Kulbir Singh Sarao v. State Of Punjab



 

  

  

  

   
       
       
       
                  
  
  
  
  





%'( 6(4,&"+

%'( 6(4,&"+

%'( 6(4,&"+

%'( 6(4,&"+ 4'& ?

4'& ?

4'& ?

4'& ?/  

!% %&

B5(''&"( <( ,

 "*% B5(,3&"6("'

+
+
+
+

 (,("'+  (,("'+  (,("'+  (,("'+  8- 5 !
 !  8- 5 !
 !  8- 5 !
 !  8- 5 !
 !  -  -  -  -

 5

%<6((3 6<&4%'(  5  6 % !$% :%/ 6<&4%'(

"6

3(''&"( 5

 5 *"6( ! %/ 66'&"

"%

  "*%

===== ===== ===== =====

- - - -/ 5 1-9 5 1-9 5 1-9 5 1-9

!  !  !  !   (,("'

>0 $% %';%

%#% .

!

%.,$% !%"$'%/  0 1)& ,$& '

2

!!89 # %"'

4%,(

(% "# 

&507 6%'( 5 5 0/ (#,'( (6

&))("4(, ",$%

!(4'&", 0 >/ 0> / >?/ >0/ > >

"6%"

("%

&6(/ 7 1)& ,$& '


89 1!( 4'&"

0 


%66(6

%'( &"9/

(#,'( (6  & &,'

%*%'

& !'%'&"

!

!%6% $% % / ,' 4'

!!

%#% 1&$% 9/  "*%

5

# %<%:("

 ,'&"

4&:3 %"%"'/ "%:( ;/

$% %"*'

!"

"#$/ ,'%'(6 "'( <(""#

"#$'

>D5 5 /

+ :6"# #$'

+0 / "(3$(A  .%,$6((3 ")& :(6

'( (3$&"4%

('

""#
$%"6#% $

("&

(% "# (#,' %'&"

0E07?5

#('

&<( (,

%* % ;&<( / ,&:

:(

&;, %"&'$( ("&

<($4 %''%4.(6

&'$ .%,$6((3 !"#$5 $(,(

&;, % :(6 6(%6 A(%3&", $%6 ("4 4 '$(:5 )'( (4(<"#

4&:3 %"%"'/

&'$( / "%:( ;/ %,<

::(6%'( A("'

'&A% 6, (,

%* % "(% ;&<( / A$( ( :('

.%,$6((3 !"#$5 ( ")& :(6 '$(:

$%6

'%.("

%G &,3'% $%,(7/ &$% $(;

,$(6 $&,3'% A$( ( 6&4'&

")& :(6 $%6 "* (,5  &4((6"#,

?>
&6(
:"%

 &4(6 1
55
59 "'%'(6

3&

%,(6 ,'%'(:("'

.%,$6((3 !"#$5 -%'( / .%,$6((3

")& :(6 "#$'

>5 5 /

$%6 #&"( 

"(%  %

$%"6#% $5 '

% (

,4 )) '&&.

%4(

('A(("

'$(:

%44 ,(6 3( ,&", !%#%

%$% / % :"6( 

!% %& 13(''&"( $( ("9/  "4(/ >H

"6("')(6 "6<6 ,5 )'( '( 4%'&"/ '$(,( %44 ,(6 3( ,&",

&A(6

("& 4% 5 .%,$6((3

4 &,, (,

%* % ;&<( &%6/ %44 ,(6

( %'(

,6(/ ,"# ,#")4%"'

6%:%#(5 $( (%)'( / %44 ,(6

,'&33(6 ("4 4 <($4 (5 $(;

#$'(6 4% / )& 4

&3("(6 ) &"'

A"6&A .%,$6((3 !"#$8, 4% / 6 %##(6

'5 %44 ,(6 '$("

,'% '(6 %,,%

'"#

&'$ .%,$6((3

!"#$5 .

' (6

(,4%3( ,6( &%6 ,%<( )5 %44 ,(6 4$%,(6

%"6/

,$"# <& ("'

;/ ,(6

:%4$%

&%6A%;,

(% "# (#,' %'&"

0?>  4&:"#

&33&,'( 6 (4'&"5 6(4(%,(6 ,'

4.

,'%"(6 ,(<( ( $(%6

"* ;5

6 <( /  ,'&33(6

4%:( '/

%,,% %"', ,3&'

4% 5 ,

"* ,'%"(6

"# %,,%

,(@ ("'

,&"/ 6(65 , 6(%'$

&44

(%'"#, <& ("'

%4', 4&::''(6

%)& (:("'&"(6

%44 ,(6 3( ,&",/ A$& )& 4(6 "'& 3%'$

A$ A%, ' ;"#

(,4%3( '$(:5

-(% "(6 ",(

'( %'(6

,'&6;

,"4( 5 05 05 -(% "(6 ",(

'( %'(6

)% ,( :3 4%'(6 "'&  (,'&"5 -(% "(6 ",(

,& '( %'(6 %,, :"# % # ("6&/ 3 &,(4 '&"

<( ,&"

'%.("

4& (4'/ &))("4(

0 


:%6( :&,'/

&))("4(

0 >


5

(#% 6/

(% "(6 ",(

3% %# %3$0 ,'%'

(3& '

A%;

%))6%<'

6%'(6

5 05 I (<%"'

A$( (&) (%6, '$ ,+

J05

$%'

3( ,%

 ,$&A, '$( ( % ( ,3(4)4

(#%'&",

3 (,("'

4&%44 ,(6 %)'(

#$'"#

6(4(%,(6

&3(""# ) &"'

,6( A"6&A5 $( (%)'( / ,'% '(6

(%'"# A$("

.

