← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2198/2016dismissed

Google Inc & ANR v. M/S Shree Krishna International & ORS

2016-12-21Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal19 pages

    

  ! "#      

"

$!

% $!&!   

    !'"( "

!

)# 

 !

 "

"  $ !

"

#  

   

     

   

           

"

"#

!"#  $ 

  %&%'(%")    *+  

 ,  -        

  *+.""/ "0   "&"1$1   ")& 2

  +

 !(# $" 1 +  *+

    3         $  "                  4

 

        

    (   

 

1 +

3  $

 (    



                  *

+*$( * + "41 + !'# $

     



  +  

$  5

     **+

 

    +  $  5

  64 57

   8 * 

    

         +    +       

 64 

     

      

 !" # $"   % "&"% "  '   "

  ( ) *+ '' ',  #-".

  #/ & 1 

 23 4 & 1 

 56 "   7,* 8 22 9 8 " "! %" :

122 ; . 3 22

*  # <8 22    #=$22  &"& 0+22   8  3

*  ":

1+22 ' 6 , 6 #-".22    > !0# $ +

  64 "  $     

  7  -     "/=0"   ""$   

    "  77"0 

-.

  $    *   

 -   "*    ..  0"$ "  .7    "  0"*  00     - "0"- " 4"  7 7 - =0"$

-"$ 

""1="$  0="0 "$  ""$-=1."0.- 7"$ " " "$  "-. "$   "4 1"   4"

"7"$"$"    ?"  $ - :". = "*"= .46"4"0 -. ""77 4 @0.="* * ."

  =1""$0-"$ A 9:                             +

  

   

   *

              

      +          *    *                     + 1   ; 

 9:

   

     <   

   *  + 9:      *  

 = 9:    *+  

 9:         8     

 + 

+ +

    *

= 9:   

=

 9:  +9:  

 

   * *+>?* 1   8+@ !&# 2 + +"

  

5

$ +'<  +



*+ 

$ +0

 



  !)#

  

,   ,* 7 

<  ,A  (  *+       B      <      

    %&%"(%")  %C%"(%")    %D%"(%")   

      *+    

  .    *   

     

 *+

 .""/ "0  "&"1$1  

")&2 !C# B

     

          

,                    9 :  

  9*:   9:  

  9: 3/E  

 

 

7   .



  64 "+B=77"0   " "

  0 7  * .70 -  ""$ -   ="+( * 1=$  "

 0 +(0  - =0    +> ""+("0 0=$$  

 +  " "  .$   7     * =  

=$ * "  +(7

1  =;=1

0   - =0     "

 .$   7     "

 * = 0..

0"> """+("0 0=$$   .$ 

  7  #      1 "$   " "

 1

 ++(7

1 (0 - =0 

  > "*+(

"" 1*  4"   .

"

 "7 ,"$"*  .$7

"  "

 -   7 -. "0=.

 0

7 " 7=-. "$7

0   "..  "   6"$  4   1  =    

0-. "7-. ""77+;

4"  7=   

 (0 - =0 ""7

1 +> *+;

4"   

 ""0 0 =$$     

   +     =$  * "    "-. 

   

0    "0 "7 =-.

4

0  "< 1 0 (&=  4          "< "  -."0  7    0  "0 +> !D# B



* 

          *+

                  ;

  +

   64  " "  7/="0 

 +   6" .1  " 0

=-  - =0    0=    

 ".

 " -  $ -7" --."0 ""0.= "$

00=  7  -7"  4"0  "

.    " - "  7   

   1 7  

9C1.

?= 1 "$ . 

   " )= "" -  ="+ 1          7=   

  4"0  " 9C1.

?=

7"  -- " 7 0   0"0= 0   7    0   1  . - 

+> !5# 7    

*+  ( ' 

    8+

    *   +

*+

 *   

*+

B

    *+

      '9:            F     

-   8     

   *              *+       $

     *             *       +       !"%# 7

1  *+

        +             

 *         

  +  +    1  8      71

  

+

    1  * 



  .*    ? (   5





  *+  

*    1  *  





      *+    !""# 7

1

*      +          

                 *    

   7

 1    *         

     .  ""  /   "0  1$1    8        .""/ (%1$1   +7

1



   +<                          5

 !"(# B      !"'# E   

  +;  .(%/ ")1$1   

+  *        .  ""  /   (%  1$1           * 7      +    

 $    + " )=    !"0# E    

  + *    * 

+   *    3/E *   G

+@G3 @  +2          *   *8     7         +  

3/E * $  

  *   + 3/E    *  8+   !"&# E                   + *

     

