'"+&!"' '!& &* 22 8 $ !" !*" #".%&"# 6+".%&"& '# * '#8"+ %!& $!5 2 6*;&%$ 2 '# 8 $ '! 6&&"&&%'0 +"" +. 22 "'$5.<+ '$"& ! !*" +"&6'#"'! 2 '#2+#0 ' + <"

+" !*" &!%652 !"# # !" %" ? @0

%2%'-1*%$*+"&6'#"'!2 '#2+#&* 22<" +""!"D"$5!"!*" +#"+ "8%$!%' '#<! %'6&&"&&%'A '# 8% 6"!%!%'"+&!"' '!& &* 22

5+'%&* ' 5'#"+! C%'-%'!*" <8"!"+.&0<;1 ; '

%# 8%!01%!*%' !1 1""C& +. !# ;0 <"

+" !*" "D"$5!%'- $5+!0 %2%'- 1*%$* - %'+"&6'#"'!2 '#2+#&* 22<" !2%<"+!;!"D"$5!" !*"+#"+ "8%$!%' $!<"+)0 = ' +5' 22% 5#-"