'$("

,'% '(6

"""# ,6( &%6

,%<"# 4&%44 ,(6

%44 ,(6 ,'% '(6

&A"# !"#$5

%44 ,(6 "4

6"# 3 (,("'

,$(6

,$/

6(6 ,6(

6<6( :%4$%

&%6A%;, &<( ":("'

$(%6 6(4(%,(6 %)& (,%6

,5

6 <( #$'(6

%)'( ,'&33"# ,%:(

'$("

%44 ,(6 "4

6"# %A%;

,3&'

4% 5 ("4(/ 6(6 %44& "'

%)& (,%6

(%'"#, #<("

4& %44 ,(6 A$& $%6 )& 4(6

%)& (,%6 :%4$%

&%6A%;,

,/ A$ A%, %''(:3'"# ,%<(

'$(:5K

$ ,/

3 %;(6 )& 5

>5

-(% "(6 ",(

&33&,(6 3 (,("'

% # "#

(#%'&", %,(6 %#%",'

% ( ,( & "%'

'$ ,/

6&(, 6(,( <( 4&"4(,,&"

-(% "(6

",(

,((., %4( (4& 6 ,'&6;

4( ')4%'( 6%'(6 >5 5 

'&6%;/ '%.("

(4& 65

>

5

$%<( $(% 6 ",(

<%

3% '(, $%<( #&"( '$ & #$

%<%

(4& 6, 4%,(5

A%, % (,'(6 5 05 0 A$( ("%)'(

"<(,'#%'&"

A%, 4% (6 4$%

3 (,("'(6

5 ?5 05

6,3 '( '&'%

> 3 &,(4 '&"

A'"(,,(, 4'(6/

"&"(

(G%:"(6

6%'(5

'$ ,/ "6

'%

4&"4

,&"

' %

'%.(

':(5 <%

4&"'("'&", %,(6 #<( ,(

%'%

,, (,/ ,$%

%'&4"%'(6

"# ,( ' %

$, 6&(, 6((:

%33 &3 %'( <( 6((3 "'& '$(,( <%

4&"'("'&",/ ,'%#(/

(,'

:%;

3 (* 64( ' %

&'$"# '%"#

#$'

)& A% 6 "64%'(

.( $&&6 ,4&"6"#

3 &4(,, * ,'4( "'( )( "# 3 &,(4 '&"

(<6("4(5

755

, 3( ,'&6;

4( ')4%'( 6%'(6 >5 5 

(% "(6

",( (%6;

))( (6 "4% 4( %'&"

3( &6

;(% ,/ ?

:&"'$, 7 6%;,/ ,$&A"

"<& <(6 %";

1,95

!

))4( ,%;/ 6('("'&"

"6( ' %

A% %"'(6 )%4', 4 4 :,'%"4(, 4%,(5

?5

<(A &<(/ 3 (,("'

&A(65 (''&"(

& 6( (6

(%,(6

",$"#

D, (';

&"6,

,%',)%4'&"

-65 4&"4( "(6
D ';

%#,' %'(5 &A(<( / %66'&"

4&"6'&", :%;

:3&,(6

4&"4( "(6
D ';

%#,' %'(/

,$%

(:%"

"6

&A"# 4&"6'&",+

19

,$%

:, ,(

( ';

# %"'(65

19

,$%

'%:3( %";

(<6("4(/ & %

6&4 :("'% ;/ "# ' %

19

,$%

,("'

%";

6%'(

()& (

' %

1<9

,$%

4&::'

%";

&))("4( A$



1<9

,$%

6(3&,'

3%,,3& '/ %";/

' %

'5

1<9

,$%

#<(

3$&"(

"<(,'#%'"# ))4( D! 4&"4( "(6 & !'%'&"

,$%

4$%"#(

3$&"( A'$& 3 &

3( :,,&"

' %

'D

%@% %#,' %'(5

1<9 ,$%

%";

:%""( ' ;

%;

' %

5

4%,(

(%4$ %";

%)& (,%6 4&"6'&", '$&,(

:%;

:3&,(6

4&"4( "(6
D ';

%#,' %'( 6 (4'(6

$( ("% &<(

,$&A"# %";

))4("'

,(/ !'%'(D4&:3 %"%"'

,$%

( ';

:&<( 4%"4(

%'&"

3(''&"( 5

 6( (6 %44& 6"# ;5

 5

&'$"# ,%6 $( ("% &<( ,$%

4&",'

(G3 (,,&"

&3"&"

:( ', 4%,(5

5

!"4( :%"

4%,(

6(46(6/ 3("6"# :,4(

%"(&

%33 4%'&"/ %";/ ,$%

,& ,'%"6, 6,3&,(6 &))5

1! - ! - ! - ! -9

   

4'& ?

4'& ?

4'& ?

4'& ?/

:%$%<

F$('$( ,3(%."#D (%,&"(6+

(,D

F$('$( (3& '%

(+

(,D