    +  3           *+

1*+

+     8    7 + 

      

               

    * *+ 

1 !")# E  *+  

'  *   ' *

 2 +9 : * 

$ +



  + 

  + 



   *  H4

4H    



  

 ***   * +  +



 H4 4H       '  



$  0

 



    

  +

  8    +  !"C# B*     

.(%/ ")1$1  

  

    +           .  (%  /   ")  1$1         + *      

 + B +     

<    . ("/ "'1$1    + * 

*  



      *

2   +  * 

  

+ 1

*   

     +  *



 .(%/ ")1$1  + *      

  B  +   !"D#

+   !

 $  % & '

'

  #())*+(,!!(-.#       *

  +      

                   *       H    **   +

*   

8+



     

 *       

  !"5# E           *+   +   .""/ (%1$1*   +

+ +   *    1 *   +                   8 !(%# 7.""/ "01$1 *   +  +   *     +  

+   

+        *+1 + +   



  !  

    %  /0 "1  !

  /2    #()34+3, !

+!&, .)*   H   + 

+

  

+               *

  *           ;       

     +" )=+

 !("# 718 +*



   + .""

/ "((%1$1E   1     7 *< 

7  +  + *   7   

 5 % 2   

67   #()).

+(, !

+!&,8..

!((# E             *    +

+ 1   +    

   7<+   +  *< *+1 

* .""/ "01$1 8+  * *+1 !('# .    *        

       "'%5(%""      + 

    



 F +  7

1                      +       

    "C"%(%""

* ,   ;.&%"&(%"(17  

 *+1"(%'(%"0  

1

      .%)"((%""



    .'5 / (1$1  "C"%(%""*+ .()"%(%"'

<  44       <        

 

    $

        %5%&(%"0 81 

 7<  44 <  



 "5%5(%"0."0"%(%"& 

      E *     

  *+  7 

 %D%"(%") !(0# B          *+    ,*  7  9,A  (:

   

               .""/ "01$17   .)/ "C1$1 *+ ( '



  *

1      !(&# E  *  

4  $ , 

+ ,*1   ; * G  B 

@  

         5      

  $

     * 



<* * 7            +       

  *+

                  

 

+   *   

                   *    I7*  9   (:          F

, 



     

     

 E   

  *            .""/ (%1$1

+  

 !()# 7  8

 .""

/ "01$1    

*+

*.""/ (%1$13.(% / ")1$1   + * * 

 

7  



 +8 .""

/ "01$1.""/ (%1$1 

.(%/ ")1$17

, .""/ "01$1 *  +  +                    7  1                   

     +  8           7 8 +       ;  *   +  +  * *+ + +    *  + !(C# E     *+   +          <  ,A(,*

7                    7    * *+

+     . "" /  "0 1$1 + 

   *+ ,A  (   ,* 7     <     H  

 64 G.   

   B  *  B  @ GB    

I7*  +*  J B    B*B   @ GB   (  

 F      B*I7*    F  

@ GB       

*   *+ 'B*B   @ GA    

     5

 

+*     3/EB3/E    5

   *   



 

+*+



B

3/E *   

    *   B *@ !(D#

+     

     8.""/ "01$1

+ 

-

7          **  E  !

 ().9'

())(      &   67   %  67  67     "(%C(%%(*+1    

 

  + + 87 <        *                "(( "(' "(02  "DC(>     

 +     7  +/ "(.""1$1

+B / "0.""1$1

 8 *    + *   !(5# E  

  !

 

443)  '  ()34     $     %

& 

       %'"((%"'          .  ""  /   "0  1$1              

 <  

<   "(( "(' "(0 2.""/ "01$1  + 

 + 

    !'%# B               *+     !'"#   .(%/ ")1$1 .""/ (%1$1       +  " )=  *   B    <  ,A( <  *  *   . "" /   "0  1$1  .  ""  /   "0  1$1    * *  + <  

<    + "(( "(' "(022    



+    ;

     

   *+,A( ,* 7 <  78   

*

 1  + +*+ + +    

  + 8 1



       1  +  

         

   !'(# 7  *  *+,A(

,* 7      7+<            *B     

*        *B     * +   < 

*  *B     <   **+  .""/ "01$1 !''# B    B +*  7

1

 +

 +  +            %&%'(%")    *+ 

 ,  -      7     +   (""((%")  .)/0 !"0

 

$

!"

(3/'

4 "5  !3

$ '$

 !3